wmfchris wrote:

Taiko mod as requested

HP drain rate -> 5/6 I think 4 is fine as that's my usual practice ...?

00:49:478 - broken slider I actually made those deliberately, because when the slider is snapped, it has only 4 hits with unknown reason ( See this ) and I had to adjust the slider length in .osu to fix it. However, it seems that only the slider at 00:49 has this problem. So I just decided to set all sliders into a same value so that all of them have 5 hits and they all look better than the one when snapped.
I've talked with cRyo and he agreed to keep these sliders ( Chatlog )
01:38:889 - broken slider
02:21:242 - broken slider
02:35:359 - broken slider
02:43:522 - maybe you can make use of that sound in this section to put more notes (like ddk d) to push the ending of the song to climax Added a slider and 2 notes ~

yo, just some technical problem, the rest is fine. re-pull the slider a bit will do.

Thx for your modding

1. (Easy) - Make a same hitsound as previous one at 00:38:889 (1,2)
2. (Easy) - New combo at 02:07:125 (3) for combo pattern
3. (Normal) - Remapped some part for reason
4. (Hard) - Remove the whistle that used on sliderbody (except for normal hitsound)

Leorda wrote:

IRC Modding

1. (Easy) - Make a same hitsound as previous one at 00:38:889 (1,2)
2. (Easy) - New combo at 02:07:125 (3) for combo pattern
3. (Normal) - Remapped some part for reason
4. (Hard) - Remove the whistle that used on sliderbody (except for normal hitsound)

Bubbled

P.S. if anyone talking about unsnapped tail slider in aabc's Taiko, it's fine. If you don't believe it, talk with her. It's a bug of taiko (?)

Snowy Dream wrote:

Mod request from Snowy Dream's 骗KDS
-------------------------------------------------
[Easy]
02:19:478 (1) - spacing a little small (nazi)
02:58:301 (1) - EASY不要使用任何跳最好..
01:53:448 (1) - 有蓝色区域 修复好
a bit fixed spacing thx ><!


[Insane]
00:50:139 (2) - spacing？
这个难度相比前几个有点乱 0.0 虽然的确insane是会乱 不过看来乃之前的mapset都还好..
还是不习惯跳太多啊.-. i guess its because this is the only 1/3 map that i made ww
--------------------------------------------------
这图快rank

1. The 1/4 notes like 00:31:279 (2) - etc do seem a bit tricky for Easy, but since you keep the same rhythm for most of the map I think new players will be able to follow it.

1. The unsnapped slider ends are still okay? Apart from seems fine.

1. Honestly I think the map would be better without the x1.50 section. The patterns and sliders start to look ugly; if it was x1.25 I think it would flow and play better. It's fine as it is if you want to keep it but idk... that section just ruined the flow of the map for me.

Shulin wrote:

I got distracted and this took me a lot longer than I intended lol, mainly hitsound suggestions ~

[Easy]

1. The 1/4 notes like 00:31:279 (2) - etc do seem a bit tricky for Easy, but since you keep the same rhythm for most of the map I think new players will be able to follow it.

well yeah actually i fully remaped my E and N diffs during the moding xD, i tried to use simpe *white tick rhytm* but it sounds very bad....so i desided make normal rhytm which will follow song even if it will be more difficult then ordinary E/N maps, also used a lot of sliders to make it a bit easier

00:07:897 (2) - Reduce volume on this tick to about 20-25%, since the tick lands on 1/4 it sounds bad.
00:14:956 (2) - ^ ~ also snap this slider back to the timeline.
00:35:801 (2) - Remove whistle from the end?
01:24:772 (3) - Remove whistle from the end and add clap. It seems to follow your hitsound pattern.
01:25:985 (4) - Add clap?
02:07:125 (1) - Remove whistle from the end and add clap? i want to keep this one o.o!
02:08:338 (2) - Clap?
02:11:536 (2) - Clap instead of whistle to keep the pattern consistent?
02:57:308 (2) - Reduce the volume on this tick?
other changed !
i decided to mute slider ticks(NC1/NC2), and put low volume normal-sliderslide for both NC instead of blanket one :3
[Normal]

