TheNutritiousGuy wrote:

Modding~~ uhuhuhuhu o3o
[Weezy's Hard]
00:09:513 - I see you want the Start Point as Normal Finish. But IMO Soft Finish fits more. Keeping it as it is, normal hit finish makes a better transition for me.
00:33:239 (1) - Why Clap? Cuz it belongs there...
00:34:219 (4) - ^ ^same
01:11:866 (4) - I would remove the Clap, just for the reason you can hear the clap a bit at the silence. Just as Opinion. Nope :/
01:25:592 (3) - Remove Clap.Nope it works perfect here.
01:26:180 (4) - Try to stack it over (3) End Point. x:209, y:261 either way it makes no difference gameplay wise since it looks exactly the same.

Nymph wrote:

Hi Nymph here and request from my queue.

General:
Tags are not the same in each diff, plz change: -sekai- to -Sekai- in the hard diff to make them the same. Fixed.

I really think the sliderslide is pretty for this song, so I may suggest a silence one, at least for some part of the music, especially at the beginning.idk how to get that

And I think you need a custom clap too, using the normalhit as clap would fit pretty well imo, soft default clap is not that strong enough to fit the drum. i'm gonna use the normal hit as the clap.


Easy:
Hitsound
00:22:062 (1) - the clap on the tail sounds pretty weird Fixed.
00:25:200 (1) - and the finish with clap together sounds even more weird..... Fixed.
00:26:768 (3) - same ^ and why finish on the sliderbody...? this is a very werid error.... idk how that happened tbh. fixed.
.......I think I am not gonna to say more hitsounds stuff about this diff, No offense but I thought you have the ability to make the hitsounds much better, I don't think current is very good. None taken. if it's really that bad then i'll redo them.




Insane:
Beatmap design/suggestion
00:00:102 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - the spacing changed a little bit after 00:01:670 (1) - , I don't know why you decide to increase but it didn't look very good. alright i did something easier.
00:05:003 (4,5,6) - you see, it is very easy to find out 6 need a grid right, it would make the spacing much more beautiful.(same things like this I am not gonna mention again. I re-arranged the pattern.

Hitsound
00:08:729 (4,5) - this is actually too loud imo. i think it's fine as it goes in sync with the cymbals.
00:09:905 (1) - try some soft whistles after here, they fit pretty well for this song. this is intentional because i want to keep it silent. i agree it sounds nice but it's not picking up as in it's not upbeat.
00:20:690 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - the claps sound pretty weird, you see the music have very clear sounds at here but it is not the drum, so 24white ticks with claps may not a very good idea imo,maybe try something else. i did the normal hit like you said in the general.
01:26:376 (1) - spinner is very loud at here. what? it's at its lowest at 5%

this is pretty much for now I think, good luck~

LKs wrote:

From 【All requests posted here will be modded】 queue




Easy


01:02:062 (T) - Move this section to 01:02:454, and I don't see why you stop using sections to switch between soft and normal ooh uhh u could say that i stopped because i was lazy. fixed.



Insane


00:12:258 (7) - No normal hit switching here? Just like your Easy diff ooh you have good ears. fixed.
00:15:396 (7) - ^ ^
00:17:945 (4) - (End) ^ ^
00:20:690 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - It should be ooxxoox (o=with Normal hit) sounds nice. Fixed.
00:28:337 (1,2,3) - Suggestion ((3) with normal hit)
[attachment=0:8bda1]0041.jpg[/attachment:8bda1] Fixed.

00:33:239 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Similar to 00:20:690, xoxxoox ^
00:40:690 (5,1,2) - Spacing error between these three, stack (5,1) together and move (2) farther Fixed
00:46:768 (3,4,5,6) - new combo this stream, it's hard to read when you stack it under a slider's end ahh good point. since that's following the drums i might as well
00:48:337 (4) - Whistle no because the clap is already there.
00:49:709 (4) - Remove whistle from the end Fixed.
01:11:670 (5,6) - These two should be with normal hit too no then that would ruin the consistency.
01:16:376 (4) - Remove whistle from the end Fixed.
01:26:376 (1) - Start this 1/4 later, add a note at the current time Fixed.


That's all, Good Luck

Nymph wrote:

Winber1's Normal:
Hitsound
01:11:866 (3) - with the vocal and the music suddenly disappeared at the end of the slider, I think slience the slidertail maybe a very good idea to fit the music. it makes sense, but i can't hear a difference. The bass pedal in the drums overpowers my hitsounds no matter what i do. I also like the fading hi-hat-like sound, so i'm just gonna keep it
01:26:572 (1) - the spinner feel pretty loud here imo. >_> ok then. I made it fade out
Actually I am not a fun for those normal whistles using in a song like this, but I think it is a personal style thing, yay ok then

LKs wrote:

Winber1's Normal


Add sliderwhistle no matter you used single whistle on sliders
00:37:749 (1) - sounds like missing a sliderwhistle here, they're more slider like this. consider add sliderwhistle to all of them i guess
00:59:768 (T) - Move this to 00:59:709 sorry i want that note to be a normal hitfinish so i made the timing section come a little after the beginning of the slider.

Pretty Nice :3

Behonkiss wrote:

Easy:
- 00:25:200 (1): Consider ending the 1 slider half a beat earlier at 00:25:788 to fit the end of the lyric better. no then that would be hard for beginners to hit since it's clumped up to the next note.
- 00:40:886 (1): Again, ending this half a beat earlier fits the tune better. Fixed.
- 00:42:454 (3): And this. ^
- 00:53:435 (1): And this... ^
- 00:55:003 (3): ...and this.



Insane:
- Everything leading up to the choruses seems really light on hitsounds. I can hear the whistles fine so i'm not gonna change this.

1. Try to use some whistle in here. Like Winber's difficulty more better imo
2. 00:10:298 (1) - don't put the note in center of spinner. That will overlap with hitbursh.png after spinning finished. That's not easier read by newbie players
3. 00:30:690 (4) - use normal hitsound for this one? For consistency hitsounding
4. 00:56:572 (4) - I think add finish sound in slider's beginning is not bad too
5. 01:00:494 (1) - same as 00:10:298

1. Rename this osu file in folder, when I editing that displayed like %28TV Size%29 %28.....blah blah lol
2. I think fine in here

1. AR +1? Seems better fine imo
2. 00:05:396 (4) - add whistle in slider's beginning? I think the piano sound is supporting this
3. 00:45:592 (2) - add finish in slider's beginning? more give better effect with the song
4. 00:46:180 (3) - same as above

1. HP +1? seems more better I think
2. 00:00:886 (5) - add new combo?
3. 00:05:396 (6) - add whistle in slider's beginning? same reason with 00:05:396 (4) in Weezy's Hard
4. 00:16:376 (2) - same as above, but in here the reason is heard too silent in here
5. 00:17:945 (4) - here same as above
6. 00:20:690 (1) - same think as 00:10:298 (1) in Easy difficulty
7. 00:26:768 (3) - add whistle?
8. 00:33:239 (1) - same think as 00:10:298 (1) in Easy difficulty
9. 00:43:043 (4) - why not stack it with (3)'s tail, I think same with 00:40:690 (5,1)
10. 00:45:592 (1,2) - just my suggestion, try to add finish in slider's beginning? more giving better effect when play
11. I think you need learn how to make some slider art. you slider seems not tidy to me, but whatever :3/ *ah in easy too

Yasora-chan wrote:

hi mod by request via mod queue omg this song again XD

Easy

1. Try to use some whistle in here. Like Winber's difficulty more better imo no because it'd sound weird if i do that.
2. 00:10:298 (1) - don't put the note in center of spinner. That will overlap with hitbursh.png after spinning finished. That's not easier read by newbie players Alright Fixed.
3. 00:30:690 (4) - use normal hitsound for this one? For consistency hitsounding then that would ruin the consistency i'm following. every normal hitsound on the first downbeat.
4. 00:56:572 (4) - I think add finish sound in slider's beginning is not bad too i was thinking about this. alright.
5. 01:00:494 (1) - same as 00:10:298 Fixed.

Insane

1. HP +1? seems more better I think no i don't want to make other players fail that easily.
2. 00:00:886 (5) - add new combo? it'd look odd if i do that.
3. 00:05:396 (6) - add whistle in slider's beginning? same reason with 00:05:396 (4) in Weezy's Hard then that would ruin the consistency i'm following.
4. 00:16:376 (2) - same as above, but in here the reason is heard too silent in here no i want to keep this part silent because the singer's vocals are low. i don't want to use the hitsounds here besides the normal hitsounds which is following the drums because it'd be too loud
5. 00:17:945 (4) - here same as above ^
6. 00:20:690 (1) - same think as 00:10:298 (1) in Easy difficulty alright i moved the pattern up.
7. 00:26:768 (3) - add whistle? alright i see what you're following.
8. 00:33:239 (1) - same think as 00:10:298 (1) in Easy difficulty same as 00:20:690
9. 00:43:043 (4) - why not stack it with (3)'s tail, I think same with 00:40:690 (5,1) ooh good point. fixed.
10. 00:45:592 (1,2) - just my suggestion, try to add finish in slider's beginning? more giving better effect when play Fixed.
11. I think you need learn how to make some slider art. you slider seems not tidy to me, but whatever :3/ *ah in easy too

That's all
Good luck (:

Nymph wrote:

I really think the sliderslide is pretty for this song, so I may suggest a silence one, at least for some part of the music, especially at the beginning.

Nymph wrote:

Weezy's Hard:
Beatmap design/suggestion
00:08:141 (1) - this slider feels very far away from the center... not very comfortable to hit, so maybe using CTRL+R? (although this is just suggestion) Naw, centering it is like a normal/easy diff.
00:09:513 (1) - this timing section after here is not snapped well, I don't know if it is on purpose but just give a remind here, because I think soft finish is much better for the normal finish you were using here, so I guess maybe this is a timing section snapped error. Did this on purpose and not changing it! like it the way it is

Hitsound
00:33:239 (1,2,3,4) - I think it is not very good to use claps at here, just feel it is better to use claps after the kiai, gives me a better feeling for transition, just suggestion. Its a build up to kiai time, and claps work great here
01:11:866 (4) - same as I said in the normal diff, maybe silence the end of this slider? *points to wimber's response

LKs wrote:

Weezy's Hard

Consider HPD-1, it's same with Insane Sine you suggested AR to go up 1 which i do agree on, I find it that the HP will be too low if i did this
AR+1 too Done
00:05:396 (4) - whistle at start of slider Done
00:35:003 (2) - unify to use clap like 00:37:749 (1) Done
00:36:572 (2) - ^
00:47:552 (2) - ^
00:49:121 (2) - ^
00:57:749 - missing a note with clap here Done


SV is kinda fast for a Hard difficulty I totally disagree.

Yasora-chan wrote:

Weezy's Hard

1. AR +1? Seems better fine imo Already changed
2. 00:05:396 (4) - add whistle in slider's beginning? I think the piano sound is supporting this Aldready changed
3. 00:45:592 (2) - add finish in slider's beginning? more give better effect with the song Nope the finishes fill too forced, and right now it makes a build up for the next combo
4. 00:46:180 (3) - same as above Same as above

Leorda wrote:

Hello there

Easy
00:10:298 (1) - The head slider is overlapped by spinner-osu in gameplay. This makes hidden for beginners
00:34:611 (1) - Overlapped by hitbursts from spinner. Could be hidden for beginners

Nice work~

Leorda wrote:

Cheezy's Weezy's Hard
00:08:141 (1) - The repeating slider is covered by spinner-osu fixed
Nice work~

Leorda wrote:

Winber1's Normal
00:21:278 (3) - Remove 1 repeating slider? no sorry
00:33:435 (1) - The sliderbody is covered by hitbursts and spinner-osu. This could be hard to read for beginner who play this fixed
01:11:866 (3) - The head slider is overlapped by spinner-osu in gameplay. This makes hidden for beginners god these spinners are annoying. Tried to fix. I kinda failed to fix it. Whatever. I think it's fine anyways lolllll

TheVileOne wrote:

General

Inherited sections seem to be off by 1ms. Move them all back by 1.
Preview time is also off. It should be 34610 in all difficulties.

for now i'll keep it. if someone else suggests the same thing, then i'll change it.


Insane

00:24:023 (2) - Move the last move point sligghtly down to line it up with the next slider. adjusted properly
00:54:611 (1,2) - This just doesn't sound like a jump IMO. How about this instead?
http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/273984 Fixed.
00:58:533 (3,4) - Perhaps line up slightly better? nope this is intentional.



Well made right off the bat.

TheVileOne wrote:

Hard

Nothing serious, feel free to not consider it
00:25:788 (2) - This slider looks out of place. changed a tad bit
http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/273966 (This seems like a better option)
00:27:356 (5) - Perhaps not as important, but for consistency, consider changing this one as well.
00:35:984 (1) - I just don't like this... again changed a bit but not a big change, i like it

those wrote:

From .:Let those mod those maps:.


[Insane]
Insane diff should include at least some sv change. 01:00:101's a good place to slow down. no but i think 2454 is a place to slow down since it follows the piano.
00:20:690 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Make this pentagram regular. Start with one, then rotate the next one 144 degrees about playfield centre. Repeat. Then reposition. i don't see a problem with this. i think it looks fine as it is.
01:16:376 (4) - Add whistle at head nope the clap is already there. it'd sound weird if i add both the clap and whistle here.
01:25:592 (2) - Add whistle no. i made this a normal sampleset because it's following the drums. IMO the normal whistle wouldn't fit with this part.

Good luck :3

those wrote:

From .:Let those mod those maps:.

[Weezy's Hard]
00:50:298 (1,2) - Make these two have rotational symmetry; right now it looks awkward. Do it like you did with 01:16:964 (1,3) -
guess u modded this before the update....

Good luck :3

wcx19911123 wrote:

from my queue

[General]
uh.. I think you need find a better video, I think the original one is 16:9.. the one you using is 4:3 now, looks really weird sorry this is the best video i can find for this song.

[Easy]
why not use custom hitsounds, the slider is too noisy to me.. that's because Weezy's using them.
and I suggest turn all normal hitsound timing section's volume down a bit, the normal-hitnormal sound too loudAlright reduced to 50%
hitsound is really odd to me in this diff, I suggest to remap hitsound on this diff I made a few changes to the hitsounds.
rhyme and patterns are fine o.o

[Insane]
HD+1, it is now kinda low as an Insane diff imo I swear i thought i changed that. fixed.
00:00:886 - add newcombo, cuz the spacing is changed but rhyme is same as before, newcombo can make it easier to read ohh i see. alright then.
00:09:317 - add note here, I think here really need something to follow the music nope since Weezy doesn't have the a circle i'm not gonna do the same thing.
00:30:690 - add newcombo, or this pattern is really too hard to read no because the lyrics don't change. i'm following the combo through vocals and instrumental.
00:47:160 (1) - I suggest stack it on 00:47:062 (4) - , or it looks weird when playing.. alright, it felt kind of weird when i played this.
01:05:200 (6) - move this sldier to 01:05:003 - and add a note at 01:05:592 - , sound/play much better fixed but i added a 1/2 slider at 01:05:592 to follow the vocals accurately.
01:06:572 (2,3) - ^, yep, just do something like this

Easy and Insane need some more work imo
good luck o.o/

meiikyuu wrote:

hey sorry for the lateness ~ pls ignore if u don't like :d


Insane
00:09:513 (5) - this location is a bit odd for me? when it's touching the yellow slider and all, etc. xD maybe u can move it a bit. nothing serious though alright i'll move it a bit.
00:26:768 (3) - NC no then the combo would be too short from (1,2), and plus i'm following the instrumental, not the vocals.
00:47:160 (5) - remove NC nope following the drums.


i liked the hitsounds ~ good luck why ty <3