1. Demente (3,96 stars, 222 notes)
2. Hard (3,03 stars, 161 notes)
3. Normal (1,78 stars, 104 notes)

murutattack wrote:

Modding Request from #modreqs o/

General

+ Remove Widescreen Support
+ Remove Letterbox During Breaks work for 15 seconds

Normal

The Slider Velocities is kinda low for 166bpm, and its normal Difficulty, but its creator preference, so this is just headups.

00:21:229 - Since this song is around 1:02 Minutes, Breaks isn`t really necessary after this spinner, continue add note/slider after spinner. continuing
00:48:230 - Remove the repeated and turn to Slider, then add note in 00:48:230. Like it gives kick on this note, note added

00:58:542 - I think no need for x0.5 slowdown speed, might screw the DS settings. Hard is fine for this.
I suggest turn this one to this timeline :
Or other similarities i choose other similarities

Hard

Need to lower the Slider Velocity on this one, or raise more on Normal difficulty but lower a bit on Hard Difficulty. From 0.8x to 1.6x is really not normal :p SV will be 1,3
Disable Widescreen/Letterbox Support

00:05:667 - Difficulty Spikes on this slider, I suggest like, CTRL+G the (5) then use 1.3x DS for the (6) note, so player requires jump to last note, but not too high. i done only slider
00:10:542 - Maybe remove this note. maybe...maybe...OK, done
00:22:730 - Same problem after finish spinner, continue the song without break continuing

Insane (Demente)

I can`t play it, but only fix on cosmetic issues :p
Should set this to AR9 I will set additionally AR 7 in Hard to keep a balance
00:42:618 - Move to x:103, y:254 I did another way

This is nice map, good luck for ranking

Prismetical wrote:

Heya. :3

Normal

00:45:230 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Seems a bit odd I'm not guess

Hard

00:09:042 (7) - Hard to see I have deleted this and done something forward
00:30:230 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - Also Hard to see Ok, it will be easier to see, but might be harder to play
00:39:792 (2,3,4,5,6) - Weird order There is nothing wrong with that
00:36:792 (2,3,4,5,6) - ^ ^
00:57:230 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Weird for a player, because you first think it's about the trumpets and not the claps Claps will be, because people in the song are doing the same
I would change the Approach Rate, so the circles dissapear faster after clicking. AR has nothing to do with it I think

Mollon wrote:

hi~ here is my mod. forget my poor english.

easy
I think its well to me.

hard
00:05:667 (5) - maybe a little down would be better. i did it probably
in principle,there are too many single taps continuously,and the sliders are almostly all the same.
try some changes to improve the intrest.others are cool. after this sentence I was forced to watch your maps

insane
00:11:480 (9) - nice slider! initially I didn't know how to do it, but I remembered the loop who did Lesjuh in Lou Bega's song
00:45:980 (7,8,9) - i think its too far..(playable actually.) trumpets got a office power, that's it
00:48:417 (1,2,3,4) - maybe single tap with random jump or triangle jump would be better. its a nice place to place jumps.rhythm after this point is the same. I have to think over it well, because it's insane and it makes me huge boiler of nerves when I do something complicated.
00:58:355 (4,5) - 01:01:355 (4,5) - its intresting but i guess its against rank rule. Oh, dafuk, my mistake

really very nice map and cool music!I could learn a lot from your map.thank you for using my modding queue~

ReFaller wrote:

Mollon wrote:

hi~ here is my mod. forget my poor english.

easy
I think its well to me.

hard
00:05:667 (5) - maybe a little down would be better. i did it probably
in principle,there are too many single taps continuously,and the sliders are almostly all the same.
try some changes to improve the intrest.others are cool. after this sentence I was forced to watch your maps

insane
00:11:480 (9) - nice slider! initially I didn't know how to do it, but I remembered the loop who did Lesjuh in Lou Bega's song
00:45:980 (7,8,9) - i think its too far..(playable actually.) trumpets got a office power, that's it
00:48:417 (1,2,3,4) - maybe single tap with random jump or triangle jump would be better. its a nice place to place jumps.rhythm after this point is the same. I have to think over it well, because it's insane and it makes me huge boiler of nerves when I do something complicated.
00:58:355 (4,5) - 01:01:355 (4,5) - its intresting but i guess its against rank rule. Oh, dafuk, my mistake

really very nice map and cool music!I could learn a lot from your map.thank you for using my modding queue~

some information as always useful, good job

AmigoDoChroome wrote:

