forum

Nell - Perfect

posted
Total Posts
39
Topic Starter
chaee
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on July 11, 2014 at 8:14:24 PM

Artist: Nell
Title: Perfect
Tags: korean indie love sb escaping gravity
BPM: 92
Filesize: 4564kb
Play Time: 03:57
Difficulties Available:
  1. Hard (2.74 stars, 518 notes)
  2. Normal (1.56 stars, 249 notes)
Download: Nell - Perfect
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------

wiping
pishifat
bpm = 138
offset = 230
time signature = 3/4

it'll sound a 1/2 beat off until the drums come in at 00:26:319 because the guitar line is kind of weird. that and the 3/4 timing were probably the reasons why you were confused
Topic Starter
chaee

pishifat wrote:

bpm = 138
offset = 230
time signature = 3/4

it'll sound a 1/2 beat off until the drums come in at 00:26:319 because the guitar line is kind of weird. that and the 3/4 timing were probably the reasons why you were confused
Oh yaay. Thanks a bunch. I'm all set now ^^
samplefish
hi, here for m4m!

[General]
update tags on easy, from the hard
update countdown, widescreen sup, letterbox on easy

[Easy]
ar5 seems a little fast, try ar4?
hitsounds need a bit of work. try judging what volume is good for which parts, like turning it down at the beginning where its not that loud. up to 00:25:882 (7) - should use less volume. 100% volume is generally not used.
also, the claps seem a little out of place at the beginning, i would change it.
02:55:012 (1,6) - the kiai between these shouldnt be a kiai imo

00:10:664 (1,2) - better blanketing, slider 1st point 100x 96y looks good i think, .93x instead of 1x distance isnt that noticeable when playing
00:10:664 (1,3) - could stack the slider heads
00:19:795 (1,2,3,4) - this part is similar to 00:19:795 (1,2,3,4) - i would use the same rhythm for consistency
00:20:664 (2,3) - i wouldnt do this in an easy
00:36:751 (4,5) - blanket, use the approach circles for guidance, from http://puu.sh/9Evkh/c5641f2304.jpg to http://puu.sh/9Evml/687de14c1e.jpg
00:42:838 (4,5) - stack better
00:44:143 (6,1) - stack better
00:48:490 (4,5,6) - try something like http://puu.sh/9EvsR/a0ceeeeac6.jpg
01:01:099 (5,1) - stack better
01:04:143 (2,3) - better blanket like http://puu.sh/9Evzh/89699e23f6.jpg
01:08:056 (1,2) - better blanket
01:10:664 (4,5) - i would make 4 straighter so i can have a perfect blanket with 5 so the slider heads do not touch
01:13:273 (6,7) - can blanket these
01:23:708 (3,4) - i wouldnt have these overlap, but its not too bad.
01:31:534 (1,2) - better blanket
01:32:838 (2,3) - maybe curve the 3 so it looks better
01:52:403 (1,2,3) - try something like this http://puu.sh/9EvM8/cd6e92cf25.jpg, you can also move the 123 down a bit so 3 slider head goes with 01:51:099 (6) -
02:23:273 (7,2) - can stack these
02:57:621 (5,6) - distance?
03:04:795 (7) - midpoint 419x 249y to blanket better with 03:04:577 (6) -
03:25:012 (6) - maybe a bit high
03:47:186 (1,2) - blanket
03:53:708 (2,3) - i would take out overlap

seems like youre not finish mapping the end of the kiai? if thats where you intend to end it, i urge you to map until the end!

[Hard]
02:24:795 (5) - you should read this regarding having slider ends on big white ticks. http://puu.sh/9CTLe/fd809d0744.png im not going to point all these out, they are completely rankable, so its up to you if you want to make your map better or not.
01:00:012 (1,2) - there are a lot of these beats in the song, i think having the jump from these beats 01:47:186 (4,5) - is best, jumps on the other beats dont make much sense imo
the combos in the song could use some work. for instance, this one 03:41:969 (1) - is quite long, try NC at 03:44:577 (7) - take out NC 03:45:447 (1) - and NC at 03:47:186 (9) - i think this makes more sense. please fix up the NCs!

00:08:056 (7,1) - hard to read, because at 00:08:925 (1) - he does not start singing, only drawing his breath. i would map the part in between these two.
00:09:795 (3,4) - there are a lot of these blankets, consider making them look nicer?
00:13:490 (2,3) - same as 00:08:056 (7,1) -
00:15:664 (3,5) - try to not have overlap, even small ones
00:25:882 (3,1) - add a note between these two, it really feels like somethign was missing when i played it
00:39:795 (7,8) - stack better
00:41:099 (3,4) - stack better
00:47:186 (1,2) - i would make 2 same angle as 1
00:49:360 (6) - would use 1x distnce for this, current distance is confusing
01:25:012 (2,3) - blanket
01:57:621 (1,2) - blanket
01:59:360 (4) - make this a copy of 01:58:925 (3) -
02:14:360 (5,6) - take out this jump, make the jump from 02:14:577 (6,7) - instead.
03:20:229 (2) - try moving this a little more down so you can stack the end with 03:20:882 (4) -
03:26:099 (11) - equal distance from 10 and 1 would look nicer imo

again, i encourage you to map the rest of the song!

