blissfulyoshi wrote:

Friends:

SPOILER

Combo mod:
01:10:88 (4) - new combo for consistency done

Buddies:

SPOILER

I am not sure how easy slider stacks like 02:40:60 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) are to read for players let me think about that...

The rest of the diff is fine though.

Nice map. Star.

whymeman wrote:

Remember, some of the errors posted are suggestions, not directions. Edit to what you see fit.

Detailed Modding Go~

Osz. File Check (Done)

SPOILER

Video: No
SB (Story Board): Yes
Custom Skin: No
Background: Yes
[Current] Size: 5.56 MB / 10.00 MB
Source: Yes
Tags: Yes

[Friends] (Done)

SPOILER

Timing (BPM / Offset): 95.300 / 374 ms (Sounds good so far)
[Currently] with double BPM: No
[Currently] with altered timing sections: No
[Current] Slider Tick Rate / Velocity: 1 / 1.60
Distance Snap Average: x0.9 (Solid)
[Current] Objects: 130 ( 63 Circles / 60 Sliders / 7 Spinners )
[Current] Max Combo: 220
[Current] Max Score: 547,848
[Current] Star Rating: 3.39
[Current] HP Drain Rate: Lv.5
[Current] Circle Size: Lv.1
[Current] Overall Difficulty: Lv.4

01:26:20 (B) - Delete and replace break.
01:36:59 (B) - ^ all done

Notes: Just need to check the breaks. The rest of the map seems fine. thanks

[Buddies] (Done)

SPOILER

Timing (BPM / Offset): 95.300 / 374 ms (Sounds good so far)
[Currently] with double BPM: No
[Currently] with altered timing sections: No
[Current] Slider Tick Rate / Velocity: 4 / 2.40
Distance Snap Average: x0.9 (Solid)
[Current] Objects: 316 ( 210 Circles / 89 Sliders / 17 Spinners )
[Current] Max Combo: 527
[Current] Max Score: 4,122,432
[Current] Star Rating: 4.67
[Current] HP Drain Rate: Lv.7
[Current] Circle Size: Lv.2
[Current] Overall Difficulty: Lv.6

00:10:76 (1,3) - The stack here looks a bit uneven. (3) is not under the end of (1). fixed
00:11:54 (3,4) - Supposed to be closer or more farther apart? fixed
00:53:57 (1,3) - Same problem like at@ 00:10:76. They don't seem evenly linked. fixed01:03:49 (5,6,7,8) - If you look at (8), you can see that the spacing is not even. That's OK IMO
01:16:23 (2,1) - Maybe this can be under the slider end for the neatness? yea, fixed
01:21:27 (2) - ^ fixed
01:23:47 (1) - May want to fix up the swirl shape. It looks a bit odd. spinner instead
01:26:20 (B) - Delete and replace break. fixed
01:28:83 (1,2,3,4) - When I look at this again, it seems like (4) is closer than its supposed to be. that's OK
01:34:65 (3) - Looks a bit too closer to the slider end when you compare it to (4) at the other side. but spacing is right...
01:36:59 (B) - Delete and replace break. fixed
02:11:95 (1) - The spinner sounds 1/4 late. You can make it a bit shorter by 1/4 and it should be jsut about fine (Auto got just about got a 300 + 2000). fixed
02:18:09 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - Not sure if this really should be single note combos.... that's for TAG XD
02:53:03 (1) - Try making it shorter by 1/4 to see that if it sounds better to you. I think it's OK

Notes: The map is nice so far, but the spacing feels a bit uneven. Make sure to check the spacing as best as you can (even comparing the space to the size of the notes can help). Also, make sure the shapes are not too uneven at least so that it doesn't effect the playability. checked, spacing is correct~

Overall: The map and the SB is good so far. Not overdone or lacking. Make sure to look into the errors and to also check for more to make things easier for you. Good job overall though and i'll drop my star in then. thanks for your greaaaaaaaat mod!!

GbL wrote:

[alvisto's Mates]

02:11:32 (8,9,10) - Fix spacing It was supposed to be stacked like that. =P
02:28:95 (5) - New combo I don't think so, it is consistent with the earlier part of combo as well !