[ General]

1. Nice idea, perfect song! Good Lucky!

[ Normal]

1. 00:00:230 (1) - better in x:140 y:208 i'm not guess

1. 00:00:605 (2) - ^ x:212 y:256 ^

1. 00:00:980 (3) - x:256 y:180 ^

1. 00:24:230 (1) - 00:32:480 (4) - the clap repetitive hitsound they are according to claps done by people

[ Hard]

1. 00:18:042 (11) - very high combo i have reduced temporarily in 00:17:480 (1)

1. 00:22:542 (6,7,8,9) - positioning this strange cool (y)

1. 00:54:230 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - NICE!

1. 00:30:605 (2,3) - far it's hard who may contains short jumps

[ Demente]

1. 00:00:230 (1) - start the map with a pattern, It is more pleasant i changed start place with curving it

1. 00:05:480 (9,10,11,12) - wtf, that jumps, less distance please trying with switching order 00:05:667 (10,11)

1. 00:17:855 (4,5,6,7,1) - less distance, or make a other stream it's part of triangle pattern with 00:17:480 (2,3)

1. 00:27:605 (3) - this can not be approved of course might be

1. 00:30:230 (1,2,4,5) - Nice bro!yea, now it's more NICE

1. 00:32:480 (6,7,8,9) - curved stream pls without detailed idolizing

1. 00:33:230 (1,2,3,4) - Wtf bro, the distance insane love jumps

Wingmann wrote:

Hi!

Normal:
01:02:855 (5) - Maybe move to x220 y128 for another blanket? (your choice) and good choice
Hard:
00:26:855 (8,1) - Make the slider into a small blanket? 00:27:792 (3) is blanket with 00:26:855 (8) - rest is the stacking
Demente:
00:24:230 (12) - Why a new combo? I see how it starts the new beat but I don't think it suits. Just my opinion NC bye bye
00:42:605 (4,5,6,7,8) - Maybe make these into a star? http://prntscr.com/8wstqj ok, you know what do here

That's all. Great song, and good luck with ranking!

• - First, in the Demente difficulty, at 00:24:230 (12,1) I would switch these 2 notes on the timeline so that it is like this:
  
  
  
  
  Then, obviously change their positions to make it look good again.
  
  - Second, it is not that big of a change, but the offset sounds better to me at 224, so change it if you want.

HydroCannon13 wrote:

Ok, very short mod because this mapset is so good

I just have a few things to say.

• - First, in the Demente difficulty, at 00:24:230 (12,1) I would switch these 2 notes on the timeline so that it is like this:
  
  
  
  very good option, it will be sounds better
  
  Then, obviously change their positions to make it look good again.
  
  - Second, it is not that big of a change, but the offset sounds better to me at 224, so change it if you want.

I changed offset as earlier as possible, so more earlier will be too early.

Other than these, I absolutely love this mapset and please rank it! Tenk ju wery macz (Thank you very much)

1. 00:10:730 (1,1) - Unrankable stuff, the spinner recovery time there is not enough because on Normal at least it should be have 750ms as recovery time after a spinner
2. 00:34:167 (1) - I think it best not to NC there to keep it consistent, like you did on Hard and Insane
3. 00:41:480 (6,7) - Hmm that stacking kinda out of place imo, unless the trumpet sounded like this 00:33:230 (1,2) - and 00:34:167 (1,2) - a stacking will fit perfectly. So maybe better not to stacking 00:41:480 (6,7) - ?
4. 00:45:230 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - That consecutive long circles might be troublesome to beginner player, maybe change some into 1/1 slider might be better there, so it'll play easier

1. 00:35:480 (1,1) - Those overlap looks bad when playing imo, also give more space on 00:35:480 (1) - might be good as a sudden low spacing make the flow kinda bad to play. Maybe a placement something like this might good http://puu.sh/ldtLH/d3946a4db6.jpg
2. 00:45:230 (1,2,3,4,5) - Maybe move all to x:196 y:52? so the movement here 00:44:855 (9,1) - more natural
3. 00:46:542 (5,6) - I don't understand the spacing there, why you sudden spaced more on (5,6)?

