1. Collab (2.31 stars, 112 notes)
2. Easy (0.94 stars, 48 notes)
3. MBomb's Salad (1.68 stars, 79 notes)
4. Normal (1.66 stars, 87 notes)

People who mod my map!

1. Miya Timing help also the name of this mp3
2. [CSGA]Ar3sgice
3. arien666
4. Kawayi Rika
5. athiota33
6. kosiga
7. Byakugan249
8. Sure@ykcarrot Help Timing and Mod
9. ikari_kyon <3
10. cmn_891127 IRC MOD <3
11. Asgard IRC MOD <3
12. Frostmourne
13. l1106188
14. hillaryzx <3
15. LaceWingfield <3
16. Niva
17. BeatofIke
18. JoJo <3 Help Timing + Mod
19. Cilvery
20. Flower@iroseka
21. kusano
22. Ayu
23. kurohana
24. Tari@Taris
25. Kirino Kousaka <3
26. smallboat
27. Natsu
28. newtoniorock8
29. Lanturn
30. RandomEffect
31. -Neptune- CTB's Mod
32. [ Evil ]
33. BoberOfDarkness CTB's Mod
34. -Hakurei-
35. TicClick Timing Help
36. afk98 CTB's Mod
37. JBHyperion
38. DragonSlayer96 CTB's Mod

Thanks for your mod!!

1. 00:11:241 (2) - 1 grid up
2. 00:38:451 (2) - http://up.ppy.sh/files/screenshot166-3.jpg make this slider like this

1. 00:44:032 (7) - why whistle ? finish better ?
2. 00:46:823 (7) - ^

Miya wrote:

you're welcome . It was nice to help you.

1. I think that a difference of star rating is too big . maybe Collab diff is Hard diff ? so need Normal diff. ><;
2. Song Setup - Colors - color of combo color 1 and 2 is too near Please change the order of the colors. maybe ↓ is better.
   

   Combo1 : 255,128,255
   Combo2 : 45,88,228
   Combo3 : 128,64,0
   Combo4 : 0,128,255

1. 00:02:171 (1,2) - Why does only here different in DS ? Use change DS 0.8x
2. 00:11:939 (1) - remove NC and 00:12:637 (2) - add NC
3. 00:19:613 (4) - add NC and 00:21:009 (1) - remove NC
4. 00:22:404 (3) - add NC
5. 00:24:497 (5) - add NC and 00:26:590 (1) - remove NC
6. 00:36:358 (5) - add NC and 00:37:055 (1) - remove NC and 00:38:451 (2) - add NC
7. 00:38:451 (2) - more beautiful curve ↓try
   

   208,216,38451,2,0,B|106:216|63:139|100:51|188:15|264:57|264:159,1,400,0|4

8. 00:42:637 (3) - add NC
9. 00:44:032 (4) - slider start 00:44:730 and 00:44:032 - add note is better. ( because it is not good that there is KIAI time end&start in a slider )
10. 00:49:613 (2) - not overlap. map of the overlap is not good for beginners

1. 00:09:846 (1) - remove NC
2. 00:15:078 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Please align the DS. http://puu.sh/fkLY ↓code
   
   SPOILER

   440,192,15078,5,0
   368,288,15427,1,0
   296,192,15776,1,0
   224,288,16125,1,0
   152,192,16474,1,0
   224,96,16823,1,0

3. 00:18:567 (3) - Suggestion: Ctrl+R
4. 00:19:265 (4) - add NC
5. 00:29:381 (6) - add NC and 00:30:427 (1) - remove NC
6. 00:46:823 (7) - add NC ?

1. Timing off. BPM 85.850 / Offset 1 : 2172 (same as current), Offset 2 : 30826 (for fix metronome). And metronome should be 4/4
2. Kawayi Rika already pointed it out. You should remove audio from the video.
3. I suggest using muted soft-sliderslide.wav

ykcarrot wrote:

[General]

1. Timing off. BPM 85.850 / Offset 1 : 2172 (same as current), Offset 2 : 30826 (for fix metronome). And metronome should be 4/4 Fix ~
2. Kawayi Rika already pointed it out. You should remove audio from the video. eh?? why? I want to keep it. =="
3. I suggest using muted soft-sliderslide.wav what? I dunno about this . T.T

[Collab]
AR 8 in BPM 86? Come on, it's not funny. I recommend AR-1 highly. Fix ~
00:04:613 (2) - No reason to add circle here due to you silenced it. Just remove it. Hitting silenced circle = meh. Or You'd better make a slider from previous note. Fix ~
00:09:148 (4) - ^ yeah same. Fix ~
00:41:939 (1) - Too loud! Decrease volume by 30 points. Fix ~
00:44:032 (7) - I'm really suprised at this looooud normal hitfinish. Would you please change the sampleset and volume? gomen ~ Fix ~
00:46:823 (1) - ^ ^


[Normal]
You have unnecessary timing points.
00:23:451 - Delete fix ~
00:40:718 - ^ ^
00:41:241 - ^ ^

00:04:613 (5) - Start from next white tick fix~
00:44:032 (5) - Same opinion with Collab diff. It's normal whistle but whatever. I want to put whistle here ~ so no ~
00:46:823 (5) - ^ ^


[Easy]
00:42:637 (1,2) - Spacing. Also slider overlapping is ugly with big circle. You'd better find other position. Example http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/243563 Fix ~


I believe you can improve your map, specially formation of notes. okay~
Good luck anyway. ;3 Arigatou ^^

ikari_kyon wrote:

>3</ Ikarin ~ XD

[Easy]

- please, think about this seriously. Increase the distance snap, your objects are overlaping on a bad way >: I know is an [Easy] diff but be honest, overlaped objects are moar confusing for newbies. Distance snap x1,0 is good enough, since your slider velocity is 0.8, now let me explain why use x1,0. Fix ~
The distance snap is a multiplier of slider velocity. If you have 0.8 slider velocity, the current distance multiply by x0,8 then we have this overlaped objects.

00:02:171 (1) - whistle instead finish on start of slider is moar soft for ears >_< Fix~
00:03:567 (2) - this must be copy paste > ctrl+j, ctrl+h of 00:02:171 (1). err.. I never known that notes can copy.. @w@"
00:07:055 (3) - whistle on repeat Fix ~
and suddenly there is no whistles o.o ahaha.. Gomen >.<"
00:09:846 (1) - whistle on end of slider Fix ~
00:12:637 (2) - whistle on repeat of slider Fix ~
00:28:683 (3) - whistle on start of slider, the whistle on end of slider feels lonely >: Fix ~ >.<"
00:38:500 (2) - improve slider shape? o: ↓↓↓ Gomen.. I dunno which one is the code for that note .. ;_;

SPOILER

screen:

200,204,38500,2,0,B|96:192|72:92|116:20|216:12|272:48|256:156,1,400,0|4

00:43:732 (2) - overlaped by previous slider start, no finish on end of slider Fix? ><"
00:47:570 (3) - whistle >v< Fix~

[Normal]

- now the objects are not so overlaped because of highest slider velocity, comparated from [Easy] o.o"

00:07:753 (4) - bad overlap with (2,3) What??? I dunno overlap.. gomen.. ;_;
00:09:148 (1,2) - overlap >3< ^
00:26:241 (6) - start and end of slider are so close D: Fix ~
00:44:081 (5) - xD please remove the whistle Fix ~ =w=''
00:46:872 (5) - ↑ ^

[Collab]

00:02:869 (4) - why this object is here <_< it should be stacked with 00:02:520 (2,3) Fix ~
00:44:081 (7) - please no whistle .w. Fix ~ =w=''
00:46:872 (1) - ↑ at star of slider Fix ~ =w=''

cmn_891127 wrote:

so beautiful song~

IRC-mod

14:29 <cmn_891127> : hi~
14:29 *cmn_891127 is listening to (NicolArmarfi - Three Stars)[http://osu.ppy.sh/s/43530]
something about video,skip~
14:45 <cmn_891127> : normal is veryyyyyy good...
14:46 <cmn_891127> : collab
14:46 <cmn_891127> : 00:22:055 (2,3,4,5) -
14:46 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o''
14:46 <cmn_891127> : the hitsound is so small
14:46 <cmn_891127> : maybe it is unrankable
14:46 <Shana Aisaka> : should i change? ><?
14:47 <cmn_891127> : i am not sure, you need to ask some m/bat
14:47 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o''
14:48 <Shana Aisaka> : okay >.<"
14:49 <cmn_891127> : 00:44:430 (1) - the tail of the slider is too loud for me
14:50 <cmn_891127> : 00:51:232 (3) - I think remove it will be better
14:51 <Shana Aisaka> : okay~
14:51 <cmn_891127> : that's all~
14:51 <cmn_891127> : I really loooooooooooooove this song~~

GO!GO! Bubble it~

Asgard wrote:

okay
IRC mod

SPOILER

15:49 <Asgard> : do you have time?
15:50 <Asgard> : o.o?
15:50 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o! sure :3
15:51 <Asgard> : hm.. IRC mod ok?
15:51 <Shana Aisaka> : lol.. >w<" Okay ~ ^^
15:51 <Shana Aisaka> : ah.. In Collab right now I'm editing >.<"
15:52 <Asgard> : hm.. easy first >,<
15:52 <Shana Aisaka> : okay ~ ><"
15:52 <Asgard> : 00:11:939 (1) -
15:52 <Asgard> : remove NC
15:52 <Asgard> : and
15:52 <Asgard> : 00:14:730 (3) -
15:52 <Asgard> : here NC
15:52 <Asgard> : 00:16:125 (1) - remove NC
15:52 <Shana Aisaka> : Okay ~
15:53 <Asgard> : 00:17:520 (3) -
15:53 <Asgard> : NC
15:53 <Asgard> : 00:19:613 (1) - remove NC
15:54 <Asgard> : 00:21:009 (6) - NC
15:54 <Asgard> : 00:21:706 (1) - removeNC
15:55 <Asgard> : 00:30:078 (4) - move 148,264
15:55 <Asgard> : 00:30:826 (1) - 204,328
15:55 <Asgard> : 00:32:221 (2) - 344,260
15:56 <Asgard> : hm.. wait
15:56 <Shana Aisaka> : Okay~
15:57 <Asgard> : 00:33:617 (3) -
15:57 <Asgard> : remove
15:57 <Asgard> : and
15:57 <Asgard> : 00:32:221 (2) - 1 repeat
15:57 <Asgard> : 00:34:314 (3) - move 388,192
15:57 <Asgard> : 00:35:012 (4) -
15:57 <Asgard> : first slider point : 412,116
15:57 <Asgard> : 2th : 392,68
15:58 <Asgard> : 3th : 412,116
15:58 <Asgard> : i think this is more better
15:59 <Shana Aisaka> : @w@''
15:59 <Asgard> : 00:38:500 (2) - ugly slider
15:59 <Asgard> : wait i fixing
15:59 <Shana Aisaka> : lol >.<"
16:05 <Asgard> : ok
16:06 <Asgard> : 1th 156,136
16:06 <Asgard> : 135,99
16:06 <Asgard> : no
16:06 <Asgard> : wait.
16:06 <Shana Aisaka> : lol.. ><"
16:07 <Asgard> : 212,256
16:07 <Asgard> : 176,236
16:07 <Asgard> : 144,176
16:07 <Asgard> : 176,116
16:07 <Asgard> : 256,80
16:07 <Asgard> : 336,116
16:07 <Asgard> : 368,176
16:08 <Asgard> : 336,236
16:08 <Shana Aisaka> : wow.. so many? @@?
16:08 <Asgard> : 330,256
16:08 <Asgard> : and reverse
16:08 <Asgard> : rotate -90
16:08 <Shana Aisaka> : I think i can't understand ;_;
16:09 <Shana Aisaka> : could you show it to me? >w<?
16:09 <Asgard> : wait
16:09 <Asgard> : i'll give code
16:10 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o''
16:10 <Asgard> : 168,228,38500,2,0,B|60:212|8:124|68:44|172:36|256:60|224:196|224:196,1,400,0|4
16:10 <Asgard> : http://puu.sh/heD7
16:11 <Shana Aisaka> : hmm... how did you know that is the code? o.o?
16:11 <Asgard> : open osu file
16:11 <Asgard> : and.. find offset
16:11 <Asgard> : 38500
16:13 <Asgard> : hm..
16:13 <Asgard> : fix this?
16:13 <Shana Aisaka> : wait..
16:13 <Asgard> : hm..
16:13 <Asgard> : follow me
16:13 <Asgard> : just make slider
16:13 <Asgard> : anywhere
16:14 <Asgard> : and move fist slider point : 156,136
16:14 <Asgard> : and ctrl+click in slider line
16:14 <Shana Aisaka> : I think i found the code.. (lol)
16:14 <Asgard> : hm.
16:14 <Asgard> : okay
16:15 <Shana Aisaka> : i have replace it but still look the same @w@"
16:15 <Asgard> : hm..
16:16 <Asgard> : exit edit
16:16 <Asgard> : but still open osu file
16:16 <Asgard> : and save
16:16 <Asgard> : so maybe it will be change
16:18 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o''
16:19 <Asgard> : fixed?
16:19 <Shana Aisaka> : wait.
16:20 <Shana Aisaka> : hmm...
16:20 <Asgard> : slider length missed.
16:20 <Asgard> : wait
16:21 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o
16:22 <Asgard> : ok
16:22 <Asgard> : i'll give X and Y
16:22 <Asgard> : so just follow
16:22 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o''
16:22 <Shana Aisaka> : wakatta ><"
16:23 <Asgard> : first slider point : 156,136
16:23 <Asgard> : 2th 136,96
16:23 <Asgard> : 3th 68,68
16:23 <Asgard> : 4th 0,96
16:23 <Asgard> : 5th -32,180
16:23 <Asgard> : 6th 0,264
16:23 <Asgard> : 7th 68,292
16:23 <Asgard> : 8th 136,264
16:23 <Asgard> : 9th 156,224
16:25 <Asgard> : not yet?
16:26 <Shana Aisaka> : hmm.. should i remake it? >.<?
16:26 <Asgard> : hm..
16:26 <Asgard> : ok
16:26 <Asgard> : so.. skip easy?
16:29 <Asgard> : ??
16:29 <Shana Aisaka> : okay i just upload it ~
16:29 <Shana Aisaka> : the easy's slider >.<"
16:30 <Asgard> : hmm....
16:30 <Shana Aisaka> : still ugly? XD
16:31 <Shana Aisaka> : >.<"
16:31 <Asgard> : actually something is starnge
16:31 <Shana Aisaka> : strange* XD
16:31 <Asgard> : oh missed
16:31 <Asgard> : hm.. okay
16:31 <Shana Aisaka> : >w<''
16:31 <Asgard> : so next normal
16:32 <Shana Aisaka> : so it's good? XD
16:32 <Shana Aisaka> : okay then ~
16:32 <Asgard> : 00:06:009 (1) -
16:32 <Asgard> : so far
16:32 <Shana Aisaka> : owh.. yeah ><"
16:33 <Asgard> : don't forgot fix distance next note
16:33 <Asgard> : 00:07:055 (2,3,4) - like this
16:33 <Shana Aisaka> : okay
16:34 <Shana Aisaka> : done :3
16:34 <Asgard> : 00:16:474 (7) -
16:34 <Asgard> : NC?
16:35 <Shana Aisaka> : okay ~
16:35 <Asgard> : 00:24:497 (1,2,3,4,5) - anti jump hard for beginner
16:35 <Shana Aisaka> : no good?
16:35 <Asgard> : yes
16:36 <Shana Aisaka> : I have already use distance snap >.<" still dame kana? ><"
16:37 <Asgard> : no that's good
16:37 <Asgard> : but you don't used copy and paste
16:37 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o??
16:37 <Asgard> : i always use symmetry because i can't make shape very well
16:37 <Shana Aisaka> : do i really need it? ><"
16:37 <Asgard> : if you can't make shape and pettern
16:37 <Asgard> : just use symmetry
16:38 <Asgard> : yes
16:38 <Asgard> : hmm wait
16:38 <Shana Aisaka> : o.O
16:38 *Asgard is listening to (Tainaka Sachi - Unmeibito)[http://osu.ppy.sh/s/43011]
16:38 <Asgard> : look this map
16:38 <Asgard> : there are very very many symmetry
16:38 <Shana Aisaka> : lol >.<"
16:40 <Asgard> : if you can use symmetry very well, you will be good mapper
16:40 <Asgard> : okay so.. keep going
16:41 <Shana Aisaka> : hmmm @@"
16:41 <Asgard> : hm..
16:41 <Shana Aisaka> : i will try >.<"
16:42 <Asgard> : i think you don't need KIAI time
16:42 <Shana Aisaka> : for my map? ;_;
16:42 <Asgard> : yes..
16:42 <Shana Aisaka> : i want it >.<"
16:42 <Shana Aisaka> : cause it looks great XD
16:43 <Asgard> : hm..
16:43 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o?
16:43 <Asgard> : i think rhythm is very good
16:44 <Shana Aisaka> : thanks >w<"
16:44 <Asgard> : but note pattern is some strange :<
16:45 <Shana Aisaka> : O.o
16:45 <Asgard> : 00:39:372 - i think break time is not good
16:46 <Shana Aisaka> : okay then ;_;
16:46 <Asgard> : http://puu.sh/heKG
16:47 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o''
16:48 <Asgard> : ok collob
16:48 <Shana Aisaka> : okay ~
16:48 <Asgard> : try use symmetry when you make next beatmap
16:49 <Asgard> : 00:02:695 (3) - remove and
16:49 <Asgard> : add here 00:03:406
16:49 <Asgard> : 00:03:406 -
16:49 <Asgard> : 00:09:846 (1) -
16:49 <Asgard> : overlap
16:50 <Shana Aisaka> : what is overlap ;_;
16:50 <Asgard> : side
16:51 <Shana Aisaka> : side? o.o?
16:51 <Asgard> : try this
16:51 <Asgard> : http://puu.sh/heLG
16:51 <Asgard> : 00:09:846 (1) - 168 216
16:51 <Asgard> : and 1 repeat
16:53 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o
16:53 <Asgard> : 00:10:892 (1) - 148 344
16:53 <Asgard> : 00:11:241 (2) - 256 27
16:53 <Asgard> : 276*
16:53 <Asgard> : 00:11:590 (3) - 364 344
16:53 <Asgard> : 00:11:939 (4) - 344 216
16:53 <Asgard> : 00:12:288 (1) - 256 124
16:53 <Asgard> : 00:12:637 (2) - 168 216
16:53 <Asgard> : 00:12:985 (3) - 344 216
16:53 <Asgard> : 00:13:334 (4) - 256 276
16:53 <Asgard> : i think this is more better
16:56 <Asgard> : 00:26:067 (5) - remove and
16:56 <Asgard> : 00:26:765 - add here
16:57 <Asgard> : 00:42:337 (2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - not good pattern
16:59 <Shana Aisaka> : everything is change accept ^
16:59 <Shana Aisaka> : so how should i do? o.o?
17:00 <Asgard> : hmm..
17:00 <Asgard> : well.. i can say 1 thing. just use symmetry
17:00 <Asgard> : um
17:01 <Shana Aisaka> : O.o''
17:02 <Shana Aisaka> : wait.
17:02 <Shana Aisaka> : I update first and try to look that pattern >.<"
17:03 <Shana Aisaka> : okay ~
17:03 <Shana Aisaka> : Update >w<"
17:05 <Asgard> : hmm..
17:05 <Shana Aisaka> : yes? ><?
17:05 <Shana Aisaka> : still dame ne? >.<"
17:06 <Asgard> : 00:42:337 (2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - note good too
17:06 <Asgard> : like this
17:06 <Asgard> : http://puu.sh/heOE
17:07 <Asgard> : make people can move easier
17:07 <Shana Aisaka> : lol
17:08 <Shana Aisaka> : okay ~
17:10 <Asgard> : maybe that's all
17:11 <Asgard> : oh and
17:11 <Asgard> : delete .osb file
17:11 <Asgard> : and full submit
17:11 <Shana Aisaka> : o.o''
17:11 <Shana Aisaka> : okay ~
17:11 <Asgard> : song setup - storyboarding - retterbox during breaks
17:11 <Asgard> : uncheck it

452,96,37453,1,0
400,60,37802,5,2

hillaryzx wrote:

Hi~ my mod for this map~(but short... T.T)
Nyan.... :3 Nyaan !! >w<"

General

- disabke letterbox in break to all diff.... Opps ~ I forgot about that . >.<" Fix ~

Easy

AR -1 okay ~

Normal

00:23:799 - add a circle here? Nice idea~
00:40:244 - add a note here.. okay ~ >w<"

Collab

Seems good... Arigatou


Now, I'll give star and take my leave....

Silver:
SliderBorder : 211,211,211

Gold:
SliderBorder : 254,239,114

1. 00:02:171 (1,2,1,2,3) - I don't quite get your whistle pattern here, although they sounds fine. The piano hits high note every 2/1, so in my opinion, it's better to keep the whistling consistent at 2/1 here
2. 00:07:055 (3) - Definitely moved way too up imo. Move it ~5 grids down and right, and it will flow better with the previous (2) (:
3. 00:12:637 (4,1,2,3) - (optional) Although it's not a thing you must do, but it's better to arrange them in an arc like below, to build up more flow and avoid (2) touching the next (4):
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 00:21:009 (1) - (optional) This one also, consider moving this few grids up to prevent touching 00:20:311 (3)
5. 00:24:497 (1,3) - Woah, ugly overlap imo. Just be creative with your slider shapes though - this won't be hard to fix xD
   
   SPOILER

   
   Also whistle on (1)'s end, if you want to (:
6. 00:32:221 (2) - (optional) You could easily make a blanket pattern as you did on 00:33:616 (3,4) with (2)'s end being stacked to (6) though, it will play more beautiful imo :3
7. 00:46:174 (4) - Whistle here on slider's start. I highly recommend this, the piano here needs a hitsound companion :3
8. 00:48:267 (1,2) - Is it intentional you curve the slider this way? Because this is a 2/1 slider, the red waypoint is much better if placed on the second slider tick, for example:
   
   SPOILER

   
9. 00:51:756 (3) - (optional) Stack below (2) better for the ending imo

1. 00:04:962 (5,1) - It would fit the piano more if (5) is extended by 1/2 while (1) is shortened by 1/2
2. 00:09:148 (1) - Hmm, is this note really required? It doesn't follow anything in the music as I can hear. Also, this is just a Normal diff, don't let here be too hectic >_<
3. 00:14:381 (3) - Whistle on slider's end to keep your whistle pattern here?
4. 00:15:427 (4,5,6,1) - Sudden 90° linear slider here breaks your flow imo. The simplest thing you can do here, without altering your slider too much but still flowy, perhaps:
   
   SPOILER

   
5. 00:24:497 (1,2,3,4,5) - Why no whistle at all >_< At least one whistle should be here imo, either it's in (3) or (5) - I suggest (3) more though, because it's the downbeat
6. 00:35:360 (5,1) - Sudden spacing change here. Is it intentional?
7. 00:38:500 (3) - (optional) Curve it to the opposite direction (downward) to avoid touching (5)? (slider wave also plays beautiful here)
8. 00:44:081 (5) - Normal hitfinish feels too explosive for the song imo. What's more, if you want to keep the normal hitfinish, they should've been placed in the downbeat instead.
9. 00:46:872 (5) - Same as above
10. 00:49:663 (4) - Rigid linear slider like this is very unfitting for the ending. Why not a bezier curve instead? At the picture below, you can see that (5)'s approachcircle could be used to guide you here:
    
    SPOILER

    

1. 00:03:218 (4,5,6) - I highly recommend to add whistle on either 4 or 6, else it will be too empty here
2. 00:05:485 (2,4) - (optional) You can move (2) downward and (4) upward so this part won't be too linear and to increase the flow
3. 00:09:497 (4) - Already tested, there's a note 1/8 after this from the music. Not something you have to add, though :3
4. 00:09:846 (1) - Do you really need the new combo here? Also, (optional) make this encircle (4)?
5. 00:13:683 (5) - To avoid such overlapping with (2), I suggest to arrange (5) like below:
   
   SPOILER

   
6. 00:23:799 (2) - (optional) Encircle (5)? Plays better than just a straight slider imo
7. 00:24:497 (3,4) - Unexpected spacing change (well, I bet it's unintentional though)
8. 00:32:221 (5,6,7) - I think it's better if you keep with symmetry here to make this part looks less random, for example:
   
   SPOILER

   
9. 00:42:337 (2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5) - 1/4 stream spam in a relaxing piano song orz... Do you really need this much >_< - Triples are okay to use in this song imo, but this one... orz
10. 00:46:872 (1) - Same as [Normal], normal hitfinish is too explosive imo. (also those downbeat stuff)
11. 00:50:709 (3,4) - (optional) I think it would be nice if there's a little jump on the ending, for example:
    
    SPOILER

    

Niva wrote:

SPOILER

Hi, Shana Aisaka~
I'm here for mod4mod again, if you don't mind >_<

[General]

-> I wonder, the song is only 00:57, and downloading with the video only costs ~3MB, so why not use a 192kbps audio instead (if any)? It won't greatly affect file size, but greatly affect sound quality :3
-> As this song is actually a sad-paced one, you might want to add a silver (or gold) slider border. Open the .osu file manually, and add these codes below "Combo4 : 0,128,255":

Silver:
SliderBorder : 211,211,211

Gold:
SliderBorder : 254,239,114

This is fully optional, though.
-> Another thing worth mentioning is a new timing section should be placed on 00:14:730 with 85.90 BPM. Yep, the piano gets slower there, and keep using 86.00 there will result in an incorrect timing.
-> Oh, and Nicol Armarfi to the tags, just in case.

[Easy]

1. 00:02:171 (1,2,1,2,3) - I don't quite get your whistle pattern here, although they sounds fine. The piano hits high note every 2/1, so in my opinion, it's better to keep the whistling consistent at 2/1 here
2. 00:07:055 (3) - Definitely moved way too up imo. Move it ~5 grids down and right, and it will flow better with the previous (2) (:
3. 00:12:637 (4,1,2,3) - (optional) Although it's not a thing you must do, but it's better to arrange them in an arc like below, to build up more flow and avoid (2) touching the next (4):
   
4. 00:21:009 (1) - (optional) This one also, consider moving this few grids up to prevent touching 00:20:311 (3)
5. 00:24:497 (1,3) - Woah, ugly overlap imo. Just be creative with your slider shapes though - this won't be hard to fix xD
   
   Also whistle on (1)'s end, if you want to (:
6. 00:32:221 (2) - (optional) You could easily make a blanket pattern as you did on 00:33:616 (3,4) with (2)'s end being stacked to (6) though, it will play more beautiful imo :3
7. 00:46:174 (4) - Whistle here on slider's start. I highly recommend this, the piano here needs a hitsound companion :3
8. 00:48:267 (1,2) - Is it intentional you curve the slider this way? Because this is a 2/1 slider, the red waypoint is much better if placed on the second slider tick, for example:
   
9. 00:51:756 (3) - (optional) Stack below (2) better for the ending imo

[Normal]

1. 00:04:962 (5,1) - It would fit the piano more if (5) is extended by 1/2 while (1) is shortened by 1/2
2. 00:09:148 (1) - Hmm, is this note really required? It doesn't follow anything in the music as I can hear. Also, this is just a Normal diff, don't let here be too hectic >_<
3. 00:14:381 (3) - Whistle on slider's end to keep your whistle pattern here?
4. 00:15:427 (4,5,6,1) - Sudden 90° linear slider here breaks your flow imo. The simplest thing you can do here, without altering your slider too much but still flowy, perhaps:
   
5. 00:24:497 (1,2,3,4,5) - Why no whistle at all >_< At least one whistle should be here imo, either it's in (3) or (5) - I suggest (3) more though, because it's the downbeat
6. 00:35:360 (5,1) - Sudden spacing change here. Is it intentional?
7. 00:38:500 (3) - (optional) Curve it to the opposite direction (downward) to avoid touching (5)? (slider wave also plays beautiful here)
8. 00:44:081 (5) - Normal hitfinish feels too explosive for the song imo. What's more, if you want to keep the normal hitfinish, they should've been placed in the downbeat instead.
9. 00:46:872 (5) - Same as above
10. 00:49:663 (4) - Rigid linear slider like this is very unfitting for the ending. Why not a bezier curve instead? At the picture below, you can see that (5)'s approachcircle could be used to guide you here:
    

[Collab]

1. 00:03:218 (4,5,6) - I highly recommend to add whistle on either 4 or 6, else it will be too empty here
2. 00:05:485 (2,4) - (optional) You can move (2) downward and (4) upward so this part won't be too linear and to increase the flow
3. 00:09:497 (4) - Already tested, there's a note 1/8 after this from the music. Not something you have to add, though :3
4. 00:09:846 (1) - Do you really need the new combo here? Also, (optional) make this encircle (4)?
5. 00:13:683 (5) - To avoid such overlapping with (2), I suggest to arrange (5) like below:
   
6. 00:23:799 (2) - (optional) Encircle (5)? Plays better than just a straight slider imo
7. 00:24:497 (3,4) - Unexpected spacing change (well, I bet it's unintentional though)
8. 00:32:221 (5,6,7) - I think it's better if you keep with symmetry here to make this part looks less random, for example:
   
9. 00:42:337 (2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5) - 1/4 stream spam in a relaxing piano song orz... Do you really need this much >_< - Triples are okay to use in this song imo, but this one... orz
10. 00:46:872 (1) - Same as [Normal], normal hitfinish is too explosive imo. (also those downbeat stuff)
11. 00:50:709 (3,4) - (optional) I think it would be nice if there's a little jump on the ending, for example:
    

Oh, and one more stuff, you don't need awkward kiai position like that (although it's usable), short kiais plays better imo here.

Much neater and better than your Aoi Hana map~
My map's link is at your queue. Star ^^

KuronumaSawako wrote:

Niva mod so pro

KuronumaSawako wrote:

Niva mod so pro

This^^ I would love a mod from him in my map.

Anyway on topic, here's your request from my modding queue.

[General]
-Remove OSB file. There's no storyboard in your map.
-Your video file has audio in it. Remove the audio off of the video.

[Easy]
-00:30:084 (6) - Make this hit circle blanklet with slider 5.

[Normal]
-Good

[Collab]
-Good

Beautiful map indeed. Just work on your blanklets.

BeatofIke wrote:

Thanks for the kudosu! STAR~

JoJo wrote:

Hi meimeichan!
Sorry for delay >_<

Prepare to mod but..... Your timing is off completely.........
Try this:

1.BPM 85.800 OFFSET 2172

Yes only 1 timing point. I will ask kanpakyin to recheck the timing.
After fixing feel free to call me back at anytime and I'll do full mod!

Star for now! >A</

1. Purple - Unrankable stuff.
2. Blue - Extremely suggest you to follow this.
3. Black - Feel free to ignore this.

1. Reset your timing section according to this image.↓
   Select 4/4 common and add another timing section on 00:30:843 (4/4) to fix the downbeat for all diffs. Offset has no change so do not need resnapping.
2. Volume setting is too low. Sometimes players determine whether they have caught the notes on beat by hitsound so.
3. By the way add a mute sliderslide hitsound since this song is quiet but ruined by noisy sliderslide.
4. I don't know why you have set fountain effect on 00:44:829, not really fit the music.
5. Add storyboard of mapper's ID for different parts. Just suggestion.

1. 00:06:813 (0) - Delete useless timing section.
2. 00:13:360 (4) - New combo I guess.
3. 00:29:444 (1,2) - Switch new combo.
4. 00:38:185 (1,4) - ^ For map reading and downbeat. Then remove new combo on 00:40:283 (1).

1. 0.8x spacing looks not good for gameplay. All notes are end to end. (Just comment.)
2. 00:04:969 (5,1) - Switch new combo.
3. 00:07:766 (4,1) - I prefer switching new combo here. Then looks you have to fix the spacing between them.
4. 00:16:507 (1,2) - Little spacing issue I guess.

1. Same to Normal. 1.0x DS is much better than 0.8.
2. 00:24:497 (0) - Delete useless timing section.
3. 00:32:241 (2,3) - Fix the spacing here (Try move slider 3 some grids left).
4. 00:33:640 (3,4) - Try to avoid overlap.
5. 00:37:137 (1,2) - ^ Same, looks not good, try something like this↓
   
   SPOILER

   ATTACH[$2A$9G)68DBL00`}O~VX{AP.jpg]

General

Normal

00:03:220 (2) - maybe like this?
00:16:158 (6) - new combo

Taris wrote:

Random mod

also my first Since this is your 1st mod i give u KUDOS lol
Items in BOLD are my comments / What I think about the map

Items in Blue are recommended

Items in Purple are unrankable

Regular text is just suggestion / nazi


[General]

If you do not mind , you should add a hard too because the song is very short No needed @w@"

[Easy]
The diff is okay , But you can put more variation on your slider shapes and make some look nicer.

00:19:654 (2) - Line up with 00:16:857 (4) - ? Fix?
00:36:437 (2) - Move it down 4 boxes no
00:43:780 (3) - This is really break rhythm >.< Try this rhythm instead

Fix

[Normal]

00:28:395 (3) - Move 4 boxes down
00:32:241 (4) - ^
00:16:158 (1) - This slider look a bit ugly , especially the curve Fix?
00:41:332 (6) - Move this to the left a bit

[Hard]

00:40:283 (6) - Spacing is off here a little. Opps Forgot to fix it.
00:46:927 (1) - Is there a reason for this new combo here?

Mapset is alright. Good luck! Thank you

Mapian101 wrote:

I just thought id say that this is one of my favourite beatmaps so far on osu. i have played over 1200 songs and this one has a special spot as one of the top. <3 I hope there is a chance for this to get ranked. ~Niax

• [General]

1. Reduce all your hitsound's volume by 5% to 10%? They're too loud too fit the bgm imo
2. Maybe you should remove the kiai fountain placed on 00:44:829. I kinda don't like it, but it's up to you.
3. Turn your sliderslide's sound into silent, they're making weird sounds that don't fit the music :<
   
   [Easy]
4. 00:42:032 (1) - Move this 1 grid downward so it would be blanketed nicely by 00:38:535 (4).
5. 00:49:724 (3) - Turn it into this, to blanket the previous slider's end nicely :3
   
   [Normal]
6. 00:18:255 (4) - Turn it into this. If you did, fix the spacing of the next circles.
7. 00:22:102 (1) - Move this tick 3 grids to the left and 1 grid downwards.
   
   [Collab]
   clear~

BeatofIke wrote:

https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/1341536
It's been ages lol XD

Natsu wrote:

Easy:

SPOILER

00:19:654 (2,3,1) - try another pattern is so confuse for new players check why:


00:44:130 2 grids right for be in curve with (2,3)

Normal:

SPOILER

00:04:269 move it to x:176 y:64 looks better with 2 and 3
00:11:262 (1,2,3) - make this pattern more curved since 1 and 2 in line look ugly imo
00:49:724 big slider then imo you need to be creative make it more fun :3

Collab:

SPOILER

add circle 00:09:689

Sorry about poor mod since i dont see anything wrong that are just suggestions