So apparently, since things cooled down a bit now, I feel obliged to drop my word here.
In fact, I looked at this map just now and want to say, that I actually can not say anything. Why? Simply because I feel like there are only so many people that technically could say anything to this, because their playing skill and/or mapping experience is high enough to actually have an educated opinion here. I do not even know if these people even exist.
I could drop gigantic essays about how some of the slider jumps legit caused terminal cancer to me, the flow breaks, the forced full screen jumps on ridiculous BPM, etc etc etc. I probably don't like this map. But I am not sure if I don't like it because I can not play it or because it goes against legit everything I have seen so far. Even Hollow Wings, who does a lot of weird things in my opinion at times, is more controversial but way more evaluable in what she does. In both ways.
Not to speak of the unsatisfying replies from the mapper that may say "this is intentional" but nowhere actually justify the creation itself or explaining, why it is good as it is now (apart of it being intentional) - which really is insufficient and shouldn't surprise anybody if that is bond to cause backlash, as it reads like pure ignorance.
Usually, we try to rely on community feedback during Qualified phase, but it is bond to happen that at controversial creations, this is ending up failing. The fact that this isn't only hard but also purposefully "ugly" is making it not easy. And monstrata self is not helping with the fact that he literally asked 3 BNs that are not qualified to judge this kind of beatmaps at all, neither with their knowledge nor with their playing skill. These three people may do a decent job at other things, but they obviously do not know where their limit is placed. Ranking such things is very touchy and I feel like no one in the current BNG or QAT can simply evaluate that properly.
So what do we do with beatmaps that actually no one can evaluate properly? Simple: We don't qualify them. Going through the list of our BNs, QATs, mapper, staff, whoever, I feel like no one actually has the experience, know-how or skill to evaluate this creation properly and therefore I do not think that anybody should bubble this, because no one actually can reassure me that what they do is a good job, simply because it is impossible to do a good job here.
In other words: This map is too edge and pushing the bar way too much for current circumstances. I don't know if this would've been a probable map in 2 years, where people advanced in skill and experience even more. But I honestly believe that this map is maybe okay as it is, but no one can really tell. Therefore the community and this game is simply not ready for this beatmap yet (?).
I am a bit disappointed that the involved BNs are obviously unable to see this. They should've seen that their personal limits are exceeded at this creation my tenfold. They are probably good at other places, but like for everyone, they have limits. And crossing them in these cases is really unappreciated.
I hope this thread discontinues to explode and I really hope for everyone involved that they do not try to push this map again in near future, especially if they are not 123899023890954% sure they know what they are doing. And for the involved people, I am 284903489032583905% sure that they were not knowing what they are doing. I could put "no offense" here, but you are free to feel offended.
Please do not put hate on anyone, whatsoever. Errors happen, Hybris happens to everyone.
In fact, I looked at this map just now and want to say, that I actually can not say anything. Why? Simply because I feel like there are only so many people that technically could say anything to this, because their playing skill and/or mapping experience is high enough to actually have an educated opinion here. I do not even know if these people even exist.
I could drop gigantic essays about how some of the slider jumps legit caused terminal cancer to me, the flow breaks, the forced full screen jumps on ridiculous BPM, etc etc etc. I probably don't like this map. But I am not sure if I don't like it because I can not play it or because it goes against legit everything I have seen so far. Even Hollow Wings, who does a lot of weird things in my opinion at times, is more controversial but way more evaluable in what she does. In both ways.
Not to speak of the unsatisfying replies from the mapper that may say "this is intentional" but nowhere actually justify the creation itself or explaining, why it is good as it is now (apart of it being intentional) - which really is insufficient and shouldn't surprise anybody if that is bond to cause backlash, as it reads like pure ignorance.
Usually, we try to rely on community feedback during Qualified phase, but it is bond to happen that at controversial creations, this is ending up failing. The fact that this isn't only hard but also purposefully "ugly" is making it not easy. And monstrata self is not helping with the fact that he literally asked 3 BNs that are not qualified to judge this kind of beatmaps at all, neither with their knowledge nor with their playing skill. These three people may do a decent job at other things, but they obviously do not know where their limit is placed. Ranking such things is very touchy and I feel like no one in the current BNG or QAT can simply evaluate that properly.
So what do we do with beatmaps that actually no one can evaluate properly? Simple: We don't qualify them. Going through the list of our BNs, QATs, mapper, staff, whoever, I feel like no one actually has the experience, know-how or skill to evaluate this creation properly and therefore I do not think that anybody should bubble this, because no one actually can reassure me that what they do is a good job, simply because it is impossible to do a good job here.
In other words: This map is too edge and pushing the bar way too much for current circumstances. I don't know if this would've been a probable map in 2 years, where people advanced in skill and experience even more. But I honestly believe that this map is maybe okay as it is, but no one can really tell. Therefore the community and this game is simply not ready for this beatmap yet (?).
I am a bit disappointed that the involved BNs are obviously unable to see this. They should've seen that their personal limits are exceeded at this creation my tenfold. They are probably good at other places, but like for everyone, they have limits. And crossing them in these cases is really unappreciated.
I hope this thread discontinues to explode and I really hope for everyone involved that they do not try to push this map again in near future, especially if they are not 123899023890954% sure they know what they are doing. And for the involved people, I am 284903489032583905% sure that they were not knowing what they are doing. I could put "no offense" here, but you are free to feel offended.
Please do not put hate on anyone, whatsoever. Errors happen, Hybris happens to everyone.
)
