forum

Is it worth switching to single tapping?

posted
Total Posts
104
Topic Starter
Robbieyo
Hi,

I currently alternate and was wondering whether I should consider switching over to single tapping and if so why should I. From what I can see most top players single tap, is there any reason to this or is it simply personal preference?
Will3x_old
learn both
xasuma
t/211048

doesn't really matter. Humans are creatures of habits, whatever their habits might be.
Mathsma
HAUHAU is probably considered top 10 by most players and he alternates. There are countless other top players who primarily alternate as well. Just pick whatever feels most comfortable for you.
Loves
Alternate and single tapping are the same if you're used to it. I mean SilviA did it and he was probably top 5 at some point before he quit.
A Medic
Do whatever you're comfortable with.
Akali
It's just simpler, it's easier to be somewhat consistent.

Quoting the smartest person who ever walked on this planet and played this game, alternate patterns you can't single tap. Or just alternate all the time if you are comfortable with it. Just remember that single tapping is way more manly.
Blueprint
You can learn both I think the hardest thing is to learn how to single with both,
from doing the above I end up breaking because of finger confusion this has now turned into an annoying bad habit of using my second finger to single
Slith
all has pro's and con's alternate helps you on streams while single tap helps you with rhythm. when i first started i single tapped then after 6 months switched to alternate. it greatly helped me practice DT maps and then switched back to single tapping after 3 months of alternating. now i single tap more consistently then alternating. learn both as mentioned and you'll find what you like
jesse1412
IDK why everyone is so pro "both work". It's quite clear singletapping generally leads to faster improvement. ANYONE can alt but an alter can't 1key well.
Azer
>anyone can alt
mmyes id love to see you ss an od10 alt map and tell me everyone can alt properly

Just pick whatever you're most comfortable with, OP. The more natural method will be the best for you.
jesse1412

Azer wrote:

>anyone can alt
mmyes id love to see you ss an od10 alt map and tell me everyone can alt properly

Just pick whatever you're most comfortable with, OP. The more natural method will be the best for you.
I couldn't SS an od10 map regardless of what I did : (
thelewa
I can SS an OD10 map by alternating
nyrox
I think singletapping has a more steady improvement because you can always be getting faster.
Alternating, at least for me, gave me a quick spike in improvement but now I'm really struggling to gain speed.
f i z i k

thelewa wrote:

I can SS an OD10 map by alternating
But...Bikko can do it better?
Xyrax Alaria
Really up to you. I find I'm more accurate by single tapping but whatever ya want to do if you feel like you're doing fine don't change anything.
nanochannel

f i z i k wrote:

thelewa wrote:

I can SS an OD10 map by alternating
But...Bikko can do it better?
actually he can't anymore because he turned his hand into a paperweight
Azer
i feel bad for laughing at that
Ichi
It´s faster to improve with singletapping, it is really difficult to alternate correctly, and by that i mean that you FULLY alternate, and not just when a bunch of notes come together, and some other times you single. Singletapping is way more consistent and simpler to learn, simplicity is good, specially for your brain to get used to. I personally alternated when i first started, but i realised i was doing singletapping sometimes, so it wasn´t really a good style, i was caught in the middle of both. I´d say go singletap.
EcksDee

Ichi wrote:

It´s faster to improve with singletapping, it is really difficult to alternate correctly, and by that i mean that you FULLY alternate, and not just when a bunch of notes come together, and some other times you single. Singletapping is way more consistent and simpler to learn, simplicity is good, specially for your brain to get used to. I personally alternated when i first started, but i realised i was doing singletapping sometimes, so it wasn´t really a good style, i was caught in the middle of both. I´d say go singletap.
How is singletapping easier to learn though? When you alternate you know the next note will always be your other finger. When you singletap you gotta think about whether you do need to use your other finger or not. Add onto that the fact that alternating streams when you are a singletapping dude is a completely different set of finger movements being used.

Its like such a roundabout way of playing the game I'm legitimately baffled whenever I see people singletap.
RaneFire

EcksDee wrote:

How is singletapping easier to learn though? When you alternate you know the next note will always be your other finger. When you singletap you gotta think about whether you do need to use your other finger or not. Add onto that the fact that alternating streams when you are a singletapping dude is a completely different set of finger movements being used.

Its like such a roundabout way of playing the game I'm legitimately baffled whenever I see people singletap.
How about you switch to single-tapping and give it a serious try to get good at it before saying stuff that makes no sense.
Vuelo Eluko

EcksDee wrote:

Ichi wrote:

It´s faster to improve with singletapping, it is really difficult to alternate correctly, and by that i mean that you FULLY alternate, and not just when a bunch of notes come together, and some other times you single. Singletapping is way more consistent and simpler to learn, simplicity is good, specially for your brain to get used to. I personally alternated when i first started, but i realised i was doing singletapping sometimes, so it wasn´t really a good style, i was caught in the middle of both. I´d say go singletap.
How is singletapping easier to learn though? When you alternate you know the next note will always be your other finger. When you singletap you gotta think about whether you do need to use your other finger or not. Add onto that the fact that alternating streams when you are a singletapping dude is a completely different set of finger movements being used.

Its like such a roundabout way of playing the game I'm legitimately baffled whenever I see people singletap.
on the contrary it takes even less thought to singletap and patterns become easier because it's easier to learn to tap on tempo with one finger than two because you can go at a fairly consisent speed but if you full alternate you have to constantly change your rate of tapping while also holding tempo so it becomes harder to read patterns and be sure of when to tap

i mean ive used both styles altho im not near as good as you this is my way of seeing it.
EcksDee

Bassist Vinyl wrote:

on the contrary it takes even less thought to singletap and patterns become easier because it's easier to learn to tap on tempo with one finger than two because you can go at a fairly consisent speed but if you full alternate you have to constantly change your rate of tapping while also holding tempo so it becomes harder to read patterns and be sure of when to tap

i mean ive used both styles altho im not near as good as you this is my way of seeing it.
None of that is what I'd call difficult though. Like for me, I don't ever think about patterns of notes. I just subconsciously thing "Ok, 3+1+5+3" or whatever, and my fingers do all the work.