Azure_Kyte wrote:

[Buddies]
01:04:90 (9,10) - I might move these back 1/4 beat Thanks, but I think it's OK
01:23:55 (1) - end this at the white tick Fixed
02:45:64 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Love these things <3 arrow: Thanks
02:52:96 (1) - Try moving this to the white tick for a cleaner end Fixed

Great beatmap, and I love the storyboards. Great job!
Starr'd

LuigiHann wrote:

Why isn't the title capitalized? Should be "I'll Be There for You"

Gens wrote:

Also, the 02:50:04 (5) slider on [alvisto's Mates] is totally unrankable.

Beuchi-chan wrote:

~alvisto's Mates~
01:22:069 (4,5,6) - Fix spacing :3 Sure
02:11:032 (8,9,10) - This spacing is intentional, right? If it isn't, fix it please :3 It's stacks, so no spacing to be fixed there..
02:50:004 (5) - OMG such a strange and cool slider!! No anymore. T.T
02:52:087 (6) - Make it end at 03:00:439 and maybe silence it? or at least the end of it oxo Too long, anyway, tone down the volume

osu_CN_yaya wrote:

几点建议
1，map做的太跟歌词了，比较无聊。 节奏感确实没那么好orz只会跟歌词
2，18个spinner...这也太太太太多了吧。。。 的确,会减少的...
3， hitsound，主要加到白线上，因为重音都是在白线，音效加到白线上才会好听。 谢谢提醒~

自己做下节奏试试。

jockeytiyan wrote:

Moddy mod mod mod~


Friends:

SPOILER

00:14:006 (7) - Suggestion: Unsilence. It's not slience, just a little lower
00:32:095 (1) - Extend spinner.
00:37:099 (1) - ^ all fixed
00:51:084 (8) - Suggestion: Unsilence.

alvisto's Mates

SPOILER

ILY ALVIS. <3

General: Decrease slider tick rate to 1. It sounds better for me. :3

01:20:064 (1) - Silence this spinner.
02:45:000 (5) - Put a break after this. So it does

Buddies

SPOILER

00:32:079 (1) - Unsilence
00:45:070 (5) - Suggestion: Put a spinner after this, in place of the break
00:51:084 (10) - Unsilence
01:04:059 (8) - Add another beat after this
01:04:059 (8,1,2) - Suggestion: Either stack or make it a stream
02:52:040 (9) - Suggestion: Delete this or replace it with something that doesn't sound like it all Fixed

Nice SB you got there. :3

Mystearica wrote:

Wow Friends lol, love that show.

minyeob wrote:

orz check.
[Buddies]
00:51:084 (10) - Only this object has a lol spacing(Just asking) I didn't noticed it orz...thanks ! fixed

That's all.

osuplayer111 wrote:

[Friends]

00:17:005 (3) - I'm not sure about this slider, can confuse new players for sure. Change it. Changed
00:26:034 (4) - ^
01:00:097 (6) - ^ All fixed
01:32:013 (3,4,5) - A bit hard too see and to read for new players. I think that's OK, just a little hard

[alvisto's Mates]

SPOILER

Set a preview point.
Why have you used another BPM here? Use the same BPM for all difficulties, please.

02:10:085 (7,8) - Spacing.
02:09:027 (2) - Unsnapped.
02:10:022 (5) - ^
02:10:053 (6) - ^
02:11:032 (8) - ^
02:11:079 (10) - ^
02:12:058 (11) - ^
02:13:037 (1) - ^
02:13:068 (3) - ^
02:14:094 (8) - ^
02:16:004 (3) - ^
02:16:083 (1) - ^
02:17:030 (4) - ^
02:17:062 (1) - ^
02:18:056 (4) - ^
02:18:088 (1) - ^
02:19:019 (3) - ^
02:19:035 (4) - ^
02:19:066 (1) - ^
02:20:045 (1) - ^
02:22:034 (5) - ^
02:23:028 (3) - ^
02:23:060 (4) - ^
02:24:086 (8) - ^
02:25:017 (9) - ^ And more... (See AIMod for more info).

alvisto has remapped these all

[Buddies]

Seems fine.

ykcarrot wrote:

Unsnapped notes already pointted by osuplayer111. So I don't point it.