00:07:897 (3) - Reduce volume of the tick to about 20-25%? Sounds bad imo
00:14:955 (2) - ^
02:57:308 (2) - ^
03:04:367 (2) - ^

[aabc's taiko]

1. The unsnapped slider ends are still okay? Apart from seems fine.

since AI mod said its fine, i guess so ^^
[Hard]

00:52:345 (4) - Align this with 00:52:014 (3) -
01:39:661 (3) - This slider is ugly... why not use a shape like 01:39:661 (3) - and rotate it?
01:44:955 (4) - ^ ;__;
01:59:514 (6) - ^ it's that slider again lol
all changed ^^
[Insane]

1. Honestly I think the map would be better without the x1.50 section. The patterns and sliders start to look ugly; if it was x1.25 I think it would flow and play better. It's fine as it is if you want to keep it but idk... that section just ruined the flow of the map for me.

01:47:051 (6) - This would be better as a straight slider or something like 02:14:625 (5) -
some players said its funny, someONE!!! (not you xD) also said whyyyyyyyyyy, dunno i think its funny www
btw changed some sliders a bit ^^
Let me know if you change anything and I'll rebubble this.

1. Ranking criteria says you can't silence both the sliderslide and the ticks (that's why I said just reduce the volume) so I say remove the silent tick and reduce the volume to about 20-25% as I suggested earlier.

1. Your Insane has an extra space at the end of the difficulty name (I was wondering why it said not submitted >.<) fix this by just typing in Insane and press enter lol

Shulin wrote:

I'm here again

[General]

1. Ranking criteria says you can't silence both the sliderslide and the ticks (that's why I said just reduce the volume) so I say remove the silent tick and reduce the volume to about 20-25% as I suggested earlier.

i know but my slider slide not muted, u can check samples, its low volume (so technically i didnt break the rules ^^)
[Easy]

00:17:713 (1) - The same thing I said in Normal about switching in the middle of the slider, it sounds bad. Remember to keep the silent sliderslide active
00:26:536 (1) - ^
01:07:125 (1) - ^
01:14:183 (1) - ^
01:55:985 (2) - Why not use 1/1 here like Normal?
01:57:750 (2) - ^
01:59:514 (2) - ^
02:01:279 (2) - ^

Actually this might be harder than normal because you use sliders to cover 1/4 notes in Normal but not here, I'll have to ask a new player to play. If you wanted to make it even easier I'd suggest doing things like 01:21:242 (1,2) - more often instead of ending with a 1/4 note at the end of a long slider. Just a thought, it's up to you.
remapped this parts, and changed all N to NC1 o.o!
[Normal]

00:18:595 (3) - When you switch to normal hitsound in the middle of the slider you can hear the normal slider slide which sounds very odd. Did you forget to use the silent slider slide here?
00:19:919 (1,2,3) - ^
00:28:301 (1) - ^
01:08:007 (3,1) - ^
01:11:095 (4) - ^
01:55:654 (2) - Remove clap from this end? It doesn't really work with the song imo. this claps fine imo, too keep rhytm
01:57:860 (4) - ^
01:59:183 (2) - ^
02:01:389 (4) - ^
02:01:830 (1) - Same thing about switching hitsound in the middle of the slider, but this time it's soft lol
02:03:595 (1) - ^
02:11:095 (2) - This one should be 55% volume like the others? yep~
changed all N to NC1
[Insane]

1. Your Insane has an extra space at the end of the difficulty name (I was wondering why it said not submitted >.<) fix this by just typing in Insane and press enter lol

changed ww

Phew, almost there

Shulin wrote:

Rebubbled

Good luck.

Snowy Dream wrote:

> < Nice bubble

Reiji-RJ wrote:

Go go rank!!

• Everything looks good, apart from the two backgrounds you have to change. I'm glad to see a full spread like this. Oh yeah, tick rate 2 sounds much better with this song, because the drums are a constant 1/2. =P

• Pretty good. Lower AR by one though, as it's pretty high right and now, and the difference between OD and AR is too big. The rhythms used are quite complex for an Easy, but it plays fine and fits the song.

• Looks rather nice, except for a couple sliders that break your comboing and throw up the consistency of the map:

1. 00:18:595 (3) - The new combo should be on this slider's end (on the big white tick), but you can't put a new combo on these, and that breaks your comboing. Remove the repeat from the slider and add a circle where it ended (with a new combo) to fix this. (don't forget to remove the new combo on the next object)
2. 00:20:801 (2) - Same for this. Apparently, you went for a new combo every big white tick, but this slider stops this from being even possible.
3. 01:08:007 (3) - Same as 00:18:595 -
4. 01:10:654 (3) - For consistency in your comboing, add a new combo here.
5. 02:30:838 (2,3,4) - This rhythm (and all the others that follow) sound pretty confusing and substantially harder to play than what you've been using so far. The added 1/2 isn't directly hearable in the song, and the pattern and low spacing makes the clicking confusing.

1. This is too hard and the score is too high. The difficulty spread is unbalanced as it is now. You'll have to make this easier. You can start my greatly reducing the number of 1/4s in this diff...
2. 00:07:566 (2,3) - And all similar patterns: this jump is very surprising and makes the rhythm used here unclear. (2,3) are spaced as if they were 1/1 apart, but they are 3/4 apart.
3. 00:49:478 (1,2,3) - I found this pattern to be pretty confusing. I thought the first two sliders were 1/4 apart and had been placed like this for symmetry. Can you redesign this to make it a bit less confusing ?

1. I fail to understand the logic under the 1/4 spacing. Some are regularly spaced, others are jumps, and it changes even within the same combo (like 00:30:948 (3,4,5) - ). I personnally think that spacing them all normally would play and look better, especially during that very surprising speedup, when the 1/4 spacing becomes huge and similar to what was previously 1/2 spacing.
2. 01:35:801 (3,4) - Space these normally ? The same part of the song just a few seconds later has no jump, while this one has one - it's inconsistent.
3. 02:39:330 (2,3,4) - see what I said above for 1/4 spacing
4. 02:43:522 (6) - Please change the shape of this slider. It goes back on itself right now and is borderline rankable.
5. 02:50:580 (1) - Same.
6. 03:02:272 (3,4,5,6) - Any reason why this spacing is so... Weird ?

• That's just me being nazi and all but why not add "Oni" at the end of the name ? ;_;

Dark_Ai wrote:

This Map is okay for me ;>
Nothing to say

Good luck with ranked~

nold_1702 wrote:

SPOILER

19:37 nold_1702: : 02:12:418 (1) - 
19:37 nold_1702: : snap it
19:38 nold_1702: : a unsnap
19:38 nold_1702: : You can resnap it by moving 
19:38 nold_1702: : it
19:40 nold_1702: : useless time sections:
19:40 nold_1702: : 28853
19:40 nold_1702: : 121720
19:40 nold_1702: : 166279
19:40 nold_1702: : [Insane]
19:41 nold_1702: : 121720
19:41 nold_1702: : 127235
19:41 nold_1702: : [Normal]
19:41 nold_1702: : 72088

wmfchris wrote:

So when this is ready find me again? <_<

h3k1ru wrote:

SPOILER

Byakugan249 wrote:

[aabc's Taiko]
00:51:022 (1) - i feel that this should be a K. it should follow up the drumroll to the next note in this part. I guess you're saying that I should remove the finish here. Done for the consistency. Didn't notice this b4 www
01:12:860 (2) - i feel that this K doesn't fit since there's no cymbals in the drums. make this a k to follow the drums in this part. I'll keep it as K because it's intended to follow the vocal. You can notice that both 1 & 2 have the same level of high pitch, so using K will be nice imo ~
02:01:389 - consider adding 2 notes here to continue the drumroll. i suggest d k as it plays nicely with the drumroll IMO. I'll also keep this because I want to keep the pattern consistent. ( o o o o oooo pattern )

Shiro wrote:

So, I was rechecking this, and you changed nothing in the Hard and the Insane. The Hard is still too hard (mainly rhythm-wise) and the spacing in Insane is still inconsistent. I can't possibly rebubble this. You didn't even change the comboing in the Normal difficulty. Changing just a few minor things to make it look like you considered the mod isn't the right way to go.

I'll just leave this to be checked by other BATs or MATs. If they think that's good, fine by me, I won't stop this from getting ranked - but I won't bubble it.

LKs wrote:

I'm not clear of the other issues but as for the Hard, it's ok for me. The mapper follow the song precisely so I don't see any hardship for an advanced player

You'd bargain and discuss. That's all from me

Shiro wrote:

You didn't even change the comboing in the Normal difficulty.

Shiro wrote:

Changing just a few minor things to make it look like you considered the mod isn't the right way to go.

OnosakiHito wrote:

Leorda asked me about the sliders. So I'm here to fix your taiko sliders!

00:49:478 (2) - 256,192,49478,2,0,B|256:32,1,161 256,192,49478,2,0,B|256:32,1,154.000004699707 256,192,49478,2,0,B|256:32,1,155
01:38:889 (2) - 256,192,98889,2,0,B|256:16,1,161 256,192,98889,2,0,B|256:32,1,154.000004699707 256,192,98889,2,0,B|256:32,1,155
02:21:242 (2) - 256,192,141242,2,0,B|256:32,1,161 256,192,141242,2,0,B|256:32,1,154.000004699707 256,192,141242,2,0,B|256:32,1,155
02:35:359 (2) - 256,192,155359,2,0,B|256:16,1,176 256,192,155360,2,0,B|256:16,1,167.999994873047 256,192,155360,2,0,B|256:16,1,169

http://puu.sh/R0Jl

I think it should be okay if I do it for aabc, since I know him really well.

Kawayi Rika wrote:

Hi ~ cRyo[iceeicee] ~

Checked map for my Random Queue ~ really perfect to me ~ Nice job ~!

Just a issue in taiko diff :

00:49:478 (2) - Unsnapped slider (end point).
01:38:889 (2) - ^
02:21:242 (2) - ^

Fix and call me back ~

SapphireGhost wrote:

If Kawayi Rika rebubbles this, I can probably try to rank it afterwards and you can move on to your real life things. Lastly, are you sure the title is correct? I couldn't find any matches when looking for a source. Is there a source?

Kawayi Rika wrote:

Hi ~ cRyo[iceeicee] ~

Checked map for my Random Queue ~ really perfect to me ~ Nice job ~!

Just a issue in taiko diff :

00:49:478 (2) - Unsnapped slider (end point).
01:38:889 (2) - ^
02:21:242 (2) - ^

Fix and call me back ~

Snapped slider ( Missing hit )

Unsnapped slider ( No missing hit )

Snowy Dream wrote:

=v=?
What's エトセトラ Could I eat this?

aabc271 wrote:

As the title is changed, please overwrite the existing taiko bg with this :3

And btw, seems that the title of normal & insane haven't been changed properly ( Issues of capital letters ). You may want to recheck them and full submit ~

cRyo[iceeicee] wrote:

aabc271 wrote:

As the title is changed, please overwrite the existing taiko bg with this :3

And btw, seems that the title of normal & insane haven't been changed properly ( Issues of capital letters ). You may want to recheck them and full submit ~

Changed !
idk what happened to titles, i rechecked it and everything was fine o:

Kawayi Rika wrote:

OK ~ Looks fine now ~

Here we go :3

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Quick question, I looked up the album on vgmdb http://vgmdb.net/album/34742 , and it said that the album was published by monoROSETTA and composed by void. Wouldn't that make "void" the artist.

Edit: I went to check the past few Touhou songs that were ranked, and it seems like the current trend is to use either Circle name or artist name. As a result, the artist name is probably fine....

Edit 2: Bubble repair to add void to the tags.

Garven wrote:

[General]
Tick rate 2 fits this song best. I+H = ST2, E+N = ST1
You can't have the sliderslide and the slidertick silenced for such large portions of the song. The sliderslide is too quiet, so it is effectively silenced. Just use the default soft sliderslide sound for an easy fix since I'm sure you're morally opposed to ticks. ok +Ticks \x.x/
No kiai? Fountain \^^/
Is monoROSETTA - Koi no recipe to Et cetera (cRyo[iceeicee]).osb an old file from a previous name? removed

[Easy]
00:30:948 (2,1) - This really isn't an easy-level-friendly technique to use. Simplify it please.
00:38:007 (2,1) - ^
01:20:360 (2,1) - ^ etc. I won't point them out anymore.
ok x.x
02:51:242 (1) - Fairly soon after a spinner for an Easy. At least position it closer to the center please, but I'd prefer more recovery time regardless. moved it closer to center, this spinner is not short and i think its enough recovery time for 2.34 star diff !

[Insane]
01:06:353 (4) - Whistle on sliderslide there was some slider slide whistle, but now i removed it ^^

Saturos-fangirl wrote:

[aabc]
Might want to label it as an Oni
I actually name my diffs as "aabc's Taiko" unless it's a taiko-only mapset
( You can refer to this for proof )
So I think it's fine to keep the name unchanged for consistency ~
Edit : If you're referring to adding tags of "Oni", I'm fine with that. I can find cRyo to do so ~

Saturos-fangirl wrote:

[Easy]
looks amazing

[Normal]
ok you really need to do something about that tick rate, only having ticks as a hiccup at the end of sliders is weird. I suggest a tick rate of 2 or 4 (4 is kind of super high but makes it symmetrical, 2 is a nice compromise)

[Hard]
looks great

[aabc]
Might want to label it as an Oni

[Insane]
this map is incredibly well done in all difficulties I wish you the best of luck in getting it ranked ASAP

Garven wrote:

wut. I suggested tick rate 2 for all maps. 2 would make the awkward tick rate 1, which you originally had, better. Also: if you change the tick rate, it'll have to be rebubbled again. =P

h3k1ru wrote:

＼(〇O〇)／

1. Snap all green lines in all diffs çwç

1. 00:30:066 (1) - I can hear a sound similar to a clap here. I suggest you to use clap on this slider's end removing it from 00:30:948 (2)'s head instead
2. 00:37:125 (1,2) - ^
3. 00:38:889 (1,2) - ^

1. 00:14:955 (2) - Forgot clap on the slider's end?

1. Looks awesome

1. 00:41:978 (3) - Use 2.19x spacing from the previous circle to keep consistency
2. 02:02:272 (2) - x:364 y:144 for symmetry with (1) and (3)

1. 00:12:198 Add kat
2. 00:20:470 The vocal starts here. Add a kat?
3. 00:21:353 ^ add a don?
4. 01:38:448 (5,1) - k d instead of d k, the sound is really much better
5. 01:39:992 (4) - kat
6. 00:49:478 (2) - Unsnapped slider's end
7. 01:38:889 (2) - ^
8. 02:21:242 (2) - ^

Chewin wrote:

[General]

1. Snap all green lines in all diffs çwç The green lines are already snapped ?
   
   [Taiko]
   
   
   1. 00:12:198 Add kat My original intention was to make this part a bit easier ( Beginning of song ), but I've added one because this sounds valid ~
   2. 00:20:470 The vocal starts here. Add a kat? But I would like to keep a similar pattern with 01:09:110 ( ooo o & o ooo ), so I'll keep this unchanged ~
   3. 00:21:353 ^ add a don? ^
   4. 01:38:448 (5,1) - k d instead of d k, the sound is really much better I'll say d k fits better in this case. You can notice that I map based on vocal, but not drum. As the slider part is significantly higher in pitch, I wanna use d k to show the rising pitch ( k d gives the opposite feeling and so they don't really fit the coming slider )
   5. 01:39:992 (4) - kat Um... OK. Also changed other similar parts ~
   6. 00:49:478 (2) - Unsnapped slider's end Why don't you guys read the map description x_x See this
      To other Mats / Bats : I hope you guys won't complain about this again. Other mats / bats like Garven, Rika & kpy all agreed to be rankable and I don't think there's any valid reason for me to use broken sliders instead of complete ones Orz
   7. 01:38:889 (2) - ^ ^
   8. 02:21:242 (2) - ^ ^

Yusura Sakurae wrote:

why don't you set a kiai time to Easy , Normal , Hard , Insane
taiko has kiai time ....
Well, I think kiai sections fit well in taiko ww
I'm not sure how's the effects in other diffs, but I believe cRyo has a strong reason for not using them
At least from what I remember, it's not a must to follow the same kiai sections in all diffs, as long as they make sense :3

Chewin wrote:

Hi cRyo <3 Chewiiiiiin <3
Garven asked me for a recheck and.. let's start.

[General]

1. Snap all green lines in all diffs çwç

but i dont know which of them snapped and which not www, its because everytime when i want to change section for 1 note i using double click and new section automaticly appears 100ms later from previous (just saving time x.x) so everything should works correctly, kiai and SV changes always normally snapped ^^

[Easy]

1. 00:30:066 (1) - I can hear a sound similar to a clap here. I suggest you to use clap on this slider's end removing it from 00:30:948 (2)'s head instead
2. 00:37:125 (1,2) - ^
3. 00:38:889 (1,2) - ^

i used consistent rhytm with claps and whistles on whole map, i think it sounds fine :>

[Normal]

1. 00:14:955 (2) - Forgot clap on the slider's end?

no i just decided to end without claps :3, same with 00:07:897 (3) - , 03:04:367 (2) -

[Hard]

1. Looks awesome

[Insane]

1. 00:41:978 (3) - Use 2.19x spacing from the previous circle to keep consistency waaaaa my bad, fixed ~
2. 02:02:272 (2) - x:364 y:144 for symmetry with (1) and (3) yeah!

Call me back ;3

Yusura Sakurae wrote:

nice map!!

why don't you set a kiai time to Easy , Normal , Hard , Insane
taiko has kiai time .... kiai brings bad luck \o.o/ just dont like kiai ww

hmm....

this map will be ranked ! i'm practicing now~ yeah lets hope ww

Chewin wrote:

[Easy]

02:11:536 (2) - To keep consistency with 02:04:478 (2) remove whistles, or, at least, remove it from the head like the other diffs

I noticed it just now, sorry.

Chewin wrote:

Nice, have your bubble :3

Garven wrote:

Make the slider ticks audible or the slider slide louder. You know why.

Garven wrote:

Well, so much for setting that up for a rank. Since tick rates were changed -again- I have to rebubble.

1. 01:34:367 (2,1,2,3) - For the beginner, the difference between these spacings is a bit too difficult to read imo. Try to use the same pattern as 00:45:948 (1,2) or 02:31:830 (1,2)?
2. 02:17:713 (1,2,3) - ^ Same here.

1. 00:49:478 (2) - Unsnapped slider end.　O|￣|＿
2. 01:38:889 (2) - ^
3. 02:21:242 (2) - ^

Suzully wrote:

Don't need to wait so long time

[aabc's Taiko]

1. 00:49:478 (2) - Unsnapped slider end.　O|￣|＿
2. 01:38:889 (2) - ^
3. 02:21:242 (2) - ^

Tell me when done fixes.

Kawayi Rika wrote:

Suzully wrote:

Don't need to wait so long time

[aabc's Taiko]

1. 00:49:478 (2) - Unsnapped slider end.　O|￣|＿
2. 01:38:889 (2) - ^
3. 02:21:242 (2) - ^

Tell me when done fixes.

Again ~you are forgot see this p/1742682

Suzully wrote:

Don't need to wait so long time

[Easy]

1. 01:34:367 (2,1,2,3) - For the beginner, the difference between these spacings is a bit too difficult to read imo. Try to use the same pattern as 00:45:948 (1,2) or 02:31:830 (1,2)?
2. 02:17:713 (1,2,3) - ^ Same here.

both changed to sliders!
[aabc's Taiko]

1. 00:49:478 (2) - Unsnapped slider end.　O|￣|＿
2. 01:38:889 (2) - ^
3. 02:21:242 (2) - ^

Tell me when done fixes.

Suzully wrote:

~

Mythol wrote:

Touch me now~ \></