i don't think they're meant to be that long...maybe a character limit or making the text drop to the second line when it gets too close to the rank counter
EDIT:
;___;
forum
[resolved] [confirmed] Playing maps in multiple collections always expands last one
posted
Total Posts
91
i don't think they're meant to be that long...maybe a character limit or making the text drop to the second line when it gets too close to the rank counter
EDIT:
;___;
So when we are at the collections:
1.After trying to create collection (ad. for the first time), click the text box, and just make sure it was used (so the default text disappeared). Then hit cancel, without creating collection:
This appears, even though it shouldn't.
2.After you do collection, and remove it, beatmeaps which were in it, are still having button to remove them from a collection, EVEN if they're not in any.
1.After trying to create collection (ad. for the first time), click the text box, and just make sure it was used (so the default text disappeared). Then hit cancel, without creating collection:
This appears, even though it shouldn't.
2.After you do collection, and remove it, beatmeaps which were in it, are still having button to remove them from a collection, EVEN if they're not in any.
a couple of things i've noticed. i'll post more stuff as a notice it
Same here :<
Oh I see deadbeat you've tried to replicate 1. point
However - there should be NO text, after you use text box. Leave it blank.
However - there should be NO text, after you use text box. Leave it blank.
Don't know if this is known yet, but if you delete a map that belongs to a collection and try to add another map to any collection, the game throws an error and sometimes crashes because the collection is broken. This seems to be fixed once the game is restarted though.
Appeared with last b20130421 update. Right-click on any beatmap in song select and you will see "1." without any mention of collections.
The way the list is sorted is bugged as well. Sorting by artist, title, length, etc. does nothing to change the sorting.
Topic Starter
same. :/XPJ38 wrote:
Appeared with last b20130421 update. Right-click on any beatmap in song select and you will see "1." with any mention of collections.
This also happens.Floks wrote:
The way the list is sorted is bugged as well. Sorting by artist, title, length, etc. does nothing to change the sorting.
Hi, some problems. Sorry for the derp at the end of the video I was looking for another "bugged" map like the first one.
tldr; can't remove fav A and B, bug on some (many) maps when clicking on 1., doesn't save changes until osu! reboot so if osu! crash you can do again all the things again, funny glitches.
Yes I am having fun with each one of your updates.
tldr; can't remove fav A and B, bug on some (many) maps when clicking on 1., doesn't save changes until osu! reboot so if osu! crash you can do again all the things again, funny glitches.
Yes I am having fun with each one of your updates.
thats odd, i've just checked the test build and it looks fine. wonder if something went wrong when pushing it to the public build
Just noticed that if you happen to delete FavouritesA and B, they come back after restarting the game.
SameScorpiour wrote:
same hereXPJ38 wrote:
Appeared with last b20130421 update. Right-click on any beatmap in song select and you will see "1." with any mention of collections.
When trying to switch songs by using arrow keys, it happens that it jumps to different collections without any apparent reason.
Sometimes this happens too if you sort songs by "Date": if you're checking Today's songs, without any apparent reason it goes to Yesterday's songs, if you navigate using arrow keys.
I don't know why this is happening, and this bug occurs quite often, but not all the times.
Sometimes this happens too if you sort songs by "Date": if you're checking Today's songs, without any apparent reason it goes to Yesterday's songs, if you navigate using arrow keys.
I don't know why this is happening, and this bug occurs quite often, but not all the times.
Sorting is completely broken
etc
etc
Damn! I had this bug for years. When I tried to make a osu! Compilation I've added the Maps to these Favorites but it always reset itself. ;n;XPJ38 wrote:
Just noticed that if you happen to delete FavouritesA and B, they come back after restarting the game.
When there are too many collections in list they overlap buttons "Add" and "Remove". I think whei I will add more collections they will fill all screen.
ps don't ask why I have too many collections - just want to sort my library with a lot of tags. Maybe 30 or 40 different tags or even more
I like when all things are very well organized.
ps don't ask why I have too many collections - just want to sort my library with a lot of tags. Maybe 30 or 40 different tags or even more
I like when all things are very well organized.added that and:KosMos_pv wrote:
When there are too many collections in list they overlap buttons "Add" and "Remove". I think whei I will add more collections they will fill all screen.
ps don't ask why I have too many collections - just want to sort my library with a lot of tags. Maybe 30 or 40 different tags or even more
x button overlapping total number.