I assume it's the same for you. You don't think about when you have to use both fingers and when you only gotta use one, do you?

Bassist Vinyl wrote:

this is EXACTLY why singletapping makes being accurate and holding tempo easier

That makes I think literally less than no sense.
Vuelo Eluko

EcksDee wrote:

You don't think about when you have to use both fingers and when you only gotta use one, do you?
this is EXACTLY why singletapping makes being accurate and holding tempo easier
Especially on maps that quickly transition between 1/4 and 1/2
nrl

EcksDee wrote:

I assume it's the same for you.
It's not.

Single tapping is intuitive because it ties finger movements to musical rhythm. For any given subdivision of the measure you'll prefer your dominant finger, only using your other finger when that subdivision becomes insufficient to fully describe the rhythm to be tapped. This allows rhythmic complexity to be built on top of a very simple, repetitive foundation. Alternating is non-intuitive because it actively disregards musical rhythm in favor of efficiency. You no longer have a simple, repetitive, foundation to start with, and as a result it's very difficult for a player not experienced with alternation to keep any semblance of rhythm.

Maybe you find alternation easier, but the average player does not, and as an experienced musician I can tell you that the concept single tapping is built on is far more prevalent in the music world than true alternation.
EcksDee

NarrillNezzurh wrote:

EcksDee wrote:

I assume it's the same for you.
It's not.

Single tapping is intuitive because it ties finger movements to musical rhythm. For any given subdivision of the measure you'll prefer your dominant finger, only using your other finger when that subdivision becomes insufficient to fully describe the rhythm to be tapped. This allows rhythmic complexity to be built on top of a very simple, repetitive foundation. Alternating is non-intuitive because it actively disregards musical rhythm in favor of efficiency. You no longer have a simple, repetitive, foundation to start with, and as a result it's very difficult for a player not experienced with alternation to keep any semblance of rhythm.

Maybe you find alternation easier, but the average player does not, and as an experienced musician I can tell you that the concept single tapping is built on is far more prevalent in the music world than true alternation.
I started alternating at like 1000 to 2000 plays I believe. After getting used to it, I immediately saw a rise (relatively speaking) in skill and accuracy. I distinctly remember switching between singletapping and alternating on some demetori song on insane. And it just felt more natural.

I might be illiciting some knee jerk reaction by saying osu isnt that much about maintaining a constant rhythm all the time. Osu is more about knowing how much time it takes for the next note to require pressing, including 1/4 1/2 and sometimes that weird 1/6 shite.

Or at least, I don't play it like that, by maintaining some foundational sense of rhythm in my hands.


Tho against an 'experienced musician' im totally out of my depth
Bweh
It's really a matter of personal preference. I started off alternating, picked up single tapping later, now I just switch between both styles (and single tapping fingers) and I've found that I can play comfortably with either, like shifting gears on a bike. Each style helps with different patterns and tempos, though I'm sure it would depend on the player.

If you really want to know what to do, just give every style a try. Single tapping helped me improve my speed, at least.
leepdesu

Will3x wrote:

learn both
RaneFire

EcksDee wrote:

I started alternating at like 1000 to 2000 plays I believe. After getting used to it, I immediately saw a rise (relatively speaking) in skill and accuracy. I distinctly remember switching between singletapping and alternating on some demetori song on insane. And it just felt more natural.

I might be illiciting some knee jerk reaction by saying osu isnt that much about maintaining a constant rhythm all the time. Osu is more about knowing how much time it takes for the next note to require pressing, including 1/4 1/2 and sometimes that weird 1/6 shite.

Or at least, I don't play it like that, by maintaining some foundational sense of rhythm in my hands.


Tho against an 'experienced musician' im totally out of my depth
Lol'd at last sentence.

The foundational sense of rhythm is mostly a mental thing. However, when you pass your comfort zone in terms of stream speed, "knowing" that exact timing while alternating becomes a little tricky, since it is smaller and thus harder to feel (same for long windows), but at the same time is not as detrimental to accuracy because of the reduced hit window gap between notes. It's just a bit deceptive.

Osu! is about maintaining a constant rhythm. That's what music is, it's ordered and neatly divisible, but there is more than one way to go about it. You have presented your method, but it's not the only one... and 'musicians' will far prefer keeping a beat with the respective body parts used as well (creation of music vs playing along). That is done by using the division method where 1 finger represents a 1/2 note and the other the 1/4 notes. Typical mapping will also cater towards these denominators, except for obscure usage of sliders which gives both styles a hard time. It's a game, not a musical instrument, so you don't have to do this, but many people prefer it since it makes more sense in their heads, where your sense of rhythm is kept.
Blueprint
How is singletapping easier to learn though? When you alternate you know the next note will always be your other finger. When you singletap you gotta think about whether you do need to use your other finger or not. Add onto that the fact that alternating streams when you are a singletapping dude is a completely different set of finger movements being used.

Its like such a roundabout way of playing the game I'm legitimately baffled whenever I see people singletap
.

