This is basically what I was going for. I was seeing if you'd lie (Seeing as I basically assumed it was a lie from the start, and if you were mafia, you'd have reason to lie about that, as you could set up a mislynch D2 if town drove someone to L-2 without anyone voting you, although now when I think about it that'd be stupid considering you'd be lynched D3 and so you probably wouldn't take that risk), and if you did, and we forced you to vote D2 before we got to that point, it'd be obvious you were lying, and we could lynch you. I did actually answer something when you originally answered the question, but to be honest I'm too lazy to go back and quote it.sLaiNi wrote:
Now that you say it, I might have heard it somewhere passively. It's pretty selfexplaining though.Ace Timing wrote:
@slaini ever heard of lynch all liars?
forum
The Mafia Tree - Game Over
posted
Total Posts
1,971
MBomb
MBomb
well my role can't target people, so I obviously didn't target them
Topic Starter
Vote Count 2.02
- Magic Bomb - (2) - sLaiNi, Drezi
Not Voting (9) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Ace Timing, Zexion, -[Jess]-
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
- Magic Bomb - (2) - sLaiNi, Drezi
Not Voting (9) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Ace Timing, Zexion, -[Jess]-
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
And MB is rolefishing pretty heavily with his request, and getting stupid answers like this, telling scum who not to target...Ace Timing wrote:
well my role can't target people, so I obviously didn't target them
I don't really care if he rolefishes, my role will become extremely obvious by the end of today. Unless of course I don't use it.
MBomb
And this has to do with what you know from your PR?- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Except I don't care for their role. I just care who they targetted.Drezi wrote:
And MB is rolefishing pretty heavily with his request, and getting stupid answers like this, telling scum who not to target...
MBomb
No, it has to do with something that is very easy to notice, but I won't point out exactly what until everyone answers.sLaiNi wrote:
And this has to do with what you know from your PR?- Magic Bomb - wrote:
And MB is rolefishing pretty heavily with his request, and getting stupid answers like this, telling scum who not to target...
Except I don't care for their role. I just care who they targetted.
MBomb
inb4 wifom scumpainting moon logic
I don't see it as joke post. Rather funny that you see it as one.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
inb4 scumread for joke post :^)Ace Timing wrote:
inb4 wifom scumpainting moon logic
I also heard heavy machineriesZexion wrote:
I heard exactly the same Ace did. Directionless. That would point to Slaini or two people with "heavy machinery".
so how come you didn't accuse Haneii D1 when she tried to fish for my possible real role?Drezi wrote:
And MB is rolefishing pretty heavily with his request, and getting stupid answers like this, telling scum who not to target...
1-Shot governor confirmed.Ace Timing wrote:
I don't really care if he rolefishes, my role will become extremely obvious by the end of today. Unless of course I don't use it.
not really. I find most of MB post at the ending half of D1 more town than scummy tbh.Drezi wrote:
To be honest the Bus Driver claim alone should have been reason enough to lynch him D1...
Still upset people did not want to switch the lynch over to Zexion and Frosting, your read on me sux.
MBomb
@MB humor me, what do you think it is?
MBomb
Topic Starter
Vote Count 2.03
- Magic Bomb - (2) - sLaiNi, Drezi
Not Voting (9) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Ace Timing, Zexion, -[Jess]-
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
- Magic Bomb - (2) - sLaiNi, Drezi
Not Voting (9) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Ace Timing, Zexion, -[Jess]-
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
well shit
Ace Timing
Ace Timing
EDBWOP: [/b]vote Ace Timing[/b]
wow I'm shit at this vote Ace Timing
yeah, since you got it, not reason to keep the vote up
unvote
unvote
MBomb
I only wanted to know if he had a one-shot like mine, because if roles are alignment dependent, which they are according to my interpretation of Sakura's answer to my question, then slaini is town.
MBomb
This was kinda my thought process too, when he claimed doublevoter that wasn't just for D1, I was under the assumption that if a doublevoter appeared that was just for one day, he would probably be scum.Ace Timing wrote:
I only wanted to know if he had a one-shot like mine, because if roles are alignment dependent, which they are according to my interpretation of Sakura's answer to my question, then slaini is town.
Well Sakura did state that alignment are not choosen before role. So either the roles are chosen at the same time with alignment or roles are chosen before alignment. I would go with the first one for obvious reason.Ace Timing wrote:
I only wanted to know if he had a one-shot like mine, because if roles are alignment dependent, which they are according to my interpretation of Sakura's answer to my question, then slaini is town.
Topic Starter
To clarify confusion, setups are created before ppl sign up, so both roles and their respective alignment were created beforehand.
This means that it's possible for neutral-alignment roles to be either, Scum only roles can exist, and Town only roles can exist.
i.e. a Scum Cop wouldn't make sense, but a Town cop is possible. Sorry if my words from before were confusing.
This means that it's possible for neutral-alignment roles to be either, Scum only roles can exist, and Town only roles can exist.
i.e. a Scum Cop wouldn't make sense, but a Town cop is possible. Sorry if my words from before were confusing.
I'd throw all double voters being town right out the window. That's exactly what happened in Nightingale and there's no way this wasn't accounted for in some way.
Topic Starter
Vote Count 2.04
- Magic Bomb - (2) - sLaiNi, Drezi
Not Voting (9) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Zexion, -[Jess]-, Ace Timing
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
Will be busy for a few hours.- Magic Bomb - (2) - sLaiNi, Drezi
Not Voting (9) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Zexion, -[Jess]-, Ace Timing
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
MBomb
Ik this is based on what Ace Timing said, not me, but just to clarify, I didn't think this, I just thought the other way around, if there was a double voter that wasn't one day only they would probably be scumAmianki wrote:
I'd throw all double voters being town right out the window. That's exactly what happened in Nightingale and there's no way this wasn't accounted for in some way.
So I guess my town read on slaini is for the most part thrown out the window. Sorry @slaini you're back to null town.
Magic Bomb, that would be way too easy. I'd be very shocked if there was a multi-voter in this setup.
MBomb
There isn't one, we've already confirmed that because everyone voted yesterday (Unless they have the ability to hide their DV, which I doubt considering slalni and (I assume) Ace Timing's trigger instantly.Amianki wrote:
Magic Bomb, that would be way too easy. I'd be very shocked if there was a multi-voter in this setup.
interesting result I should probably claim: I apparently heard sounds of heavy machinery last night. this is explicitly not the same as hearing sounds from above/below me.
I haven't read D2 yet.
I haven't read D2 yet.
welp.
I probably won't be around the rest of tonight; when I have more time I'm probably going to go back and check some stuff.
this is what I'd assume too. either way, I don't think there's any point in discussing it.Amianki wrote:
It's most likely a one-shot scum ability that masks all other sounds for the night. Not worth dwelling on much.
I probably won't be around the rest of tonight; when I have more time I'm probably going to go back and check some stuff.
I hear the heavy machinery sound too.and look like everyone should hear it
Prod dodge
Everyone is literally role claiming and saying "lets not discuss about the heavy machineries"anyway. It's not like we're doing any real discussion.Raging Bull wrote:
Prod dodge
Literally only one person roleclaimed, and the fact that the sound is directionless means we basically can't figure anything out about it too. So what's your point?
I roleclaimed,slani did, you did,MB did.Ace Timing wrote:
Literally only one person roleclaimed, and the fact that the sound is directionless means we basically can't figure anything out about it too. So what's your point?
People are still talking about the noise instead of hunting for scum.
My point is, you're discussing nothing helpful for town seeing that Sakura have already explained how alignment and roles are chosen and the fact that because we don't know anything about what happened to the noises, we should be hunting scum instead of holding discussion that WON'T find scum.
I'm glad to see you leading by example as always, Setsuen.
So @Magicbomb,
Noone answered your target thingy if you're ready I would like to hear what your plan was.
Actually I would be happier to hear Amianki's and Hanei's thoughts on what you wanted to find out first.
Noone answered your target thingy if you're ready I would like to hear what your plan was.
Actually I would be happier to hear Amianki's and Hanei's thoughts on what you wanted to find out first.
Topic Starter
Vote Count 2.04
- Magic Bomb - (2) - sLaiNi, Drezi
Not Voting (9) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Zexion, -[Jess]-, Ace Timing
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
- Magic Bomb - (2) - sLaiNi, Drezi
Not Voting (9) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Zexion, -[Jess]-, Ace Timing
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
Wut?sLaiNi wrote:
So @Magicbomb,
Noone answered your target thingy if you're ready I would like to hear what your plan was.
Actually I would be happier to hear Amianki's and Hanei's thoughts on what you wanted to find out first.
plz This game is as bad as that one where Sephibro won due to inactivity. I am just doing what I did there:NOTHING BUT TROLL JUST LIKE NAVIZEL. 10/10 GGAmianki wrote:
I'm glad to see you leading by example as always, Setsuen.
and tbh if I trusted my gut more than logic I would be voting either RB/Drezi just bc my gut tells me that some people are taking advantage of the fact that I tend to NOT scum read people who don't suspect me and kind of sheep my reads. Which was the reason why I lost the Madoka game in the first place.
MBomb
I would still prefer to hear if anyone actually did target them. Haneii probably noticed why I'm asking this if anyone did, they seem to be paying the most attention this game.sLaiNi wrote:
So @Magicbomb,
Noone answered your target thingy if you're ready I would like to hear what your plan was.
Actually I would be happier to hear Amianki's and Hanei's thoughts on what you wanted to find out first.
MBomb
This surprises me. You'll understand why when I say, but idk if this is a lack of attention or something else. Most likely just a lack of attention, but still, I would've assumed it's something you would pay attention to (Unless, you didn't see a reason to, which is possible, but highly unlikely.)Amianki wrote:
I actually have no idea what he's talking about.
so it IS moon logic
MBomb
inb4 distancing from scumteam- Magic Bomb - wrote:
I'm sorry but could I get an explanation of what moon logic actually is? I google it but can't find anything...Ace Timing wrote:
so it IS moon logic
...I have no idea what you're talking about.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Haneii probably noticed why I'm asking this if anyone did, they seem to be paying the most attention this game.
btw, I should sheep your wagon for not putting me in 8th. How could you? :U
I heard sounds of heavy machinery last night.
MBomb
...But you did notice, what you just said basically said you noticed, though tbh I understand it may not've seemed significant, in my opinion it was. I mean, someone asked earlier on if there were roles which could change the places of people in the treehouse, and then one changes the places and no one comments on it, it seems really weird to me.Haneii wrote:
...I have no idea what you're talking about.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Haneii probably noticed why I'm asking this if anyone did, they seem to be paying the most attention this game.
btw, I should sheep your wagon for not putting me in 8th. How could you? :U
Drezi already commented on it though.
I'm pretty sure most people were more concerned with someone saying BusDriver should be lynched bc you some crazy reason post.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
...But you did notice, what you just said basically said you noticed, though tbh I understand it may not've seemed significant, in my opinion it was. I mean, someone asked earlier on if there were roles which could change the places of people in the treehouse, and then one changes the places and no one comments on it, it seems really weird to me.
OMG I didn't even notice that they changed their places.
So here the starting positions:
So here the starting positions:
Sakura wrote:
Current Housing:
[pieguy1372]
[Setsuen]
[- Magic Bomb -]
[Amianki]
[rEdo]
[Static Noise Bird]
[Haneii]
[Ace Timing]
[sLaiNi]
[Zexion]
[fartownik]
[Frostings]
[Drezi]
After thinking about it, the whole "switching places"-thing just brings too much WIFOM, I don't know if we should think on these right now.
MBomb
MBomb
Pg 57
I assume he is referring to your action last night and how it could be unlimited or a one-shot. I could be wrong?Drezi wrote:
I didn't target Amianki/Haneii Mr. Busdriver, who might or might not have actually used up his ability, which could very well be unlimited in fact aswell, to confuse the shit out of town even more later
MBomb
Yeah but he never mentioned (And seemingly, if he himself realised, he didn't explain it well enough for anyone else to understand) how the houses had changed, to me it doesn't seem like he noticed that at all.Haneii wrote:
Pg 57I assume he is referring to your action last night and how it could be unlimited or a one-shot. I could be wrong?Drezi wrote:
I didn't target Amianki/Haneii Mr. Busdriver, who might or might not have actually used up his ability, which could very well be unlimited in fact aswell, to confuse the shit out of town even more later
I'm starting to believe the machinery was to actually hide all the movements on the tree since nobody claimed hearing another thing. I just had that idea so that's the last I'm going to speculate.
We basically got no information about the night thanks to the heavy machinery. So we're still like D1 again.
-----------
Who was the one who switched houses again? I assumed there was some way.
Is the case on MB still the previous stuff or are there some new points?