1. First, personaly the combo is way too long (e.g. 00:45:323 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14) - ) and imo It would be nice if you make the nc on every single downbeat to cut the long nc
2. 00:17:855 (4,5,6,7) - Imo by following the trumpet sound the stream there a bit overmapped, so maybe by deleting (5) the stream will sound more reasonable?
3. 00:27:605 (3,4) - Tbh the placement of (3) kinda make me confused on playing, that placement can cause misleading toward this slider 00:27:792 (4) -
4. It would be nice if you nerf down some jumps like 00:44:480 (4,5,6,7) - and 00:45:980 (7,8,9) - 00:56:480 (7,8,9,10) - so the diffspread more balance on hard->insane
5. 01:02:855 (11) - How about a circle instead on 01:02:855 - to make it consistent on all diff to stop there? because the slider ending here 01:03:042 not really good to ending the song

Mako Sakata wrote:

Hellooo as requested,
Some small sugestion

[Normal]
Before applied this mod for a map: From this moment i think this might be the worst diff in this mapset, cuz i know it's wrong

1. 00:10:730 (1,1) - Unrankable stuff, the spinner recovery time there is not enough because on Normal at least it should be have 750ms as recovery time after a spinner shorten or something, i don't know, i'll try to shorten a little
2. 00:34:167 (1) - I think it best not to NC there to keep it consistent, like you did on Hard and Insane no problem, easy
3. 00:41:480 (6,7) - Hmm that stacking kinda out of place imo, unless the trumpet sounded like this 00:33:230 (1,2) - and 00:34:167 (1,2) - a stacking will fit perfectly. So maybe better not to stacking 00:41:480 (6,7) - ? this too
4. 00:45:230 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - That consecutive long circles might be troublesome to beginner player, maybe change some into 1/1 slider might be better there, so it'll play easier this gave me an idea for reduce 1/1 spam

[Hard]

1. 00:35:480 (1,1) - Those overlap looks bad when playing imo, also give more space on 00:35:480 (1) - might be good as a sudden low spacing make the flow kinda bad to play. Maybe a placement something like this might good http://puu.sh/ldtLH/d3946a4db6.jpg with BG it's easy
2. 00:45:230 (1,2,3,4,5) - Maybe move all to x:196 y:52? so the movement here 00:44:855 (9,1) - more natural how much natural?
3. 00:46:542 (5,6) - I don't understand the spacing there, why you sudden spaced more on (5,6)? ok, usually fixed

[Insane]

1. First, personaly the combo is way too long (e.g. 00:45:323 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14) - ) and imo It would be nice if you make the nc on every single downbeat to cut the long nc and add: correct NC by every the big black thite tick
2. 00:17:855 (4,5,6,7) - Imo by following the trumpet sound the stream there a bit overmapped, so maybe by deleting (5) the stream will sound more reasonable? try with deleting...what....oh 00:17:948 (6,8) - them
3. 00:27:605 (3,4) - Tbh the placement of (3) kinda make me confused on playing, that placement can cause misleading toward this slider 00:27:792 (4) - i have changed also a flow due to this thing
4. It would be nice if you nerf down some jumps like 00:44:480 (4,5,6,7) - and 00:45:980 (7,8,9) - 00:56:480 (7,8,9,10) - so the diffspread more balance on hard->insane i tried to do some good
5. 01:02:855 (11) - How about a circle instead on 01:02:855 - to make it consistent on all diff to stop there? because the slider ending here 01:03:042 not really good to ending the song but this one is easy as usually

[]
Good set, but the insane rather too hard imo with big spacing and jumps, despite the hard is rarely have any jump or big jumps, so maybe you can consider lowering the jumps on insane, good luck!

[ microism ] wrote:

[ Normal]

1. 00:02:105 (4) - In my opinion, this looks bad relative to the previous slider. this one fixed
2. 00:09:230 (1) - I don't think you should put a spinner here. I would put spinners in a part where the notes are long, or if it's the outro. i guess might be ok
3. 00:18:230 (1,2,3,4) - This is a good idea, but make the slider's head and tail perpendicular to eachother. So you may need to remap that part of the song. And I don't know if this was intended or not but the sliders are not perfect, they don't perfectly blanket each other. Sorry if I sound like a perfectionist, but I believe making things "perfect" can make the map ranked easier. Try reversing the slider and use the approach circle as a guide, then reversing it again. i used this approach circle and they are pefrecty blanket
4. 00:21:230 (1,2,3,4) - Not perfectly blanketed, same as last time. same
5. 00:24:230 (1,2) - Again, these sliders are not perfectly blanketed with each other. ok, you caught me
6. 00:27:230 (1,2) - Not perfectly blanketed. ^^
7. 00:30:230 (1,2,3,4) - For this part, I believe that you need to make more creative sliders, so it looks better. it's creative enough
8. 00:34:167 (3) - It would be better to start a new combo on this circle to avoid confusion. mako sakata allowed this (she's more important person)
9. 00:37:355 (4,5,6) - For patterns like these, put in a red point what put? in the sliders to make it look better I guess.
10. 00:51:230 (1,2,3,4) - Not perfectly blanketed. right
11. 00:55:730 (5,6,1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - Not perfectly blanketed. particulary you've a right