Thing is its easy to hit every circle while alternating but like people have said it's easy to misstime so unless your an experienced alt you simply mash through certain things, anyway I alternate maps I can't single at all ^
jesse1412
If you alt you are more likely to hit "the wall" faster. It's just how it is, both are good but your chances of being good at one are much higher.
nrl

EcksDee wrote:

Tho against an 'experienced musician' im totally out of my depth
All I'm saying is that if alternation is legitimately more intuitive for you, you're an outlier.
EcksDee

jesus1412 wrote:

If you alt you are more likely to hit "the wall" faster. It's just how it is, both are good but your chances of being good at one are much higher.
I'm legitimately interested in the evidence for this.
AegisFTW
I've managed to cram both in, I gain the ability to alternate not because I thought it was better, but it just came naturally to me as my brain/fingers prefer alternating rather than focusing on one finger, however instead of alternating everything like most do, I usually just alternate everything unless everything is in a 1/2 stack, no matter what speed, this came also by accident, not by force. This is great for me since I can practice single tapping at least a little bit, and it has managed to get me to stupidly ridiculous single tap speeds, too bad it's not directly related to streaming for me.

If I were to choose either, I just say preference, but you might as well learn both.

jesus1412 wrote:

If you alt you are more likely to hit "the wall" faster. It's just how it is, both are good but your chances of being good at one are much higher.
What exactly is "the wall"?
GoldenWolf
the stamina wall
nrl
I don't know how true that is. Alternating is moderately tiring, but I think attempting to single tap instead would be even worse.
EcksDee

NarrillNezzurh wrote:

I don't know how true that is. Alternating is moderately tiring, but I think attempting to single tap instead would be even worse.
I think the point they mean is..
I actually don't know. You don't get tired when alternating, ever. Is that the point? It's less exhausting?
GoldenWolf
You don't push your stamina as hard as with singletaping
But then again it depends whether or not you play a lot of streamy maps/practice streams often, etc
buny

jesus1412 wrote:

If you alt you are more likely to hit "the wall" faster. It's just how it is, both are good but your chances of being good at one are much higher.
Not exactly true, but we haven't reached the skill level where we're playing 200bpm jump maps yet.

Personally I alternate when it gets to 170bpm, as it's just too much strain afterwards
Topic Starter
Robbieyo
Cool thanks for all the replies, guess I'll probably stick to alternating for now have tried single tapping a few times but don't really like it as much feel its easier for me to follow the rhythm of the song when I alternate.
buny

Robbieyo wrote:

Cool thanks for all the replies, guess I'll probably stick to alternating for now have tried single tapping a few times but don't really like it as much feel its easier for me to follow the rhythm of the song when I alternate.
If you really want to push past the standard skill level, you should learn how to single tap.

By that, I mean you're aiming for a long term goal of 270bpm
jesse1412

GoldenWolf wrote:

the stamina wall
Most players hit the wall and progress becomes a rarity. Alting players get the speed burst at first "huh lol i can play scarlet rose". After a while the 1key players catch up and don't stop until they hit their own wall as they are FORCED to get faster. Both can be accurate as fuck but the wall is all about physical ability, not reading or accuracy.

EcksDee

jesus1412 wrote:

GoldenWolf wrote:

the stamina wall
Most players hit the wall and progress becomes a rarity. Alting players get the speed burst at first "huh lol i can play scarlet rose". After a while the 1key players catch up and don't stop until they hit their own wall as they are FORCED to get faster. Both can be accurate as fuck but the wall is all about physical ability, not reading or accuracy.


Please show evidence for this not hurr durr i got draw good

Like how can you tell it's not



also sry i draw "A" for "Ability" weird
jesse1412
Black are alters white are people who use 1key when possible. most of the alt players aren't "fast" players. Fits the trend very nicely, few, far, and not as fast as the faster 1key players. I have provided more reasoning than you in this discussion. "hurr durr u have no base" has even less basis than what I'm saying.

EcksDee
Trend does not indicate an objective super-wall of objective universal suckage.
Just because most blacks have big dicks doesnt mean whites cant have dicks just as big.


edit:
I understand, and I am well, well aware that 95% of the top players are singletappers. This is the only 'reasoning' you have.
Your statement however is that alters hit the wall faster.

How do you know this is some kind of truth of the universe and not just the fact that most people singletap because of reasons?
jesse1412
And that's why if you'd have read the posts you'd have realised even the title of the graph says "Typical players".

It's more common and easier for 1key players to progress in the long term, not all.

I used the front page of the ranking to indicate that MOST of the people who get good use 1key primarily.

EDIT:

I understand, and I am well, well aware that 95% of the top players are singletappers.
Your statement however is that alters hit the wall faster.

How do you know this is some kind of truth of the universe and not just the fact that most people singletap because of reasons?
I don't, it's just what I have seen from observing friends/players in general.
nrl

jesus1412 wrote:

Fits the trend very nicely
It in no way confirms the trend you graphed. Correlation does not equal causation, and there are a number of explanations for the relative lack of alternaters in the top 50, most of which have nothing to do with the actual limitations of alternation.
RaneFire

EcksDee wrote:

How do you know this is some kind of truth of the universe and not just the fact that most people singletap because of reasons?
Quite a few alters switch to single-tap when they hit that wall. That's what is skewing the statistics. I can assure you that the statistic is not 95% because of "follow the leader."

I haven't heard of anyone going back to full-alt after changing to single-tap and learning to play it properly. They still alternate when necessary, but primarily single-tap forever after the change because they get the results they want.

I haven't heard of any single-tappers changing to primary full-alt because it seemed better, but the other way around has happened a lot and many alternating players come to these forums and also pm asking for help with complicated maps, whereas single-tappers just post "pls help stream speed AR10 pls". That sounds like enough evidence for me... For whatever reason... You are free to deduce your own.

Top alternating players are seen as exceptional. We seem to set them apart. There's a reason for that and I don't know why, but it exists. It's probably all in our heads, but I wouldn't underestimate what goes on in our heads, as opposed to just our fingers.

You're not going to get any objective evidence, because noone is at the skill cap for the human race. But for those who are still progressing, there is plenty of this "trend."
Vuelo Eluko

NarrillNezzurh wrote:

jesus1412 wrote:

Fits the trend very nicely
It in no way confirms the trend you graphed. Correlation does not equal causation, and there are a number of explanations for the relative lack of alternaters in the top 50, most of which have nothing to do with the actual limitations of alternation.
theres no doubt a lot of factors in what makes a top player but if a lack of one factor is almost always the case, that ONE factor raises red flags. I played WoW and you know why there were no enhancement shamans on a single one of the top 100 arena teams in season 9 [keeping in mind, an arena team, like a player, has many things that make it work well]? enhancement shamans, like alternating, just weren't the most viable way. or it would have been seen more I think.

unless you have a good explanation for the lack of alternators besides lack of viability which I'd be interested in...
jesse1412
It's not unviable. Just harder to master.
Vuelo Eluko

jesus1412 wrote:

It's not unviable. Just harder to master.
yeah but in a game where everyones basically in a constant race to the top in a sense, that makes it unviable. kind of like how a slow car is 'just as good' as a fast car because it can go just as many miles before needing to be serviced, but in the end, it's just not going to be as viable in a competitive setting like that. Yeah the slower/harder to master car/tapping style can get just as far as the faster car, but the fast/easier to master one will always, always be ahead of it

this analogy might have some flaws and it might be a little over iterated but I think it's valid, probably
GhostFromTCR

EcksDee wrote:

Ichi wrote:

It´s faster to improve with singletapping, it is really difficult to alternate correctly, and by that i mean that you FULLY alternate, and not just when a bunch of notes come together, and some other times you single. Singletapping is way more consistent and simpler to learn, simplicity is good, specially for your brain to get used to. I personally alternated when i first started, but i realised i was doing singletapping sometimes, so it wasn´t really a good style, i was caught in the middle of both. I´d say go singletap.
How is singletapping easier to learn though? When you alternate you know the next note will always be your other finger. When you singletap you gotta think about whether you do need to use your other finger or not. Add onto that the fact that alternating streams when you are a singletapping dude is a completely different set of finger movements being used.

Its like such a roundabout way of playing the game I'm legitimately baffled whenever I see people singletap.
I single tap and I think that alternating is farking impossible. I probably am okay at alternating, but not very good since I usually single tap most of the notes.
nrl

Bassist Vinyl wrote:

theres no doubt a lot of factors in what makes a top player but if a lack of one factor is almost always the case, that ONE factor raises red flags. I played WoW and you know why there were no enhancement shamans on a single one of the top 100 arena teams in season 9 [keeping in mind, an arena team, like a player, has many things that make it work well]? enhancement shamans, like alternating, just weren't the most viable way. or it would have been seen more I think.

unless you have a good explanation for the lack of alternators besides lack of viability which I'd be interested in...
Correlation does not equal causation. That single factor does raise red flags, but without proper evidence you can't prove that it's the cause. Maybe few top players alternate because they started off single-tapping and never found a need to learn to alternate. Perhaps many of those top players are old enough that alternation simply wasn't a commonly known thing when they were learning. Perhaps they just don't see a need to learn it because what they have now is working. And of course, this disparity in the top bracket of players gives alternating a certain stigma, meaning new players are less likely to pick it up, leading to fewer alternating top players a few years down the road. It's entirely likely that these things are reasons why alternating isn't more common, and none of them have to do with the viability of alternating at all.

Personally, I've found alternation to be a very valuable skill to have, and I firmly advocate learning it and using it side by side with single tapping. Where one fails, the other shines.
jesse1412

NarrillNezzurh wrote:

Bassist Vinyl wrote:

theres no doubt a lot of factors in what makes a top player but if a lack of one factor is almost always the case, that ONE factor raises red flags. I played WoW and you know why there were no enhancement shamans on a single one of the top 100 arena teams in season 9 [keeping in mind, an arena team, like a player, has many things that make it work well]? enhancement shamans, like alternating, just weren't the most viable way. or it would have been seen more I think.

unless you have a good explanation for the lack of alternators besides lack of viability which I'd be interested in...
Correlation does not equal causation. That single factor does raise red flags, but without proper evidence you can't prove that it's the cause. Maybe few top players alternate because they started off single-tapping and never found a need to learn to alternate. Perhaps many of those top players are old enough that alternation simply wasn't a commonly known thing when they were learning. Perhaps they just don't see a need to learn it because what they have now is working. And of course, this disparity in the top bracket of players gives alternating a certain stigma, meaning new players are less likely to pick it up, leading to fewer alternating top players a few years down the road. It's entirely likely that these things are reasons why alternating isn't more common, and none of them have to do with the viability of alternating at all.

Personally, I've found alternation to be a very valuable skill to have, and I firmly advocate learning it and using it side by side with single tapping. Where one fails, the other shines.
Yes both should be learnt. I'd just advice one is learnt before the other.
buny
Of course you would prefer alternating over single tap when "single tap fails", because you would rather use an alternative method than putting in the effort to improve your speed/stamina thus hurting you in the long run as you play higher bpm.

It's like taking the elevator rather than the stairs - one takes more effort, sure I might take a while longer to get there but it is more beneficial to me if time isn't of essence.
And what would happen if I kept doing this each day, for each month? Each year? There would be a point where I could probably get there faster than if I took the elevator (unless it was some really large building)
nrl
It's not at all like taking the elevator rather than the stairs. You'll get better at alternating over time, but you'll never get better at taking the elevator. It's more like typing rather than writing on paper. It's more rigid, but far faster.

Now that I think about it, that's not a solid line of thinking at all. What you're suggesting is akin to single-tapping streams because it'll be better for our stamina in the long run.
buny

NarrillNezzurh wrote:

It's not at all like taking the elevator rather than the stairs. You'll get better at alternating over time, but you'll never get better at taking the elevator. It's more like typing rather than writing on paper. It's more rigid, but far faster.

Now that I think about it, that's not a solid line of thinking at all. What you're suggesting is akin to single-tapping streams because it'll be better for our stamina in the long run.
True it wasn't the best analogy I could come up with the time, but what I was trying to say is that alternating puts nearly no strain or pain on your fingers at all - thus you wouldn't really be training your stamina or speed in any way and the only aspect that you're going to improve is your aim and accuracy (which can be done single tapping also).

Also, I'm not limiting to what I say as in 150bpm maps with 150bpm 1/4 streams, I'm meaning maps that are 300bpm with 300bpm 1/4 streams and 1/2 single taps. I highly doubt a player that alternates could be more or equally likely to be able to stream that fast compared to a single tap player.
nrl

buny wrote:

I highly doubt a player that alternates could be more or equally likely to be able to stream that fast compared to a single tap player.
Why? I can't speak for anyone else, but for me the physical motions of single-tapping and streaming are different (wrist motion vs. finger motion), so training one doesn't really help the other. The only way for me to practice streaming high bpm is to stream high bpm.
Topic Starter
Robbieyo
Just gave single tapping a decent go and still fairly unsure if it would actually be better for me but going to as most people suggested learn both. I still can't really see how single tapping would improve my speed faster than alternating, I mean if I wanted to "hit the wall" I could just sit there playing maps like End Time for a while till my fingers just die.
EcksDee

Robbieyo wrote:

Just gave single tapping a decent go and still fairly unsure if it would actually be better for me but going to as most people suggested learn both. I still can't really see how single tapping would improve my speed faster than alternating, I mean if I wanted to "hit the wall" I could just sit there playing maps like End Time for a while till my fingers just die.
Generally the justification for this is that singletapping tires you out faster which trains your muscles more, but as one is in the wrist and the other is in the fingers, I don't see how this can truly be the case.
Dexus
if you're using your wrist/arm/elbow to single tap you're doing it wrong. Just the fingers; that's how it works.

Think of it this way: you move one finger the same way you would as if you were streaming.

Practice this with both of your fingers and you can find your limit pretty quickly and train to overcome it.

Gotya Gotya Uruse (220 bpm): https://osu.ppy.sh/b/76638&m=0
This map is good to see how well you handle single tapping. In theory if you can easily do this with both of your fingers (single tapping that is) then you can stream at 220bpm. This can be applied with any bpm. Of course actual stream training would still need to be done, but it's still a good indicator of what you need to practice.

F.I. (180 bpm): https://osu.ppy.sh/s/25828
This is a slower map where the intro is another good indicator, if you can't even do this with both of your fingers then you need to practice it or play more 180-185 bpm maps.

More single tap maps can be found here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc ... ring#gid=0

Also, If you're not really noticing any difference try lifting your fingers higher. This will pose more of a challenge.

As for my thoughts on alternating, it's just slow streaming, so the concept and being able to do it isn't very difficult. I did it for 3 years when I started osu! and didn't see much improvement, 1 year of single tapping (still continued to this day) has blown away anything I did previously. I remember it was very difficult to switch, but very worth it.
Akali
if you're using your wrist/arm/elbow to single tap you're doing it wrong. Just the fingers; that's how it works.
Ugh, unless you are literally cookiezi? I realise that if he did something it doesn't necesarily mean everyone should play exactly like him, but you can't tell consistency of his single tap and streaming wasn't amazing, thus that he did it wrong, or that anyone that has good effects using wrist does it wrong.
Karuta-_old_1
I started off single tapping and alternating for sliders
I begin alternating in order to improve my streaming and most Japanese players can alternate and single
(And single tapping through EVERY song is a really really mundane thing to do)

Now I've adapated to a mixed style of alternating and single tapping depending on the situation and yes I use both fingers for single tapping as well regardless of which finger's turn it is to tap. but I can hardly improve in my streaming speed and stamina.

There is no one size fits all thing in this game, you've gotta try it out yourself
buny

Dexus wrote:

if you're using your wrist/arm/elbow to single tap you're doing it wrong. Just the fingers; that's how it works.
This

Stop comparing single tapping as wrist tapping, it's like saying double tapping is to alternating...
EcksDee

buny wrote:

Dexus wrote:

if you're using your wrist/arm/elbow to single tap you're doing it wrong. Just the fingers; that's how it works.
This

Stop comparing single tapping as wrist tapping like double tapping is to alternating...
And yet most liveplays on youtube of singletappers involve a combination of finger and wrist/arm movement for faster singletapping.

I quoth:

The most efficient method of playing singles with your arm that I found is to
Tense up your finger
Lift your wrist from the table a bit
Move your elbow up and your hand down at the same time
Move your elbow down and your hand up at the same time
Repeat last 2 steps. This essentially is rotating your forearm around the point between your elbow and hand back and forth.
lovelace

EcksDee wrote:

The most efficient method of playing singles with your arm that I found is to
Tense up your finger
Lift your wrist from the table a bit
Move your elbow up and your hand down at the same time
Move your elbow down and your hand up at the same time
Repeat last 2 steps. This essentially is rotating your forearm around the point between your elbow and hand back and forth.
I support the later quote, though I believe some parts are down to preference and style. For instance, I sometime like to rest my wrist on the edge of my keyboard (as it's all curved and stuff). Though the general aspect is the same. Tap with your arm. Not your wrist. Tensing perhaps isn't a must, but I suppose it helps...?
buny

EcksDee wrote:

And yet most liveplays on youtube of singletappers involve a combination of finger and wrist/arm movement for faster singletapping.

I quoth:

The most efficient method of playing singles with your arm that I found is to
Tense up your finger
Lift your wrist from the table a bit
Move your elbow up and your hand down at the same time
Move your elbow down and your hand up at the same time
Repeat last 2 steps. This essentially is rotating your forearm around the point between your elbow and hand back and forth.
The most efficient method to playing singles that you can't single tap is to alternate
what's your point?
EcksDee

buny wrote:

The most efficient method to playing singles that you can't single tap is to alternate
what's your point?
The point is, no-one fucking ever plays any singles past 200 bpm by just using their fingers like streaming with one finger.
buny

EcksDee wrote:

buny wrote:

The most efficient method to playing singles that you can't single tap is to alternate
what's your point?
The point is, no-one fucking ever plays any singles past 200 bpm by just using their fingers like streaming with one finger.
Using 200 bpm as a counterpoint is just extreme, as players haven't reached that breakpoint yet (I'd say highest NORMAL single tapping is 180bpm)
And even then, 180bpm is a stretch on the capabilities we as humans can reach as of right now. I'm not saying to single tap EVERYTHING, but up to a competitive level such as image material, which is 260bpm and has 260bpm streams and 130bpm singles.

I'm pretty sure 240bpm streams seemed impossible a few years back, now 240bpm and over is seen as hard work and dedication and players that alternated in the past are seen as less skillful because they can't keep up.
Vuelo Eluko

EcksDee wrote:

The point is, no-one fucking ever plays any singles past 200 bpm by just using their fingers like streaming with one finger.
Pls stahp.




@buny i believe when he said 200 bpm singles he meant 1/2 notes which would be 100 bpm 1/4.
Coffee Hero
@buny i believe when he said 200 bpm singles he meant 1/2 notes which would be 100 bpm 1/4
What, but soooo many people can singletap that, that can't possibly be what he means.
EcksDee

Shirokami- wrote:

@buny i believe when he said 200 bpm singles he meant 1/2 notes which would be 100 bpm 1/4
What, but soooo many people can singletap that, that can't possibly be what he means.
I said anything above 200 bpm. I can singletap 200bpm easily, of course. Anything under that I can do with just my fingers, anything over that my body involves the wrist and arm.

Really that guy doing the image material is the exception not the rule as far as I've seen
f i z i k

EcksDee wrote:

I said anything above 200 bpm. I can singletap 200bpm easily, of course. Anything under that I can do with just my fingers, anything over that my body involves the wrist and arm.

Really that guy doing the image material is the exception not the rule as far as I've seen
Well I'm pretty sure if you can stream 260bpm then you can also do a couple singles on that bpm,but using wrist is so much more reliable/consistent and not half as tiring so why do otherwise? I think what he means is literally the best practice is tapping with your fingers only,but if you really wanted to do a good run youll use your wrist for a certain bpm anyway.
Hitoyomi_old
Just my 2 cents as an alternate player, but play the way you have more fun.

Even if you could theoretically prove that single-tapping is de facto "better", if the switch is going to be tedious and unfun, it'll just lead to pointless frustration down the line and leave you less motivated to play and perfect your technique.
On the other hand if you have fun learning single-tapping, why not - being a more versatile player is not going to hurt.
otoed1
I don't really get it, but when I started I used single tap, I tried alternating and it was awful at first. However, after a few hours I found it waaaaay better then single tap. This was on normal - easy maps tho so idk. I guess i'll try out single tapping again, but alternating seems better, logically you can tap faster with two keys rather than one and having two means you'll tire out slower as well. Personally alternating seems straight up better. The only pro to single tapping appears to be only thinking about one key for the majority of maps imho.
nrl

buny wrote:

This

Stop comparing single tapping as wrist tapping, it's like saying double tapping is to alternating...
It still doesn't matter, because there's no reason to use a less efficient tool just for the sake of using a less efficient tool. No matter how you do it, streaming isn't the same as just adding a second finger to single-tapping; the added motion of the second finger makes them different on a physiological level, and the alteration to the movement as a whole means the muscle memory doesn't transfer. If anything, alternating is much closer to streaming simply because the motions are identical, so alternating very high bpm maps would train everything but your speed, and if you want to train your streaming speed the best way to do it is to stream.

You claim that single tapping is beneficial because it allows for faster improvement, but you don't seem to get that the reason it allows for faster improvement is because it pushes the player harder, and that it's entirely possible to get that extra push from alternating by simply playing faster maps. I highly doubt that alternating players hit a "stamina wall," and if they do I'd say it's entirely their own fault for not figuring out how to push through it with the tools available to them. I think it's far more likely they hit an accuracy wall.
RaneFire
The walls you hit and their order depends mostly on the person though. Single-tappers hit walls too, and everyone has their own wall/s to overcome. To try and pin 1 of those on alternating is pointless.

Also to say that wrist single-tapping doesn't train your fingers is also a myth. That's like saying we don't use our neck muscles to hold our heads up if we aren't moving it. The impact from hitting the keyboard harder due to using your wrist causes a strain on your finger too. It allows you to tap faster and a marginal improvement to stamina, which quickly becomes a problem again as we step up to even higher BPM's to get the same challenge. As long as you don't settle, the method doesn't matter too much.
Vuelo Eluko

Shirokami- wrote:

@buny i believe when he said 200 bpm singles he meant 1/2 notes which would be 100 bpm 1/4
What, but soooo many people can singletap that, that can't possibly be what he means.
he was referring to the technique of only using your finger to tap not wrist, which he believed could not be used above 200 bpm 1/2, thats why i posted keigoclear [aka who?] playing image material
look at the post he was quoting
shavit

nyrox wrote:

I think singletapping has a more steady improvement because you can always be getting faster.
Alternating, at least for me, gave me a quick spike in improvement but now I'm really struggling to gain speed.
nyrox always tells the truth
+1337
Zare
is it worth playing osu
jesse1412

NarrillNezzurh wrote:

buny wrote:

This

Stop comparing single tapping as wrist tapping, it's like saying double tapping is to alternating...
It still doesn't matter, because there's no reason to use a less efficient tool just for the sake of using a less efficient tool. No matter how you do it, streaming isn't the same as just adding a second finger to single-tapping; the added motion of the second finger makes them different on a physiological level, and the alteration to the movement as a whole means the muscle memory doesn't transfer. If anything, alternating is much closer to streaming simply because the motions are identical, so alternating very high bpm maps would train everything but your speed, and if you want to train your streaming speed the best way to do it is to stream.

You claim that single tapping is beneficial because it allows for faster improvement, but you don't seem to get that the reason it allows for faster improvement is because it pushes the player harder, and that it's entirely possible to get that extra push from alternating by simply playing faster maps. I highly doubt that alternating players hit a "stamina wall," and if they do I'd say it's entirely their own fault for not figuring out how to push through it with the tools available to them. I think it's far more likely they hit an accuracy wall.
To an alting player a map needs to be either full of streams (good luck diving straight in after building up on singles) or above 400bpm to get some fast 1/2 notes to practice. Good luck to you my friend pushing yourself without spamming deathstream maps constantly. Of course you can go play fast maps which are evidently in abundance, assuming you've learnt to read and aim 400bpm 1/2 full screen jumps in which case I applaud you.
EcksDee

jesus1412 wrote:

To an alting player a map needs to be either full of streams (good luck diving straight in after building up on singles) or above 400bpm to get some fast 1/2 notes to practice. Good luck to you my friend pushing yourself without spamming deathstream maps constantly. Of course you can go play fast maps which are evidently in abundance, assuming you've learnt to read and aim 400bpm 1/2 full screen jumps in which case I applaud you.
Whats wrong with practicing on deathstream maps separately

I mean truth be told im still very much on the fence about that "singletapping fast with your arm/wrist with a stationary finger helps speed up your two finger streaming with a stationary arm/wrist"

I remember you said "it just does", but i'll hold my breath until we see an alter in the top5 players.

May or may not happen, but thats a whole lot of claims being thrown out yknow.
jesse1412

EcksDee wrote:

jesus1412 wrote:

To an alting player a map needs to be either full of streams (good luck diving straight in after building up on singles) or above 400bpm to get some fast 1/2 notes to practice. Good luck to you my friend pushing yourself without spamming deathstream maps constantly. Of course you can go play fast maps which are evidently in abundance, assuming you've learnt to read and aim 400bpm 1/2 full screen jumps in which case I applaud you.
Whats wrong with practicing on deathstream maps separately

I mean truth be told im still very much on the fence about that "singletapping fast with your arm/wrist with a stationary finger helps speed up your two finger streaming with a stationary arm/wrist"

I remember you said "it just does", but i'll hold my breath until we see an alter in the top5 players.

May or may not happen, but thats a whole lot of claims being thrown out yknow.
The problem is most people just don't like deathstream maps straight out. Even 1key players.
EcksDee

jesus1412 wrote:

The problem is most people just don't like deathstream maps straight out. Even 1key players.
Yeah, I hate deathstreams. Heck, I genuinely hate streaming full stop, but if what I need to do to continue alternating, as that's what feels natural to me, is specifically practice them, then that's what I'm gonna do.
nrl

jesus1412 wrote:

To an alting player a map needs to be either full of streams (good luck diving straight in after building up on singles) or above 400bpm to get some fast 1/2 notes to practice. Good luck to you my friend pushing yourself without spamming deathstream maps constantly. Of course you can go play fast maps which are evidently in abundance, assuming you've learnt to read and aim 400bpm 1/2 full screen jumps in which case I applaud you.
And this is a problem unique to alternating players because...
Vuelo Eluko

NarrillNezzurh wrote:

jesus1412 wrote:

To an alting player a map needs to be either full of streams (good luck diving straight in after building up on singles) or above 400bpm to get some fast 1/2 notes to practice. Good luck to you my friend pushing yourself without spamming deathstream maps constantly. Of course you can go play fast maps which are evidently in abundance, assuming you've learnt to read and aim 400bpm 1/2 full screen jumps in which case I applaud you.
And this is a problem unique to alternating players because...
as in its harder for a full alt to push themselves in stamina/speed because they have to go way faster than a singletapper to reach that speed where it becomes difficult physically.

it's limiting
nrl
I've already explained why I don't believe that to be the case.
EcksDee

Bassist Vinyl wrote:

as in its harder for a full alt to push themselves in stamina/speed because they have to go way faster than a singletapper to reach that speed where it becomes difficult physically.

it's limiting
If you can show why singletapping is somehow better in training your streaming speed, then you might have a case.
RaneFire
You guys are turning this into a technical debate when it's not. If it were about technical details, then alternating is superior, since you can just train streams to sort out your speed/stamina.

Fact is, it's not that simple. You can argue this forever (as it has been going on forever already), because like I said, everyone has different walls to overcome and some may not apply to certain people who have success with alternating. Generally people have an easier time grasping the game and learning to be accurate when single-tapping.

If all you are going to say is, "oh, but that can be sorted out with practice" - then you don't have an argument. We aren't comparing the skill cap, we're comparing rate of progression, since it's quite obvious that no one is there yet and alternating has a lot of potential. Many people share the opinion that alternating takes more effort/practice since there are extra variables... like practicing to do patterns in both directions with your fingers, and to do that fast and accurately.

Anyway, that's not all there is to it. If it were just a speed/stamina issue, how do you explain why alternating players don't challenge themselves? Who would get comfortable so easily? There has to be another reason and I think reading has something to do with it because alternating players aren't anywhere near challenging their speed/stamina on typical maps. You actually have to go to deathstream maps to practice something you rarely use.
nrl
I agree completely. I just don't think it's a good idea to totally throw out the concept, and many players do just that using silly, potentially circular logic.
tollox
Could anyone who has successfully managed to increase their singletapping speed comment on the method they used? Did you practice on singletapping maps at the limit of your speed or slightly above? Or did it come naturally by just playing whatever?

Also, does anyone have any good maps for singletap practice between 210 and 220 bpm? I can't pass past that barrier.


These are good at 210:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/27306
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/20328
RaneFire

tollox wrote:

Could anyone who has successfully managed to increase their singletapping speed comment on the method they used? Did you practice on singletapping maps at the limit of your speed or slightly above? Or did it come naturally by just playing whatever?
Wrist tapping trains strength in your finger and wrist, but your wrist is mostly affected in terms of speed/stamina gains, not your finger. The gain in finger strength can help to reaffirm muscle memory with the method below. This is done simply by hitting your keyboard harder and playing at or above your limit.

Finger-tapping leads to a direct gain in speed and stamina for your finger, but not much strength, since it is important to maintain a relaxed state in your hand while isolating finger movement, when playing at your limit. This is less important at slower speeds where you can use more strength for each hit and help to reaffirm muscle memory for when you go back to higher speeds (like interchanging slow & fast stream training to improve stream speed).

So use your wrist for things that are faster than you are capable of finger-tapping (above limits). Use finger-tapping on anything within your limits, gradually using more force when things get slower to reaffirm muscle memory and get some moderate finger strength training.

Or you could start lifting and forget all that.

Feel free to disagree, I won't get butthurt, I promise.
Yuunee
Do whatever you feel comfortable with. Most of people singletap because this is their preference. I, personally, can do both. But i feel comfortable when alternating between 2 keys ^~^
jesse1412

tollox wrote:

Could anyone who has successfully managed to increase their singletapping speed comment on the method they used? Did you practice on singletapping maps at the limit of your speed or slightly above? Or did it come naturally by just playing whatever?

Also, does anyone have any good maps for singletap practice between 210 and 220 bpm? I can't pass past that barrier.


These are good at 210:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/27306
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/20328
Got you covered buddy. Thank ranefire. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc ... ring#gid=0
Topic Starter
Robbieyo
Well been single tapping for quite a bit now and I can't really say I can see what you guys say. I really don't even come close to getting tired or to feel "pushed" even if I spam play things like talent shredder chata remind and a bunch of other songs. Granted those aren't the fastest of maps but what keeps me from even trying to play faster things is my accuracy/reading and not really my single tap speed. I still only manage to get tired when I play https://osu.ppy.sh/b/117580&m=0 for a while but thats pretty much because its a lot of streaming the entire time which involves me alternating.
tollox

RaneFire wrote:

tollox wrote:

Could anyone who has successfully managed to increase their singletapping speed comment on the method they used? Did you practice on singletapping maps at the limit of your speed or slightly above? Or did it come naturally by just playing whatever?
Wrist tapping trains strength in your finger and wrist, but your wrist is mostly affected in terms of speed/stamina gains, not your finger. The gain in finger strength can help to reaffirm muscle memory with the method below. This is done simply by hitting your keyboard harder and playing at or above your limit.

Finger-tapping leads to a direct gain in speed and stamina for your finger, but not much strength, since it is important to maintain a relaxed state in your hand while isolating finger movement, when playing at your limit. This is less important at slower speeds where you can use more strength for each hit and help to reaffirm muscle memory for when you go back to higher speeds (like interchanging slow & fast stream training to improve stream speed).

So use your wrist for things that are faster than you are capable of finger-tapping (above limits). Use finger-tapping on anything within your limits, gradually using more force when things get slower to reaffirm muscle memory and get some moderate finger strength training.

Or you could start lifting and forget all that.

Feel free to disagree, I won't get butthurt, I promise.
Sounds like good advice! Gotta work on them wristtaps it seems, there are huge areas outside of my limits.

jesus1412 wrote:

tollox wrote:

Could anyone who has successfully managed to increase their singletapping speed comment on the method they used? Did you practice on singletapping maps at the limit of your speed or slightly above? Or did it come naturally by just playing whatever?

Also, does anyone have any good maps for singletap practice between 210 and 220 bpm? I can't pass past that barrier.


These are good at 210:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/27306
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/20328
Got you covered buddy. Thank ranefire. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc ... ring#gid=0
Sweet, that's really helpful.
aizhid
I regret full alternating.
My accuracy is hopeless and im not raising my limits because maps that are hard overall do not make me push my speed.
nooblet

aizhid wrote:

I regret full alternating.
My accuracy is hopeless and im not raising my limits because maps that are hard overall do not make me push my speed.
What in the -

What does full alternating have to do with bad accuracy? You have to work on something to get good at it. I full alternate as well, and I'm fully capable of mashing semi-accurately (98-99.5) on songs of OD 7-8.
Hitoyomi_old
Yeah, 85% accuracy is a not an issue with your tapping technique. Like I'd guess either you have no ear for rhythm or your offset is beyond wrong.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply

/