Oh, you ninja. Okay. Change of plans.
Bmin wrote:
I'm a 50% chance Detective. If I target the victim (NK'ed) of the night successfully, I'm able to draw the culprit's face
So, if you are the detective as you claim, you have quite the odd ability, for being a detective. The ability you claim to have is not standard to what a normal Detective consists of. In fact, if you were a "100% chance detective," that's still even a much weaker role compared to a standard detective. Do you have any opinions on this subject?MafiaWiki - Detective wrote:
This role has the ability to track one person's activity each night.
The mafia's goal is to be the only faction left alive, thus they win when nothing can prevent that from happening.Rolled wrote:
Mod: Hypothetical, again ^_^
What exactly is a standard win condition for mafia? Is it just to outnumber town?
ie. 2 town, 2 neutral (both separate) and 3 mafia. Does mafia win in this scenario?
Theoretically. <--- word of the dayRolled wrote:
Hey faceman would you create your own variation of a role without it being available on a wiki or something somewhere?
On one hand, it's a little too convenient that his ability only works half the time, especially when it's so weak- it provides heck of a lot of deniability if he's faking it, and he can also get us to vote for somebody incorrectly at LyLo. On the other, though, the flavor of the claim seems correct (though I wonder why bmin chose Daru). When you factor in on his general activity, I'm more inclined to vote Kiddo barring further input from him.Rolled wrote:
Any opinions on the whole bmin detective bit?
1. If foulcoon is mafia:bmin11 wrote:
People I want for the lynch
Kiddo
foulcoon
Lilac
This is what I assumed would happen too - out of interest at the start of the game I asked what would happen if LS got nightkilled, but 0_o simply said I'd find out if it happened. And what happened was I became a survivor.Rolled wrote:
Upon LS's death, Mashley claimed that his "win condition is invalidated." What I don't understand is, why are you now a survivor winning with either side? Wouldn't you have already lost the game? Half-win, perhaps? Please elaborate a little, Mashley.
Yeah because it's basically impossible, given the number of kills and people who were killed. Oh, unless you want to claim something other than night vig?foulcoon wrote:
you guys keep forgetting the "hypothetical" situation that I'm neither mafia nor SK, btw. I'm starting to lose hope.
Wojjan most likely either jailed the SK, or jailed the target. Didn't really go back and read who she is likely to have jailed.Lilac wrote:
Hold up, speaking of that. Let's rewind back to N1.
Only one person died during N1, I didn't use my commuter ability at that time and considering that there was the mafia and SK lose it's an odd phenomenon to wonder why one one person died.
Opinions?
lol you think foulcoon is townLilac wrote:
Look at this Chris guy.
What a fag, seriously. I'll be damned if you lynched town.
Lilac wrote:
I'll be damned if you lynched town.
not gonna happenLilac wrote:
Lilac wrote:
I'll be damned if you lynched town.
Also, for the lulz I targeted myself last night. I had a feeling Rolled would switch me my target. Seems like I was right, boy is this game getting hilariousthat was like, the worst lie I've ever seen.
Lilac wrote:
And I think I've just figured out who's SK.
Oh wow...I have to reread this thread again to confirm.
Why did you just roleclaim serial killer.Lilac wrote:
Also, the SK won't have the balls to kill me. I dare you.
Kinda skimmed through it. Probably missed some important information.bmin11 wrote:
@Kiddo
Have you read the thread yet?
youakrolsmir wrote:
... me or kiddo?
or you can sit here for a couple of days and come up with the exact same outcomeakrolsmir wrote:
Same. Meanwhile, chris seems to be encouraging the easy lynch to get to the next night a lot quicker.
Remember what adam's death revealed D2?Rolled wrote:
i thought SK needed to be last alive
no one picked you ~Rolled wrote:
For the record, I called foulcoon to be most likely to be mafia from the get go because I couldn't imagine him picking anybody other than awp/ival/seibei/me ^__^
0_o wrote:
Remember what adam's death revealed D2?Rolled wrote:
i thought SK needed to be last alive
"There is an independent killer who wins when a certain group of people are eliminated."