I'm pretty sure that for you anything I'll say will be a "scumtell". Seriously, your reasons to suspect me at the end of D1 were bad.Drezi wrote:
And this is like a classic scumtell, lol.Zexion wrote:
Ugh.. they hit the cop. That's pretty bad.
I was thinking of even or odd day double-voter.Amianki wrote:
Magic Bomb, that would be way too easy. I'd be very shocked if there was a multi-voter in this setup.
Your roleclaim only bought WIFOM, aside from Slaini's and Ace which would be obvious after a while, the only person who trully claimed was MB.Setsuen wrote:
I roleclaimed,slani did, you did,MB did.Ace Timing wrote:
Literally only one person roleclaimed, and the fact that the sound is directionless means we basically can't figure anything out about it too. So what's your point?
People are still talking about the noise instead of hunting for scum.
My point is, you're discussing nothing helpful for town seeing that Sakura have already explained how alignment and roles are chosen and the fact that because we don't know anything about what happened to the noises, we should be hunting scum instead of holding discussion that WON'T find scum.
We basically got no information about the night thanks to the heavy machinery. So we're still like D1 again.
-----------
Who was the one who switched houses again? I assumed there was some way.
Is the case on MB still the previous stuff or are there some new points?
Are you saying, you don't care to look at yesterday's lynch and last night's kill?Zexion wrote:
So we're still like D1 again.
@Magicbomb: Did your role description tell you that you'd be masking noise upon using your ability?
Topic Starter
Vote Count 2.05
- Magic Bomb - (2) - sLaiNi, Drezi
Not Voting (9) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Zexion, -[Jess]-, Ace Timing
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
- Magic Bomb - (2) - sLaiNi, Drezi
Not Voting (9) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Zexion, -[Jess]-, Ace Timing
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
Actually, would it also say it will make noise for everyone? it does not make sense for drezi to hear anything. Also why did you target haneii and CB?
MBomb
Nope.Haneii wrote:
@Magicbomb: Did your role description tell you that you'd be masking noise upon using your ability?
I targetted Haneii because they are my strongest town read, and I thought scum would target them. I targetted Amianki because after the Frostings flip, I'm not feeling as confident about my other reads, and so I decided to go with having faith in the town, and Amianki was 2nd most voted (Before slalni and Navizel moved their votes for a Frostings lynch), and people had voiced their suspicions on him who hadn't been voting for him, including Frostings.Raging Bull wrote:
Actually, would it also say it will make noise for everyone? it does not make sense for drezi to hear anything. Also why did you target haneii and CB?
MBomb
I was debating in my head whether to change Amianki or Zexion, or just trust my initial thoughts and go with Drezi, but my final decision was Amianki. Didn't make a difference (Or wouldn't have done if it wasn't Navizel that died, which seems bad to me because now Amianki only has one neighbour which is better for him if he is scum).
Did your role state anything about noises? While i can see why you wanted to protect haneii, it seems that you may also unintentionally blocked our sounds
MBomb
Raging Bull wrote:
Did your role state anything about noises? While i can see why you wanted to protect haneii, it seems that you may also unintentionally blocked our sounds
- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Nope.Haneii wrote:
@Magicbomb: Did your role description tell you that you'd be masking noise upon using your ability?
prod dodge. i should *actually* be around tonight this time
[quote="-Magic Bomb-]I targetted Haneii because they are my strongest town read, and I thought scum would target them.[/quote]
And why exactly did you think that?
For myself, I don't see an obvious reason why Haneii should be targeted over anyone else.
And why exactly did you think that?
For myself, I don't see an obvious reason why Haneii should be targeted over anyone else.
MBomb
prob dodge,I can't think now
And my summer holidays homework are waiting for me to do it
MBomb
Only just realised how badly I messed up quotes here but yeah you get what I'm replying to because it was the last post.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
As far as I know, Haneii is being townread more than anyone else, though I suppose to scum may've thought they were too obvious of a target.sLaiNi wrote:
[
MBomb
You just ruined 24hours of no one posting anything. Now how am I suppose to lose while complaining about the fact that scum are winning like they did in Perpetual MyLo?- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Only just noticed this whilst rereading through and it was me, as a side effect of my ability.Zexion wrote:
Who was the one who switched houses again? I assumed there was some way.
vote: MB
Topic Starter
Vote Count 2.06
- Magic Bomb - (3) - sLaiNi, Drezi, -[Jess]- [L-3]
Not Voting (8) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Zexion, Ace Timing
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
- Magic Bomb - (3) - sLaiNi, Drezi, -[Jess]- [L-3]
Not Voting (8) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Zexion, Ace Timing
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
And why exactly don't you keep up your playstyle? Posting this won't bring us any further. Also, you were so actively pushing everyone around D1, why stop doing that now?Setsuen wrote:
You just ruined 24hours of no one posting anything. Now how am I suppose to lose while complaining about the fact that scum are winning like they did in Perpetual MyLo?- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Only just noticed this whilst rereading through and it was me, as a side effect of my ability.
Tell that to the me who did the same thing in Perpetual MyLo D2.sLaiNi wrote:
And why exactly don't you keep up your playstyle? Posting this won't bring us any further. Also, you were so actively pushing everyone around D1, why stop doing that now?
Not my fault NONE OF YOU WANTED TO LYNCH ZEXION and you're still voting MB when she is probably more town than Zexion at this point.
MBomb
To be honest I was trying to bring back some life to the discussion so we could avoid scum winning so easily.Setsuen wrote:
You just ruined 24hours of no one posting anything. Now how am I suppose to lose while complaining about the fact that scum are winning like they did in Perpetual MyLo?- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Who was the one who switched houses again? I assumed there was some way.
Only just noticed this whilst rereading through and it was me, as a side effect of my ability.
MBomb
Also, I really don't get what happened to all the suspicion on both Zexion and Amianki. I assume no one targetted Zexion last night, and if someone targetted Amianki, they didn't say, so as far as I know, people have no reason to lose suspicion on either of them overnight (Unless they re-read the thread and stopped from something there, which if that happened, I would have expected them to talk about what they saw which made them realise they're innocent)Setsuen wrote:
Tell that to the me who did the same thing in Perpetual MyLo D2.sLaiNi wrote:
And why exactly don't you keep up your playstyle? Posting this won't bring us any further. Also, you were so actively pushing everyone around D1, why stop doing that now?
Not my fault NONE OF YOU WANTED TO LYNCH ZEXION and you're still voting MB when she is probably more town than Zexion at this point.
Topic Starter
Ace Timing has been prodded!
Then tell me a good reason, why to vote Zexion.Setsuen wrote:
Tell that to the me who did the same thing in Perpetual MyLo D2.sLaiNi wrote:
And why exactly don't you keep up your playstyle? Posting this won't bring us any further. Also, you were so actively pushing everyone around D1, why stop doing that now?
Not my fault NONE OF YOU WANTED TO LYNCH ZEXION and you're still voting MB when she is probably more town than Zexion at this point.
There have to be dozen if you are so sure about him.
literally almost any reason why people voted for Frosting can be used for Zexion.sLaiNi wrote:
Then tell me a good reason, why to vote Zexion.
There have to be dozen if you are so sure about him.
Also take note that Zexion DARES to 1v1 me as town BUT he does not try to do so in this game when I accuse him of being suspicious.
why did people vote frostings again?
You mean the Frostings that was actually town and that we misslynched?Setsuen wrote:
literally almost any reason why people voted for Frosting can be used for Zexion.sLaiNi wrote:
Then tell me a good reason, why to vote Zexion.
There have to be dozen if you are so sure about him.
Also take note that Zexion DARES to 1v1 me as town BUT he does not try to do so in this game when I accuse him of being suspicious.
Good, let's go and vote Zexion for the same reasons that let us misslynch a town.
Topic Starter
Amianki has been prodded!
Vote Count 2.07
- Magic Bomb - (3) - sLaiNi, Drezi, -[Jess]- [L-3]
Not Voting (8) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Zexion, Ace Timing
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
- Magic Bomb - (3) - sLaiNi, Drezi, -[Jess]- [L-3]
Not Voting (8) - pieguy1372, Setsuen, - Magic Bomb -, Amianki, Raging Bull, Haneii, Zexion, Ace Timing
With 11 Alive it takes 6 to lynch
Any oppinions on your side? That prod dodge was so good, I didn't even notice it.Ace Timing wrote:
why did people vote frostings again?
I don't see what's so scummy about zexion, only the classic scum tell at the beginning of the day, so common it's on the wiki...
tbh I'd rather lynch MB, not because he's scum or anything, but because Bus Driver sounds like a pain to deal with.