mapped by _underjoy
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 17 August 2023!
nominated by AWMRone and Maxus
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:04:588 (4588|2) - Minor but concept wise you usually jack your pattern with previous chord such as 00:06:672 - etc, so this one kinda stood out awkward in comparison. Try Ctrl+H 00:04:588 (4588|2,4727|4) - to achieve that

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:10:561 - I think you misplaced some of the 1/3 around this part. there is no sound at 00:10:653 (10653|1,10931|2) - . You should actually put notes at 00:10:607 - and 00:10:885 - instead because that's where the sound is.

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:12:366 - 00:12:644 - these can probably be triple chord considering how emphasized these instruments are compared with previous one, and this also serves as the basis for build up as well which i think should be good for you

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:12:852 (12852|1) - Really wanna delete this because the 1/4 things start at 00:12:922 - . 00:12:991 (12991|2,13130|3) - you can compare with the two with 00:12:852 (12852|1) -

permalink

agreed with this.

permalink

agree

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:14:588 (14588|1) - I think it should be a rice cuz seems 00:14:519 (14519|6) - short LN for the piano but 00:14:588 (14588|1) no piano and no melody

permalink

oke

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:17:494 (17494|4,17633|6) - Personally think you can accent the pitch a bit better by making it slightly more denser. Something like this will be fine i think. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18698466/454d

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:25:144 - I think the LN 00:24:450 (24450|3) - should not be divided here cuz the melody here is :https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477145/e78e

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:28:963 - Not sure if you intentionally ignore this for playability, but it doesnt seem more difficult than 00:29:658 - even if you try to layering that part. Something like this can be considered ig? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18698474/8242

permalink

I think the current ver is better and more smooth

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:29:172 - 00:29:033 - OK compare with the strength , 00:29:172 - are stronger . and same part 00:29:866 - only use single so I suggest 00:29:033 - 00:29:866 - double 00:29:172 - 00:30:005 - triple. and 00:30:144 (30144|3) - should be LN like 00:29:311 (29311|3) -

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:32:783 (32783|6,32922|6,33061|6,33200|6,33338|6,33477|6,33616|6) - Not sure if you intentionally wanting the 7 notes anchor but moving 00:33:477 (33477|6) - to column 6 won't hurt i think? should be easier to hit

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:36:533 - I believe its 1/6 here but not 1/8.

permalink
permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:37:505 - shuold reduce the chord size cuz no kick here

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:38:269 - add one to triple compare with 00:38:130 - 00:37:991 - ...

permalink
permalink

I left it double for better pattern transition

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:41:047 - I prefer add one on col1 (1-7) cuz the burst has a obvious stop sound here

permalink

adjusted patterns here as such

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:41:672 - use at least quad cuz it is stronger than 00:41:764 - 00:41:857 -

permalink

changed as such

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:42:135 (42135|6) - delete this cuz no kick like 00:41:950 - and more smooth pianoly

permalink

done

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:42:366 - reduce chord size compare with 00:42:227 -

permalink

okies

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:42:644 (42644|4,42644|6,42713|4) - This part kinda stood out for me because for the entirety of this section you usually layered with either double jack or triple jack, while this is the only single jack in the entire section. Wouldn't it better to also layer this double minijack for structural purpose

permalink

this is the only one with jack being due to high pitch sound, others are for kick or other drum sounds, so I'll leave it

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:42:644 (42644|6,42644|4,42713|4) - You can grace this part as well since this also has strong continuous sound like the previous grace at 00:46:429 (46429|4,46429|2) -

permalink

ok I'll apply

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:43:026 (43026|4) - more like a ghost note ? how about this : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477153/7fe3

permalink

looks good

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:45:838 (45838|0) - I prefer delete this for no-kick chord size compare with 00:45:700 -

permalink

changed accordingly

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:46:950 - I believe it is not a stairly pattern but two small wubs and 00:47:088 - should be quad compare with 00:47:158 - so how about this ? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477159/29eb

permalink

seems good

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:48:078 (48078|0,48095|2,48113|4) - I think it should be 1/16 earlier. The timing is different with 00:47:870 - the three

permalink

I think making this 1/16 earlier makes it a bit harder to play -- will change if necessary but I think current version is fine (arranged patterns to be slightly easier to play)

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:50:005 - Oh I think the burst should start here so the structure should be more like this : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18687611/9ba0

permalink

ok, rearranged a bit too

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:50:422 (50422|4,50491|5,50561|4,50561|6,50653|4) - Not sure how this transition will work, probably balance it a bit with this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18698511/a386

permalink

did differently

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:51:255 - Oh honey look this small burst I think its longer and slower like this :

permalink

agree

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:51:950 - 00:52:019 maybe convert some notes from the hexa chord into a bursty stair? it can represent the synth sound after the kick even more.

permalink

oke

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:55:005 - 00:55:213 imo, three 1/16 notes here is not that powerful to represent the scratch so i would suggest that we need to sacrifice a note from both of the said timestamp and make it a 1/16 stair burst instead. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18746173/18f3

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:55:109 - Too scary here // how about this ? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477167/64fd

permalink

rearranged in a different way

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:58:304 (58304|1) - 01:00:526 (60526|5) - ... for these 1/8 just for visual ? I think its unreasonable to make a wub here . seems more quiet compare with 00:59:496 (59496|2,59542|1) -

permalink

01:07:193 (67193|1) - and many more

permalink

Made those 1/4

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

00:59:033 - should be quad refer to your 4+1+4+1 logic this part

permalink

Made it a triple to accommodate for that slight density increase with using 1/6s

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:00:422 (60422|4) - Should be at column 4 imo, you always maintain that shield visual consistency so break it here is awkward

permalink

true

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:03:755 (63755|5,63894|5,63894|6,64033|6,64033|5) - I'm not too confident on this part actually. having 01:03:755 (63755|5) - at column 4 will be cool i think.

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:09:450 - reduce to triple compare with 01:09:727 -

permalink

Sure xd

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:09:797 - can add one on col 5

permalink

Alrighty

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:11:533 - I think it would be better if you actually bracket this part so that it would transition better into non bracket part at 01:11:811 - . Currently you have sudden non bracket after the bracket at 01:11:255 - which is awkward structural wise. How about try modify the pattern into something like this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18698533/8bac

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:12:227 (72227|4) - I think it is a rice cuz the LN is not devided . how about this ? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477177/1f77

permalink

Applied

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:19:588 - how about this ? to emph the chord here 01:19:658 - and more clear https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18687614/4bb4

permalink

ok sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

from 01:19:866 - to 01:21:047 - I wanna ctrl+H this cuz near 01:19:727 - the left hand are under too much pressure.(nitpick).fell free to keep

permalink

I'll keep

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:20:561 (80561|0,80630|2) - I think would be better if you make these into LNs, your pattern kinda have a hole right now which doesn't seem so good atm. You can try use this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18698545/d774

permalink

makes sense

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:26:811 - how about make a burst here like 01:27:088 - ? but 01:26:950 - should be a chord . do sth like this ?https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477179/77e0

permalink

that's a great suggestion. So I changed it to a similar way https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18489604/fa5b

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:31:325 - The chords should be 1/2 LN follow the sound consistency of 01:31:116 (91116|5,91116|1,91116|0,91116|6,91672|0,91672|5,91672|6,91672|1) - . Playability wise it should be alright too.

permalink

true

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:31:950 (91950|0,91984|1,92019|2) - just for visual ? Turn the to rice ? cuz quite here

permalink

removed the LN and placed it in the same rice as before https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18489606/4eea

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:34:727 - 01:35:838 - 01:36:255 - 01:36:672 - 01:36:950 - might wanna put double if you want to emphasize the crash for the sake of keeping consistency with 01:35:283 -

or if you just want to keep single note for everything, then remove 01:35:283 - into single note only also fine, up to you.