[ Hard]

1. This is pretty nice, lol. Don't have much to say.
2. I see the uneven blanket thing going on again. Just keep an eye on your blankets.
3. With circles that are 1 whole beat close to each other, make a new combo because it will get confusing. Like this:
   
   Before

   
   After

   
   Another example:
   
   Before

   
   After

   https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3938677
   This is very important. It is pretty much what makes people distinguish between 1/1 notes and 1/2 notes. That's what pishi taught me i don't prefer this idea, but i'll try it
4. 00:53:480 (5,6) - This is confusing, at least to me. I'm like "oh hey (5) is going to be a reverse slider" and then i lose. try making (5) a reverse slider and (6) a hitcircle. Movethem to the right so that there are no jumps. like this: done like an image
   
   SPOILER

   

That's all for now. It's already late at night here so I'm going to do Demente and some probably some more on Hard later.

-Nya- wrote:

Heya~! Responding to your request in-game~

General:

1. You’ll have to get a background image that’s 1366X768. If you have trouble with this, you can always ask Ringating for help. easy
2. Add this file into your song’s folder: http://puu.sh/ljZZN/719949ac98.wav
   It’s a soundfile that silences those annoying sliderslide sounds. installed
3. Remove “game” and “instrumental” from the tags. “Game” is already in the source and “instrumental” will be added to the genre when ranked. bye tags
4. I think the metadata should be this:
   
   Picture

   
   Basically you have to change the I in “in” to a capital letter and the source has to be Shrek 2: The Game OST, but I’m not 100% sure so I suggest you check with a BN that’s an expert at metadata. this fixed too

Normal:

1. The approach rate of 5 will possibly be an issue for this diff since it’s the easiest diff. I remember one of my maps getting unranked because of this. Change the HP drain rate to 3 and the overall difficulty to 3 as well, and then change the approach rate to 4. fixed
2. 00:09:230 (1,1) –I feel the gap between the spinner and the next note might be too short, so beginners won’t have enough recovery time to hit the next object after the spinner. In my opinion, it’s not really necessary to place a spinner there. My advice would be to remove the spinner and map that section out. But I guess if you really want to keep the spinner then just end it here: 00:10:730 – i like spinners, spinners are cool
3. 00:38:480 (7,1,2) –I would rather place these notes like this to avoid the overlapping with 00:37:355 (4,5) – fixed with remapping some part of song
   
   Picture

   
   Hopefully, you’ll understand what I did there. >.<
4. 00:47:855 (8,2) –Try to make a perfect stack here. Looks a bit untidy if you don’t.
5. 00:51:980 (2,1) -^, (1) on the head of (2). You may have to move previous notes around for the stack to work. yea, little remap for this part too[/color]

Hard:

1. 00:09:042 –Place a note here since there’s clearly a beat. You can then place the circles like this:
   
   Picture

   
2. 00:13:917 (1) –I never like double repeats really >.< Especially when there are better options. Maybe remove the repeat and place a slider there. Like this:
   
   Picture

   
   Or two circles instead.
3. 00:37:917 (1) -^ fixing hard was also easy

Demente:

1. 00:51:230 (1,2,3,4,5,6) –Ease down on these jumps a bit. I understand what Mako was saying about the jumps in the insane. Rather not use too big jumps when you almost have no jumps in the Hard. Just do something similarly to what you did here: 00:48:230 (1,2,3,4) –
2. 00:56:480 (7,8,9,10) -^, jumps are a bit too big. all above and this forced me to little remap
3. 01:02:480 (7,8,9,10,11) –I suggest placing these notes like this for a more exciting ending:
   
   Picture

   
   Entirely up to you though with image is easy.

Nice mapset. Didn’t really find anything else major.
You may call me back after making the necessary fixes.