very nice map, with a little bit of polishing i think it will be good to go!

good luck!!
Celizavia
M4M :D

GENERAL

- The timing preview (yellow line) should at 00:55:882
-remove the kiai at 03:15:882, it wasnt the chorus
- make the kiai consistent

Easy
  1. HD = 2/3, 5 is too much for a begginer
  2. AR= 3
  3. OD = 2
  4. the hitsound doesnt matches with the song, try fix it
  5. 00:08:056(5) the sliders end should ended at 00:08:925
  6. 00:49:795(5) blanket this better to the (4)
  7. 00:56:316 a long sliders is better than a a spinner
  8. 02:00229(5) blanket this better
  9. i assume that the song ends at 03:57:621 so you should disable the kiai after that part
Whispering Love
  1. HP=6
  2. one part of the vocal starts at 00:09:143, so i think that the circle should move 1/4 backwards
  3. 00:18:925(6) blanket this better
  4. 00:20:447 ^
  5. 00:25:447 ^
  6. 00:35:229 NC
  7. 01:02:186 remove NC
  8. 01:18:273 insert break time here
  9. ugly overlap at 01:36:534(3,5)
    other same mistakes around the diffs
thats all thanks^^
_Stan
Hi m4m

[Easy]
00:08:056 (5) - slider is ok but do you think that the sound a little weird?
00:10:664 (1,3) - overlap
00:42:838 (4,5) - this is EZ so change it, do not overlap
00:49:795 (5,6) - blanket
00:53:708 (3,4) - ^
01:01:099 (5,1) - overlap
01:08:056 (1,2) - you can blanket these more nicely
03:15:773 - why stop the kiai time then start again rapidly?
03:58:056 - not finish? cancel the kiai time


[Whispering Love]
00:19:795 (2,3) - blanket
00:35:229 (8,9,10) - ^
00:51:316 (4,5,6) - ^
00:57:621 (1,2,3,4) - DS
01:01:534 (6,7) - ^
02:08:708 (2,3) - blanket
02:22:403 (3,4,5) - up the DS
02:29:143 (6) - change color
02:31:969 (14) - ^
03:05:447 (1,3) - overlap
03:53:708 (3,4,5,6) - blanket

good luck~ :)
Topic Starter
chaee

samplefish wrote:

hi, here for m4m!

[General]
update tags on easy, from the hard done
update countdown, widescreen sup, letterbox on easy done

[Easy]
ar5 seems a little fast, try ar4? fixed
hitsounds need a bit of work. try judging what volume is good for which parts, like turning it down at the beginning where its not that loud. up to 00:25:882 (7) - should use less volume. 100% volume is generally not used.fixed!
also, the claps seem a little out of place at the beginning, i would change it. yeah you're right. claps removed
02:55:012 (1,6) - the kiai between these shouldnt be a kiai imo i think it's fine. i chose to put kiai on the most eargasmic parts of the song.. i'll consider it

00:10:664 (1,2) - better blanketing, slider 1st point 100x 96y looks good i think, .93x instead of 1x distance isnt that noticeable when playing
but it would be off the grid if i were to change it
00:10:664 (1,3) - could stack the slider heads done
00:19:795 (1,2,3,4) - this part is similar to 00:19:795 (1,2,3,4) - i would use the same rhythm for consistency this part is similar to waah?
00:20:664 (2,3) - i wouldnt do this in an easy yeah i was thinking that too but where would i put it i don't want to mess up the whole flow of the map because of one hit note..
00:36:751 (4,5) - blanket, use the approach circles for guidance, from http://puu.sh/9Evkh/c5641f2304.jpg to http://puu.sh/9Evml/687de14c1e.jpg fixed
00:42:838 (4,5) - stack better fixed
00:44:143 (6,1) - stack better fixed
00:48:490 (4,5,6) - try something like http://puu.sh/9EvsR/a0ceeeeac6.jpg cool
01:01:099 (5,1) - stack better fixed
01:04:143 (2,3) - better blanket like http://puu.sh/9Evzh/89699e23f6.jpg eeh..
01:08:056 (1,2) - better blanket fixed
01:10:664 (4,5) - i would make 4 straighter so i can have a perfect blanket with 5 so the slider heads do not touch agreed
01:13:273 (6,7) - can blanket these added blanket
01:23:708 (3,4) - i wouldnt have these overlap, but its not too bad. the top right feels so empty that's why i overlapped them
01:31:534 (1,2) - better blanket yay for blankets. fixed
01:32:838 (2,3) - maybe curve the 3 so it looks better curved
01:52:403 (1,2,3) - try something like this http://puu.sh/9EvM8/cd6e92cf25.jpg, you can also move the 123 down a bit so 3 slider head goes with 01:51:099 (6) - nice i like it c:
02:23:273 (7,2) - can stack these stacked
02:57:621 (5,6) - distance? oh right distanced
03:04:795 (7) - midpoint 419x 249y to blanket better with 03:04:577 (6) -
fixed
03:25:012 (6) - maybe a bit high fixed
03:47:186 (1,2) - blanket meh
03:53:708 (2,3) - i would take out overlap

seems like youre not finish mapping the end of the kiai? if thats where you intend to end it, i urge you to map until the end!

[Hard]
02:24:795 (5) - you should read this regarding having slider ends on big white ticks. http://puu.sh/9CTLe/fd809d0744.png im not going to point all these out, they are completely rankable, so its up to you if you want to make your map better or not. keeping it
01:00:012 (1,2) - there are a lot of these beats in the song, i think having the jump from these beats 01:47:186 (4,5) - is best, jumps on the other beats dont make much sense imo i'll think about changing it
the combos in the song could use some work. for instance, this one 03:41:969 (1) - is quite long, try NC at 03:44:577 (7) - take out NC 03:45:447 (1) - and NC at 03:47:186 (9) - i think this makes more sense. please fix up the NCs! NCs fixed thank you!

00:08:056 (7,1) - hard to read, because at 00:08:925 (1) - he does not start singing, only drawing his breath. i would map the part in between these two
i took out the notes and left the sliders instead.
00:09:795 (3,4) - there are a lot of these blankets, consider making them look nicer? the blankets look fine to me ; ;
00:13:490 (2,3) - same as 00:08:056 (7,1) - genius fixed
00:15:664 (3,5) - try to not have overlap, even small ones alright fixed
00:25:882 (3,1) - add a note between these two, it really feels like somethign was missing when i played it added note
00:39:795 (7,8) - stack better fixed
00:41:099 (3,4) - stack better fixed
00:47:186 (1,2) - i would make 2 same angle as 1 allrighty
00:49:360 (6) - would use 1x distnce for this, current distance is confusing how??
01:25:012 (2,3) - blanket fixed
01:57:621 (1,2) - blanket i don't see anything wrong here
01:59:360 (4) - make this a copy of 01:58:925 (3) - done
02:14:360 (5,6) - take out this jump, make the jump from 02:14:577 (6,7) - instead. did both
03:20:229 (2) - try moving this a little more down so you can stack the end with 03:20:882 (4) - wooh fixed
03:26:099 (11) - equal distance from 10 and 1 would look nicer imo

again, i encourage you to map the rest of the song!

very nice map, with a little bit of polishing i think it will be good to go!

good luck!!
wow i'm in awe. thank you so much for this! this mod really helped me a lot, i'm pretty sure i did like 98% of the things that you suggested haha
Topic Starter
chaee

_Stan wrote:

Hi m4m

[Easy]
00:08:056 (5) - slider is ok but do you think that the sound a little weird? not really
00:10:664 (1,3) - overlap nope
00:42:838 (4,5) - this is EZ so change it, do not overlap got it
00:49:795 (5,6) - blanket done
00:53:708 (3,4) - ^ done
01:01:099 (5,1) - overlap no
01:08:056 (1,2) - you can blanket these more nicely okay
03:15:773 - why stop the kiai time then start again rapidly? nope. kiai 1 and kiai 2 are both the most eargasmic parts of the song
03:58:056 - not finish? cancel the kiai time done


[Whispering Love]
00:19:795 (2,3) - blanket done
00:35:229 (8,9,10) - ^ nope
00:51:316 (4,5,6) - ^ no
00:57:621 (1,2,3,4) - DS no they're jumps
01:01:534 (6,7) - ^ nupe
02:08:708 (2,3) - blanket done
02:22:403 (3,4,5) - up the DS again, jumps
02:29:143 (6) - change color done
02:31:969 (14) - ^ no
03:05:447 (1,3) - overlap ew, no
03:53:708 (3,4,5,6) - blanket maybe..

good luck~ :)
thanks for your mod
Topic Starter
chaee

Celizavia wrote:

M4M :D

GENERAL

- The timing preview (yellow line) should at 00:55:882 done
-remove the kiai at 03:15:882, it wasnt the chorus kiai removed on easy
- make the kiai consistent i removed the two kiai's that don't fit if that's what you mean

Easy
  1. HD = 2/3, 5 is too much for a begginer noobs get wrecked fixed
  2. AR= 3 done
  3. OD = 2 done
  4. the hitsound doesnt matches with the song, try fix it
  5. 00:08:056(5) the sliders end should ended at 00:08:925 nah i like it it suits the music
  6. 00:49:795(5) blanket this better to the (4) fixed
  7. 00:56:316 a long sliders is better than a a spinner nope
  8. 02:00229(5) blanket this better
  9. i assume that the song ends at 03:57:621 so you should disable the kiai after that part
yeah fixed

