mapped by In Dark Sky
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 3 April 2023!
nominated by Roxy- and BlackBN
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:05:864 (21) - 特に音は鳴っていないのでdelete?

permalink
permalink

繰り返しになるのを防ぐために入れていて、この周辺はもともと取れると思われる音も少なく、その配置を除くとほかの配置も修正する必要性が出てきてしまい、異様に疎になってしまうと思うので、keepします。

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

00:13:578 (25) - この後に音が鳴ってるのでなにか置いてみては。僕だったら00:13:407 (23) - からkkd_d_kって感じにします。ここは完全に好みの問題だと思いますが><

permalink

妙案

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

00:26:864 (102) との一貫性のためにパターンのタイミングを同じにしましょう。曲は繰り返しであるのにリズムが異なっているのは一貫性に欠けます

00:32:092 - add k
00:32:264 (138) - remove

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

00:33:121 (145) - kickの音に合わせるためにk?
dだと個人的にすごく変な感じがします

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

00:33:121 - Missing this snare feels pretty awkward espeically there's nothing good to emphasize at 00:32:950 - . I would assume it's a mistake when applying #3636894 ?

permalink

i fixed, but my english is not good so i may be misunderstanding X(

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

00:42:721 - I think making this to kay would make this chain less tricky overall?

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky
permalink
Reopened by BlackBN
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

02:11:862 - missed this

permalink
Reopened by BlackBN

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

00:42:892 は個人的にkのほうがいいと思います

permalink

修正しました

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

00:42:892 (203) - 個人的にここはDでいいかなと思います。他の音符はDで統一されているので、ここもDに変えることで統一感が生まれて見た目がきれいになる気がします

permalink
permalink
permalink
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky
permalink
Reopened by Roxy-
permalink

I think they are fine cuz they are consistently used with piano supported, plus if changing all of them to D then this map would have no K

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by Roxy-

00:49:064 - These two triplets sound a bit overwhelming when the vocals are not really dragging too much or something. I would suggest removing 00:49:150 - 00:49:235 - .

permalink

If apply remove 00:51:892 - 00:51:978 - for consistency

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky
permalink

let me reopen

permalink
Reopened by BlackBN
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

I believe if following the cymbals then 01:04:664 - should be unfinished and 01:04:835 - should be finished instead.

permalink

02:33:806 - same here

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:05:521 (52) - 02:34:663 (52) - ちょっとsvが見ずらいと感じてしまったのでkdをなにか同じ速度にしたほうがいいんじゃないかなと思いました><

permalink

採用 fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:06:035 - This map is not like a map focusing on SV, I think this jumpscare is a bit too excessive. Would suggest lowering the value to something like x1.2

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky
permalink
Reopened by BlackBN
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:06:37801:17:350 - 全体的にvocalに寄ってるなと思いましたが、01:16:150 - ここからいきなりゴリゴリにドラム合わせなのは統一感に欠けるので、ここら辺のパートはvocalではなく捨ててドラムに焦点をあてた方が良いのではないでしょうか?

permalink

01:07:750 - 01:08:264 - 個人的にここら辺など違和感がありました。同じようなところも同様に。

permalink

妙案

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:09:635 (136) - このセクションは全体的にドラム寄りのパターンですが、この偶数だけkickの音をスキップしているのが個人的にすごい不自然です。なので01:09:978 (137) - を01:09:807に移動させてkickの音に合わせましょう

permalink
permalink

02:35:520 (125) ~のセクションも同様です

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:16:664 (7) - change k
01:17:007 (9) のkickとの一貫性のため

permalink
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:17:350 - I think the SV jump here is a bit too excessive. If you are not going to buff the value at 01:06:378 - , then I would suggest having 01:17:350 - as x0.875 instead and back to x1 at 01:20:092 - or 01:25:578 - .

permalink
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:20:864 - Would suggest removing this note to lower the density a bit, it looks quite dense right now comparing to the previous chain

permalink
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:25:578 - 01:26:264 -ここは特に強い音鳴ってないのでfinisher消してもいいと思います

permalink
permalink

何回か聞きなおしてみましたが、finisherが無いと違和感を感じたので一旦finisherを消した状態でアップしておきますが後にfinisherを置きなおすかもしれません....

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:32:177 - 01:32:863 - change to d これは個人的な感性なんですが、ddkkd k ddkkd k の方が回ってる感じがしますw

permalink
permalink

02:06:206 (48,49,50,51,52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59) - もし”めぐる”をkkddk、”まわる”をddkkdで統一できるなら対になっててとても楽しくなりそうだったので、01:53:863 (19,20,21,22,23) - 04:30:204 (19,20,21,22,23) - ddkkd、01:43:834 - k そして”めぐる”と差別化のため 03:12:976 - 04:20:176 - d

permalink

対比設けるのいいですね。fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:34:320 (206,207,208,209) - この偶数はvocalに合っていないと思うので、01:34:406 - move to 01:34:492 - それか埋めてしまうか

permalink

01:34:320 - unsnapped

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:38:777 (239,240) - Ctrl+G ボーカル合わせならdkよりkdだと思います

permalink
permalink

全部修正したら、いい感じになりました

permalink

提案を適用した場合にはグッドボタンを押して返信して解決を押してください
適用しなかった場合はグッドボタンを押す必要はないのでそのまま返信して解決をしましょう

permalink

分かりました。ありがとうございます。

permalink

解決

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:51:634 - Pretty subjective but here is basically the same reason I said at #3637008
Could be nerfed to x1.1?

permalink
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:53:606 - This is quite questionable as basically no sound for you to present. I would suggest removing it

permalink
permalink
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:55:914 - 01:57:292 - 同じ配置が続いてるのが気になるのでどちらかを変えてみてはどうでしょうか (kkddkkddkdkkdkdなど)

permalink

04:32:261 (38) - 04:33:633 (53) - も同じ理由

permalink

確かに繰り返しになっていました。修正します。

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

01:58:406 - A bit too overmapped, would suggest removing it to follow the vocals

permalink
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

02:05:948 - This as well? and 04:42:290 -

permalink
Reopened by BlackBN

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

02:10:148 - Think this drum should not be ignored as this part is really focused on the drums

permalink
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

02:22:834 (62,64) - i would prefer those notes to be color-switched.
02:23:349 (65,66,67) - kkd -> ddk

permalink

nice idea,fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

02:54:72002:55:406 はbigにしないのでしょうか

permalink

以前その箇所のbigを消すようにアドバイスを頂いたので削除しましたが、戻そうか迷っていました。bigに修正しておきます。

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

03:01:234 (95,96,97,98,99,100) - change this to kdkkd d

permalink

I think it's better not to change,so keep

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

03:12:548 - This D but 01:43:406 - is K, not really sure if it's intended.
And 03:12:205 - should be triplet?

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

03:18:034 - DkddDkdK to consistent with 01:48:892 - ?

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

03:31:062 - move to 03:31:748 - and 03:33:119 - 終点 05:10:319 - ここがシンバルの音に合わせているなら、統一するべきだと思います。その際スピナーを叩く音量が100%だとでかすぎるので、両方ともかなり低めにvolume調整してください。

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

03:31:748 - How about moving this greenline to 03:32:434 - instead?
This way the barline there would be still at x0.75 and looks visually better imo.

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

03:32:091 ~ 03:43:404 ボーカルに沿ってノーツが置かれていますが、この範囲のパートは他のMapだとBreakとしてノーツを置かない傾向が多いと思います。最後のサビのKiai前の休憩としてこの範囲はノーツを消すことを個人的にお勧めします。

permalink

その区間はノーツ数を盛ろうと無理やり置いていたので、削除しました。

permalink

解決

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

03:32:434 - スピナーの始点をここからにすることをお勧めします。あなたは01:28:664 でボーカル部分にスピナーを置いていないですし、一貫性のためです。

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

04:04:833 (140) - 序盤と同じようにd_k_d_ddddkにしてみてはどうでしょうか。そっちのほうがサビに気持ち良く繋がるような気がします。

permalink

採用 fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

04:08:261 (166) - ボーカルに合わせるのならhttps://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18505485/67d9 のようなパターンにすべきです。現状だとボーカルの音とずれています。

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

While I understand you want to increase the density in the 3rd kiai, 04:08:861 - 04:09:547 - these two notes are just feel pretty out of place as the vocal really not supporting them. Try to move the notes to somewhere else? For example 04:10:576 - 04:11:433 -

permalink
Reopened by BlackBN

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

04:15:461 - を 04:15:633 - に移動するのはどうでしょう? 前者では特に目立つ音がないのに対し後者ではドラムの音が鳴っています

permalink

確かにそっちの方がしっくりきました。ありがとうございます

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

04:15:976 - A bit too overwhelming. Consider removing 04:16:233 - ?

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

04:20:004 - add d 04:09:033 - ここで密度上昇のために加えているなら、04:20:004 - ここも加えるべき。

permalink

加えたところ音取りが平らな印象を覚えたので、密度上昇の統一という点は採用し、音取りはこちらで修正しました。 fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

04:20:004 - Would remove it when this is the only 7plet in this kiai if apply #3636889/9764248

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

04:27:976 - Snap back the note, it's inconsistent with the barline SV rn

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

04:49:919 - Having x1 here just not really make sense, song intensity already dropped a lot. Given you are using x0.75 for calm sections. I would suggest using x0.75 here as well.

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

05:00:890 - This volume change here is quite abrupt cuz song doesn't change much here, would suggest removing this greenline
05:09:118 - same ^

Also please move the 35% at 05:10:318 - to 05:10:490 - instead

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

05:09:119 - change to d スピナーが二つ続くのは違和感があるので、最後だけスピナーの方が無難ではないでしょうか?

permalink

他の同曲のランクドとの差別化としてkeepします。

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

絶対音符置いた方が良いです

permalink
Reopened by Roxy-

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

05:09:633 - Why there would be a big blank here, it just looks really inconsistent when you mapped a lot of stuff in this whole section. I would suggest adding notes on 05:09:461 - 05:09:633 - 05:09:976 - 05:10:147 -

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

05:10:318 - two greenlines here?

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

シンバルの音的にも05:10:319 (1) - のスピナーの終点を05:11:861 (1) - にしたほうがよさそうです。

permalink

気づいてなかった...fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

05:10:319 - Could be a note instead and move the spinner start from 05:10:490 - so the piano sound still can be presented with a note.

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

05:10:319 - Please move this greenline 1/4 forward so the kat is still on 70% instead of 35%

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky

forward means at 05:10:404 - ....

permalink
Reopened by BlackBN

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by In Dark Sky
/