sorry for my inactivity, wasn't really able and had no spare time to read the topic due to some stuff that recently happened.
Mod: Unprod me, please.

I don't want to make any conclusions right off the bat, since this is my first mafia game (and that's why I don't feel confident enough to post here haha), but hey, that's what this game is about. The thing is that NoHitter seems to write quite much. A lot, actually. He tries to come up with a lot of ideas, that he could seem as the one that's searching for the scum the most, and that's a common trick used by mafia itself; to integrate with the city in order to get their acceptation and trust. However, that massclaim thing indeed seems so scummy that I couldn't resist thinking of him as the guy who's in the mafia.

Vote: NoHitter

what is prod?? xD

rEdo wrote:

Mod: Unprod me, please.

You don't need to ask for "unprod" as soon as you post you're fine.

Irreversible wrote:

what is prod?? xD

prod is like a poke to the person to remind them of the game, when you don't respond to your prod within X hours (varies with different games and mods) you're in danger of getting replaced or modkilled. Check the rules regarding activity for further info.

i feel so stupid all the time i ask things like that XD

this was useless as well, k
why don't you deactivate it?

Take a guess.

Irreversible wrote:

i feel so stupid all the time i ask things like that XD

you do know that there is a rules thread stickied? with a link to a very useful wiki?

I mean, wtf, I looked up stuff for 2 weeks and lurked o going games before I joined this game. it's common sense that you read the rules to a game before you start playing it.

Honestly, I knew the general gameplay but not roles. I asked questions quite a bit in games. Nothing wrong with that really.




Also depending on what NoHitter flips. I'll shoot someone.

If NoHitter is town, I'll shoot rEdo
If NoHitter is scum, I'll shoot Hika

Actually, I was trying to save me some trouble (in case I was actually playing), by not letting anyone know that I was a power role. But in this case, I don't want my replacement to get lynched if they decide to take my place.
Claim: JK

There you have it, I am a power role, now do what you want to do.

Hika wrote:

Actually, I was trying to save me some trouble (in case I was actually playing), by not letting anyone know that I was a power role. But in this case, I don't want my replacement to get lynched if they decide to take my place.
Claim: JK

There you have it, I am a power role, now do what you want to do.

lol

and another role that wasn't mentioned in the original set up \:D/

how can this thing get even more confusing now?

so should we just lynch hika for the sake of it? town skewing the massclaim is actually worse than scum skewing the massclaim.

if hika even is town. which is doubtful, I think. if she really is town, though, then we have to deal with 2 mafia PRs. which is an entirely different pair of shoes.

If you lynch me, it's town's loss. I have nothing further to say.

K make this more confusing for me

BRBP wrote:

Actually one of my posts earlier took about 45 minutes to write only because I wasn't sure if I should say there might be a hidden PR or not.
I don't want to believe it's Hika though...

Yeah, I find it a bit difficult to believe mafia only chose 1 power :S

@ Hika: What was your plan when you decided to lie?

My plan was this, I wanted to be able to survive the next couple of days and nights in order to block any threats to town. I'm pretty sure it was going to be hard D1 and N1 because we don't have enough leads just yet.

Since I've been occupied, I haven't been really looking here much until yesterday, realizing that I needed a replacement but only to come back to what seemed like everyone wanted to lynch me. I want town to win, not a loss, so I'm going to try and play a bit more actively before my replacement comes in. I don't know how long that will take but I'm waiting for it.

Back to the point, if you lynch me and if it soothes you all to see me flip town after lynching, go for it, but you've lost an extra PR.

Also, I'm pretty sure I was going to be targeted for claiming JK if I claimed it at the beginning.

EBWOP: And I don't mean claim JK, I just mean claiming a PR in general.

I must say this claim is pretty convenient for the current situation. However, the majority of votes is still on NH so there was technically no threat for her at the moment, she could've claimed it later if there was a need, this leans more for a Town lie. However x2, she jumped with it right after RB mentioned he might kill her tonight if NH flips scum. Possible scumpartners of NH and Hika? Maaybe, but it'd be a little too easy imo (NH is not stupid, I doubt he would make a slip like this if he was scum [unless it was just Hika's slip, but I also doubt she'd make the decision to claim only by herself]). Also it was still 50/50 risk that BRBP is a PR that Hika fakeclaims (or more because someone might've lied, LIECEPTION?), so this argument is also for a Town lie.

BRBP wrote:

JK actually cancels out the rolecop that mafia was able to pick, so it sort of makes sense.
But she's had a lot of time to think about that as well, and there might be experienced mafia who told her to say that of course.

I'll put this on the table: I'm not a JK


It's also intresting to see Tanz hop from NH to Hika.

oh, I'm still on NH. if I wouldn't, I already unvoted him and voted hika. but hika definetly rose in my suspicions.

if she survives the first day and gets a replacement, it surely will be interesting to see how the replacement will deal with this situation.

@Hika: but we all risked being targeted by claiming our PRs, it was literally the same risk for everyone of us is going to be killed tonight. Not sure what's your base of the paranoia that you will be the one killed at the night.

fartownik wrote:

@Hika: but we all risked being targeted by claiming our PRs, it was literally the same risk for everyone of us is going to be killed tonight. Not sure what's your base of the paranoia that you will be the one killed at the night

I agree with fartownik here. 3 people claimed PR before it got to you lying about yours. Why did you think you'd be targeted first of?

Hika wrote:

My plan was this, I wanted to be able to survive the next couple of days and nights in order to block any threats to town. I'm pretty sure it was going to be hard D1 and N1 because we don't have enough leads just yet.

Didn't you think your inactivity + empty contributions would be counterproductive to your self-preservation plan?

fartownik wrote:

@Hika: but we all risked being targeted by claiming our PRs, it was literally the same risk for everyone of us is going to be killed tonight. Not sure what's your base of the paranoia that you will be the one killed at the night.

basically, the reasons are those that I brought up as counterargument against the massclaim, I believe. such as "knowing who the PR is more helpful for scum than it is for us" and "losing PR is hurtful for town".

still, when the massclaim was finished, she should've directly claimed PR, because lying town at that point helped noone except scum. of course she didn't really watch the game (or care for it), so she didn't claim PR. which leaves us with a "maybe" for her status as PR, and a big "yay" for scum, as they now know all the PRs, while town has to fight against the odds of lying town.

oh mah gawd Hika claimed JK in the last moment, I agree with her reasons for stay hidden in the crowd, but her attitude is quite contradictory, she got by herself many FoS and now it seems to trying to shake them off, she's quite suspicious to me by doing so, I can't trust her given this situation, she wasn't even in danger (tied with NH).

This is why I didn't like too much NH's plan, even town wouldn't want to cooperate, not saying that Hika is town, but scum would put this as an excuse and try to look as a lying townie, making it harder to find sure scum.

Hika and NH may be scum, but not together. Posting more in a moment, I need to structure better some thoughts I have.

I just ignored the last couple of posts to say 'lynch me'. So do it if you guys are completely paranoid? I certainly can't be anti-town for suggesting that, due to the fact I can't convince anyone. You could possibly get someone who is also a PR to confirm with me by breadcrumbing or saying something similar to my pm.

And Haneii, that was IF I was playing actively, which I did not decide to do because I'm busy doing other things. I'll be sure to keep out of future games for the next couple of months when I'm not so busy in order to save whichever faction I'm on the trouble. It's safe to say that I'd have had a more successful run if I was playing actively.

Also farto, I'm not ignorant enough to claim, given the fact that us PRs are equal in getting NK'd. I think I'm a pretty important role myself so why not keep myself hidden?

I can't understand how people can get suspicious with posting less, I mean what if they are really busy in real.

Irreversible wrote:

I can't understand how people can get suspicious with posting less, I mean what if they are really busy in real.

scum normally lurks or tends to lurk because they have practically no motivation to post. they don't have to scumhunt, and going on the "scumhunt" may let you slip, so yea, if someone is superlurky/inactive, he probably is scum. and even if he isn't, then you still lynched just a lurker, who didn't contribute anyway.

Hika wrote:

Also farto, I'm not ignorant enough to claim, given the fact that us PRs are equal in getting NK'd. I think I'm a pretty important role myself so why not keep myself hidden?

Because we all agreed to claim, simply because of that. Your action had its pluses ('had' because I don't see any of them at this very moment), I can't deny that, but it also skewed our numbers of Mafia's PRs (we thought Mafia only picked 1 option, now we might guess they picked 2) and confused us right now if you're truly Town, making it more anti-town.

EBWOP: Watcher, Vigilante - both are also very powerful roles, I'd even say a Watcher is more dangerous for scum than a Jailkeeper.

Tanzklaue wrote:

Irreversible wrote:

I can't understand how people can get suspicious with posting less, I mean what if they are really busy in real.

scum normally lurks or tends to lurk because they have practically no motivation to post. they don't have to scumhunt, and going on the "scumhunt" may let you slip, so yea, if someone is superlurky/inactive, he probably is scum. and even if he isn't, then you still lynched just a lurker, who didn't contribute anyway.

that's true, but this game is actually like 'i'm town, believe me and don't kill me' because otherwise town wouldn't win the game - so if you were town you wouldn't be like 'oh nvm, we killed a lurker, doesn't matter if he's town or not' or am I wrong? (well i know for scum it's better to kill town.. ahh i'm confused by my own thoughts, op)

Please let me know if you see any mistakes.

BRBP wrote:

Time is running out ._.

worried about nohitter? or why do you care about that, you already setted your vote oô

pieguy1372 replaces Hika effective immediately

If pieguy wants he may request deadline to be extended by up to 2 days to give them time to read the thread.

Welcome, pieguy. Your view on the current situation would be quite useful.

Irreversible wrote:

BRBP wrote:

worried about nohitter? or why do you care about that, you already setted your vote oô

Yes, I'm worried about NH, that's why I'm voting for him.
Asking stupid questions from masons is always a wise thing to do.

Yeah, why not? If Nohitter is scum it's most possible that you are his scumbuddy, and now you're trying to get the attention away from you. Sorry for my conclusions but ~

And stop raging about my posts, you aren't funny LOL

BRBP wrote:

Mod: If say, 1-2 people vote Hika/pieguy or if he/she suddenly gains a majority, can he/she still ask to extend the day? What I mean is, if the result is obvious.

Yes, do remember that if hammer isnt reached by deadline then no lynch happens, and is only fair to give the replacement time to catch up, if he starts posting and contributing without requesting an extension tho then he will lose the right to request the extension as I will assume by default that he's already read and is fine with the current deadline.

Irreversible wrote:

Yeah, why not? If Nohitter is scum it's most possible that you are his scumbuddy, and now you're trying to get the attention away from you. Sorry for my conclusions but ~

And stop raging about my posts, you aren't funny LOL

irre, a mson is a confirmed townie :3

he and rantai are masons, they can talk to each other and because we don't have bastard shit like scum masons in this game, they are both confirmed town. fakeclaiming mason is impossible, as the real masons can just say that the scum fakeclaiming is not one of their masonbuddies.

at this point, I would again advise you to go to wiki.mafiascum.net and read how to fucking play mafia and what the effing roles do so you don't have to embarass yourself anymore.

maybe i just shut up now XD

Irreversible wrote:

maybe i just shut up now XD

I suggest you read this too: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=13710 There's a lot more explained than just the RVS there, including techniques that will help in general for mafia games.

hi everyone o/
Let me just read the thread real quick...
Mod: a deadline extension would definitely be nice, give me an extra day I guess. thanks >w<

so hopefully all external issues are now gone (assuming irre finally decides that learning the rules and how to play the game is an actual good thing for playing said game), we hopefully can have a normal round of mafia.

welcome pieguy o/

Vote:Pieguy

gut feeling

Seeing as day extended, I will try my best to post later on tonight. Will be busy today.

Although if you want my current thoughts, I say we should keep pieguy as one of our top suspects. Using NoHitter's plan, we should get the non confirmed VTs first. At the rate we're going, looks like Nohitter will get lynched (fine with that, still iffy about suggsting plan. Although he hasn't really defended himself yet so perhaps town?) Haneii and rEdo seems scummy to me. Still because of that second post by Haneii as a back up of "let me rephrase why I voted Hika" and then a slight defense on rEdo saying he's still on top of scum list but not going to vote him cause Hika.

Irre. God damn I'll just say he's town.

Rest of non PR + pieguy I assume one would be traitor/scum

by PoE

Raging Bull wrote:

Rest of non PR + pieguy I assume one would be traitor/scum

funnily enough, I would say NH is the most traitor-ish guy in the round. doing something huge and attentiongrabbing, potentially or most likely antitown, is something a traitor would do so his scumbuddies won't kill him by accident (because really, is there anything more embarassing than shooting your own buddy on accident?).

irre would of course fit into the other big thing traitors do - the bad townie. but I think irre is just that - a bad townie. or he is the most amazing traitor the world has ever seen

also NH laid out his plan as protown, and convinced some of us. so smart scum could pick it up and see that he is the traitor, while town not necessarily suspects him of being a traitor.

That's why depending on what he flips, I'm shooting different people.

Thanks pieguy, and last post I'm making here, but I AM busy. I also have school work and I read often tyvm. Like I said, not joining a game for several months so pieguy, stay active for me

That and I'm specifically going to mention name because if mafia kills me and there is only one NK, then the one I shot is obvious mafia.

Tanzklaue wrote:

or he is the most amazing traitor the world has ever seen

Rofl'd.

But seriously, this is not a bad call. Irre has played plenty of games already, and in this one suddenly dropping in with the basic terms ignorance?

NH as traitor is also not a bad theory.

Wikipedia wrote:

Play Advice

If the scum know that there is a Traitor in the game, it should not be difficult for the Traitor to distinguish themselves to the scum. Just do something outrageously scummy or eye-catching for them.

His tactic was at least eye-catching, might turn out scummy as well. Though following directly a wiki advice that everyone can read is not very clever

Tanzklaue wrote:

irre would of course fit into the other big thing traitors do - the bad townie. but I think irre is just that - a bad townie. or he is the most amazing traitor the world has ever seen

maybe i'm just playing the stupid, you can never know~
oh wait

Irreversible wrote:

maybe i'm just playing the stupid, you can never know~
oh wait

U:<

Unvote
I will wait for what pieguy has to say. No point in keeping my vote on him.

fartownik wrote:

Wikipedia wrote:

Play Advice

If the scum know that there is a Traitor in the game, it should not be difficult for the Traitor to distinguish themselves to the scum. Just do something outrageously scummy or eye-catching for them.

His tactic was at least eye-catching, might turn out scummy as well. Though following directly a wiki advice that everyone can read is not very clever

well, for me, it's basically better than not knowing how to do anything. though the metagame they describe there is probably outdated and traitors play completly different nowadays.

btw. irre asked about terminology in other games aswell if I recall right, though such a drop to the depths of being so bad that it gives you braindamage is really odd.

also, as irre (maybe?) showed us, some people actually didn't read the wiki, though I highly doubt that NH wouldn't have done it.

hm, well i have to be honest, i didn't read everything properly that's why i posted senseless crap.. I try to avoid that in future, for example this with brbp and town. xD

and btw tanzklaue, i wouldn't get a better player with reading the wiki, maybe if i look up a list for these shortcuts like Prod or w/e would help me, but asking here is just more comfy~ so lazy

Irreversible wrote:

and btw tanzklaue, i wouldn't get a better player with reading the wiki, maybe if i look up a list for these shortcuts like Prod or w/e would help me, but asking here is just more comfy~ so lazy

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?tit ... reviations
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Glossary