Whispering Love
  1. HP=6 i think 7's okay
  2. one part of the vocal starts at 00:09:143, so i think that the circle should move 1/4 backwards deleted circles
  3. 00:18:925(6) blanket this better done
  4. 00:20:447 ^ done
  5. 00:25:447 ^ done
  6. 00:35:229 NC got it
  7. 01:02:186 remove NC okay
  8. 01:18:273 insert break time here okay
  9. ugly overlap at 01:36:534(3,5)
    other same mistakes around the diffs
keeping it

thats all thanks^^
Topic Starter
chaee
UPDATED
Shiranai
Helloooo :)

[General]
  1. Please check AiMod (Ctrl+Shift+A) some objects out of screen, please fix that and object are not allowed to touch the HP bar (e.g. this one 01:57:621 (1,2) - )
  2. Please change the extention of BG from .png to .jpg to reduce the size of .osz, I already convert one feel free to use http://puu.sh/9FVGQ/399ccc2551.jpg
  3. I think you should enable Widescreen Support, since the BG dimension is widescreen
  4. You also need a custom combo colors to make your map more beautiful, you can use mine
    [Colours]
    Combo1 : 246,128,180
    Combo2 : 255,255,255
    Combo3 : 186,231,235
    Combo4 : 159,154,208
    Or you can find It on your own
  5. Delete Nell from Tags because It's already on Artist name
  6. Since Escaping Gravity is an album name, you should put It on Tags instead on Source, because the rules say so
  7. I think your Offset is a bit to fast, maybe you should asking help for timing
  8. Your easiest diff must be named Normal instead of Easy to complete the Diff spread criteria (at least Normal and Hard) you can also read the ranking criteria to make sure
[Whispering Love]
  1. 00:08:708 - Add a circle there? I hear the harp or guitar sound there
  2. 00:09:143 (9) - New Combo? the singer begin to sing a new lyric there
  3. 00:13:925 - Add a circle there?
  4. 00:28:056 (5) - Maybe you should move that circle to x:220 y:328 to prevent overlap, then move this 00:28:273 (6) - to x:208 y:244, like this http://puu.sh/9FWnq/dfe670c01f.jpg
  5. 00:39:360 (6) - Move that to x:472 y:248 the move them 00:39:795 (7,8) - to x:392 y:328 to make them neater, like this http://puu.sh/9FWNR/5c31e25000.jpg
  6. 00:42:621 (6) - I think that one better to be blanket like this http://puu.sh/9FWUt/c81b5aa983.jpg then 00:43:273 (7) - that one will better look like this http://puu.sh/9FX49/a0c1ce8c97.jpg
  7. 00:50:664 (3) - Make It a bit curve? http://puu.sh/9FXeY/bb251bf195.jpg
  8. 00:57:186 (4) - Move this to x:80 y:88 then move this 00:57:621 (1) - to x:213 y:176 then move 00:57:838 (2) - to x:284 y:216 then move 00:58:056 (3) - to x:300 y:296, so It'll look neater, like this http://puu.sh/9FXzw/b7d44e8301.jpg
  9. 00:58:490 (5,6) - I think that one is a bad flow, maybe you can Ctrl+J this 00:58:490 (5) - http://puu.sh/9FXGx/f5b42909cc.jpg
  10. 01:03:490 (4,6) - I think that one is a bad overlap, you can make (4) a perfect stack under slider (6)'s body or you can move (4) a bit farther like this to make a jump http://puu.sh/9FXUA/140e87b768.jpg
  11. 01:07:621 (8,1,2,3) - Maybe the rhythm will be better like this http://puu.sh/9FY4g/a26d1c3731.jpg
  12. 01:13:164 (2) - Delete thta? I think there's no need to be a note there
  13. 01:21:099 (6) - NC? since after a long a break and also a new rhythm so I thing It should be NC, then delete this NC 01:22:403 (1) -
  14. 01:24:143 (5) - Move this to x:400 y:216 to prevent overlap with this 01:23:056 (3) -
  15. 01:30:229 (8) - You should spread It more to make a better blanket, like this http://puu.sh/9FYHi/8ed6029126.jpg
  16. 01:34:795 (9) - Move up a bit to prevent overlap
  17. 01:36:099 (3,5) - That overlap is also not good, how about make them like this? http://puu.sh/9FZ8n/f3b5ab34c9.jpg
  18. 01:41:316 (6,7) - Make them like this? http://puu.sh/9FZh3/def79d7af0.jpg to prevent overlap
  19. 02:01:425 (2) - Delete? then add circle here 02:02:295 -
  20. 02:08:708 (2) - Spread It more for better blanket with this 02:09:360 (3) -
  21. 02:27:621 (3) - Move up a bit to prevent overlap
  22. 02:32:838 (4) - Move It a bit to left to prevent overlap
  23. 02:33:925 - Pull the break time to the right until big white tick, before http://puu.sh/9FZCS/bc57414eae.jpg after http://puu.sh/9FZE8/c1456e288c.jpg It'll affect when we play
  24. How about add a spinner here 02:53:273 - I geuss It's lack of spinner, start from 02:53:273 - end on 02:54:795 -
  25. 02:55:664 (3,6) - Bad overlap, maybe you should move this 02:56:534 (6) - to x:264 y:180
  26. 03:00:229 (1) - Spread It more for better blanket, then stack this 03:00:012 (10) - on 03:00:229 (1) - (1)'s head, like this http://puu.sh/9G03u/3c3057f87e.jpg
  27. 03:10:664 (1,2) - Out of screen and can be blanket better
  28. 03:15:882 (1,2) - Move them a bit down to prevent overlap
  29. 03:19:795 (1,2) - Move them a bit up to prevent overlap
  30. 03:21:099 (5,6) - Not looking so good, maybe you should move up (6) a bit
  31. 03:33:708 (2) - Better stack It perfectly under 03:32:838 (9) - (9)'s body, like this http://puu.sh/9G0oH/4fcadc11f7.jpg
  32. 03:39:795 (7,8,9,10) - How about make them like this? http://puu.sh/9G0Aj/9669483cd5.jpg It's look neater
  33. 03:41:316 (11,1) - The shape of (11) can be better like this http://puu.sh/9G0Im/6e08dae3ca.jpg
  34. 03:54:143 (7,8) - Move them to x:96 y:292
  35. How about you map the last part after kiai time untill here 04:18:490 - ? It's bit weird since he still singing and the song also not fading away