I feel like that icon should only be visible when hovering over each collection.
Is sorting works in Collection?
Seems like all maps stay in the same order for any sorting type.
UPD 1. Also now there are no sorting by difficulty within the track.
UPD 2. By the way, another issue:
Seems like all maps stay in the same order for any sorting type.
UPD 1. Also now there are no sorting by difficulty within the track.
UPD 2. By the way, another issue:
yeah, sorting doesn't work. I've mentioned that in my post and already added it to the OP.Unic wrote:
Is sorting works in Collection?
Seems like all maps stay in the same order for any sorting type.
UPD 1. Also now there are no sorting by difficulty within the track.
UPD 2. By the way, another issue:
I can't see any of the screenshots you've posted. Please try to use the in-game screenshot shortcut: Shift + F12.
I reuploaded them for you.theowest wrote:
I can't see any of the screenshots you've posted. Please try to use the in-game screenshot shortcut: Shift + F12.
1st: http://nsa33.casimages.com/img/2013/04/ ... 443043.jpg
2nd: http://nsa34.casimages.com/img/2013/04/ ... 714898.jpg
3rd: http://nsa33.casimages.com/img/2013/04/ ... 356527.jpg
I guess the first two images there depict the problem with not being able to sort collections, the third one seems to be an issue which would be better solved with this idea: https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/2255685
If you edit a map that's in a collection and save changes, it disappears from all collections it's in and if you try to add it to a collection afterwards osu! crashes.
I made a collection for my WIP maps so it's easier to browse through them, but with this problem it's kinda defeating the purpose.
Not sure how this would be fix-able since you change the beatmap and it makes sense for it to get removed from a collection..
I made a collection for my WIP maps so it's easier to browse through them, but with this problem it's kinda defeating the purpose.
Not sure how this would be fix-able since you change the beatmap and it makes sense for it to get removed from a collection..
I'm on it.
edit: done.
I didn't include deadbeat's issue (the first mentioned in the video, i.e. right-click > "delete beatmap" on a group not containing the now playing song deletes said song) because it isn't specific to collections: it works with every group, be it a collection or not.
I also added a screenshot and a Youtube video for 10. and 11.
And why is the first link of a spoilerbox never properly formatted? ;_;
edit 2: intelligibility
edit: done.
I didn't include deadbeat's issue (the first mentioned in the video, i.e. right-click > "delete beatmap" on a group not containing the now playing song deletes said song) because it isn't specific to collections: it works with every group, be it a collection or not.
I also added a screenshot and a Youtube video for 10. and 11.
And why is the first link of a spoilerbox never properly formatted? ;_;
edit 2: intelligibility
just had enough time to get round to it, and i was a bit late :p
hadn't realized that there were so many issues
hadn't realized that there were so many issues
Thanks for formatting the starting post XPJ38. Looks nice and tidy.
Though I only noticed numbers two, seven and eight myself, they're annoying. =(
Me neither. =/deadbeat wrote:
hadn't realized that there were so many issues
Though I only noticed numbers two, seven and eight myself, they're annoying. =(
Oh by the way, protip: do not try to reproduce bug #11, you'll lose all your collections. I had to recreate mine from scratch and that was annoying >.<
You didn't notice number 6? Well shit XDJustykanna wrote:
Though I only noticed numbers two, seven and eight myself, they're annoying. =(
Whoops. I meant six, not eight.XPJ38 wrote:
You didn't notice number 6? Well shit XD
Still waiting for a fix.XPJ38 wrote:
Just noticed that if you happen to delete FavouritesA and B, they come back after restarting the game.
Also I didn't see this in the topic but sorting by Artist/Creator, maybe more does not sort correctly.
After updating from an 1-month-old build, my favorites A/B weren't converted into collections, and just vanished from the game.
Screenshots
Screenshots
It also needs a delete confirmation. I just accidentally deleted my FavB list with 750+ maps in it and I'm really really REALLY pissed.
If you ever experience favourites deletion ingame, copy the osu! config file named after your computer into somewhere else while the game is still on. Then turn off the game and put that file back. It's only possible because config files don't get updated until osu! closes properly, which is why crashes always result up in "outdated" favourites.
A helpful tip for those facing such problems.
A helpful tip for those facing such problems.
Not only editting remove's a beatmap from the collection, updating a beatmap will remove it either...Mira-san wrote:
Editing a map in a collection removes it from the collection and makes osu! crashes.
p/2265075
If you edit a map that's in a collection and save changes, it disappears from all collections it's in and if you try to add it to a collection afterwards osu! crashes.
I made a collection for my WIP maps so it's easier to browse through them, but with this problem it's kinda defeating the purpose.
Not sure how this would be fix-able since you change the beatmap and it makes sense for it to get removed from a collection..
XPJ38 edit: here's a screenshot of what happens after clicking on 1. just after editing the map:
After that, osu! is running but totally locked. Only way to get out of here is to close osu! by closing the window.
You sir have saved me from a suicide. Thank youSup A Noob wrote:
If you ever experience favourites deletion ingame, copy the osu! config file named after your computer into somewhere else while the game is still on. Then turn off the game and put that file back. It's only possible because config files don't get updated until osu! closes properly, which is why crashes always result up in "outdated" favourites.
A helpful tip for those facing such problems.
If you want to save all your other collections, you need to do this with collection.db file insteadSup A Noob wrote:
If you ever experience favourites deletion ingame, copy the osu! config file named after your computer into somewhere else while the game is still on. Then turn off the game and put that file back. It's only possible because config files don't get updated until osu! closes properly, which is why crashes always result up in "outdated" favourites.
A helpful tip for those facing such problems.
If this still happens, and you want to get rid of favouritesA/B once and for all, you can edit osu!.YourWindowsUsername.cfg file with notepad and delete all song codes after FavouritesA = and FavouritesB = . The file's start should look like this:XPJ38 wrote:
Just noticed that if you happen to delete FavouritesA and B, they come back after restarting the game.
FavouritesA =
FavouritesB =
TreeSortMode = Search
TreeSortMode2 = BPM
...
Don't forget to make a backup first though in case something goes wrong
Apparently favouriting maps in results screen does jack shit.
Someone please confirm this for me.
Someone please confirm this for me.
Thanks for the help, works fine.Sup A Noob wrote:
If you ever experience favourites deletion ingame, copy the osu! config file named after your computer into somewhere else while the game is still on. Then turn off the game and put that file back. It's only possible because config files don't get updated until osu! closes properly, which is why crashes always result up in "outdated" favourites.
A helpful tip for those facing such problems.
Collections are way too easy to remove! 
It needs prompt window! (good that FavoritiesA came back after restart) 
It needs prompt window! (good that FavoritiesA came back after restart) I have been waiting for so long for something like Collections, but seems its pretty buggy and useless by now, I thing that right clicking, select 1, and choose collections to add the song to is pretty damn slow, I would love to have a ticky option to easily sort my songs while scrolling down all over the songs.
Edit: And the current collection menu should be more like for managing collections instead of choosing wich songs goes to each one, also it wold be helpful to have an option to choose wich collections you would like to show along the song selection menu.
Edit: And the current collection menu should be more like for managing collections instead of choosing wich songs goes to each one, also it wold be helpful to have an option to choose wich collections you would like to show along the song selection menu.
Removed "missing label on 1. button" issue. I haven't checked if some of the other issues were gone though.
I've found that when you just opened a collection and press random it will select the first beatmap in the collection, but after that you can use random properly
In addition to the favourites problem :
I've had some trouble with the undeletable favourites A and B myself, so I tried deleting every map one by one from the collection (700 maps T_T)
After relogging all the maps were back in my favourites, just as if I did nothing at all...
I haven't tried deleting just a map or two (not every maps) from the favourites though, it might work little by little, I don't know.
I've had some trouble with the undeletable favourites A and B myself, so I tried deleting every map one by one from the collection (700 maps T_T)
After relogging all the maps were back in my favourites, just as if I did nothing at all...
I haven't tried deleting just a map or two (not every maps) from the favourites though, it might work little by little, I don't know.
When navigating using left and right arrow, sometimes it happens to jump through different collections.
This happens when you put the same song in 2 different collections, and you get through them using arrow keys. It only happens when you navigate a collection which is located under the ones that contain the same song.
In other words, in the video, if I navigated in Test 1 using arrow keys nothing would have happened, because it's above the collection Test 2.
This happens when you put the same song in 2 different collections, and you get through them using arrow keys. It only happens when you navigate a collection which is located under the ones that contain the same song.
In other words, in the video, if I navigated in Test 1 using arrow keys nothing would have happened, because it's above the collection Test 2.
Confirming. Will merge this topic into this one.Pagno wrote:
When navigating using left and right arrow, sometimes it happens to jump through different collections.
This happens when you put the same song in 2 different collections, and you get through them using arrow keys. It only happens when you navigate a collection which is located under the ones that contain the same song.
In other words, in the video, if I navigated in Test 1 using arrow keys nothing would have happened, because it's above the collection Test 2.
edit: issue added to OP.
After editing the map goes away from collection and game don't react to any user's input events (but music still playing and animations are working).
Also next error message appears:
Also next error message appears:
Already mentioned: issue #9 in OP.Unic wrote:
After editing the map goes away from collection and game don't react to any user's input events (but music still playing and animations are working).
i think this one is fixed. can someone confirm?Mira-san wrote:
- If you hit random/F2 too fast you will jump to the next collection group.
yep! that's fixed alright.deadbeat wrote:
i think this one is fixed. can someone confirm?Mira-san wrote:
- If you hit random/F2 too fast you will jump to the next collection group.
adding this one:
The first time you randomize in any folder/grouping/collection the first map in that list will always be selected. Kind of wish randomizing were 100% random.
The first time you randomize in any folder/grouping/collection the first map in that list will always be selected. Kind of wish randomizing were 100% random.
I just noticed that. Was about to report ittheowest wrote:
adding this one:
The first time you randomize in any folder/grouping/collection the first map in that list will always be selected. Kind of wish randomizing were 100% random.
I also have a issue with collections. I do not see the issue in the first post.
The problem occurs if I try to remove a map from a collection. I do that by
Right click map -> Manage Collections -> Select collection -> Remove -> Close.
If I do this, then the map is removed from the collection, as desired. But when I close osu! and then start it again, the map is back in the collection.
I don't know if I'm doing something wrong or osu! is (probably the former). I assume it has something to do with writing privileges, but it also occurs if I run osu! as administrator. Dunno if it matters, but I have Windows 7.
The problem occurs if I try to remove a map from a collection. I do that by
Right click map -> Manage Collections -> Select collection -> Remove -> Close.
If I do this, then the map is removed from the collection, as desired. But when I close osu! and then start it again, the map is back in the collection.
I don't know if I'm doing something wrong or osu! is (probably the former). I assume it has something to do with writing privileges, but it also occurs if I run osu! as administrator. Dunno if it matters, but I have Windows 7.
Alt+F4ryuu wrote:
hi.
this has happened several times already.
i just play and then decide to add something to the collection. that's all.
"After that, osu! is running but totally locked."
and the only way to close osu is to kill the process through task dispatcher.
When removing a song from my collection, it seems to return after restarting my Osu.
Also when playing a song from my collection, if it's in another collection as well, I will alway end up in the lowest collection afterwards.
Thanks in advance for fixing this asap ;-)
Also when playing a song from my collection, if it's in another collection as well, I will alway end up in the lowest collection afterwards.
Thanks in advance for fixing this asap ;-)
If I play a song in a collection folder that's also in another collection folder under it, it will return me to the lower-most collection folder that map when I finished playing.
(For example, I have a folder called "Stream Practice", and under it is "Favorites A". If I go into "Stream Practice" and play a song that's also in "Favorites A", I will be returned to the "Favorites A" collection instead of the "Stream Practice" collection.)
Not sure if this bug was mentioned before.
(For example, I have a folder called "Stream Practice", and under it is "Favorites A". If I go into "Stream Practice" and play a song that's also in "Favorites A", I will be returned to the "Favorites A" collection instead of the "Stream Practice" collection.)
Not sure if this bug was mentioned before.
Bug found while spectating someone.
Not sure if it's allready mentioned here so I'll just say it.
Not sure if it's allready mentioned here so I'll just say it.
I thought he added them back.
Damn I must be blind, sorry >.<deadbeat wrote:
XPJ38 wrote:
Bug #6 (can't remove FavA and FavB) seems to be resolved. Can someone confirm?deadbeat wrote:
[woc2006] Totally get rid of favouritesA/B, backup your cfg file if you still need them.
problem 6 fixed?
I am not sure that this is related to the FavA/B impossible deletion bug... Needs clarification.TheVileOne wrote:
I thought he added them back.
after i put some map to test into Favorites A from old build,
i tried with current build, and Favorite A removed from config.. automatically added to collections..
maybe it's combined between Favorites removal and migration,
i tried with current build, and Favorite A removed from config.. automatically added to collections..
maybe it's combined between Favorites removal and migration,
I moved some bugs that are confirmed to be fixed in test build.
I can't test 2, not replicate 3. I think 3 is fixed if anyone can test it on test build.
I can't replicate 7 apart from that it removes the map from the collection. It doesn't crash in public nor test build.
1. Not being able to organize collections should be an issue to be fixed. You can't rename a collection and you can't organize them.
2. If you have text in the name box when you close, a collection is added. I did not consider typing text into a box as submitting a collection. Hitting enter makes the collection visible. I'm not sure why pressing close has the same effect as pressing Enter. Actually clicking any button adds a collection. I doubt this is intended.
3. <test build only> the + - buttons don't take the state of add mapset. Even though add mapset is unchecked by default, it will still add the entire mapset.
4. It's annoying to have to keep selecting Add Mapset for each song.
5. Managing collections button collapses the expanded collection list. This is unwanted behavior since there is no way of viewing which maps are in a collection from the collection window. Could you add a collection management feature similar to how osudirect is structured? I don't think a GUI less management system is the way to go.
6. Managing collections is horribly inefficient. I have to click manage collections for each map individually and then select add mapset, and select the collection. There needs to be a way to add or remove several maps within the same screen. The current method requires you change your sorts and filters. You can't use the search feature with collections filter.
7. It is impossible to find which collections contain a beatmap if you have a difficulty that isn't included with the collection selected. Even clicking on add mapset wont highlight the map. I think that if you click add mapset, it should show all collections that the selected difficulty is in regardless if that difficulty is added to any collection. It is slightly misleading that the game will say that the entire mapset isn't part of any collection when only a single difficulty isn't included. If this doesn't make sense, please include show options for any difficulty and all difficulties in the collection management window.
8. Don't bother including your WIPs into a collection. You will need to constantly readd them each time you make a change.
9. the game does not make it obvious that a song is being removed from a collection because of edited changes or updates. You could just look for a song via a collection one day and find that the song no longer appears in your list. I consider collections to be a more stable way to organize your beatmaps. The tendency to remove your beatmaps from collections without warning irks me. Please have the game readd beatmaps to collections after they get changed.
10. Pressing delete collection unselects the collection. If you select No, there will be no collections selected.More of an inconvenience than unintentional behavior.
I can't test 2, not replicate 3. I think 3 is fixed if anyone can test it on test build.
I can't replicate 7 apart from that it removes the map from the collection. It doesn't crash in public nor test build.
1. Not being able to organize collections should be an issue to be fixed. You can't rename a collection and you can't organize them.
2. If you have text in the name box when you close, a collection is added. I did not consider typing text into a box as submitting a collection. Hitting enter makes the collection visible. I'm not sure why pressing close has the same effect as pressing Enter. Actually clicking any button adds a collection. I doubt this is intended.
3. <test build only> the + - buttons don't take the state of add mapset. Even though add mapset is unchecked by default, it will still add the entire mapset.
4. It's annoying to have to keep selecting Add Mapset for each song.
5. Managing collections button collapses the expanded collection list. This is unwanted behavior since there is no way of viewing which maps are in a collection from the collection window. Could you add a collection management feature similar to how osudirect is structured? I don't think a GUI less management system is the way to go.
6. Managing collections is horribly inefficient. I have to click manage collections for each map individually and then select add mapset, and select the collection. There needs to be a way to add or remove several maps within the same screen. The current method requires you change your sorts and filters. You can't use the search feature with collections filter.
7. It is impossible to find which collections contain a beatmap if you have a difficulty that isn't included with the collection selected. Even clicking on add mapset wont highlight the map. I think that if you click add mapset, it should show all collections that the selected difficulty is in regardless if that difficulty is added to any collection. It is slightly misleading that the game will say that the entire mapset isn't part of any collection when only a single difficulty isn't included. If this doesn't make sense, please include show options for any difficulty and all difficulties in the collection management window.
8. Don't bother including your WIPs into a collection. You will need to constantly readd them each time you make a change.
9. the game does not make it obvious that a song is being removed from a collection because of edited changes or updates. You could just look for a song via a collection one day and find that the song no longer appears in your list. I consider collections to be a more stable way to organize your beatmaps. The tendency to remove your beatmaps from collections without warning irks me. Please have the game readd beatmaps to collections after they get changed.
10. Pressing delete collection unselects the collection. If you select No, there will be no collections selected.More of an inconvenience than unintentional behavior.
why is this marked as duplicate. can someone please explain this?
I don't know. I fixed it.
I've addressed the add mapset issue in the latest test build.
The vast majority of these issues are either symptoms of other issues or resolved in the latest test build. Only two left.
I wouldn't be so sure. Even if all of the current issues are resolved in the test build, I wouldn't resolve this until the changes go public.
I'm not resolving it anyhow, there are still two (admittedly quite minor) issues remaining. And aren't we supposed to mark things as resolved once they're fixed on test?
Collection group is collapsed when I leave manage collection screen.
Steps to reproduce:
1. Choose any map in any collection
2. Go to Beatmap options - Manage collections
3. Close manage collections screen
4. osu! collapses collection group and scrolls up to top of collections list.
ps I'm sorry if this issue already posted somewhere but i did not find it.
Steps to reproduce:
1. Choose any map in any collection
2. Go to Beatmap options - Manage collections
3. Close manage collections screen
4. osu! collapses collection group and scrolls up to top of collections list.
ps I'm sorry if this issue already posted somewhere but i did not find it.
Added that to the bug list. I can still replicate the other two issues.
Two of the three issues have been fixed, so the thread has been renamed to match the last one. The last one had an attempted fix, but the fix failed, as it still happens on latest test.
Changing gamemodes also selects last one.
I really hope this is getting fixed soon
For me this is the most annoying thing.
For me this is the most annoying thing.
I agree with skritsch the main topic here still isn't fixed and this bug is the most frustrating bug in the game for me. It happens literally more than 20 times every time i play osu!. Would love to see a fix.
amenDalvoid wrote:
I agree with skritsch the main topic here still isn't fixed and this bug is the most frustrating bug in the game for me. It happens literally more than 20 times every time i play osu!. Would love to see a fix.
Nothing would make me more happy then this fix. Its been a really annoying problem ever since the improved collection system was available. You can do this, go gogo!
Honestly, this issue has become far more annoying now that collections are forced into alphabetical sorting because before, we could create the collections in a specific order so the one we use the most would be the one expanded usually after a play, but since this is no longer the case, this issue is a much bigger problem. And we can't even rename them as a temporary fix to put them in the order we would like them. It's horrible.
I've tested it multiple times, it seems like the focus will return to the correct Collection after playing a map.
However, accessing the Collection Menu (F3) at song select will make the Collection Collapse. If current Collection is expanded again, the focus will return to the correct map again.
Minor issue but can be annoying at times...
However, accessing the Collection Menu (F3) at song select will make the Collection Collapse. If current Collection is expanded again, the focus will return to the correct map again.
Minor issue but can be annoying at times...