Please let me know if you see any mistakes
Moderator's Notes: I will put some helpful links in the OP later if i dont forget. Also need to remember to add pieguy and BRBP to the ISO >_<

OK let's see here

PRs: me (JK), fartownik (Watcher), BRBP (?), Raging Bull (Vigilante)

Masons: Rantai, BRBP

Others: Irreversible, Jinxy, NH, Tanzklaue, DakeDekaane, Haneii, rEdo

So we have 4 claimed PRs, therefore either mafia has 2 PRs or they have one and they claimed it. As soon as NH stated his plan, I guess I just assumed all mafia would claim non-PR (claiming PR, IMO, puts them under way more suspicion than not claiming PR). Also, given a ninja, a rolecop, and a bulletproof, all three of those PRs make sense for the current situation (and BRBP is confirmed town). Thus, I'd guess mafia has 2 PRs. Also, I don't think BRBP claimed yet (someone correct me if I missed it please).

Given that Sakura specifically said "tracked" and we haven't seen a Tracker yet, BRBP might be the Tracker. Alternatively, there might not even be a Tracker as a Watcher has a similar effect. There also is probably a cop (which we also haven't seen) considering there's a Traitor.

NH seems town to me, since he started this whole thing, and now we have way more information than before. I'd be suspicious of rEdo since he's not doing anything, but it's his first game so I'll excuse that. I'm not sure about Haneii, she seems to be just going along with what everyone else says, but she's also asking some questions and trying to find some stuff out so she seems more town to me. I'm just going to hope Irreversible is town since I can't make any sense out of anything he's done so far. ><// Tanz seems to be town to me (do I need to say "gut feeling" anymore? ) JInxy didn't post for a few days, so he could be mafia. Also, DakeDekaane hasn't posted very much relatively and just seems to be going along with what's going on, so currently he seems to be the most suspicious for me.

There's also the chance one of the PRs that was claimed was mafia as I said before, but it's certainly not RB (why else would there be a BP in the game, plus he's shooting someone N1), BRBP as he's a mason, or me from my perspective, so the only option in that case is fartownik. At this point I think it'd be better to assume for now all the claimed PRs are town though.

I'm not sure who the Traitor is. There's also the chance that mafia recruited the Traitor (in which case any attempt to read the Traitor would just lead to misinformation), so I think it's best to focus on scumhunting for now until we have a better idea of what's going on.

vote: DakeDekaane as stated before.

my things always get deleted, why does chrome's back button never save my life?? :c

brbp, your ava makes me wanna cry :C

I'm wondering how dake will react to this conclusion of pieguy

BRBP wrote:

Apparently pieguy managed to ninja me as well.

I don't really know why you're trying to guess my role when most of us has decided it's best if it's not known.
The only thing you're helping with that is scum, because if town wanted to know, I could just say it.

Well, mafia could come up with the same kind of reasoning I did anyway. Also my bad, I must have missed the part where everyone decided that was best >< that's what I get I guess when I have to read the whole thread at once

I doubt a watcher and a tracker are in the same game (if we're going to go by the complimentary roles). I'm going to go out on a limb here and say Pieguy is less likely to be scum than town just because Hika wasn't in immediate danger + did actually leave the game.


Outside that though, I honestly have no reads on anyone, just a ton of gut feelings (which in my opinion is close to worthless, sorry Pieguy )

@Mod - BRBP didn't replace me (ISO)

Ops, fixed, thanks!

- Sakura

Nice wall of text there, pieguy. You bring a lot of good arguments there. I must agree that Dake only 'goes with the flow' of the current actions, dropping by and saying only what he's 'supposed' to say. Such playstyle doesn't bring much attention, yet turns out scum in a lot of games.

I don't agree with rEdo though. It's his first game, indeed, but it doesn't justify anything. I know him and he played Mafia before (an offline one), so he's not as unexperienced in it as you think.

I also don't see a point with revealing BRBP's PR at the moment, unless we wanted to plan our night actions, but it still wages better to scum than Town.

Also your argument about the specified PRs is invalid. The game COULD have PRs identically opposed to the Mafia ones, but it's also possible other ones were randomized. It's not an Open or Semi-Open setup, it's a closed one (however we made it an open-like by massclaiming), the list of potential PRs for Town wasn't revealed (but it's obvious the PRs opposed to the mafia's have a higher chance of appearing in game).

Welcome pieguy, I didn't know that trying to catch up with the game is suspicious, I could post every time of what makes me unable to actively post, but that's quite useless and it'd break the essence of the game imo.

I'd put my thoughts here, if Hika continued here, if you want to know it I can tell you but it's not as applyable as before, or maybe it can, I really don't know until I get a better read from pieguy.

Guessing BRBP's role won't lead to anything good for town, he should stay as that, when he gets/does something important, then he just have to spit it out. Also I'm curious how you read NH as his plan is clearly anti-town, not saying scum as there's nothing confirmed, in exchange of getting confirmed towns and possible scum, we served some tasty PRs for them in a silver plate.

@fartownik: I wasn't saying for sure that that's what it was, just something it might possibly be

@DakeDekaane: it's not just that, it's that your posts don't really have anything in them. It's just you always seem to go along with what everyone else does.

Why hello there, pieguy. When it's about my Mafia experience, I played it like twice, and these games were like a year or two years ago, so I don't remember almost anything of them :­P

Anyway, like everybody else said, BRBP should hide his profession as it is right now, since in this situation it'll just give the scum even more information, while we gain almost nothing in exchange. And my eye still looks at NoHitter, that high activity of his seems way too suspicious to me. A lot of activity implies trying to cover himself, and I'll stay with that idea of mine.

When it's about the other players, I haven't been paying that much attention, so I'll restrain from stating my opinion - let's see how the situation advances.

My posts do have something there, they aren't that empty as you think, read again and you'll find it out, I'm not surprised you say that as almost everytime it seems like everybody read the half of what I write, unless I'm bad explaining myself :p

Unvote
I'm willing to trust pieguy here. Not to mention that his post is opposite of what I remember him doing as scum (meta).

rEdo wrote:

And my eye still looks at NoHitter, that high activity of his seems way too suspicious to me. A lot of activity implies trying to cover himself, and I'll stay with that idea of mine.

I'm always active in my games?

And regarding my plan:
I understand that my plan with revealing townie PRs was a risk, but the reward of it was greater than the risk.
I believe I posted the numbers earlier, but even when we had only three confirmed PRs even if the PRs were with the Masons, we had a 33% chance of lynching scum today. That's a HUGE chance for Day 1.
Now assuming Hika is really a JK, that gives us (5-3-4) (conf - scum - town). Now we have a 3/7 chance or 42.8% chance of lynching scum today.
Maybe you guys are the type to rely on PRs more than scumhunting and lynching? IDK, but those odds for lynching scum are GREAT.

Re: Traitor
(WIFOM AHEAD) If you read above statements: exchanging PR info for a higher chance of being lynched is a bad move for scum.
Well that being said, if I do get lynched because of it, it's just a consequence of my plan. (being unconfirmed and all)

Vote: rEdo
For earlier specified reasons. I'm sticking with my reads this game.

@ Dake
Earlier you said my tactic allowed for voting scum by PoE and therefore I looked town, but now you're saying that my plan is anti-town. Why the flip-flop?

@NH: Your plan is anti-town for the facts I've stated, that it allows voting scum by PoE doesn't change it, it's like a double-edged sword. There's no flip-flop at all.

No, you said he was leaning town here: p/2394498/
And then you said you were curious of pieguy's town read here: p/2396280/ which means you are questioning that town read.

The massclaim is a double edged sword, but you clearly flipped between focusing on the different sides of it in these two posts

Please let me know if you see any mistakes

hm, NH, you already executed the plan, so you dying wouldn't change too much, wouldn't it? defending yourself with this much effort seems kinda icky. of course you normally don't want to die, but you still get the win if you die and town succeeds.

also you have no PR, so you dying is (basically) no biggie. and you opposed RB shooting someone in N1. but why would you do that? your great odds of 3/7 would swing to 3/5, if we shoot and lynch unsuccessfully, over 50%, and we still could hit scum with the lynch AND/or the shoot of RB, which would leave us with one/two scum. there is basically no pro-town reason for not shooting in N1.

why would you suggest something like this after your "superprotown" massclaim strategy?

I hope my "I only slept 5 hours yay" reads aren't too messed up

oh man they are messed up so bad...

still, NH wasn't too sure at first about shooting in Night 1. but it's basically not enough for an accusation :/

don't mind that part of the post.

Tanzklaue wrote:

hm, NH, you already executed the plan, so you dying wouldn't change too much, wouldn't it? defending yourself with this much effort seems kinda icky. of course you normally don't want to die, but you still get the win if you die and town succeeds.

also you have no PR, so you dying is (basically) no biggie. and you opposed RB shooting someone in N1. but why would you do that? your great odds of 3/7 would swing to 3/5, if we shoot and lynch unsuccessfully, over 50%, and we still could hit scum with the lynch AND/or the shoot of RB, which would leave us with one/two scum. there is basically no pro-town reason for not shooting in N1.

why would you suggest something like this after your "superprotown" massclaim strategy?

I hope my "I only slept 5 hours yay" reads aren't too messed up

Because I am town, and lynching a townie would be a wasted lynch. That's why I'm defending myself.

And regarding the shooting, it's a precaution I thought of with the old information from before.
Back then when we thought we had only 3 PR, the stats were 3-3-6. If we lynch incorrectly, we get 3-3-5.
Mafia would NK a confirmed town -> 2-3-5. There's now a 3/8 chance only for hitting mafia.
If in the case RB hits a townie, we would reach 2-3-4. Mafia would control half the votes in that situation.

Now though with 5 confirmed townies, the stats are different. 5-3-4 if we lynch incorrectly -> 5-3-3
It's now a 50% chance which I would accept.

What.

Now assuming Hika is really a JK, that gives us (5-3-4) (conf - scum - town)

So basically you're saying if we assume they're town, they're confirmed town. Might I be able to suggest that we have a little flaw in that?

Actually, who came up with the idea that having reciprocal town PR's was something that made a claim more believable?

Because how do you 'counter' a JOAT or daychat? I'm willing to bet that our PR's are randomly pooled and not chosen to counter other roles.

Rantai wrote:

Actually, who came up with the idea that having reciprocal town PR's was something that made a claim more believable?

Because how do you 'counter' a JOAT or daychat? I'm willing to bet that our PR's are randomly pooled and not chosen to counter other roles.

My idea was that scum PRs were made to counter the existing town PRs. That's why Watcher and Vig were confirmed for me since they would be countered by Bulletproof and Ninja.

Rantai wrote:

So basically you're saying if we assume they're town, they're confirmed town. Might I be able to suggest that we have a little flaw in that?

What I meant by that was that assuming Hika was a Jailkeeper, *insert statistics computation here*.

NoHitter wrote:

Rantai wrote:

So basically you're saying if we assume they're town, they're confirmed town. Might I be able to suggest that we have a little flaw in that?

What I meant by that was that assuming Hika was a Jailkeeper, *insert statistics computation here*.

but what if hika/pieguy isn't town? or if fart or RB lied?

basically, our masons are the only real confirmed town people for town. the other 3? we can't say that they are confirmed, because they might have lied to us. basically, we have three people who might be town, and nobody but the PRs themselves can find out if there is scum amongst them, because we vanilla townies will have a hard time setting a train up if we suspect one of them, as we are the scumsuspects.

on the other hand, scum of course has up to 4 primary targets, those being our PRs that are not only masons (as shooting a mason after them claiming is not that much more useful as shooting a vanilla townie).

what also caught my suspcion is the way you enlisted the roles. like 5-3-4, being confirmed townie, scum and unconfirmed townie respectively. but technically, we as town don't know the difference between scum and unconfirmed town, so basically we are all "unconfirmed". the list would probably look more like 2-3-7, those being confirmed towns, possible PRs and completly unknown people. amongst these unknown people, there could be all 3 scums, or just 2. amongst the possible PRs there could be 1 scum hiding (or 2, if they are really WIFOMy). basically, we can't say almost nothing for certain. the only certain townies are Rantai and BRBP, while RB, fart and pieguy are just people who claim to be PRs, but not necessarily have to be that.

if we break it all down, the massclaim gave us two confirmed townies, while scum got the full information they could possibly need. heck, if they picked rolecop then they will be angry because they could've used that pick for something actually useful. the massclaim didn't bring town nearly as much information as you, NH, and Jinxy said it would. why? because most of it is build on the assumption that nobody lied. and with one townliar, we can already say that this isn't the case anymore.

this whole thing caused a lot of WIFOM, and only very few actual benefits. we also could have gotten the two masons to claim anyway without revealing all of our PRs and we would be practically in the same spot informationwise, but with a lot less WIFOM.

*coughs* The thing is - if we don't have any leads, it's the safest to rely on the probability (unless someone has some crazy gut feelings that everyone respect and are always truth, but it's really rare). NoHitter's tactic has clarified all these probabilities, giving us the information who COULD be scum the most in the first order, but obviously not who IS scum at the moment. Such raise of probability of hitting scum in D1 is pretty good, especially when it's usually just RVS and nothing much besides gut feelings. You're of course right that the PRs are not confirmed Town, but the probability of them lying is less than the probability of scum hiding in the non-PRs. It's obviously everyone's personal call if they want to rely on probability or gut feelings, but I'd just like to point that out.

@Jinxy: In the first post I also put the reasones why they weren't likely to be town and possibly scum, I noticed I chose bad words after that, but forgot to explain it later.

Now, I'll put this, this were my thoughts that I didn't post previously and I came to the same conclusions now. Some of us are still wary about NH, and some voted him, now what can we get if there's a NH lynch?
If he flips scum, then there is at least 1 scum in the claimed PR, as he's no far of saying they're confirmed town, and I'm still in doubt about that JK claim.
If he flips town, then there's still the possibility of what I put above, but it's minimal, and we still have a great chance of hitting scum in D2 based on our Night Actions and finding a liar in them, if there's one.

Of course lynching a townie is risky, but if we can get more from that lynch, at least I think it'd be better that going in just suppositions and probability, I don't know what you think.

Also NH, why you say in the 2-3-5 scenario mafia control half of the votes?, with 10, it requires 6 to hammer, and mafia still would need to convince at least 3 other people (or 4 in case they didn't recruit the Traitor) and we have 3/7 of hitting scum, higher than 3/8, if we talk about probability, which itself is bad imo.

It's very stupid for scum to claim vigilante because of how there WILL BE 2 NKs if the vigilante keep saying he will shoot. The only thing is if mafia kills the same person as me, but that is really stupid since that gives town even more of an advantage by having 1 less death.

And I'm also suspicious of NH too, but I feel like him not defending himself as much is giving me a town read on him. Mafia would probably keep doing their best to try to get votes off him.

IMO, what NH did is better than just leaving us all sitting here in the dark. Even if it doesn't seem like it now, I'm sure all the information (reactions, posting habits etc.) we got D1 could prove to be even more useful in the future.

Also, keep in mind that at least two of the claimed PRs will be confirmed (BRBP cause he's a mason and RB because if we'll have 2 NK's tonight he's telling the truth), so the only possible liar is fartownik (and me, but I know I'm town). Either way, I think it'd be best for information's sake to assume all the claimed PRs are town.

If nohitter is town, shooting rEdo

if nohitter is scum, shooting Jinxy.

I'm a bad vigilante, just saying. Unless you guys have a better target.

wait, so NH dying is part of the plan? Sorry, I must have overlooked where you all agreed on that ><

No but looks like no one wants to unvote