[]
For now that's all, maybe I'll take a look on your Normal tonight or tomorrow morning
Your map is good and flowing nicely, but the NC and hitsounding still have to be improveeed, good luck~
Kamio Misuzu
hi~ m4m here

[Whispering Love]
00:07:838 (6,7) - try to change it into a note + 1/2 slider + note, just like this one
00:09:143 - NC

00:09:143 (7,8,9) - move note 9 to 00:09:143 -

00:14:360 (1,2,3) - ^

00:14:360 (1) - remove NC

00:13:056 (1,2) - please change this like 00:16:969 (1,2,3) -

00:25:447 (2) - slider‘s tail and 00:25:882 (3,4) - maybe you can heard a drum, right? please change the additions into drum and add claps also change is up to you, just like 00:36:099 (3) - and others

00:34:577 (7,1) - it's not a good idea to get a break here imo, try to change into a note + 1/2slider? i think it will be better :)

00:49:360 (6) - move to 00:49:577 -

01:18:056 (5) - a reverse slider seems suit for here. from 01:17:838 - to 01:18:273 - , maybe you can know my means ;w;

02:33:708 (6) - ^ also dont forget add a note here 02:34:143 -

01:57:621 (1) - 03:10:664 (1) - unrankable because they are out of range

03:10:664 (1,2) - blanket

03:40:664 (10) - NC

03:41:969 (1) - remove NC

[Easy]
01:53:708 (3,4) - check the DS

02:34:143 - add a note with whistle

00:08:056 (5) - reverse at 00:08:490 -

the drum hitsound suggestion same as Whispering Love

nothing else

good luck~! :)
Kasuga
Hello :)

From my modding queue

[Easy]
I have nothing to say here....

[Whispering Love]
- Too many offscreen object. Check AiMod for details and consider fixing it
- 00:09:143 (8) - Put new combo here
- 01:30:229 (8,9) - Blanket it properly
- 02:33:708 - Try to reduce the break. It's too long, try to make it less than 15 seconds
- 03:57:621 - Suggestion. Try to add more note until 04:28:925 -
Topic Starter
chaee

Mako Sakata wrote:

Helloooo :)

[General]
  1. Please check AiMod (Ctrl+Shift+A) some objects out of screen, please fix that and object are not allowed to touch the HP bar (e.g. this one 01:57:621 (1,2) - ) alright ffixed
  2. Please change the extention of BG from .png to .jpg to reduce the size of .osz, I already convert one feel free to use http://puu.sh/9FVGQ/399ccc2551.jpg
  3. I think you should enable Widescreen Support, since the BG dimension is widescreen didn't think of that alright
  4. You also need a custom combo colors to make your map more beautiful, you can use mine
    [Colours][color=#FF0000] i thought i had custom combo colors already[/color]
    Combo1 : 246,128,180
    Combo2 : 255,255,255
    Combo3 : 186,231,235
    Combo4 : 159,154,208
    Or you can find It on your own i thought i had custom combo colors already..
  5. Delete Nell from Tags because It's already on Artist name done
  6. Since Escaping Gravity is an album name, you should put It on Tags instead on Source, because the rules say so done
  7. I think your Offset is a bit to fast, maybe you should asking help for timing
  8. Your easiest diff must be named Normal instead of Easy to complete the Diff spread criteria (at least Normal and Hard) you can also read the ranking criteria to make sure
done

