Rhythmics & Cat Like Thief - Summer Wars [Taiko] · forum

00:00:032 - ~ 00:12:738 - here i can hear the beat clearly,try to add notes
00:12:738 - ~ 00:35:326 - hmm, i think the part is too hard to play for new player due to the tough rhythm you mapped,so i have some suggestions to improve this part :
the pattern you use on 00:12:738 - ~ 00:14:855 - :
My suggest pattern on 00:12:738 - ~ 00:14:855 - :
if you accept the above on, please remove 00:15:031 (6) - and use similar pattern on 00:15:561 - ...etc
00:57:914 (82) - add finish? here is more powerful
00:46:620 - ~ 00:57:561 - i suggest you use the pattern as 00:12:738 - ~ 00:35:326 - to make the difference with 00:57:914 - ~ 00:46:973 (60) -
01:16:973 (119) - change to k and move to 01:17:326 - is better i think
02:05:679 - ~ 02:16:973 - as i said before,this part's rhythm is hard to play,so use the easier pattern would be better

Comment
The main problem is hard pattern you use on some part , try to make this diff easier can improve the diff well

[

Futsuu]

00:00:032 - ~ 00:12:738 -same as Kantan,try to add note
00:12:738 - ~ 00:33:914 - same as kantan, this kind of rhythm is hard to catch for new player try to use this pattern :

(00:12:738 - ~ 00:17:679 - )
02:03:208 (277) - move to 02:03:561 - end on 02:04:267 - and 02:03:208 - add note sounds better to me
02:05:679 - ~ 02:16:973 - also need improve as i said before

Comment
Same as Kantan, some part's rhythm is a bit weird, also need improved

[

Muzukashii]

00:26:149 (90,91) - move to 00:26:326 - and 00:26:679 (92) - remove to follow the vocal is better i think
00:28:973 (102,103) - ^
00:31:796 (115,116) - ^
00:44:679 (166) - move to 00:44:855 - and end on 00:45:208 - and add note 00:44:679 - .the slider start on red line is a bit weird
01:58:091 - try to add note as 01:54:738 (432,433,434,435,436) - ?
02:07:267 (484) - remove? i think there is not obvious sound

Comment
Good diff in general! just remember that some part need follow vocal

[

Oni]

00:42:738 (202,203,204,205) - is similar with 00:41:326 (194,195,196) - try to remove 00:42:826 (203,212,218) - may be better for me
01:28:002 (488,497) - ^
01:11:502 (383,384) - i think here can put kkdkk pattern
01:10:091 (373) - move to 01:10:002 - and 01:10:355 (375) - move to 01:10:179 - to make the 4 and 2-plet pattern as 01:10:973 (379,380,381,382) -
01:21:385 (445,446,447,448,449) - ^
02:00:032 (124) - add finish, here is more powerful than other part

Comment
pretty good diff! the beat and note's relationship is really nice~

That's all~
GL~

Kin

2,618 posts

Joined August 2010

Topic Starter

Kin 2014-01-05T20:40:10+00:00

well firefox crashed when I fix'd the mod, and I'm too lazy to re write,
also almost everything fix'd
thanks !

captin1

osu! Alumni

2,595 posts

Joined February 2011

captin1 2014-01-07T20:34:09+00:00

hi

sorry for poor taiko mod >.<

[Kantan]
reduce to 1.2 or 1.0 sv? seems fast for a low diff, and ranking criteria seems to say that 1.2 or 1.0 is more common for kantan/futsuu

00:51:914 (43,44) - swap these? since melody goes from low to high here
01:45:208 (131) - k? the vocal does have a small increase here
01:55:796 (148,149,150) - and 01:58:620 (153,154,155) - swap the patterns of these? not sure since there's like, two vocal sounds, so either is fine. but i think it would be better to have the pattern with less k first, just my thought
02:45:914 (32) - move to 02:45:561 - and 02:48:385 (38) - move to 02:48:738 - I think with these two it will help the rhythm be more consistent, so that you have them kinda in two sets 02:39:561 - to 02:44:855 - and then 02:45:208 - to 02:50:502 - (although that skpped note at the end does work well with the new phrase)

[Futsuu]
same as kantan, reduce to 1.2 sv?

01:17:855 (118) - d? seems like the pitch of the vocal stays the same from the note before, and doesn't change until the note after
01:27:208 (139,140) - swap so it's d K? would be nice to have some variety in big notes and the end note is higher pitched than the one before
01:40:267 (165) - end 1/4 earlier? I think doing so would help make the sound after a lot cooler by opening up the space for it
01:46:973 (175) - d? to me this ruins the effect of the vocal being low, I think waiting until 01:48:385 (178) - to have a k seems more effective
02:02:855 (209) - why not add a finish so this is a big stream? imo would fit the build up
02:48:914 (56) - d? similar reason as 01:17:855 (118) -

[Muzukashii]

00:50:326 (183) - d? seems like it fits the music better to me
00:54:561 (202) - k? ^
01:29:326 (347) - d? since the vocal drops in pitch
01:41:326 (383) - same as futsuu
02:57:208 (686,687) - swap? it surprised me while playing that this started on k when the pitch is so low

[Oni]
are you sure using cs5 is right? I thought that they should all be the same so that the star rating isn't influenced by settings that don't affect gameplay

don't really have much to say about this one tho hah, it's fast o.o

good luck!

Kin

2,618 posts

Joined August 2010

Topic Starter

Kin 2014-01-11T12:19:30+00:00

captin1 wrote:
hi

sorry for poor taiko mod >.<

[Kantan]
reduce to 1.2 or 1.0 sv? seems fast for a low diff, and ranking criteria seems to say that 1.2 or 1.0 is more common for kantan/futsuu

00:51:914 (43,44) - swap these? since melody goes from low to high here prefer keep it
01:45:208 (131) - k? the vocal does have a small increase here sound strange to me
01:55:796 (148,149,150) - and 01:58:620 (153,154,155) - swap the patterns of these? not sure since there's like, two vocal sounds, so either is fine. but i think it would be better to have the pattern with less k first, just my thought fix'd
02:45:914 (32) - move to 02:45:561 - and 02:48:385 (38) - move to 02:48:738 - I think with these two it will help the rhythm be more consistent, so that you have them kinda in two sets 02:39:561 - to 02:44:855 - and then 02:45:208 - to 02:50:502 - (although that skpped note at the end does work well with the new phrase)

[Futsuu]
same as kantan, reduce to 1.2 sv?

01:17:855 (118) - d? seems like the pitch of the vocal stays the same from the note before, and doesn't change until the note after fix'd
01:27:208 (139,140) - swap so it's d K? would be nice to have some variety in big notes and the end note is higher pitched than the one before hm prefer keep it
01:40:267 (165) - end 1/4 earlier? I think doing so would help make the sound after a lot cooler by opening up the space for it idk what you mean since I changed a lil thing but I end it on white tick
01:46:973 (175) - d? to me this ruins the effect of the vocal being low, I think waiting until 01:48:385 (178) - to have a k seems more effective almost fix'd
02:02:855 (209) - why not add a finish so this is a big stream? imo would fit the build up fix'd
02:48:914 (56) - d? similar reason as 01:17:855 (118) - the melody start to became more high pitched there, so prefer keep it

[Muzukashii]

00:50:326 (183) - d? seems like it fits the music better to me fix'd
00:54:561 (202) - k? ^ pattern has changed a bit
01:29:326 (347) - d? since the vocal drops in pitch fix'd
01:41:326 (383) - same as futsuu better to end it on white tick
02:57:208 (686,687) - swap? it surprised me while playing that this started on k when the pitch is so low previous pattern has change, so this one is better to play

[Oni]
are you sure using cs5 is right? I thought that they should all be the same so that the star rating isn't influenced by settings that don't affect gameplay I knew it was not a big deal, so I never touch it (and I'm lazy

don't really have much to say about this one tho hah, it's fast o.o

good luck!

thanks for mod !

XinCrin

2,846 posts

Joined January 2012

XinCrin 2014-01-24T20:57:40+00:00

OMG <33333333

Good Luck with this project

Evening

2,464 posts

Joined December 2012

Evening 2014-02-26T03:52:01+00:00

Mod from Queue o/

d = Don
k = Kat
D = Big Don
K = Big Kat
">" = Change to

Timing Check

Offset

No Problems

BPM

No Problems

Oni

Hit-Sound Check/Addition of Notes

00:16:267 - There seems to be a lack of kats here, it creates a gap the kat rhythm which sounds awkward for me, I suggest to add kat(s) somewhere here
Minor Suggestion : 00:50:326 (253,255,257) - This rhythm feels awkward for me, I suggest to change this rhythm to something more smooth (1/2s) since this music mostly uses 1/2
01:06:385 (352,353,354,355,356,357,358,359,360,361,362,363,364) - This kat rhythm seems a bit messy in my opinion, I suggest to have a kdkdk kdkdk kkk rhythm here since it is a build-up in the music and you might want to have an increase in kat density as it progresses ( if you get what I'm talking about )
01:18:561 - I suggest to not have a break here, you did not have a break on the previous pattern, also, the rhythm in the music doesn't really cut off at any point here, the break is a bit awkward in my opinion.
01:19:796 (441,442,443,444,445) - ddkdd > DD(remove)DD | I suggest to emphasize on these dons since they are emphasized heavily in the music on 1/2s, you might not want to have any 1/4s here.
02:56:679 (100) - k > K | Since you emphasized 02:56:502 (99,101) - , I suggest to also emphasize this

SV Check

No Problems

Kiai Time Check

No Problems

General

Ranking Criteria Check

No Problems

AiMod

No Problems

Title Check

No Problems

[Muzu]

00:24:561 (84) - k > d | There's a strong bass here I highly recommend to change to don
01:19:091 (304,305) - Swap | Not putting a kat on 305 will ruin the kat rhythm here, I suggest to swap this since you might not want to have that much kats in succession
02:50:502 (656,657) - kd > KD | Since the music strongly emphasizes these two notes with a strong bass I suggest to change both of them to finishes

[Futsuu]

00:58:796 (64,66) - Swap | There seems to be too less kats around 64, I suggest to swap so that there won't be that much kats in succession around 66 also, this is to balance out the kat and don density
01:51:914 (185) - d > k | Shouldn't this be a kat in your pattern here?

[Kantan]

Not much to say about kantan

01:42:738 - I suggest to add a big kat here since this is pretty loud in the music and you might not want to neglect it
02:39:208 - Same here I suggest to add a normal kat

Not much problems for the whole mapset, the kat rhythm spread is pretty smooth in all charts

Good luck!

Kin

2,618 posts

Joined August 2010

Topic Starter

Kin 2014-02-26T20:03:16+00:00

lZenxl wrote:
Mod from Queue o/

d = Don
k = Kat
D = Big Don
K = Big Kat
">" = Change to

Timing Check

Offset

No Problems

BPM

No Problems

Oni
Hit-Sound Check/Addition of Notes

00:16:267 - There seems to be a lack of kats here, it creates a gap the kat rhythm which sounds awkward for me, I suggest to add kat(s) somewhere here maybe fix'd when changed lil thing
Minor Suggestion : 00:50:326 (253,255,257) - This rhythm feels awkward for me, I suggest to change this rhythm to something more smooth (1/2s) since this music mostly uses 1/2 pattern changed
01:06:385 (352,353,354,355,356,357,358,359,360,361,362,363,364) - This kat rhythm seems a bit messy in my opinion, I suggest to have a kdkdk kdkdk kkk rhythm here since it is a build-up in the music and you might want to have an increase in kat density as it progresses ( if you get what I'm talking about )
01:18:561 - I suggest to not have a break here, you did not have a break on the previous pattern, also, the rhythm in the music doesn't really cut off at any point here, the break is a bit awkward in my opinion. I didn't really fix it, but I change the pattern, the kat density is no higher at the end
01:19:796 (441,442,443,444,445) - ddkdd > DD(remove)DD | I suggest to emphasize on these dons since they are emphasized heavily in the music on 1/2s, you might not want to have any 1/4s here. fix'd
02:56:679 (100) - k > K | Since you emphasized 02:56:502 (99,101) - , I suggest to also emphasize this fix'd

SV Check

No Problems

Kiai Time Check

No Problems

General

Ranking Criteria Check

No Problems

AiMod

No Problems

Title Check

No Problems

[Muzu]

00:24:561 (84) - k > d | There's a strong bass here I highly recommend to change to don
01:19:091 (304,305) - Swap | Not putting a kat on 305 will ruin the kat rhythm here, I suggest to swap this since you might not want to have that much kats in succession I prefer keep it, I'm following the vocal here, the voice is more high pitched, so I prefer keep k
02:50:502 (656,657) - kd > KD | Since the music strongly emphasizes these two notes with a strong bass I suggest to change both of them to finishes fix'd

[Futsuu]

00:58:796 (64,66) - Swap | There seems to be too less kats around 64, I suggest to swap so that there won't be that much kats in succession around 66 also, this is to balance out the kat and don density fix'd
01:51:914 (185) - d > k | Shouldn't this be a kat in your pattern here? yeah fix'd

[Kantan]

Not much to say about kantan

01:42:738 - I suggest to add a big kat here since this is pretty loud in the music and you might not want to neglect it fix'd
02:39:208 - Same here I suggest to add a normal katfix'd

Not much problems for the whole mapset, the kat rhythm spread is pretty smooth in all charts

Good luck!

thanks for mod !

mingmichael

1,720 posts

Joined May 2012

mingmichael 2014-03-03T14:56:40+00:00

kin~ from my modding queue~

Red ~> unrakable issue, must be changed
Blue ~> highly suggested, consider to use it
Black ~> suggestion, just free to choose it

====================

[

Kantan]

☞ change Slider Velocity to be 1.20. 1.00 is too slow for this btw, and don't worry. 1.20 isn't hard imo

☞ basically all notes are nice and patterns are nice too. catch some mods again for kantan and it'll look better too

• move 00:33:561 - to 00:33:914 - and add a note (don) at 00:34:267 - and change them to be kats. well maybe you wanted to make a different patterns at the last part of there. well nice~ but becareful and look carefully again with the consistency of the patterns. from 00:24:032 - when then new part comes, you used o o oo constantly until 00:31:443 - . but at the last (00:32:502 - ) you didn't use it. consider again about this

• remove this finisher 01:23:326 - . you didn't follow it at the previous notes 01:09:208 - ; 01:20:502 - . please keep the consistency there

• change 01:59:326 - to keep the dons pattern at the white strikes at that part (you used don too at 01:56:502 - btw)

• move 02:27:738 - to 1/2 backward. well i know that you used a note at 02:27:738 - to follow the instrument sound which comes at there right? yeah it's nice basically~ but, consider again for the kantan player. a note which comes at the red strike (with 1/2 beat snap divisor) is quite hard for the kantan player, and then before that note comes, you gave a break. it makes the kantan players will be more confused too and hit that note incorrectly
btw, change it to be kat to make a good patterns for 4notes if you use this mod. so the notes will be o o o o

====================

[

Futsuu]

☞ okay~!

☞ basically patterns are nice~ hihii

• a don missing at 00:45:208 -

• a finisher missing at 01:00:738 - , to keep the finisher pattern that you used to follow the cymbals sounds like 00:56:502 - ; 00:57:914 - ; 01:03:561 - ; 01:06:385 -

====================

[

Muzukashii]

☞ okay~!

☞ nice job here basically~! :3

• upss you missed finisher again at 00:57:914 - . basically 00:57:914 - has a same part like 00:46:620 - (same pitch sound too also) and you used finisher too at 00:46:620 - . so to keep the consistency, add a finisher too at 00:57:914 -
btw change 00:57:914 - to don too, not kat. to keep the the consistency too like 00:46:620 - . and it'll make a good pattern too which is o o o O

• and you must change 00:58:267 - to be kat if you use the previous mod ^ because of the kat pattern that you used constantly at this first kiai part (kats always appear at the white strikes. not at the white strikes actually, but at x:1 and x:3 on metronome). and it has a same part too like 00:46:973 - and you used kat too there

• move 02:03:738 - to 02:04:091 - and change it to be don. change 02:03:914 - and 02:03:208 - to be kat and change 02:03:385 - to be don. and change 02:02:855 - and 02:03:561 - . sorry for the long suggestion. but this suggestion is to keep the finisher patterns. i saw that you followed the finisher sounds from 01:57:208 - (like at 02:00:032 - ; 02:01:443 - and 02:04:267 - ). it's nice~! but, why did you not follow that sound too at 02:02:855 - and 02:03:561 - ? consider this again

• kat at 02:09:561 - to make a good increasing piano sounds at there. you can hear 02:09:561 - becomes quite higher than 02:09:208 - and 02:09:385 - and you put dons at there. so to make a different sound at 02:09:561 - which becomes quite higher, i changed it to be kat. btw it'll make a good pattern too which is o o o o o

• 02:15:208 - ^

• just a suggestion here from my opinion. change 02:21:561 - to be don because of the low vocal. it's different like 02:18:738 - that the vocal becomes higher that the previous note. at 02:21:561 - , the vocal becomes lower that the previous note. so it looks quite weird for the lower sounds to use kat
btw you used dons too at Oni

• 02:27:208 - ^

• change 02:28:267 - to be kat. basically 02:28:267 - has a higher pitch sound than the previous three notes, but you used don there. so basically it'll be low because of don. and then please change 02:28:620 - and 02:28:973 - to be dons because the pitch sounds are lower than 02:28:267 - . and it'll make a reverse pattern with the next note. you can see here
btw you used O O O too at 02:32:502 - ; 02:32:855 - and 02:33:208 - . they have a same pitch sound too like02:28:267 - imo

====================

[

Oni]

☞ HP and OD are 6? well, i think that you wanted to make a good spread of the diffs. so kantan 3, futsuu 4, muzu 5 and oni 6. but for this diff (oni) for using 6 for HP and OD are quite hard for my own opinion. so, how about to change OD to be 5, and keep the HP with 6?

☞ some inconsistent for finishers. you can look Notes box to see the suggestions

☞ hihii nice patterns basically :3 like it