banvi wrote:

Myoldmapisbaaaaaaad
とりあえず少しでも良くなるよういろいろ変えてみました(´・ω・`)

[attachment=0:8f5e4]Kicco - Kokoro Hare (Short Ver.) (kusano) [banvi's Normal].osu[/attachment:8f5e4]

あと、赤タイミング線の前にノートがあるのはあまりよろしくないと思うのでオフセットを-685にした方がいいと思います

banvi wrote:

remake done

NewRulerNA wrote:

hi~

[Easy]
HP・OD共に-1?
Normalが4設定であることを考えるともう一段階下げてしまっても良いように感じました 変えました

01:05:092 (4) - このスライダー全体にwhistleの効果が入っていて、sliderslideが無音になっていません fixed.

01:33:537 - この緑線、SVが0.75倍になってますが特に変更する必要は無いように思えます fixed.

[Hinacle]
実質的なプレイに影響はありませんがSliderMultiplierが1.69999990463257になっているので1.7に変更で

[Insane]

00:09:315 (1) - Easyの時と同じようにwhistleの効果が全体に入っていてsliderslideの無音化がされていません fixed.

00:19:648 (8,9) - (8)のヒットバーストが(9)の2回目のターンに隠れてしまっています
ここまでの曲の流れ的にここが2回ターンだと分かりにくいように思えます
・・・が、この程度ならRankにはそこまで大きな影響はしないと思うので、個人的な意見として うーん…保留で。他のModderにも言われるようなら変えます。

00:46:314 (8,9) - ^

00:57:981 (1) - HPバーに少し被ってしまっています

全難易度以前のもの同様突っ込みどころのない譜面でした

Rankedがんばって～
good luck!

1. Rename Hinacle's difficulty to "Hinacle's Hard".

1. 00:02:870 (2) - It would sound consistent and nice to put a whistle on the end of this slider.
2. 00:33:537 (2) - Add a whistle to the beginning of this slider for consistency with your hitsound pattern.
3. 00:37:981 - It would make sense to add a note here to keep things flowing. There's even vocals there.
4. 00:43:759 (1,2,3) - Align these in a more intuitive pattern like this.
5. 01:11:759 - Add a note here for the same reason as 00:37:981.

1. 00:19:314 (4) - Pretty odd shaped slider to me. Why not do something like this?
2. 00:20:648 (1) - ^
3. 01:09:092 (7) - ^
4. 01:22:870 (1) - ^

1. See my general mod.
2. 00:29:981 (1) - Add a whistle to the beginning of this slider to follow your hitsound pattern.
3. 00:30:870 (3) - ^
4. 00:31:759 (2) - Finish to the beginning of this slider.
5. 00:58:870 (3) - Add a finish to the end of this slider. It's in the music.

1. Nice work. Couldn't find anything rather than nazi stuff.

Jacob wrote:

banvi's Normal

1. 00:19:314 (4) - Pretty odd shaped slider to me. Why not do something like this?
2. 00:20:648 (1) - ^
3. 01:09:092 (7) - ^
4. 01:22:870 (1) - ^

Kawayi Rika wrote:

[banvi's Normal]

1. 00:08:203 - Missing add finish here.

Aleks719 wrote:

Insane
HP6 is same as in Hard diff. Make it higher in Insane or lower in Hard? fixed
00:30:426 (1,2) - i'd keep spacing here as in stream before, easier to play/read, imo fixed

Easy
01:30:648 (1) - nc seems so lonely, remove please.. fixed
01:31:537 (1) - imo, whistle fits better, as in Insane /this suggestion for Normal diff too/ fixed

Aleks719 wrote:

Hinacle's Hard
01:01:537 (1) - i'm pretty sure you can make something better here.. also it sounds not good for me
01:31:648 (1) - imo, whistle fits better, as in Insane

Darkpira7e wrote:

This is such a WONDERFUL song! First song I've managed to get a double platinum S on every difficulty, except for insane =< Great beatmap!

Frostmourne wrote:

It's good map which should be ranked.

Someone,who mentioned about this very little issue in #modhelp, likes to see unranking the map.

You're so good.

Jacob wrote:

Frostmourne wrote:

It's good map which should be ranked.

Someone,who mentioned about this very little issue in #modhelp, likes to see unranking the map.

You're so good.

Actually, no. This map has an issue that breaks the Ranking Criteria and makes it legitimately unrankable. Rena has said that she sliderbroke on that part of the map. On top of that, I've played the map multiple times now. Even though I remember there's a hidden repeat there, I manage to sliderbreak due to the hidden repeat.

Sorry if I was rude. Don't accuse people of "liking to see maps unranked". kusano could easily change those parts of the map and it could be re-ranked quickly. Thank you.

Gaiety wrote:

Wasn't it established that hidden second slider repeats were fine, and only the first slider repeat that matters?