[Whispering Love]
  1. 00:08:708 - Add a circle there? I hear the harp or guitar sound there added
  2. 00:09:143 (9) - New Combo? the singer begin to sing a new lyric there added combo
  3. 00:13:925 - Add a circle there? done c:
  4. 00:28:056 (5) - Maybe you should move that circle to x:220 y:328 to prevent overlap, then move this 00:28:273 (6) - to x:208 y:244, like this http://puu.sh/9FWnq/dfe670c01f.jpg oh cool! fixed
  5. 00:39:360 (6) - Move that to x:472 y:248 the move them 00:39:795 (7,8) - to x:392 y:328 to make them neater, like this http://puu.sh/9FWNR/5c31e25000.jpg fixed in previous update but thanks
  6. 00:42:621 (6) - I think that one better to be blanket like this http://puu.sh/9FWUt/c81b5aa983.jpg then 00:43:273 (7) - that one will better look like this http://puu.sh/9FX49/a0c1ce8c97.jpg oh you're right! fixed
  7. 00:50:664 (3) - Make It a bit curve? http://puu.sh/9FXeY/bb251bf195.jpg eeh nope. not my style
  8. 00:57:186 (4) - Move this to x:80 y:88 then move this 00:57:621 (1) - to x:213 y:176 then move 00:57:838 (2) - to x:284 y:216 then move 00:58:056 (3) - to x:300 y:296, so It'll look neater, like this http://puu.sh/9FXzw/b7d44e8301.jpg
  9. 00:58:490 (5,6) - I think that one is a bad flow, maybe you can Ctrl+J this 00:58:490 (5) - http://puu.sh/9FXGx/f5b42909cc.jpg
  10. 01:03:490 (4,6) - I think that one is a bad overlap, you can make (4) a perfect stack under slider (6)'s body or you can move (4) a bit farther like this to make a jump http://puu.sh/9FXUA/140e87b768.jpg
  11. 01:07:621 (8,1,2,3) - Maybe the rhythm will be better like this http://puu.sh/9FY4g/a26d1c3731.jpg
  12. 01:13:164 (2) - Delete thta? I think there's no need to be a note there
  13. 01:21:099 (6) - NC? since after a long a break and also a new rhythm so I thing It should be NC, then delete this NC 01:22:403 (1) - fixed in previous update
  14. 01:24:143 (5) - Move this to x:400 y:216 to prevent overlap with this 01:23:056 (3) - done
  15. 01:30:229 (8) - You should spread It more to make a better blanket, like this http://puu.sh/9FYHi/8ed6029126.jpg done
  16. 01:34:795 (9) - Move up a bit to prevent overlap i like the overlap here
  17. 01:36:099 (3,5) - That overlap is also not good, how about make them like this? http://puu.sh/9FZ8n/f3b5ab34c9.jpg nice fixed
  18. 01:41:316 (6,7) - Make them like this? http://puu.sh/9FZh3/def79d7af0.jpg to prevent overlap fixed
  19. 02:01:425 (2) - Delete? then add circle here 02:02:295 - deleted
  20. 02:08:708 (2) - Spread It more for better blanket with this 02:09:360 (3) - nope it's a duplicate of 1
  21. 02:27:621 (3) - Move up a bit to prevent overlap nope
  22. 02:32:838 (4) - Move It a bit to left to prevent overlap done
  23. 02:33:925 - Pull the break time to the right until big white tick, before http://puu.sh/9FZCS/bc57414eae.jpg after http://puu.sh/9FZE8/c1456e288c.jpg It'll affect when we play cool done
  24. How about add a spinner here 02:53:273 - I geuss It's lack of spinner, start from 02:53:273 - end on 02:54:795 - added
  25. 02:55:664 (3,6) - Bad overlap, maybe you should move this 02:56:534 (6) - to x:264 y:180 done
  26. 03:00:229 (1) - Spread It more for better blanket, then stack this 03:00:012 (10) - on 03:00:229 (1) - (1)'s head, like this http://puu.sh/9G03u/3c3057f87e.jpg done c:
  27. 03:10:664 (1,2) - Out of screen and can be blanket better fixed in previous update
  28. 03:15:882 (1,2) - Move them a bit down to prevent overlap
  29. 03:19:795 (1,2) - Move them a bit up to prevent overlap
  30. 03:21:099 (5,6) - Not looking so good, maybe you should move up (6) a bit fixed in previous update
  31. 03:33:708 (2) - Better stack It perfectly under 03:32:838 (9) - (9)'s body, like this http://puu.sh/9G0oH/4fcadc11f7.jpg fixed
  32. 03:39:795 (7,8,9,10) - How about make them like this? http://puu.sh/9G0Aj/9669483cd5.jpg It's look neater awesome done
  33. 03:41:316 (11,1) - The shape of (11) can be better like this http://puu.sh/9G0Im/6e08dae3ca.jpg fixed. kind of..
  34. 03:54:143 (7,8) - Move them to x:96 y:292 fixed
  35. How about you map the last part after kiai time untill here 04:18:490 - ? It's bit weird since he still singing and the song also not fading away but that part is unmapped?


thanks so much for your mod! it really improved my mapset ^^
[]
For now that's all, maybe I'll take a look on your Normal tonight or tomorrow morning
Your map is good and flowing nicely, but the NC and hitsounding still have to be improveeed, good luck~
Topic Starter
chaee

Kasuga wrote:

Hello :)

From my modding queue

[Easy]
I have nothing to say here....