Anyway, all diffs are seems good. Star~

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Single diff mod:

alvisto's Mates:
Normal mod:
00:58:296 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - this part get pretty repetitive and boring. Please change the pattern after one reflection. Because I use gradual spacing increase, thus a constant pattern is essential imho. xD
02:18:883 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - make this section curvier because 1-4 forms a straight line

Combo mod:
00:33:270 (4) (and any section similar to it in the song) -make these sections consistent in combos because here there is no new combo, but at 00:43:186 (1) and at the end of the song, there are new combos. I used no combo for these patterns.

Timing section mod:
00:10:60 - unneeded timing section, please remove
00:37:84 - ^
01:50:86 - ^
02:20:45 - ^

(Just wondering, does buddies have a higher slider tick rate because of score?)

===
Nice revised diff.

Mystearica wrote:

[Buddies]

Suggestions are as follows, you should remove all normal whistles though.

00:29:177 - Add a circle
00:35:001 - Add one here
00:35:631 - Add one here
00:40:667 - Add one here

00:58:611 (1,2,3,4,5) - Sounds a bit odd but ok. I think you can do better here though. fixed
01:02:860 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - That part for sure sounds weird to me. fixed some
01:06:481 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Very nicely done here!

01:09:471 - Add one circle
01:09:943 - Add one circle
01:13:406 - Add one circle
01:14:508 - Add one
01:14:980 - Add one
01:18:443 - Add one I know what you mean, 3 combo hits are always appeared in maps, it's popular, but I think it's not suit this song, sorry

01:35:914 (7) - Why the whistle? It's out of place. removed
01:43:941 (1,2,3) - Remove these whistles, try using low volume finish on the end instead or maybe claps... whistle removed

02:16:365 - Add one here
02:16:680 - Add one here

02:17:624 (4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I like this, but remove the whistles again after this.
02:25:179 (7) - Add one here
02:30:216 (5) - Add one here

[Friends]

Cut the whistles... Why are so dislike whistle >:, at least most people didn't complain about it, I would keep it, sorry

01:12:462 (2,4) - Couple parts like this would've been much more fluid I think with another circle in-between but this is normal...hm. You mod so careful XD

whymeman wrote:

Sorry to do this, but I see that [Buddies] has the stack leniency distabled. See into fixing that please.

Mystearica wrote:

[alvisto]

Rhythm is better overall but still a little odd at a couple parts, though I won't complain too much about that.

Remove normal whistles please.

I do question the usage of that custom sound during the middle jump part though...sounds...hmm

whymeman wrote:

Sorry to do this, but I see that [Buddies] has the stack leniency distabled. See into fixing that please.

awp wrote:

Blegh - the maps look fine to me, but the background image appears for a split instant at the very beginning of the map. I'm not sure whether or not this is a bug in the v6 file format, but you can easily fix this, bug or not, by adding the following SB line:

F,0,-500,0,0,1

to the code block:

Sprite,Background,Centre,"black.png",320,240
M,0,0,5489,-49,240
F,0,-500,0,0,1 (<--See, I added this line here) OK, fixed! When I finished this SB, I didn't know anything about SB by scripte ;_; I start to use SB by scripte in the after maps

that'll make the background fade more elegant instead of abrupt and WTF-ish

imo it's a trivial reason to pop a bubble, but since all your scripting is in your .osu files (took me a lil while to figure out why, but I got it) I don't know if this is something that can be fixed post-rank without unranking, so ;______; I'll have to pop it for now, but I should be able to immediately re-bubble once it has been tweaked. PM me on the forums so I actually know to recheck, thanks.

Sprite,Background,Centre,"black.png",-81,275
 F,0,-500,0,0,1
 M,0,0,5426,-81,275

Sprite,Background,Centre,"black.png",-81,240
 F,0,-500,0,0,1
 M,0,0,5426,-81,240

awp wrote:

aaaaargh I'm sorry but I didn't do a comb-over of the files when I made my last post - what you have is good, but you need to do some clean-up.

white-1.png is never used in the SB, so you should delete it from the folder. oops, I didn't remembered I put it in the folder orz, now deleted.
black.png can also be reduced to 480px tall - all SB images are treated as a 640x480 resolution image, so an image that is 480 pixels tall will cover the entire screen top to bottom when positioned at y=0. When you crop the height from it, you'll probably need to tweak the SB a bit to make it fit correctly:. This is what you currently have:

Sprite,Background,Centre,"black.png",-81,275
 F,0,-500,0,0,1
 M,0,0,5426,-81,275

Just adjust the y-co-ord to be centered, like so:

Sprite,Background,Centre,"black.png",-81,240
 F,0,-500,0,0,1
 M,0,0,5426,-81,240

Fixed

The SB could be further optimized (you don't need an 1800px image to cover a 640x480 screen) but I don't think it'd really have any impact to add a black-1.png for the opening fade effect.

white.jpg should also be resized to 640x480 for the reason above - it still fills the screen when positioned at 320x240 Centred k, all fixed, full submitting...

I think I've covered everything @_@

awp wrote:

aaaargh the intro glitch came back

when you were updating the SB code, you left out the Fade line from earlier

Sprite,Background,Centre,"black.png",-81,240
F,0,-500,0,0,1
M,0,0,5426,-81,240 Ouch...I got it now

Also the organizational structure in the SB folder is nice, but you've now got a Thumbs.db file in there - this is just Windows being an idiot, but the file isn't needed at all, so you'll have to delete it before re-uploading. Emm, I didn't find the Thumbs.db file

One last little tweak that I think is needed is at the 9 second mark, where the whole cast is shown:

The foreground black layer contains these two lines near the end of the block (lines 73 and 74, according to alvisto difficulty):

M,0,9515,10273,427,240,651,240
S,0,9515,10273,0.9999999,5

and they should be changed to:

M,0,9515,10160,427,240,725,240
S,0,9515,10160,0.9999999,8 Fixed

sorry for making you do another full resubmit - I'm all too familiar with submitting a 10MB beatmap over a dozen times due to SB fixes. But oh, it's so worth it~ Yeah, I love SB :3

awp wrote:

The black is found through all 3 difficulties, but the

M,0,9515,10160,427,240,725,240
S,0,9515,10160,0.9999999,8

code was only changed in alvisto's difficulty, and it needs to be added in all three

as for Thumbs.db, it's found in the SB folder - you may need to set hidden files to viewable. You can do this by going to the folder and selecting Tools > Folder options in the menu at the top, selecting the View tab in the window that comes up, and under Advanced Settings > Files and Folders > Hidden files and folders, make sure "Show hidden files and folders" is selected. It still not found in my folder o.o It's not a hidden file. I can't find it even ctrl+F to search it. Emm...I creat a new "SB" folder and delete the previous one

Though, the Thumbs.db isn't a hidden file when I download...

anyhow, keep PMing me after fixes until we get this bubbled <3

Matma Rex wrote:

alvisto's diff has countdown while other diffs do not.

awp wrote:

Matma Rex wrote:

alvisto's diff has countdown while other diffs do not.

It also starts at a different time

RemmyX25 wrote:

Friends:
00:19:104 (6) - End this slider on the red tick. it would sound so much better. fixed
00:26:344 (4) - end on blue tick, on "week" yup, it sounds better now
01:12:619 (2) - move this entire slider right one tick. I dont know why, it just sounds better (fix distance snappings etc) fixed
Also why isnt this mapped to the end? It really wont affect difficult if you keep it the same way the rest of the difficulty is. orz, sorry, I'm lazy...and also short one is easier >///<

Buddies:
00:23:590 (1) - Spinner seems a tad unnecessary...
Could also benefit from more whistles and finishes, especially the first half. It sounds kinda plain and boring as it is. Claps are fine.

EVEN AT MY WORST IM BEST WITH YYYYYYYYYOOOOOOOOOOOOOUUUUUUUUUUUUU YEA

RemmyX25 wrote:

Much better job! The only other recommendation i can make is to make easy's spinner at the end one long spinner, instead of two. Fixed

Also did i miss something or is there no storyboard/background in alvisto's difficulty? Yup, SB code disappeared lol, now added

and again, hard could use more finish sounds, especially during the choruses. added some notes with finish

Almost there!

It looked better now

alvisto wrote:

Yay , finally it's ranked... An old map~~~ ^.^