Like you could have picked Sonic the Hedgehog <insert number here> and someone else could have chosen Super Mario <insert number here> and you'd have to lynch him.
or something
or something
forum
PyP Video Game Mafia [MAFIA+SURVIVOR] - Dr. Hitter Escapes!
posted
Total Posts
1,343
Yeah I was thinking that too Luigi's Mansion might want to step out of Super Mario Galaxy's shadow or something.
That's only because LS appeared to be taking it seriously. >.<//Lybydose wrote:
I wasn't really serious either (I mean come on, using judge that many times?), but you seem to be keen on defending yourself and completely making sure everyone knows.
That said, I just realized I never confirmed, so /confirm
While this whole thing is rather suspicious, I don't think Salvage is mafia, nor do I think fishie is mafia. I disagree with Lyby's accusation on Salvage, but I don't think Lyby is mafia either. Actually, my gut is pointing towards LunaticMara at this point. unvote, vote LunaticMara though I'll probably change it once more people show up (as it is we have about 37 people who are inactive)
...go on.pieguy1372 wrote:
Actually, my gut is pointing towards LunaticMara at this point. unvote, vote LunaticMara though I'll probably change it once more people show up (as it is we have about 37 people who are inactive)
no reasoning?
..wait, 37? How did you get such a ridiculous number? There's only 19 people in this, not 37.
this guy
puush/Fao and such
puush/Fao and such
That was an exaggeration
Also, as I've been saying the past few games, I always vote on my gut day 1 unless someone does something obvious. With less data, there's a higher chance of a statistical error, especially with a lower critical value. As a result, the person who seems most suspicious isn't always mafia, especially when you consider when the mafia does a good job blending in day 1.
IIRC Rantai, Lilac, Rolled, foulcoon, DxS, adam2046, Jaqennn, and bmin11 (and fishie but I think he's town) didn't post anything after RVS, so I don't have any reads on any of them. I probably forgot one or two people though
Also, as I've been saying the past few games, I always vote on my gut day 1 unless someone does something obvious. With less data, there's a higher chance of a statistical error, especially with a lower critical value. As a result, the person who seems most suspicious isn't always mafia, especially when you consider when the mafia does a good job blending in day 1.
IIRC Rantai, Lilac, Rolled, foulcoon, DxS, adam2046, Jaqennn, and bmin11 (and fishie but I think he's town) didn't post anything after RVS, so I don't have any reads on any of them. I probably forgot one or two people though
see pies last time I called you out for voting on a gut feeling D1 you were mafia.
I was mafia too but thank Two for that one
I was mafia too but thank Two for that one
Yeah, but that's because I always do it as town too. When mafia, IMO the optimal strategy is to play exactly the same as if you were town except perhaps in cases when it would harm one of your teammates.
mkay i'm back , didn't sleep much >.<
just to clarify i said it was highly unlikely in this setup to have a lyncher , of course i'm not saying it's impossible.
just to clarify i said it was highly unlikely in this setup to have a lyncher , of course i'm not saying it's impossible.
What makes it highly unlikely? It's pyp, you could end up with any role.Salvage wrote:
just to clarify i said it was highly unlikely in this setup to have a lyncher , of course i'm not saying it's impossible.
why are we loosing so much time in a meaningless thing like it? i just wanted to clarify that i didn't said it was impossible.
Because we can?
Unvote
Vote: Salvage
Unvote
Vote: Salvage
I almost want to vote you just for thatSalvage wrote:
why are we loosing so much time in a meaningless thing like it? i just wanted to clarify that i didn't said it was impossible.
sorry lyby D:
adam : i'd rather waste time thinking about more important things , we won't reach anything discussing the probabilty of roles being used when we don't know anything about them yet , glad you start moving things with that vote ^_^.
adam : i'd rather waste time thinking about more important things , we won't reach anything discussing the probabilty of roles being used when we don't know anything about them yet , glad you start moving things with that vote ^_^.
Salvage and pieguy1372 are the most suspicious people to me so far.
You are being watched.
I'll just leave this here.
Unvote
You are being watched.
I'll just leave this here.
Unvote
He just hates me so much in general. That's all.Wojjan wrote:
no reasoning?
And okay.jpg.
unvote
Vote: Salvage
because you know its bad when you're more suspicious than swift.
because you know its bad when you're more suspicious than swift.
Really now?Salvage wrote:
adam : i'd rather waste time thinking about more important things , we won't reach anything discussing the probabilty of roles being used when we don't know anything about them yet , glad you start moving things with that vote ^_^.
That sounds rather scummy right there, glad to see you don't mind wasting time, as long as it's not around you.
I like when you're start realizing wich people are good at mafia and wich aren't.
I guess I can put you in the latter group then huh
even though he is really anoying i dont think salvage is mafia, he is just drawing too much attention, i think that would be a stupid thing to do as mafia.
Unvote
Vote: Jaqennnthebox
Since you have yet to draw attention, that must mean you are mafia.
Flawless logic.
Vote: Jaqennnthebox
Since you have yet to draw attention, that must mean you are mafia.
Flawless logic.
on the other hand you're not drawing too much attention , are you mafia?
What the hell I posted something and it does not show
I had meant to post:
I had meant to post:
Lybydose wrote:
I guess I can put you in the latter group then huh
Did you, like, just claim Mafia?Salvage wrote:
why's that , i actually find me pretty good at it.
i don't get your point krzy , mafia as the game , not the role , and i won't roleclaim d1 , kthx.
oh okaySalvage wrote:
mafia as the game
You make my life hard, Salvage. Now I just want to stop reading this thread ;~;
WHY
DO
YOU
USE
A
SPACE
BEFORE
EACH
COMMA
?
DO
YOU
USE
A
SPACE
BEFORE
EACH
COMMA
?
It's called pressure. It's a good way to try to force out scum.pieguy1372 wrote:
That's only because LS appeared to be taking it seriously. >.<//
That being said I still am suspicious of you for voting without reading the thread or having read the thread joining on the bandwagon anyway. I highly expect it was the former though.
That being said salvage is also being highly suspicious to me. However I'm not really sure if it's suspicious suspicious or animask suspicious.
It feels a lot closer to the 'try hard' suspicious opposed to the ... animask suspicious(sugarcoating... ;_;). Or it's his posting style that's rubbing me the wrong way?
The fact is, Salvage always posts like that, regardless of alignment. I've still got my eye on you though.
While I don't particularly like meta...
I have not seen him be anything but scum so far (Wolf) and the only other game I've seen him play here is the touhou mafia that you moder-
You've got to be kidding me. I'll go swallow that bullet now.
I have not seen him be anything but scum so far (Wolf) and the only other game I've seen him play here is the touhou mafia that you moder-
You've got to be kidding me. I'll go swallow that bullet now.
Referring to 'regardless of alignment'
You know what? Screw this. Vote: Salvage I hate you from WWG, and I'll keep hating you now.
I am going through meta and meta alone.
According to my searching he has/is playing 2 games, that wolf one where he was a wolf and the concurrent touhou game. (if he has played another one I will drop this straight away). You say he plays the same 'regardless of alignment' but he has only ever been revealed once as a scum. I put two and two together and came up with that conclusion because it's the only logical one I can think of.
I am not discussing another thread's dealings, just my observations of the significance of your post in this game.
According to my searching he has/is playing 2 games, that wolf one where he was a wolf and the concurrent touhou game. (if he has played another one I will drop this straight away). You say he plays the same 'regardless of alignment' but he has only ever been revealed once as a scum. I put two and two together and came up with that conclusion because it's the only logical one I can think of.
I am not discussing another thread's dealings, just my observations of the significance of your post in this game.
Goddamnit I thought of Yellowswift or whatever his frickin' name is.
Oh ok. Then I will back off now.
"Yellowswift" is fine. I've heard combinations like these and I am not offended by any of them.Lilac wrote:
Goddamnit I thought of Yellowswift or whatever his frickin' name is.
Vash was a better name to remember.
Unvote. I hate too many people, I just need to calm down or something......Really really long day.
Unvote. I hate too many people, I just need to calm down or something......Really really long day.
I swear to God I thought Salvage was in Less Experimental Mafia 2.
HoS: Swift and Salvage. One of you two are the mafia and I determine to find out who it is...tomorrow.
HoS: Swift and Salvage. One of you two are the mafia and I determine to find out who it is...tomorrow.
My gut has a feeling that you're on the right track with Salvage, but I don't think it'd be necessary to make a vote D1. It's just how I play.
Also, when pieguy mentioned his strategy, I have a slight feeling that he might be mafia.
Also, when pieguy mentioned his strategy, I have a slight feeling that he might be mafia.
I'm a newbie. What kind of suspicious is "animask suspicious"?LadySuburu wrote:
suspicious suspicious or animask suspicious.
The kind of suspicious that makes me suspicious of them regardless of alignment.LunaticMara wrote:
I'm a newbie. What kind of suspicious is "animask suspicious"?
I reference it because it seemed that animask would always do something that would be suspicious even though pretty much every time he was town.
In short: It's their personality and how they tend to act regardless in these games.
Ah, I understand now.
LadySuburu wrote:
It's called pressure. It's a good way to try to force out scum.
That being said salvage is also being highly suspicious to me. However I'm not really sure if it's suspicious suspicious or animask suspicious.
You kinda contradict you right there , you talk about pressure to find out scum then you find me highly suspicious for using pressure to try to find scum.
Lilac wrote:
HoS: Swift and Salvage. One of you two are the mafia and I determine to find out who it is...tomorrow.
Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
My gut has a feeling that you're on the right track with Salvage.
so smart swift.
bmin11 wrote:
You make my life hard, Salvage. Now I just want to stop reading this thread ;~;
boohoo D:
Whatever i just woke up , not much to say , LS got my attention tho
.Where did I say I found you suspicious for using pressure to try to find scum?Salvage wrote:
You kinda contradict you right there , you talk about pressure to find out scum then you find me highly suspicious for using pressure to try to find scum.
Trying to put words in my mouth isn't nice you know.
Vote: Salvage
Vote Salvage
Jesus christ you're scummy
Jesus christ you're scummy
what do you mean? i quoted the first sentence cause it's exactly what i'm doing and then you say that you find me highly suspicious cause of that .. don't try to get away with yours here ls , your not good at being mafia.
Since you know so much about what I find you highly suspicious for, why don't you go ahead and quote a few of the posts I find you suspicious for?Salvage wrote:
what do you mean? i quoted the first sentence cause it's exactly what i'm doing and then you say that you find me highly suspicious cause of that .. don't try to get away with yours here ls , your not good at being mafia.
Also, I really like how you're baselessly accusing pretty much everyone of being mafia. Multiple people who've attacked you too, heavy OMGUS.
Since it's fitting...
Don't try to get away with your act here Salvage, you're not good at being mafia.
Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
My gut has a feeling that you're on the right track with Salvage, but I don't think it'd be necessary to make a vote D1. It's just how I play.
I think this person is mafia but I won't vote himaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
oh btw am I voting salvage yet?
If he turns up mafia Backfire is also totally mafia. Mark me wordsss
Vote: Salvage
It's cause i'm not mafia right now .. you pretty much know it anyways so it's kinda useless to discuss this with you.
Also :
Roleclaim : Spy Infiltrator, i'm kind of a watcher/tracker depends on what i want .. so can we stop wasting time with me please.
Also :
Roleclaim : Spy Infiltrator, i'm kind of a watcher/tracker depends on what i want .. so can we stop wasting time with me please.
usually you claim some flavor to go along with things in a PYP game.
i don't really know since i sent : deus ex human revolution , splinter cell and metal gear solid. So yeah i could be pretty much any of those , i think i'm splinter cell tho.
probably that, yeah. Unvote then becuase Sam fischer is awesome and never lynch power roles.
So did we really have to force a roleclaim this early?
seems like it , i said i didn't want to roleclaim this early ..i don't think my role is that important anyways , but since i'm the only one who roleclaimed i'm probabbly gonna die n1 .. anyways LS is mafia imo.
Unvote
Nothing was forced either adam, Salvage claimed early on his own. (After being pretty suspicious and gaining a decent amount of votes.)
Unfortunately now we're left with Salvage who won't be providing us any real information except night results assuming he's telling the truth and doesn't die.
Nothing was forced either adam, Salvage claimed early on his own. (After being pretty suspicious and gaining a decent amount of votes.)
Unfortunately now we're left with Salvage who won't be providing us any real information except night results assuming he's telling the truth and doesn't die.
You've killed yourself.
Questions like that are pointless.Salvage wrote:
so are you gonna kill me LS?
If I'm Town, I answer no.
If I'm independant, I answer no.
If I'm neutral, I answer no.
If I'm mafia, I answer no.
Please try to find mafia and explain your reasonings, and not say "X person who voted me is mafia, so is Y over there for no reason, and Z because they're suspecting me for reason B even though that had nothing to do with why they suspect me."
As far as I can tell, you haven't stated one good actual reason why any of the people you've said are mafia actually are mafia.
Also:
LadySuburu wrote:
Nothing was forced either adam, Salvage claimed early on his own. (After being pretty suspicious and gaining a decent amount of votes.)
xXxSavageManxXx wrote:
GUYS! IF YOU KEEP VOTING ME IMMA GONNA ROLECLAIM
Hairflip58 wrote:
Vote: Salvage
Point taken.adam2046 wrote:
Also:xXxSavageManxXx wrote:
GUYS! IF YOU KEEP VOTING ME IMMA GONNA ROLECLAIMHairflip58 wrote:
Vote: Salvage
It still was his own decision, he barely had half the required votes for a lynch if that.
EBWOP: I think, I skimmed the votes.LadySuburu wrote:
It still was his own decision, he barely had half the required votes for a lynch if that.
You pretty much know my playstyle LS , and even knowing that you said i was highly suspicious trying to incriminate me. That's why i think you're mafia , but as everyone knows .. conclusions can't be taken D1 that easily .. so either we go with a plan right now or we do nothing and waste a day.
So, how do I know your playstyle? If I'm not mistaken I'm in two games with you right now and haven't run into you before. I can only potentially guess that you may be similar to animask, who by the way I also always see as suspicious.Salvage wrote:
You pretty much know my playstyle LS , and even knowing that you said i was highly suspicious trying to incriminate me. That's why i think you're mafia , but as everyone knows .. conclusions can't be taken D1 that easily .. so either we go with a plan right now or we do nothing and waste a day.
Also, you're right about it being D1. That's why when you and pieguy both were suspicious, I mentioned it. Should I just sit quiet and not mention any of my thoughts about the game? Should I not call attention to anyone that I see as suspicious and just let them do what they're doing? I dunno, but I'm pretty sure it's better than RVS for me to mention these things.
so again, i'm scummy for scumhunting .. i'd need to improve it a little bit i guess. And i said you know my playstyle cause i pretty much told you everything i was gonna do and why on WWV.
i still don't know why i get compared to animask, i readed his games before and he's playstyle it's not even close to mine, but whatever .. and i didn't said you should sit quiet, i wasn't doing that exactly neither .. it's too early to come into conclusions right now since we don't have enough information yet.
i still don't know why i get compared to animask, i readed his games before and he's playstyle it's not even close to mine, but whatever .. and i didn't said you should sit quiet, i wasn't doing that exactly neither .. it's too early to come into conclusions right now since we don't have enough information yet.
"if you vote for me I will roleclaim" is really no reason not to vote someone. Mafia is gonna roleclaim too in that situation.
WWG is somewhat different than this, and you were mafia (wolf) in that game.Salvage wrote:
so again, i'm scummy for scumhunting .. i'd need to improve it a little bit i guess. And i said you know my playstyle cause i pretty much told you everything i was gonna do and why on WWV.
As for comparing you to animask, it doesn't mean you two play the same. It means that both of you may end up suspicious to me regardless of your role (due to the way you each play, even if different.)
I won't know until this game ends. (Maybe not even then.)
There were better ways to go about it. We didn't need him to roleclaim.Wojjan wrote:
"if you vote for me I will roleclaim" is really no reason not to vote someone. Mafia is gonna roleclaim too in that situation.
Urgh.
That sounded extremely desperate. No idea what to think right now.
That sounded extremely desperate. No idea what to think right now.
yes like a no lynchadam2046 wrote:
There were better ways to go about it. We didn't need him to roleclaim.
Okay then unvote
Whatever , we have something to move on with right now , and start making a plan now , unless there is a strongman on the mafia the doctor can save me and i'll bring some information on the table for d2.
Salvage I'd suggest you self-watch so you can confirm the doctor as town when it comes to that.
Topic Starter
VOTE COUNT:
Salvage (1) - foulcoon
Backfire (1) - DeathxShinigami
pieguy1372 (1) - Lybydose
LunaticMara (1) - pieguy1372
Jaqennn (1) - adam2046
Wojjan (1) - bmin11
Not Voting (13) - Rantai, LunaticMara, fishie, Lilac, Salvage, Swiftwolf Yellowtail, Rolled, Mashley, Wojjan, Backfire, Jaqennn, KRZY, LadySuburu
Clarifications:
1) You may not target yourself in regards to actions.
2) Unvoting isn't required but appreciated.
Edit: Modified clarification to be more specific.
Salvage (1) - foulcoon
Backfire (1) - DeathxShinigami
pieguy1372 (1) - Lybydose
LunaticMara (1) - pieguy1372
Jaqennn (1) - adam2046
Wojjan (1) - bmin11
Not Voting (13) - Rantai, LunaticMara, fishie, Lilac, Salvage, Swiftwolf Yellowtail, Rolled, Mashley, Wojjan, Backfire, Jaqennn, KRZY, LadySuburu
Clarifications:
1) You may not target yourself in regards to actions.
2) Unvoting isn't required but appreciated.
Edit: Modified clarification to be more specific.
^
Edited that post cause i tought i had a vote on swift but i forgot i unvoted him.
Edited that post cause i tought i had a vote on swift but i forgot i unvoted him.
is this true for all roles, or was this in regards to voting. if you were addressing wojjan's suggestion did you just confirm salvage as spy infiltrator? lolNoHItter wrote:
Clarifications:
1) You may not target yourself.
also shut up adam. read his posts, its not like he was being attacked as an innocent. he was acting like an arrogant asshat calling people bad at mafia, and accusing multiple people with no information to go on. there is a difference between an FoS and saying "X is mafia".
Topic Starter
This is referring to all roles with applicable actions.foulcoon wrote:
is this true for all roles, or was this in regards to voting.
wow! just got back from college and you guys have had quite a talk and salvage already rolleclaim, im kinda lost now, everyone is playing agressive, but we still are on d1
hey, a roleclaim.
roleclaim: team recruiter
This is probably because I sent in Pro Evolution Soccer as my first choice. I can choose a player at night and gain day/night talking privileges with that player. If said player is scum, I die.
Basically I can target Salvage at night and see if his claims are true. If, for some reason, I end up dead the next day, you know who to vote.
roleclaim: team recruiter
This is probably because I sent in Pro Evolution Soccer as my first choice. I can choose a player at night and gain day/night talking privileges with that player. If said player is scum, I die.
Basically I can target Salvage at night and see if his claims are true. If, for some reason, I end up dead the next day, you know who to vote.
That narrows things down a bit.
unless of course if you get nightkilled!KRZY wrote:
hey, a roleclaim.
roleclaim: team recruiter
This is probably because I sent in Pro Evolution Soccer as my first choice. I can choose a player at night and gain day/night talking privileges with that player. If said player is scum, I die.
Basically I can target Salvage at night and see if his claims are true. If, for some reason, I end up dead the next day, you know who to vote.
go KRZY you're just on a roll today aren't you
..oh wow, now that I think about it, Wojjan's right.
Lurkers (bmin and Jaquennn): Thoughts on this situation?
..EBWODP:
(bmin and Jaquennn)should be
(bmin, Lybydose and Jaquennn)because even though he's not showing up, that doesn't mean he's not here.
With a potential watcher/tracker/whatever present? I think not.Wojjan wrote:
unless of course if you get nightkilled!
Don't forget about protectors!
You shouldn't pull that lurker thing against us, because Lyby and I are also playing another mafia game (PyP touhou mafia).
Nothing much to say. Salvage was being animask suspicious for the last 10 pages and KRZY's plan can turn into WIFOM quite easily.
tl;dr
KRZY's role seems almost like a cult leader lol
Nothing much to say. Salvage was being animask suspicious for the last 10 pages and KRZY's plan can turn into WIFOM quite easily.
tl;dr
KRZY's role seems almost like a cult leader lol
I'm only doing this because I don't want people to just post in one thread and seemingly ignore the other. (ie: Pretending you didn't notice this thread at all)
All of this is unlikely to lead to any positive results if there is a roleblocker.