[Whispering Love]
- Too many offscreen object. Check AiMod for details and consider fixing it thanks fixed
- 00:09:143 (8) - Put new combo here fixed in previous update
- 01:30:229 (8,9) - Blanket it properly fixed in previous update
- 02:33:708 - Try to reduce the break. It's too long, try to make it less than 15 seconds the break is fine
- 03:57:621 - Suggestion. Try to add more note until 04:28:925 - nope the map ends here
thanks
truonant
Hello~ from my Mod Queue

General
Your background image is in png format, I would recommend using a JPG because you can still achieve the same quality while decreasing the file size: DL LINK
I like what you did with the hitsounds during the beginning portion of Whispering Love, please continue to add the rest of the hitsounds I think they were removed?
Sorry, I started my mod 2 days ago, updated and then finished the rest today, so it may seem a bit confusing and messy since some of it might already be fixed within your previous update

Easy Normal - briefly looked at it
With all of the ½ tick notes, your Easy plays like a Normal. I would highly recommend changing to Normal.
Change HP drain to 3 for Easy, otherwise leave it at 4 if you plan to change this to Normal Since you changed it to Normal, fix your HP, AR, and OD
02:55:012 – no kiai section?
00:08:056 (5) – I recommend pulling it back http://puu.sh/9HJgG/3d81d7b3ff.jpg because it sounds weird with the slider hitsound on the blue tick

Insane
03:57:621 – Not mapping after this?There’s potential to end it here: 04:19:658 -

Combo placement
SPOILER
00:06:751 (4) - Suggestion: http://puu.sh/9HJTj/698f1df229.jpg
00:09:143 (8) –NC
00:13:056 (1) – remove NC
There are some sections where you have jumps. I would suggest incorporating some patterns to enhance readability/flow or you could just leave it. It’s up to you.
00:57:621 (1,2,3,4) – ^
01:00:012 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ play around with pattern to see what works. Example : Here’s a possible suggestion: star pattern - http://puu.sh/9HKCK/ccb7ce4957.jpg
01:01:534 (6,7,8,1,2) - ^
01:28:925 (4,5,6,7) – ^
02:06:751 (8,9,10,11,12) – ^
02:25:230 (6,7,8,9) – ^
03:10:012 (7) – stack on slider end

Aesthetics[spoilerbox]
00:24:360 (6) – better blanket - http://puu.sh/9HJY1/46548a033f.jpg
00:25:447 (2) – better blanket - http://puu.sh/9HK36/f6086e26e5.jpg
00:26:316 (1,3) – These aren’t quite parallel
00:36:099 (3) - move left a bit so that (1) and (2:head) are parallel with (2:tail) and (3:head)
01:30:229 (8) – you can blanket bow sliders like this - http://puu.sh/9HL7G/19de1232c6.jpg
01:33:490 (6,7,8,9) - Looked neater? http://puu.sh/9HLcW/c189953f5f.jpg
01:35:664 (2) – blanket
01:40:012 (3) – blanket
01:41:316 (6) – blanket
01:52:621 (2,3) – I think it’ll look better parallel
01:58:273 (2) – stack slider tail on 01:57:621 (1) – slider tail
02:04:143 (3) –blanket
02:08:708 (2) – blanket
02:20:447 (6) – slider bow blanket
03:00:229 (1) – slider bow blanket
03:17:186 (3) – blanket
03:21:751 (6) – move up a bit
03:32:186 (8) – blanket
03:37:403 (2) – blanket
03:41:316 (11) - A better way to make this type of slider (make it on a larger grid first and then rotate) -http://puu.sh/9HLJU/5cb1f3c0f6.jpg

Good luck with your map. I hope my mod was helpful.
emilia
Well its just 2 diffs for now...

Ok GO!

Normal
01:34:143 (3) - Blanket better
02:28:925 (1) - You can consider angling this
03:05:447 (1) - Blanket better

Not many problems for an Easy map, good job! But I have to say, at some points, the beatmap doesn't go with the song at all; you don't have to place your notes on the white lines (assuming your timing is right) all the time, the important thing is that people need to get the beat of the song. Nice flow, patterns and sliders though.

Whispering Love
00:06:099 (3,4) - Consider blanketting
00:44:360 (1,2) - Consider aligning
01:08:708 (5) - Consider shifting this lower
01:55:012 (1) - Consider curving this
02:13:490 (2,3,4,5,6) - Htcirles look mundane here
02:32:838 (4,5,6,7) - Make this shape look better
03:45:882 (4,5,6) - Uneven spacing

Its a little too easy for a mapset with a special name. I like your consistency though, keep it up!

