00:04:588 (4588|2) - Minor but concept wise you usually jack your pattern with previous chord such as 00:06:672 - etc, so this one kinda stood out awkward in comparison. Try Ctrl+H 00:04:588 (4588|2,4727|4) - to achieve that
00:12:852 (12852|1) - Really wanna delete this because the 1/4 things start at 00:12:922 - . 00:12:991 (12991|2,13130|3) - you can compare with the two with 00:12:852 (12852|1) -
00:14:588 (14588|1) - I think it should be a rice cuz seems 00:14:519 (14519|6) - short LN for the piano but 00:14:588 (14588|1) no piano and no melody
00:17:494 (17494|4,17633|6) - Personally think you can accent the pitch a bit better by making it slightly more denser. Something like this will be fine i think. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18698466/454d
00:25:144 - I think the LN 00:24:450 (24450|3) - should not be divided here cuz the melody here is :https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477145/e78e
00:28:963 - Not sure if you intentionally ignore this for playability, but it doesnt seem more difficult than 00:29:658 - even if you try to layering that part. Something like this can be considered ig? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18698474/8242
00:32:783 (32783|6,32922|6,33061|6,33200|6,33338|6,33477|6,33616|6) - Not sure if you intentionally wanting the 7 notes anchor but moving 00:33:477 (33477|6) - to column 6 won't hurt i think? should be easier to hit
00:42:644 (42644|4,42644|6,42713|4) - This part kinda stood out for me because for the entirety of this section you usually layered with either double jack or triple jack, while this is the only single jack in the entire section. Wouldn't it better to also layer this double minijack for structural purpose
00:42:644 (42644|6,42644|4,42713|4) - You can grace this part as well since this also has strong continuous sound like the previous grace at 00:46:429 (46429|4,46429|2) -
00:43:026 (43026|4) - more like a ghost note ? how about this : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477153/7fe3
00:48:078 (48078|0,48095|2,48113|4) - I think it should be 1/16 earlier. The timing is different with 00:47:870 - the three
00:50:422 (50422|4,50491|5,50561|4,50561|6,50653|4) - Not sure how this transition will work, probably balance it a bit with this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18698511/a386
00:55:005 - 00:55:213 imo, three 1/16 notes here is not that powerful to represent the scratch so i would suggest that we need to sacrifice a note from both of the said timestamp and make it a 1/16 stair burst instead. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18746173/18f3
00:58:304 (58304|1) - 01:00:526 (60526|5) - ... for these 1/8 just for visual ? I think its unreasonable to make a wub here . seems more quiet compare with 00:59:496 (59496|2,59542|1) -
01:03:755 (63755|5,63894|5,63894|6,64033|6,64033|5) - I'm not too confident on this part actually. having 01:03:755 (63755|5) - at column 4 will be cool i think.
01:11:533 - I think it would be better if you actually bracket this part so that it would transition better into non bracket part at 01:11:811 - . Currently you have sudden non bracket after the bracket at 01:11:255 - which is awkward structural wise. How about try modify the pattern into something like this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18698533/8bac
01:12:227 (72227|4) - I think it is a rice cuz the LN is not devided . how about this ? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477177/1f77
01:20:561 (80561|0,80630|2) - I think would be better if you make these into LNs, your pattern kinda have a hole right now which doesn't seem so good atm. You can try use this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18698545/d774
01:26:811 - how about make a burst here like 01:27:088 - ? but 01:26:950 - should be a chord . do sth like this ?https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477179/77e0
01:35:075 (95075|1,95769|3,96880|3) - hmmmmm the LN tails are dangerous I think it seems unreasonble for rank yea
I can get maxus but I wanna say this is really isnt a place for visual. Other LN place have many wubby/windy sound so thats make sence but this place Dont have anything and its not a good example for ranked map. As you can see many unnecessary heartbreak things happend these days. Overall I think ud better delete those tails plz (I dont know if its appropriate to put it in discuss area sorry)
01:36:394 - I think it should use similar trilly structure like 01:34:172 (94172|1,94241|3,94311|1,94380|3) - and 01:35:977 (95977|4,96047|3,96116|4,96186|3) - so sth like :
01:59:449 - seems need to add the chord size so how about this ? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477194/6c1d
02:01:115 - Think you can shorten this LN at 02:01:115 (121115|5) - so that you can filled out the note gap at 02:01:208 -
I'm meaning you can try make more coherent pattern , so that you will have more consistent shield pattern with 02:01:856 -
Something like this for example:
if you accept, you might wanna shorten 02:01:949 (121949|1) - to 1/2 LN too to make it consistent with previous structure.
02:11:578 - can make them 1/12 for more symmetry:https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18687624/cad1 and the real length are more longer than current one yeah
02:20:189 (140189|3,140189|5,140251|0,140251|2,140313|6,140313|4) - Wouldn't it better to Ctrl+H this?
the reason is that you already have upcoming burst chord at 02:20:560 (140560|6,140560|4,140583|5,140652|6,140652|4,140676|5,140745|6,140745|4,140745|5,140930|5,140930|4,141115|6,141115|5,141115|4,141177|4,141177|5,141177|6) - , So it will help for the balance more this way.
02:29:911 (149911|1,149911|5,149911|3) - make them to rice ? or at least make 02:29:911 (149911|5) - this shorter. cuz no main melody here compare with 02:29:981 (149981|6,149981|4,149981|2) - . Its a blowhole like here 02:33:800 -
02:43:731 (163731|5) - I think the The syncopation rhythm needs to be reflected, so extend this LN https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477218/0b71
02:46:509 - try this more clear one ? : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18687629/aaa9
If you dont wanna to this, at least make this shorter 02:47:134 (167134|1) - seems no cross :3
03:05:235 (185235|2,185241|1) - Slight nitpick but these grace should be at col 2 and col 3 instead, as the counterpart for the grace you have at 03:05:351 (185351|5,185363|4) -
03:27:064 (207064|0,207064|6) - shorten to 1/2 ? I think thay are Equivalent ( 03:26:856 (206856|0,206856|6,206925|5,206925|1,206995|4,206995|2) - )
03:58:106 (238106|4) - may nit pick : I want move this to →col6 cuz the anchor u used this part is : one sentense (3 beat LN melody) for 5 or 6 jack but not it may have loonger anchor for col5 . My plan seems more balanced
03:58:592 (238592|5) - These part should be 1/6 grace actually, same thing as what you did at 03:55:096 (235096|4,235143|6) -
04:19:703 (259703|6,259703|4,259772|5) - This movement potentially being awkward imo, better make 04:19:703 (259703|4,259772|5) - into col 6 and col 5 instead.
04:25:953 (265953|1,265953|0,265953|2) - Bit of preference but i think it's better to just make these into LN tail grace instead for visual purpose, it's to accomodate for the other grace part you use at 04:25:884 (265884|6,265884|5,265884|4,266022|6,266040|5,266057|4) - as well.
Something like this is cool :
04:30:536 (270536|4) - make a short LN like others ? 04:30:189 (270189|0,270259|1,270328|2,270397|1,270467|0,270606|6) -
04:31:578 (271578|2,271578|3,271578|0,271578|1,271647|6,271647|4,271647|5,271717|0,271717|2,271717|1,271786|3,271786|6,271786|5) - having these as rice notes give you much better transition into LN part at 04:31:856 - instead of doing the LN now. Right now the transition sort of mixed up which makes the boundary not too clear
04:31:856 - You can even try buff this part with LN a bit if you decide to apply previous suggestion, which should give overall advantage for you.
Something like this as example:
04:36:092 - 04:36:231 - why not miss the melody ? intention ? how about this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477254/2a97
04:46:248 (286248|6) - and 04:46:254 (286254|1) - they are not in the same snapping.
Recommend having 04:46:248 (286248|6) -at 1/6 instead.
04:50:328 -
I think 04:50:328 (290328|1,290536|3) - are equal and here is not a LN density part yeah so I think they should be same length and 04:50:397 (290397|4,290606|4) - is more loud isnt it ? and consider 04:50:397 (290397|4,290606|4) - are different pitch so I have a clearer plan :
04:51:022 (291022|5,291092|4,291161|3) - I think its more like an echo of 04:50:745 (290745|0,290791|1,290837|2) - and the 04:51:161 (291161|3) - is main one so why not make it more clearer:
05:13:522 - burst adjust : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477265/4069 or https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477266/ff49
05:14:078 (314078|0,314113|1,314147|2,314182|1,314217|0) little bit unfriendly i guess? if you wanna change it, you can drag these three 05:14:147 (314147|2,314182|1,314217|0) - one column to the right. it will also solve the absence of col 1 notes if you will apply this #3880308