permalink

agree

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:34:884 (94884|4) - accident ? it should be on 01:34:866 -

permalink

it just my mistake changed

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:35:075 (95075|1,95769|3,96880|3) - consider delete them. they are sooo weak

permalink

applied

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:35:075 (95075|1,95769|3,96880|3) - hmmmmm the LN tails are dangerous I think it seems unreasonble for rank yea

permalink
permalink

applied

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:38:894 - OH and here

permalink
Reopened by AWMRone

I think I Post a wrong timestamp before sorry

permalink
permalink

is that 727....

permalink

yes

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

Reopen for discord disscussion

permalink
Reopened by AWMRone

still not sure what the problem is...

permalink

My suggestion is : (Its clear durms here. I know its for visual but its not a good place)

permalink

Personally for me i'm fine with LN tails tbh. The whole map concept already having a lot of irregular LN tails usage anyway, and using normal chord might make it too plain (?)

I will leave it to you guys, but personally i like having better visuals xD

permalink

I can get maxus but I wanna say this is really isnt a place for visual. Other LN place have many wubby/windy sound so thats make sence but this place Dont have anything and its not a good example for ranked map. As you can see many unnecessary heartbreak things happend these days. Overall I think ud better delete those tails plz (I dont know if its appropriate to put it in discuss area sorry)

permalink

applied but changed the drum to match more

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:36:394 - I think it should use similar trilly structure like 01:34:172 (94172|1,94241|3,94311|1,94380|3) - and 01:35:977 (95977|4,96047|3,96116|4,96186|3) - so sth like :

permalink

yea

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:55:282 - Think since there is certain clear sound here you shouldn't ignore it. Probably you can try rearrange pattern to fit this as well. Maybe how about this?

permalink

good one

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

01:59:449 - seems need to add the chord size so how about this ? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477194/6c1d

permalink

owo)b

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:01:115 - Think you can shorten this LN at 02:01:115 (121115|5) - so that you can filled out the note gap at 02:01:208 -

I'm meaning you can try make more coherent pattern , so that you will have more consistent shield pattern with 02:01:856 -

Something like this for example:

if you accept, you might wanna shorten 02:01:949 (121949|1) - to 1/2 LN too to make it consistent with previous structure.

permalink

oke

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:02:412 - can make them longer for more obvious wub and 02:03:893 - can make them to rice cuz so quiet

permalink

applied for first set, no change for second

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:06:949 - seems unreasonable to use double jack compare with 02:06:764 - I prefer : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477200/7be0

permalink

okies

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:09:541 to 02:11:115 i would suggest to emphasize the whistle sound here since its pretty obvious not to map. Like adding 1/8s

permalink

not sure how they could be added so I'll leave it as it is

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:09:912 (129912|2) - prefer delete this similar with #3610585 seems no double sound here

permalink

good

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:10:097 - Probably bit confused why it layered as 6 chords when 02:10:467 - got 5 instead. Probably reduce one note?

permalink

agrere

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:10:745 - This can have bit denser chord because the instrument is pretty stand out here

permalink

added 4-chord bc of 02:10:004 - also being remade into 4-chord

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:10:930 - add one on col 3 ? (1-7)

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:11:115 - Should be 3 chord at max, the instrument are very soft here

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:11:578 - can make them 1/12 for more symmetry:https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18687624/cad1 and the real length are more longer than current one yeah

permalink

okk

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:17:875 - Oh sorry I find another one place

permalink
Reopened by AWMRone

yep

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:14:171 (134171|5,134171|6) - they should be on 1/3 : 02:14:202 -

permalink

changed

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:16:115 - should be 4+2+2 refer to the strength but not 3+3+3

permalink

changed accordingly

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy
permalink

I think the current pattern is better actually

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:22:597 - add one on space compare with 02:22:319 -

permalink

okies

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:23:523 - 02:23:615 - the chord size is 3+2 but not 2+3

permalink

changed

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:25:560 - shuold be quad refer to your logic this part

permalink

good

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:29:911 (149911|1,149911|5,149911|3) - make them to rice ? or at least make 02:29:911 (149911|5) - this shorter. cuz no main melody here compare with 02:29:981 (149981|6,149981|4,149981|2) - . Its a blowhole like here 02:33:800 -

permalink
permalink

oke

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:31:786 (151786|4) - wanna delete this for no sound and last-beat surcture. just make a relax