Nice mapping style you have there~
Don
This map is in an unmoddable state. Change the tempo to 92, 4/4 and set the slider speed to 2.4. Send me a forum PM or contact me in game once it's fixed. Notes should be snapped to 1/6.
Topic Starter
chaee

Kamio Misuzu wrote:

hi~ m4m here

[Whispering Love]
00:07:838 (6,7) - try to change it into a note + 1/2 slider + note, just like this one
00:09:143 - NC

00:09:143 (7,8,9) - move note 9 to 00:09:143 -

00:14:360 (1,2,3) - ^

00:14:360 (1) - remove NC

00:13:056 (1,2) - please change this like 00:16:969 (1,2,3) -

00:25:447 (2) - slider‘s tail and 00:25:882 (3,4) - maybe you can heard a drum, right? please change the additions into drum and add claps also change is up to you, just like 00:36:099 (3) - and others

00:34:577 (7,1) - it's not a good idea to get a break here imo, try to change into a note + 1/2slider? i think it will be better :)

00:49:360 (6) - move to 00:49:577 -

01:18:056 (5) - a reverse slider seems suit for here. from 01:17:838 - to 01:18:273 - , maybe you can know my means ;w;

02:33:708 (6) - ^ also dont forget add a note here 02:34:143 -

01:57:621 (1) - 03:10:664 (1) - unrankable because they are out of range

03:10:664 (1,2) - blanket

03:40:664 (10) - NC

03:41:969 (1) - remove NC

[Easy]
01:53:708 (3,4) - check the DS

02:34:143 - add a note with whistle

00:08:056 (5) - reverse at 00:08:490 -

the drum hitsound suggestion same as Whispering Love

nothing else

good luck~! :)
alright thank you
Topic Starter
chaee

truonant wrote:

Hello~ from my Mod Queue

General
Your background image is in png format, I would recommend using a JPG because you can still achieve the same quality while decreasing the file size: DL LINK
I like what you did with the hitsounds during the beginning portion of Whispering Love, please continue to add the rest of the hitsounds I think they were removed?
Sorry, I started my mod 2 days ago, updated and then finished the rest today, so it may seem a bit confusing and messy since some of it might already be fixed within your previous update

Easy Normal - briefly looked at it
With all of the ½ tick notes, your Easy plays like a Normal. I would highly recommend changing to Normal.
Change HP drain to 3 for Easy, otherwise leave it at 4 if you plan to change this to Normal Since you changed it to Normal, fix your HP, AR, and OD
02:55:012 – no kiai section?
00:08:056 (5) – I recommend pulling it back http://puu.sh/9HJgG/3d81d7b3ff.jpg because it sounds weird with the slider hitsound on the blue tick

Insane
03:57:621 – Not mapping after this?There’s potential to end it here: 04:19:658 -

Combo placement
SPOILER
00:06:751 (4) - Suggestion: http://puu.sh/9HJTj/698f1df229.jpg
00:09:143 (8) –NC
00:13:056 (1) – remove NC
There are some sections where you have jumps. I would suggest incorporating some patterns to enhance readability/flow or you could just leave it. It’s up to you.
00:57:621 (1,2,3,4) – ^
01:00:012 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ play around with pattern to see what works. Example : Here’s a possible suggestion: star pattern - http://puu.sh/9HKCK/ccb7ce4957.jpg
01:01:534 (6,7,8,1,2) - ^
01:28:925 (4,5,6,7) – ^
02:06:751 (8,9,10,11,12) – ^
02:25:230 (6,7,8,9) – ^
03:10:012 (7) – stack on slider end

Aesthetics[spoilerbox]
00:24:360 (6) – better blanket - http://puu.sh/9HJY1/46548a033f.jpg
00:25:447 (2) – better blanket - http://puu.sh/9HK36/f6086e26e5.jpg
00:26:316 (1,3) – These aren’t quite parallel
00:36:099 (3) - move left a bit so that (1) and (2:head) are parallel with (2:tail) and (3:head)
01:30:229 (8) – you can blanket bow sliders like this - http://puu.sh/9HL7G/19de1232c6.jpg
01:33:490 (6,7,8,9) - Looked neater? http://puu.sh/9HLcW/c189953f5f.jpg
01:35:664 (2) – blanket
01:40:012 (3) – blanket
01:41:316 (6) – blanket
01:52:621 (2,3) – I think it’ll look better parallel
01:58:273 (2) – stack slider tail on 01:57:621 (1) – slider tail
02:04:143 (3) –blanket
02:08:708 (2) – blanket
02:20:447 (6) – slider bow blanket
03:00:229 (1) – slider bow blanket
03:17:186 (3) – blanket
03:21:751 (6) – move up a bit
03:32:186 (8) – blanket
03:37:403 (2) – blanket
03:41:316 (11) - A better way to make this type of slider (make it on a larger grid first and then rotate) -http://puu.sh/9HLJU/5cb1f3c0f6.jpg

Good luck with your map. I hope my mod was helpful.
thanks this was very helpful
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply