forum

Hirano Aya - God Knows...

posted
Total Posts
29
Topic Starter
Dotsu
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 2011年1月12日 at 12:44:42

Artist: Hirano Aya
Title: God Knows...
Source: Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu
BPM: 150
Filesize: 7004kb
Play Time: 04:05
Difficulties Available:
  1. Easy (2.22 stars, 224 notes)
  2. Hard (4.96 stars, 615 notes)
  3. Normal (4.06 stars, 349 notes)
Download: Hirano Aya - God Knows...
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
12th map~
... ... ... ...

Thanks Verdisphena for the BG~

11-2: Mp3 changed,please redownload !
NatsumeRin
omg
Chris Chen
God knows有好多rank的版本了
Topic Starter
Dotsu

Chris Chen wrote:

God knows有好多rank的版本了
反正又没有数量限制~
:D
Musty
omg God Knows o3°

SKIN : Change the ForcedSkin at "haruhism" That coolest ;=)
BG : I think you can change it u.u
Request By me xD : Can I Create a Diff + a SB? :3

CountDown : Remove IT!


STARRED LIKED~
Verdisphena
Mai mod:

General:
The background is ugly. Change it
Hard:

00:30:844 (6) - Add a clap
00:33:844 (4) - Add a clap in the finish of the slider
00:35:444 (5) - ^
00:37:244 (6) - Add a clap
00:41:844 (5) - Add a clap in the finish of the slider
00:43:444 (4) - ^
00:45:044 (5) - ^
00:46:244 (7) - ^
00:48:444 (6) - Add a clap
00:49:844 (4) - Add a clap in the finish of the slider
00:51:444 (7) - ^
00:53:244 (8) - Add a clap
02:01:844 (5) - Add a clap in the finish of the slider
02:03:444 (3) - ^
02:05:244 (4) - Add a clap
02:06:644 (4) - Add a clap in the finish of the slider
02:08:444 (5) - Add a clap
02:09:844 (4) - Add a clap in the finish of the slider
02:11:444 (4) - ^

Normal :

HP -1 AP -1 OD -1

02:59:844 (5) - New combo?
03:01:444 (1) - Remove new combo?
03:03:444 (5) - New combo?
03:04:644 (1) - Remove new combo?
03:47:644 (1) - Remove new combo


Easy :

Fine ~
Charles445
Uhoh, a well done map.

Normal
SPOILER
00:15:244 I really dislike long breaks that are at the beginning of a song. Consider mapping some of this.
01:04:644 Remove New Combo
01:10:844 ^^
01:33:444 ^^
01:52:644 ^^
02:07:444 (1,2) The way these are on the timeline is a bit confusing
02:56:444 New Combo?
03:21:844 This looks silly http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/32094
03:44:664 Remove New Combo
03:46:244 New Combo
03:47:644 Remove New Combo
That's about it. Star.
Astom
Hi~

[General]

peppy wrote:

The bitrate of a beatmap's audio file should be no lower than 128kbps and no higher than 256kbps.
-So... can u fix it =)?

[Suggestions]
Uhmmm well nothing bad find but... you can already find anothers ver. of this song and I think Hard is fine, but the other two are lowest in quality compared with the other ver., I highly suggest to try to at least make your two diff. a little more fun and original.
In adition add full skin and video or at least sb with some strobes or pulsations.

This song deserve more so I hope for a better map :>
My little star in support for you ^^~
gyt
Hello!

[Easy], [Normal]
Nothing wrong but bored -_-
Easy use only 1/1 snap divisor, Normal - 1/2. It's sleepy and not fun for me. + Sliders are slow (and spacing is short) for such dynamic song, imho.

[Hard]
00:06:844 (1) - add whistle at the end
00:19:644 (1) - lonely whistle at the start sounds wrong for me.
I suggest to end this slider at 00:19:844, add whistle to the end and add circle at 00:20:044
00:42:244 (1) - strange slider (doesn't follow music, but OK, I think)
01:52:444 (1) - lonely whistle at the start sounds wrong for me.
I suggest to end this slider at 01:52:644, add whistle to the end and add circle at 01:52:844
02:02:244 (1) - - strange sli...oh, ok
02:24:644 (1) - delete whistle at the start?
02:32:644 (1) - add whistle at the end?

I really like hard! Star.
Verdisphena

impossiblexu wrote:

Thanks Verdisphena for the BG~
:D
James2250
-Default x , . and % don't do anything (yes they are in template but for nothing), rename them to score - if you want them for the map
(Although then you would have to put score 0-9 in too to make them match up)
-Kind of large mp3, 192kbps would be nicer but up to you
-All the green lines but none on Easy?

Easy:
Not a big fan of the overlaps like 01:03:064 (1,2), 02:03:864 (1,2), 03:37:464 (2,3) etc but they can all pass
No other problems

Normal:
All looks good

Hard:
Nice
Map might be slightly easy for the score but should be ok

Good job~
Doomsday
Yo

  1. Timing sounds pretty close. Maybe it's a tiny bit early though (as in, like 2ms early), but it's close
  2. No need to put "Haruhi" in the tags, since it's already in the source (And now the tags would be empty. I can't think of anything to go in there though since I don't know Haruhi very well.)
[EASY] (Why does the other diffs have tons of green sections while this doesn't have many? Looks like someone got lazy. ;))

This one is pretty nice. Tried some interesting patterns which is always good to see in an easy. The only things that bugged me were how the mapping at the guitar solos felt a bit random, and how you always had constant beats going in most of the map. Didn't make it feel much like an easy. Having gaps inbetween notes is good in an easy diff :P

It's more fun than most easies I see though. Nice

[NORMAL]

Again, nice work. It's a pretty hard Normal though. (Then again, my vision of a Normal diff is easier than most peoples. heh)

03:22:264 (2) - It's a small griple, but this slider would look better if it was curved rather than linear. A random linear slider in a bunch of curved ones looks a bit odd.
03:24:464 (2) - Move this 1/2 forward? Goes with the lyrics better that way imo.

[HARD]

I don't like this quite as much as the other difficulties (foregoes following the music for random stacks and jumps to make it harder, which I don't like), but it's not too bad, and it still has some nice parts in there.

00:26:264 (1,2,3,4,1) - Sure, it isn't a very big jumpy bit here, but it's still odd. I think just using the standard spacing would work fine here.
00:39:664 (2,3,4,5,1) - ^
01:17:864 (1,2,3) - ^
02:00:664 to 02:12:664 - I would've made this part somewhat easier (Or maybe even a bit slower) since the song gets slower, but that's just me. :)
03:06:264 (1,2,3,4,5) - The bigger spacing thing again.

Hmm. This is a pretty nice map. Sure, Hard may have been a little weaker to me than the other diffs due to some overmapping, but it was still alright nonetheless. Apart from a few opinionated things, Nothing much bothered me. Good stuff.

Starred
kanpakyin
Mod....
-------------------------------------
BluE=Just syggestion
ReD=i think you should fix this

[Easy]
01:11:464(2)down 1 grid?
02;53:064(2)left 1 grid?
03:53:864(1)add whistle?
04:01:064(2)^

[Normal]
01:00:464(1)use clap to instead whistle?
01:06:064(1)use soft finish and remove clap?
01:34:668(4)change to whistle?

[Hard]
00;18:868(3)down 1 grid?
01:05:064(1)use finish to instead clap?
01:34:264(5.6.7.8)not suggest jump here
02:29:464(1)add a clap?

No big problem find0.0
Good luck
Selee
Some suggetions...

[General]

  • ↑Tag
[Easy]

  • Because the beats are loose in this diff, I don't feel good about the soft-clap...
    00:51:864 (2) - soft-whistle?

[Normal]

  • 01:21:464 (5) - start from 01:21:264? 由于前面的1/2, 在白线开始有点突然
    01:56:664 (4) - Change to 1/2 roll-back slider, also remove 01:57:264 (5) ?
    02:36:464 (T) - Move this green line to 02:37:064? Feel better to have sliderwhistle for this slider..

[Hard]

  • 01:34:864 (8) - hmm, feel little awkward to put finish at the end of slider since 01:34:464 (6) has finish too. Maybe you can change 01:34:864 (8) to note, and 01:34:264 (5) add finish?
    02:34:964 (T) - add a note here?
    04:01:764 (3) - Begin with soft whistle and remove clap at the end ?
    04:02:064 (4) - Clap?
    04:05:064 (6) - Remove the whistle body and end?
Nice map...感觉没什么好mod的都想放弃了...

Star =w=

do not kds this if this doesn't help...
mm61
还可以
Topic Starter
Dotsu
... ...
wmfchris
lol so many God knows

[hard]
3:48:664 (2,3,4,1) put (2,4) on the same level (y:90) and (3,1)on the same level (y:200)

...almost perfect spacing >w<

[normal]
1:22:464 (2) try x:115 y:240 (being slapped)
1:52:464 (3) try x:165 y:171
3:16:664 (1,2,3,4) form a parallelogram?


[easy]fineeee

The above are only suggestions and not even a problem for spacing 0w0

double star~
Leorda
NI HAO

[General]
1) You need a score custom number (example : score-1, score-percent, etc)
2) When I start the slider show on approachcircle.png, the glow was cut off, I suggest you to remove it

[Easy]
00:39:064 (3) - Like this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/33851
01:07:864 (2) - Move 1 grid right? So the pattern looks clean?
01:48:664 (2) - ^
01:49:464 (3,4,5,6,1) - Arrange the pattern like this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/33853
02:35:864 (1) - Remove whistle at slider trace (keep the whistle at beginning and end)?
03:51:864 (4) - Move 1 grid right? So the pattern looks clean?

[Normal]
03:20:664 (1) - Move 1 grid up?
03:22:264 (2) - Would be better if you use bezier, if this slider compared with 03:20:664 (1), it's very ugly

[Hard]
More than 1000 combo? lol

Nice song
STAR
Fapfrit
Sorry for the delay, I was very busy ._.

Modding:

General:
- I would have reduced the stack (4/9)

Timing:
Good!

Easy:
<Sound>
W - Whostle. E - Finish. R - Clap
Time (00:00:00) - exact time of bit
01:46:304 - add break time
------
01:57:464 (1) - E?
Pretty good. I don't see errors

Normal:
- This is hard for normal. rename in "Normal +"
- Timing Setup Panel - O_O give him the Nobel Prize. awesome
------
00:45:064 (2) - right by one on the grid
02:24:664 (3,4,5) - make a smooth triangle
02:25:064 (4,5,6) - too

Hard:
01:24:264 - add a circle?
<Sound>
03:06:764 - W?

A.W.E.S.O.M.E
Good Luck ~_~
Kurai
:)

[General]

Better if you change the source into "Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu"

[Easy]

03:29:096 (5) - Add finish at the beginning ?

[Normal]
03:28:696 (3) - Remove finish at the beginning and add finish at the end (remove clap)

[Hard]
03:28:696 (1) - Remove finish at the beginning and add finish at the end (remove clap)

Nice map :)
Star
MOM_old
This map is very funny~

star :)
Sandpig
hi :D

(>'(oo)')> my mod <('(oo)'<)


哨音听起来很糟糕……换一个别的音效吧


Hard

00:15:296 (2,3,4,5) - 这里的clap听起来不太好,感觉重音还是和前面统一比较好
00:16:696 (1,2,3) - ^
01:24:496 (2) - 这个slider高一点打起来舒服些

这个图我打起来真没什么问题,似乎是送分图那种。但是感觉从前奏打到高潮再到间奏再到高潮排列什么的几乎没有改变。或者说这是经典排列- -?
感觉你做这个图的时间基本都用在了调音效上……不是说不好我只是觉得打起来容易疲劳


Normal

01:00:296 - add a note?
02:22:096 - 这个音后面的停顿听起来不舒服,02:22:296这里应该加一个音,可以把02:22:496的去掉

和Hard同一个问题……这样的图我MOD不出来太多东西,抱歉。排列距离什么的完全没有问题就是打起来犯困。


Easy

有点长

其它的MOD不出来了……


star8-)
ayey
Argh sorry for my late reply , im so busy -u-

Easy
01:57:496 (1) - Extend it to 02:00:296

Normal
00:11:896 (1) - Extend it to 00:14:696
01:57:496 (1) - Extend it to 02:00:296

Hard
00:15:796 (x) - Add a note?
00:51:896 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Love this combo :P
03:45:396 (5) - It feels extra , idk

Love it , starred :)
Thanks for requesting ;)
Nakagawa-Kanon
hi

Can I make a Insane this map?
Nakagawa-Kanon
oh sorry

This is error
rust45
Nothing really wrong with it. Except that Hard has about 14,000,000 Max Score, which is against the ranking quidelines. I couldn't really find any problems with the mapset, but I didn't really find it that exciting either. But yeah, sorry I could actually mod it.
Sure
8-)
Miu Matsuoka
[Overall]
Beatmap is well-polished and good enough to be ranked, starred 8-)
but there are still some hitsounds needed to be added or modified.

[Easy]
0:15:096 - I recommend you to map here
2:47:096 (3) Bezier
3:04:696 (1) First hit Finish
3:06:296 (2) ^
3:35:896 (2) Remove clap
3:41:496 (3) Bezier
4:02:296 (1) Finish

[Normal]
0:08:696 (8) Finish
0:37:096 (5) Make it curve
1:02:096 - Add a note here
1:20:496 (4) Bezier
1:51:096 (1) ^
1:51:896 (2) ^
3:06:296 (3) Finish
3:22:296 (2) Bezier
3:38:096 (3) Make it curve

[Hard]
0:42:596 (1) Finish (First reverse & End)
2:11:896 (1) Finish
2:12:696 (2) Finish

<3 this map!
Topic Starter
Dotsu
SPOILER

cheukhin1985 wrote:

[Overall]
Beatmap is well-polished and good enough to be ranked, starred 8-)
but there are still some hitsounds needed to be added or modified.

[Easy]
0:15:096 - I recommend you to map here
2:47:096 (3) Bezier
3:04:696 (1) First hit Finish
3:06:296 (2) ^
3:35:896 (2) Remove clap
3:41:496 (3) Bezier
4:02:296 (1) Finish

[Normal]
0:08:696 (8) Finish
0:37:096 (5) Make it curve
1:02:096 - Add a note here
1:20:496 (4) Bezier
1:51:096 (1) ^
1:51:896 (2) ^
3:06:296 (3) Finish
3:22:296 (2) Bezier
3:38:096 (3) Make it curve

[Hard]
0:42:596 (1) Finish (First reverse & End)
2:11:896 (1) Finish
2:12:696 (2) Finish

<3 this map!
Fixed some~ Thanks a lot~
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply