Sushi971 wrote:

consider make hitsounds louder (just a little)

[Second stage]
02:04:941 (8) - finish 1/3 beat later, sounds better imordy

[Final Stage]
02:41:882 (x) - Here,rdy
02:42:588 (x) - here,rdy
02:43:294 (x) - here,rdy
02:44:235 (x) - and here, it feels like there's a note missing. the player can bue confused as he doesnt really know what part of the music the streams are based on.rdy
04:15:726 (2) - put on 1/3rdy
04:22:305 (1) - unsnapped??
04:26:715 (7) - ^??

the song is <3

Shulin wrote:

Copy paste into timing points in notepad:

11300.8182773109,705.882352941176,4,2,0,26,1,0
252715.684210526,631.578947368421,4,2,0,26,1,0
257737,582.52427184466,4,2,0,26,1,0
260067,606.060606060606,4,2,0,26,1,0
262520.504672897,560.747663551402,4,2,0,100,1,0
266977,495.867768595041,4,2,0,100,1,0
268962,689.655172413793,4,2,0,100,1,0
271950,689.655172413793,4,2,0,100,1,0
276127.384615385,461.538461538462,4,2,0,100,1,0

This is by no means perfect, timing dynamic bpm isn't easy, but this timing should allow you to map it (imo just don't map the end it would be a lot easier ~) but imo you should pick one part of the song and map three difficulties for it like xxheroxx and Sushi have already said, that way you could skip the end.

Anyway I'll recheck the rest later.

• 01:25:882 (8) New combo
  02:29:647 (10) Not a good idea in a Normal
  02:44:941 (8) New combo
  03:07:058 (6) Spacing

sonnyc wrote:

Hi

Normal

• 01:25:882 (8) New combo rdy
  02:29:647 (10) Not a good idea in a Normal mm ok, rdy
  02:44:941 (8) New combo rdy
  03:07:058 (6) Spacingrdy

Star

Shulin wrote:

Sorry for the delay.

General:

-- Add an Easier difficulty (3.5 stars or under) since this is a relaxing song it should be easy to make ^^mm ok
-- The skin is looking much better now.thx
-- Delete the SB when the map has finished.ok

Normal:

-- There are quite a few overlaps, maybe change the direction of some combo's so they overlap less.ok

00:47:294 (9,1) - Spacing?I did it on purpose, but I can change it
01:00:235 (2,3,4,5) - Slightly confusing maybe rearrange them so they are not all clustered around the slider?rdy
01:04:941 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - Spacing? Compare with 01:01:882 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - made on purpose, but no problems in change it
01:14:117 (3,4,5,6) - Maybe move this in a different direction to minimise overlap?mmm ok

Insane:

-- Maybe increase the circle size?ok and rdy
-- Well... this really isn't insane imo it doesn't flow as well as normal, I'd reccommend using bigger circlesand spreading this out a bit more and the score really comes from the length and absence of lots of sliders. Actually Normal would proibably suffice as you easiest difficulty but it's up to you ^^I change it to Hard+, and yea I make a review en the sliders

00:11:294 (2) - Move this from under the slider?rdy
00:30:117 (8,1,2,3,4) - These overlaps don't look so great, spread those sliders out a little?mm rdy
01:17:647 (10) - You could try and make this symmetrical if you wanted to XDI try but it's hard to do hahaha xD
01:23:647 (2,3,4) - Way too confusing respace this please.rdy
01:25:764 (1,2,3) - Doesn't fit the music. i follow a instrument :3 listen again
01:26:117 (4) - Weird jump.rdy
01:45:882 -- You may need a x2 warning here.ok
02:05:411 (1,2,1,1,1,1,1,1) - The new combos aren't really necessary here.rdy
02:07:764 (1) - Reshape? naa xD
02:11:294 (1) - Remove new combo. rdy
02:16:941 (1) - ^ rdy
02:29:411 (9) - Confusing shape.rdy

fixed... I haven't problems with this but i change it
02:41:882 (1,2,3,4,5) - These 1/6 streams don't fit that well imo. Also add some hitsounds if you want to keep it because its hard to follow with the low volume soft (maybe increase the audio volume?)
02:43:529 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - ^
02:47:999 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - ^ The spacing is probably too close to.
02:49:647 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - ^ Same thing remember add hitsounds.

03:21:176 (1) - Remove new combo.rdy
03:21:411 (2) - Delete? naa, i like the "la la" xDD

That's all for now, there's still a bit more modding to be done here so make sure to ask for more opinions but I can see you've put effort into remapping this so here's a star thx =)

Garven wrote:

[Easy]
00:48:705 This slider sticks out from all the other sliders. Try to smooth the curve out a bit.mmm.. rdy
01:28:941 This spinner's end feels really close to the next set of notes for an easy mode, though there doesn't feel like there's a better place for it. Maybe just map some more regular beats in place of this spinner.I consider it, but I don't think there will be a problem
02:11:294 ^same

[Normal]
02:52:941 Move this down 1 and left 1 grid (level 3)rdy

[Hard]
231 second play time... that's getting pretty long, especially with only one break period.yea maybe
04:12:235 [4] This beat feels like it shouldn't be there. The rhythmic phrase off the vocals feels like it should end at [3]. If you want to finish that visual pattern, just steal one from the previous combo's stacks.I follow the claps no vocals (in this part)

orioncomet wrote:

Just some suggestions.

[General]
- Delete "star.png" and full submit, I think It don't need. oke

[Easy]
01:45:882 (1) - Try sound finish at begin of silder.rdy
02:29:647 (6) - Try sound finish at last silder.rdy

[Normal]
I guess This diff is [Normal+].rdy
01:45:882 (1) - Try replace whistle with finish.

[Hard]]
And This diff can be [Hard].rdy
01:45:882 (1) - Try sound finish at begin of silder.rdy
03:38:823 (1) - Try replace clap with finish.rdy
03:38:823 (1) - After this.. spam Clap not good, IMO.rdy
04:12:235 (4) - Delete..? I think This diff end at 04:11:999 is better, IMO, and add sound finish.*snif* ok

Starrr ~

1. [00:42:117(1)] try to put here a circle and the slider just start at the white line.
2. a 2 star level but not that easy...

1. [00:51:999(5)] new combo
2. [02:03:529(4,5,6)] try this:
   
3. [02:15:529(8)] put the end at [02:15:999] and remove (9)
4. [02:16:941(1,2)(4,5)] let them be sliders
5. [02:22:588(1)] put the end at [02:23:058] and remove (2)
6. [02:25:411(2)] put the end at [02:25:882] and remove (3)
7. [02:26:588(6)] put a slider here and end at [02:26:823] (remove 3)
8. [02:42:117(T)] add a circle here
9. [03:23:058(5)] new combo
10. [03:30:352(1)] make sure that the end of (1) can be covered by the end of (2) :P
11. [03:35:999(1)] consider to increase the volume of the "Finish" sound, i can hardly hear it

1. many places same with [Normal+] and don't repeat :)
2. [01:06:352(7)] replace the circle with a slider that ends at [01:07:058]
3. [01:11:999(6,7,8)] a slider, maybe better?
4. [01:40:235(1-8)] make these more like a heart~ :
5. [03:21:411(10)] new combo
6. [03:21:882] too short *_* two sliders or circle circle slider might be better

Colin Hou wrote:

some suggestions

[Easy]:

1. [00:42:117(1)] try to put here a circle and the slider just start at the white line.rdy
2. a 2 star level but not that easy...it's not my fault xD

[Normal+]:

1. [00:51:999(5)] new combomm rdy
2. [02:03:529(4,5,6)] try this:mm nop sry xd
   
3. [02:15:529(8)] put the end at [02:15:999] and remove (9)rdy
4. [02:16:941(1,2)(4,5)] let them be slidersno D:
5. [02:22:588(1)] put the end at [02:23:058] and remove (2)nup
6. [02:25:411(2)] put the end at [02:25:882] and remove (3)nup
7. [02:26:588(6)] put a slider here and end at [02:26:823] (remove 3)rdy
8. [02:42:117(T)] add a circle here rdy
9. [03:23:058(5)] new combo rdy
10. [03:30:352(1)] make sure that the end of (1) can be covered by the end of (2) ugh ok
11. [03:35:999(1)] consider to increase the volume of the "Finish" sound, i can hardly hear itmm

[Hard]:

1. many places same with [Normal+] and don't repeat
2. [01:06:352(7)] replace the circle with a slider that ends at [01:07:058]^^?
3. [01:11:999(6,7,8)] a slider, maybe better?mm ok
4. [01:40:235(1-8)] make these more like a heart~ :mm rdy
5. [03:21:411(10)] new combordy
6. [03:21:882] too short *_* two sliders or circle circle slider might be betternaa xD

Star~ good luck with it.

Dusty wrote:

I love the cursor ^^

The title actually has a period at the end. (It's a little weird :p) ok

Title: Hartes ciel, melenas walasye.ok ok xd

[Easy]
Well, this map is confusing to me, maybe you do one of three things?

When the overall difficulty is too low, the map actually gets harder... 2, 3, or 4 Overall Difficulty ticks should be a good amount.ok

Or you could decrease the circle size by 1.nop <.<

or just increase the spacing D: mm no xd

[Normal+]
Nice job. <3 thx

[Hard]
<complaint about the spacing> Oh, wait. lol?

1. 01:21:176 - 01:22:588 (section-pass.png) - These time isn't a break time, no need to put section-pass.png in pass layer
   00:00:705 - 00:03:647 (astom.png) - Do some fade better imo

1. When spin, I can't see where cursor is ._., spinner-circle is a little eye dazling for me

1. I got 2 osb.file, delete one please, then full submit
2. world of love loving people game should not to be a tag imo, they contains too much

1. Emm, I feel this is too hard for a Easy, notes are fine
2. Slider Tick Rate : 2 IMO

1. Why this difficulty starts at a unusual place ._.

1. fine

Breeze wrote:

Only RED part is what I think you should fix, others are just suggestions

[SB]

1. 01:21:176 - 01:22:588 (section-pass.png) - These time isn't a break time, no need to put section-pass.png in pass layerRDY
   00:00:705 - 00:03:647 (astom.png) - Do some fade better imo RDY

[Skin]

1. When spin, I can't see where cursor is ._., spinner-circle is a little eye dazling for me ...

[General]

1. I got 2 osb.file, delete one please, then full submit RDY
2. world of love loving people game should not to be a tag imo, they contains too much^^?

[Easy]

1. Emm, I feel this is too hard for a Easy, notes are fine xDDDD sry i can't make it more easy xd
2. Slider Tick Rate : 2 IMO rdy

[Normal+]

1. Why this difficulty starts at a unusual place ._. because finish after of easy? lol I try to keep the same time of duration in easy and normal+

[Hard]

1. fine

nice map hehe thx
star

al2e10 wrote:

By AL2e10's MODMODMOD !!

[Hard]
00:51:529 (4,Start) - Wistle here? mmok
02:43:529 (1) - Remove new combo rdy
02:43:764 (2) - Start new combo rdy
02:44:941 (1) - Remove new cobmo rdy
02:45:176 (2) - Start new combo rdy
02:50:823 (8) - New combo here & remove new combo 02:51:058 (1) rdy
03:17:411 (1) - Remove new combo? mmm nop
03:21:411 (1) - ^?no
03:33:882 (1) - ^?ok
The last, is too many Clap !! xDD okey i fix it
You can just clap in the weite line

[Normal]
01:06:352 (1) - Remove new combo rdy

[ALL}
That prette good and beautiful for your skin ~~
STAR !!

• • Slider Velocity: 120/130
  • Spacing is really bad. Distance spacing: 1,3/1,4
  • 01:20:705 (x) - Add a break

• • Slider Velocity: 130/140
  • Sometimes spacing is weird. Keep always "Distace Snap" active.
  • 01:20:705 (x) - Add a break

• • 01:17:647 (10) - Make this slider more symmetrical
  • 01:20:705 (x) - Add a break

xxheroxx wrote:

[Easy]

• • Slider Velocity: 120/130 rdy
  • Spacing is really bad. Distance spacing: 1,3/1,4rdy
  • 01:20:705 (x) - Add a break rdy

[Normal]

• • Slider Velocity: 130/140rdy
  • Sometimes spacing is weird. Keep always "Distace Snap" active. I fix the problem of spacing, but I don't use "distance snap" because the map becomes very ugly
  • 01:20:705 (x) - Add a break rdy

[Hard]

• • 01:17:647 (10) - Make this slider more symmetrical I made a new one, but it's the best I can do
  • 01:20:705 (x) - Add a break rdy rdy

• • 00:28:235 (1) - Is this a heart? lol. Anyway, the end-slider is partially hidden.
  • 01:40:235 (1) - ^

• • 02:23:294 (2) - Like ^

xxheroxx wrote:

Rechecking...

[Easy]

• • 00:28:235 (1) - Is this a heart? lol. Anyway, the end-slider is partially hidden.
  • 01:40:235 (1) - ^

rdy

[Hard]

• • 02:23:294 (2) - Like ^

rdy

Call me again for a pubble.

xxheroxx wrote:

Pubbled~

FishHook wrote:

[Easy]
1:27:529 (4) Looking at how a lot of the sliders are curved and have a groovy feel to the pitch of the vocals or syllables. I would suggest making this slider have a little bump in the middle to go with the change in vocal pitch.
Something like this....
rdy =)
1:54:117 I know you mentioned something about your distancing being on purpose, but this suggestion would be nice since its [Easy] difficulty. This part is very similar to 2:27:529. I would suggest decreasing the spacing at the later part or increasing the spacing at the first section so they match. Would be better for the beginner players to catch on to beats and patterns, etc... I can't do that because i already decrease the spancing and the maps turns very ugly and if I increase distance, the map turns more hard

[Normal+]
1:48:470 (1)-(9) Looks messy. Maybe give it a little more style like your next combo at 1:51:529 how you have 2 diamonds in between the slider. The third combo has the a nice feel to it too so your first combo doesn't have to be symmetrical.rdy

[Hard]
3:41:647 (1) Nazi spacing here! The first note is slightly, but noticeably closer to the next beat then the rest of the combo. Maybe back that thang out from (2) a smidge so it matches. I already know that but is realy small xD but i fix it
3:51:529 (7) Maybe give this slider a little bit of a curve at the end. Give it enough curve and you can match the pattern. Something like this... I don't take this because the song sounds like laaaaa ... and not laa..aaaa .. xD


Very solid map Astom. The only real change I advice on was the nazi spacing I mentioned. All others were how I felt the flow of the music was like.
+star

YGOkid8 wrote:

Normal+

Combo Mod~
02:50:588 (6) - New Combo.

Hard

Combo Mod~
00:51:529 (1) - No New Combo.
02:06:352 (1) - ^
03:17:411 (1) - ^
---------------------
That's it, no major problems.
Star ~ ☆

Beuchi-chan wrote:

Hi hi

Here are some suggestions for your map, you don't have to change them if you don't agree with me
Let's go!!

~All Diffs~
- Is the "." really needed on the title? If it isn't, delete it?Asi es el nombre de la cancion x_x
- Sliderball looks like it's getting crazy, you should make more sliderball frames to make the animation smoother.trabajare en esto
- Fix spinner-osu.png, it cuts some parts of the letters.tambien revisare esto
- Fix scorebar-ki.png, scorebar-kidanger.png and scorebar-kidanger2.png, they have some little red dots around the leaf images.ia lo sabia pero no pense q alguien se diera cuenta xD
- Offset 0? It sounds completely off at the beggining o.o'. Though... I can't find a better one so... leave it as it is xDbueno es una cancion ripeada de un cd orginal asi q no me parece tan extraño

~Easy~
- Set slider tick rate to 3.rdy

00:13:882 (1) - Add one repeat.rdy

~Normal+~
- Why Normal+? I still don't get why people makes "whateverdiff+". Rename to Hard.Sera pq no le alcanza para ser hard
- Why does this diff start later than [Easy] and [Hard]?porque su duracion total es la misma que la de easy

~Hard~
- Rename to Insane. Emm esta dif no me parece insane, de hecho no es muy dificil x3

01:45:882 - Kinda non-sense 2xbpm part imo.lo hice por el kiai time :3
02:46:117 (7) - New Combo. ups, yes
03:38:823 - If there has to be a 2xbpm section, I would put it here oxo.bueno lo puedo agregar aki tambien

Nice map :3 *star*

Shulin wrote:

Sorry for the delayed recheck!

Easy:

-- Remove "Time X2" SB event from this difficulty. ups sry, rdy

00:22:588 (1,2,3,4) - Potentially confusing stack/overlap for an Easy. I prefer the way you mapped it at 00:28:235 (1,2,3) - fixed
00:52:235 (2) - Move this up with distance snap so its not under the previous slider?rdy
01:37:411 (1,1) - Imo it would be better if you placed these sliders so they didn't overlap at all.rdy
01:48:470 (1,2,3,4,5) - Potentially confusing stack especially with kiai.rdy

Nice overall, my suggestions are just to try and keep it easy, you can ignore them XD haha, no i don't ignore u =(

Normal +:

-- Maybe you should start this at the same place as Easy & Hard (or start Easy in the same place as Normal?)I already dice no map first part of the song, sry
-- Remove "Time X2" from the SB please (it appears at 03:38:117 when the map has just finished...)sry for that

00:49:176 (5) - New combo? rdy
01:36:470 (8) - Bad overlap with 01:36:235 (7) - imo, maybe put 8 in the same place 6 was? fixed in another way *-*

Nice difficulty ^_^

Hard:

02:44:470 (7) - This part of the stream is really hard to hit since its a 1/6 stack after a stream, maybe make it part of the stream? Or maybe delete 02:44:352 (6) - it sounds better imo. rdy
03:21:411 (1) - Delete? (And start spinner earlier?) mmm nop x3
03:28:705 (5) - New combo?rdy

Good overall!

AngelHoney wrote:

red combo color is ....not fit

Hard

01:42:823 (1) - start at 01:43:058 mmm no
02:19:529 (1) - ^ mmm no
03:55:529 (1) - ^ mmm no

Normal+

01:07:529 (1) - ^ mmm no


Slider Tick Rate 3 is ugly....( STR 1 is enough.. yea thx


Easy

02:19:529 (1) - ^ noo <.<

Slider Tick Rate 3 is ugly....( STR 1 is enough.....lol rdy

NICE SONG!!

Dangaard wrote:

good job, fumoffu pubble (ﾉﾟωﾟ)ﾉ

VanMoNky wrote:

As your request.

Read this first for the icon explanation.
- [?] Asking for a second thought.
- [!] Fatal error. You have to fix this for sure.
- [No icon] Only a suggestion.

[General]
1. Increase the slider tick rate to 3. It fits to the song.no D:
2. I love this song.me too :3
3. I'm afraid the timing is wrong. Ask someone to check for it? And anyway, the BPM of last part of the song changed. This part is map-able.Read previus post o_o this discution is closed D:

[Easy]

-- I recommend you to increase the distance a bit. Some parts look crowded. ... XD no comments, I try something
01:10:588 (1) - Could you change this slider's shape? I'm afraid it will be too hard for easy player since it almost like an overlapping slider.rdy
01:40:235 (1) - ^rdy

[Normal]
-- I'm confused. This diff does start oddly. I prefer the start point is just the same as the [Easy] diff.I already explain this :p
-- Why don't you map the diff until the end?please read previus post x3
01:38:588 (4,5) - Move them one tiny grid right. rdy
01:39:294 (6,7) - Move them two tiny grids right. rdy

[Hard]
OK. thx

Star.

Mafiamaster wrote:

Bubbled