does this remind you of stack the deck where we also 1v1'd?
only that you were obv scum back then so i had a much easier job convincing rantai of your scumminess.
this basically boils down to the question: would i with my townread on setsuen risk him being a vig and being dumb with it? that was my thoughtprocess, and i didn't want him to have that vigshot.
my read on him was mostly because he plays incredibly bad, and in my eyes his post was that of a very unexperienced noobtown. i read him town before his dumb comment about other games (for which i in a normal game would push forward a policy lynch), before you think i based my read off of that. that said, CB's argumentation was stronger (obviously, he is effing CB), therefore i wasn't 100% sure on setsuen. i would've rather lynched CB because if he is scum he definately is the strongest out of us. if he is town then... well he is the strongest out of us and he would've gotten confirmmed with that vigshot. basically, in any case, lynching setsuen was worse than lynching CB.