[ microism ] wrote:

don't give me kudosu for this :p

there was no better way for me to explain this, so i took screenshots:

before

after

i also changed something else:

before

after

in case this is too much work for you i uploaded an .osu file: http://puu.sh/lkAul/2c04061b46.osu

HappyRocket88 wrote:

~As requested~

[General]

1. Consider reducing the general volume of the red line and green lines a little to all the difficulties. I said this because it would be better to emphasize that here 00:36:230 the kiai starts and gives priority to it. Like this:
   ^

   
2. Incorrect metadata: Despite I already talked this to you on game, check the title be: "Shrek 2: The Game" OST means soundtrack and as long as it is not in the game's title, consider to add "OST" it to tags.
3. Tag Information: Also consider to add "soundtrack" to tags as long and this song makes part of the soundtracks of the official game.

[]
[Normal]

1. 00:00:980 (3) This slider is making a weird rhythm because I think you're skipping this important 00:01:730 big white tick. It would be better if you removed the reverse and add a circle there as long as it is a strong beat that need to be clickeable.
2. 00:09:230 (1) this slider doesn't flow bad, but I think it would had flowed better if you had made it end here 00:10:542 to keep consistency with the instruments of the song.
3. 00:35:480 (1) Remove NC here to keep consistent the New Combing you managed in the previous patterns.

[Hard]

1. OD - 1 I think it's not really necessary to set the high OD considering this hard isn't that hard to play. Also, it would make sense with the current increasing of HP in the Normal (3), Hard (5) and Demente (7). So OD 5 here would fit better because of the proportions.

[]

1. 00:09:230 (1,2) This pattern is making a too generic rhythm. I highly suggest you to try this pattern that highlights the main guitar beats here and make a more intuitive flow. What about this?
   ^

   
2. 00:24:230 (1,1) This pattern was very confusing and two stacks over the same slider in a different time plays off. Rhythmically talking, you're missing to emphasize these important white ticks 00:24:605 that needs to be emphasized. It would be better if you try out this rhythm which gives priority to the main beats in this section. Like this: Consider doing the same here 00:27:230 (1,1)
   ^

   
3. 00:36:230 The copy and pasta of the previous sections is very noticeable here. It doesn't flow bad, but I think it would be better if you did ctrl + J and then H, to give variety to the map from here 00:36:230 to here 00:43:542
4. 00:37:167 (4,5) I think with these make an very weird flow because it breaks the zig zag pattern you managed in the previous patterns. Consider doing ctrl + G on those to improve the readability. The same goes here 00:40:167 (4,5)
5. 00:50:480 (5) This pattern make a very monotonous rhythm. I think it would make more sense if you try out to give variety to the pattern to don't bore players with this flow. Like this. Consider doing the same here 00:53:480 (5,6)
   ^

   
6. 00:57:980 (3,4) These two notes don't flow bad but I think they would flow better if you followed the instruments here as long as you did in the previous patterns 00:34:167 (3,4). You might only need to move those notes to the red ticks and remove this circle 00:58:730 (5) .Consider doing the same here 01:00:980 (3,4)

[Demente]

1. OD 8 might be overkill for players if they played with HR. Please, consider lowering by 1 to keep consistency with the Hard diff.
2. Remove widescreen support as long as you have it disabled in the lower difficulties.

[]

1. 00:18:042 (6) Remove this object to make to give a better rhythm for players. you placed a jump before and it might need to emphasize the 00:18:230 (1) somehow.
2. 00:42:135 (2) Overmapped. I can barely hear a sound here. and this breaks the 1/4 consistency you managed in the previous patterns.

[]

~Call me back for a recheck~

-Nya- wrote:

I guess I'll recheck this again then.

In the "Demente" diff: Why no note here 00:18:042 - ? There's clearly a beat there.

image 1

image 2

HappyRocket88 wrote:

Congratulations for your first qualified map. (☞ﾟヮﾟ)☞

Sonnyc wrote:

Wow, this is a nicely made mapset! Grats with your first qualified. (personally kinda surprised haha)

Could see you were using lots of zigzag objects like 00:12:792 (2,3,4,5,6) - in Hard. Personally this felt something old-fashioned pattern which suits in 2008. Not bad at all, but maybe you could make such patterns more trendy at your future mapping!

HappyRocket88 wrote:

Congratulations for your first ranked mapset! >w</