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:40:189 - for this part I think using full LN is a little perfunctory. There are many obvious pores in this music wub. Try to shorten them to show that https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477217/d3c0

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:43:731 (163731|5) - I think the The syncopation rhythm needs to be reflected, so extend this LN https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477218/0b71

permalink
permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:46:509 - try this more clear one ? : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18687629/aaa9
If you dont wanna to this, at least make this shorter 02:47:134 (167134|1) - seems no cross :3

permalink

looks cool

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:59:356 - devide this like the music itself : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477221/a342 (may need txt fix)

permalink

ok

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

02:59:356 - think it's better for you to divide it into 2 of the 3 subsequent LN grace instead. First 3 LN grace at 02:59:356 - while the second 3 LN grace at 02:59:471 -

Something like this is good :

permalink

did something else but that should be fine

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:03:384 - Definitely need rice notes there since there is kick percussion there, to differentiate with other LN chord without any percussion

permalink

added

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:05:235 (185235|2,185241|1) - Slight nitpick but these grace should be at col 2 and col 3 instead, as the counterpart for the grace you have at 03:05:351 (185351|5,185363|4) -

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:05:745 - Oh I think this is too scray here . for real we can here three drums here clearly but if use this , the actual play may just smash the keyboard twice and 1/16 is too dense .So I prefer use sth like 03:03:870 - for more clear

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:08:522 - add one on col6

permalink

added

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:09:634 - seems need adjust the burst size for different beat eg : 03:10:189 - can be 5-burst not 7 (check the whole part)

permalink

it's an intended expression, so I'll review it a little more and revise it

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:09:772 - should use different structure cuz no drum compare with 03:09:634 - . Try sth like this ?https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18688704/b90d

permalink

i like it

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:14:911 - wrong chord size with your logic . It should be like : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18688710/b901

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

applied

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:26:509 - should be quad and 03:26:439 - 03:26:578 - should be described so how about https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477229/d579

permalink

owo)b

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

owo)b

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:28:870 - shuold have sth and 03:28:731 - should add chord size so how about this ?: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18688711/039b

permalink

makes sense

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:30:328 - After testplay I think its too scary here. Also 03:30:328 - is more weak than 03:30:397 - so how about this ? :https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18687598/f828

permalink

yea

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:31:856 - I think the pattern here can be more clear with delete the blueline note and we can also emphasize the main melody by make some LNs longer like this : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18687599/c750

permalink

okk

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:58:106 (238106|4) - may nit pick : I want move this to →col6 cuz the anchor u used this part is : one sentense (3 beat LN melody) for 5 or 6 jack but not it may have loonger anchor for col5 . My plan seems more balanced

permalink

yea 100% agree

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:58:522 - make a grace here ? so obvious https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18688718/9bde

permalink

03:55:050 - and here

permalink

ok, but added more notes in 2nd case

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:58:592 (238592|5) - These part should be 1/6 grace actually, same thing as what you did at 03:55:096 (235096|4,235143|6) -

permalink

oke

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

03:58:800 - and 03:58:939 - may need reduce the chordsize here. cuz the drum started on 03:59:356 - so my plan is set quiet chord to transition

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:00:467 - 04:00:606 - should be quad compare with 04:00:328 -

permalink

oke

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:07:272 (247272|6) - should be LN as you did 04:02:828 (242828|5) -

permalink

Nice catch, made that a LN

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:16:717 - 04:16:786 - at least 4+2 (4+3 best) but not 5+1

permalink

Made it 4+2

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:19:703 (259703|6,259703|4,259772|5) - This movement potentially being awkward imo, better make 04:19:703 (259703|4,259772|5) - into col 6 and col 5 instead.

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy
permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:21:161 - 1/16 burst vs. 04:18:939 - 1/8 busrt with same music style . may inconsistency

permalink

applied

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:25:953 (265953|1,265953|0,265953|2) - Bit of preference but i think it's better to just make these into LN tail grace instead for visual purpose, it's to accomodate for the other grace part you use at 04:25:884 (265884|6,265884|5,265884|4,266022|6,266040|5,266057|4) - as well.

Something like this is cool :

permalink

yea

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:29:495 - triple for consistency and we can descirbe the "meow" sound with Conversion of stair direction : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477248/4cb1

permalink

applied / ahahaha "meow"

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

applied

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:31:578 (271578|2,271578|3,271578|0,271578|1,271647|6,271647|4,271647|5,271717|0,271717|2,271717|1,271786|3,271786|6,271786|5) - having these as rice notes give you much better transition into LN part at 04:31:856 - instead of doing the LN now. Right now the transition sort of mixed up which makes the boundary not too clear

04:31:856 - You can even try buff this part with LN a bit if you decide to apply previous suggestion, which should give overall advantage for you.

Something like this as example:

permalink

yea that works

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:34:217 - add one here to describe continous drum 04:34:078 - 04:34:217 - 04:34:356 -

permalink

added it to 6col

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:36:092 - 04:36:231 - why not miss the melody ? intention ? how about this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477254/2a97

permalink

That one leads into my collab part which Remuring can modify freely (as long as the LN tail positions stay the same)

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:36:092 - hmm shouldnt has 1/4 things there? I mean 04:36:092 - 04:36:231 - should have notes on blue lines or ignore intentionally?

permalink

added

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:40:397 - should be LN (main melody) : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18477258/6714

permalink

Applied

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:46:248 (286248|6) - and 04:46:254 (286254|1) - they are not in the same snapping.

Recommend having 04:46:248 (286248|6) -at 1/6 instead.

permalink

04:37:359 (277359|0) - this too better turn to 1/6

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:50:328 -
I think 04:50:328 (290328|1,290536|3) - are equal and here is not a LN density part yeah so I think they should be same length and 04:50:397 (290397|4,290606|4) - is more loud isnt it ? and consider 04:50:397 (290397|4,290606|4) - are different pitch so I have a clearer plan :

permalink

works

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:51:022 (291022|5,291092|4,291161|3) - I think its more like an echo of 04:50:745 (290745|0,290791|1,290837|2) - and the 04:51:161 (291161|3) - is main one so why not make it more clearer:

permalink

yea

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

04:54:217 - wanna add a single rice on these red lines until 04:56:995 - . The current one is too boring I think ?

permalink

I think it's fine

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

yeah Its completely fine is you dont want to change but When I played until here,its feel like I'm missing something haha I will open again for u and maxus If you really think its unnecessary, just close it :3

permalink
Reopened by AWMRone

I'll close

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

05:04:147 - Worth to be double for this instrument imo.

Can try make it like this if there is concern for pattern balance:

permalink

good

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

05:04:842 (304842|1) - delete this for consistency with 05:04:703 -

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

05:05:884 - 05:05:953 - the chord size should be 2+3 but not 3+2

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

05:07:759 - Think you want to reduce this chord because the sound is much more inaudible for this.

permalink

yea

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

05:14:078 (314078|0,314113|1,314147|2,314182|1,314217|0) little bit unfriendly i guess? if you wanna change it, you can drag these three 05:14:147 (314147|2,314182|1,314217|0) - one column to the right. it will also solve the absence of col 1 notes if you will apply this #3880308

permalink

it's a very anmitsuable chord and conveys a very specific sound so I'll leave it

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

05:14:448 - add note here. sounds louder than the other

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

05:15:096 - there a synth sound after the septuple chord so i would suggest convert some into grace notes.

permalink

I think it looks worse

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy

05:26:300 - should be double refer to your logic : melody = double

permalink

true

permalink
Marked as resolved by _underjoy
/