1. Extra Stage (5.16 stars, 424 notes)

[ 98Wolfy-kun ] wrote:

Sup, my friend really likes your map, so he asked me if I could give it a mod.
I'm a very lazy person, he's that special to make me get a move on and actually do it. I wish you the best of luck, and hope you Do make it out there.
D o n ' t g i v e u p , despite whatever critique hits you. In the end it's your map sooo, do whatever, take the mods that you think are beneficial.

Mods

1. 00:04:234 (1,2,3,4) - instead of hiding the first note behind that slider, maybe just make it look like this. since it's kinda confusing. Though maybe that might just be me. -fixed
2. 00:05:288 (1) - instead of that kick slider, just do a triple. - this is so much better holy
3. 00:07:396 (1) - Flip it over, then place it somewhere further. Yeah it did look a bit weird fixed
4. 00:09:991 (1,2,3,4) - This, no. This is a nono. 2 and 3 should be close to 1, they can't just go over to another place and have their own party with 4. 4 needs to be in another party, change 4's combo color, 4 and 5 should have their own combo color. - fixed
5. 00:11:936 (2,3,4,5) - To make it more smooth, make 2 mirror 1, and then for 3,4,5 instead of doing that close spaced single taps, which can be confusing at some times as well, I suggest you make them a triangle jump. So in the end, 2.3,4,5'll look like this. and 1,2'll look like this. - holy fixing that
6. 00:16:639 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - make slider 1 like this instead,
   from then on 2,3,4,5,6 remap them to match the next 1 slider. - fixed
7. 00:21:828 (1,2) - make it look like this instead, same issue with the 5th mod
   -fixed
8. Takes a break// I'm sorry, I think I'm using " make it look like this instead," too much rip. - Its fine I appreciate the help
9. 00:24:423 (1) - same issue ^ just flip it over. - fixed
10. 00:31:720 (5) - change combo color, select that stream and rotate clockwise " ctrl + > " - fixed
11. Tip - to see if your mapping is coming out as smooth or not, what I do is that when I map a certain amount, I stop and then play the map over while following the structure with my mouse/pen to see whether which. - ty
12. 00:46:477 (4) - change the slider structure. oh man fixed
13. 00:51:504 (7) - ^ - I dunno what I was thinking
14. 03:54:585 - ^ - Again fixed
15. 01:17:774 (2) - change combo color. - fixed
16. 01:27:099 - ^ ^
17. 01:25:558 (1) - reach it up to the white tick? - fixed
18. 04:01:882 (1,2) - those two and onwards up to the second 3 woah woah wooah man, that's like a cluster right there. Hmm, make it into a stream instead, see how you like it. - I agree fixed
19. 04:05:855 (2) - this stream is marvelous. Noice. - why thank you
    

Whew, that's it for me. Some I didn't really bring up, didn't wanna end up being too repetitive with the same issues about it, that's with you to pimp/fix up.
Good luck, happy mapping. o/

1. check the offset if possible, downbeats usually just at the long white tick in beatmaps.
2. 00:01:072 (4) - jump here?
3. 00:03:342 (1) - why NC?
4. 00:05:936 (9,10,11) - (11) is abusolutely harder than 9 and 10, but you give the same ds as before. You should make it present the rhythm.
5. 00:08:855 (4) - ^
6. 00:14:045 (1,2,3) - liner flow looks werid imo
7. 00:22:639 (3,4,5) - why change ds at (5)
8. 00:23:126 (1,2) - too close
9. 00:24:909 (2,3) - not overlap imo
10. 00:26:855 (1,2) - jump?
11. 00:33:828 (1,2) - too close imo
12. 00:37:396 (7,1) - flow werid
13. 00:40:639 (4,5) - too close and no overlap
14. 01:05:126 (3,4,5) - looks werid
15. 01:09:504 (4,1) - can blanket or something, too close now
16. 01:46:964 (4,5,1) - flow werid
    
    you can try

    
17. 01:52:477 (5,1) - ^
18. 02:01:558 (4,1) - can blanket
19. 02:29:126 (8,9) - blanket better here
20. 02:51:018 (1,2,3,4) - i dont like this lol
21. 03:01:396 (3,4) - ds should change at 4 imo
22. 03:59:126 (2,3,4) - why change ds at 4

ceLy wrote:

NM as request
[Extra Stage]

1. check the offset if possible, downbeats usually just at the long white tick in beatmaps.
2. 00:01:072 (4) - jump here? -i guess?
3. 00:03:342 (1) - why NC? - opps fixed
4. 00:05:936 (9,10,11) - (11) is abusolutely harder than 9 and 10, but you give the same ds as before. You should make it present the rhythm. - sure
5. 00:08:855 (4) - ^ - sure
6. 00:14:045 (1,2,3) - liner flow looks werid imo - will adjust
7. 00:22:639 (3,4,5) - why change ds at (5) - fixed
8. 00:23:126 (1,2) - too close - fixed
9. 00:24:909 (2,3) - not overlap imo - fixed
10. 00:26:855 (1,2) - jump? - okay sure
11. 00:33:828 (1,2) - too close imo - fixed a bit
12. 00:37:396 (7,1) - flow werid - fixed?
13. 00:40:639 (4,5) - too close and no overlap - fixed
14. 01:05:126 (3,4,5) - looks werid - fixed a bit
15. 01:09:504 (4,1) - can blanket or something, too close now - sure
16. 01:46:964 (4,5,1) - flow werid - fixed
    
    you can try

    
17. 01:52:477 (5,1) - ^ - I guess
18. 02:01:558 (4,1) - can blanket - fixed
19. 02:29:126 (8,9) - blanket better here - fixed
20. 02:51:018 (1,2,3,4) - i dont like this lol - lol i spiced it up
21. 03:01:396 (3,4) - ds should change at 4 imo - okay
22. 03:59:126 (2,3,4) - why change ds at 4 - opps

GL~

LigerZero wrote:

[Metadata]
Title and Title unicode OK
Artist and Unicode Artist OK
Source OK
Tags added "mountain of faith fuujinroku Comiket75 stage 5 aya shameimaru"
Image: change to aya shameimaru except you mapping border of life no problem you use background yuyuko saigyouji - I will change


[Extra Stage]
02:21:666 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - it's confused to me..., but it's good - ty
04:14:207 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - so far jump....., i'm try in ctb and next fail - yeah a bit strange but i wanna keep it

test gameplay in ctb because i'm can play ctb

sorry i'm bad to modding because i'm trying to modding map.... bored only checking metadata.....

Good Luck i'm for your map.... i'm waiting your map ranked.....
- Thanks for modding and thank you!

1. At first testplay I noticed that yo have nice map but flow and aesthetical issues were found
2. As I checked your map I don't recall seeing any sliders with red anchors? You should use them here and there (especially in those big unique sliders) They help a lot I promise you (straight when you learn to use them tho ) And if you for some reason don't know how to make red anchor just doubleclick while making slider or ctrl + click a white anchor
3. 00:03:666 (4) - Make this slider more appealling
4. 00:04:234 (5) - Inconsistent spacing between 4 and 6
5. 00:04:478 (8,1) - NC 8 and 00:05:774 (8) - NC
6. 00:07:396 (1) - necessary NC? okay I won't point NCs out anymore if they aren't horrible
7. 00:10:234 (2,3) - how did you think this placement is a good idea?? Make spacing consistent, this looks and plays bad and breaks flow
8. 00:17:774 (6) - place to x:220 y:268 or around somwhere there and it plays much more nicely
9. 00:17:936 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I don't like this flow here
10. 00:24:423 (1,3) - overlap
11. 00:42:261 (3,1) - overlap
12. 00:44:531 (2,3,4) - Not good flow
13. 00:51:504 (7) - shape it properly and don't make it look random (symmetrical is the key!) and NC btw
14. 01:11:936 (3,4,5) - these are chronologically in same distance but then this huge jump?! (note 4) JUST LOOK AT IT
15. 01:20:369 (1,2,3,4) - Well this is a bad flow
16. 01:25:072 (4,1) - overlap
17. 02:04:477 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - wow this inconsistency made me puke. Did you know that you can make stream in this way -> 1) make slider 2)ctrl + shift + f (made one next to yours in this way)
18. 02:19:720 (6) - could be made better and cleaner
19. 02:29:126 (8) - :puke: I'm sorry for being this rude but this is not a good slider!
20. 02:45:991 (1,2,3) - CONSISTENT SPACING
21. 03:00:099 (7,1,2) - 7 and 2 are not consistent chronologically, but they have same jump -> confusion and player clicks 2 earlier
22. 03:01:558 (4,7) - overlap
23. 03:46:315 (1) - x:108 y:152, looks better with stream
24. 03:54:585 (2) - ummm.. eeehhh.. Remake it, make it look good and don't let it lap itself, and btw make this end at 03:55:720 - and start new slider at 03:55:964 -
25. 03:54:585 (2,1) - and you even managed to make these overlap :facepalm:
26. 03:57:342 (2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - you leave A LOT of sounds unmapped and they should be mapped ->undermapping
27. 04:06:747 (3,1) - here leaving guitar unmapped is ok
28. 04:36:261 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - maybe most intense stream in this map and you make this stream so boring.. ugh 0.16 Distance snap
29. 05:00:909 (1,1,1) - you don't need new timing points for these notes.. Delete timing points and use 1/8 snap divisior

lsahi wrote:

NM from my queue
[Extra Stage]
00:03:666 (4,5,6,7,8) - ds plz Nice
00:10:234 (2,3) - put them seperate from 00:09:991 (1) - may be better gave it a go
00:37:558 (1) - ds plz Nice
00:38:855 (5) - how do you think about moving it to x-308 y-108 Sure
00:51:504 (7) - strange slider Yeah had some troubles with sliders
00:54:423 (1) - ^ ^
01:11:612 (2) - get it far away from 01:11:288 (1,3) - seems better Nice
02:04:477 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,1) - ds Alright
02:07:558 (2,3) - blanket here could be considered. Meh
02:11:774 (4) - nc here will help reading Fixed
02:19:720 (6) - another strange slider Had trouble with sliders
02:29:126 (8) - ^ ^
02:35:450 (1,2,3) - ds plz Got it
03:14:369 (1,2,3) - blanket here Hmm will attempt
03:54:585 (2) - another one LOL fixed
04:17:450 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - ds plz fixed

Just something make it tidy or more interesting, I'll be happy if you accept any one above

Try using more red anchors rather than white ones will make your slider look better. Or you can speed down the slider when you tend to express a certain melody. Thanks for informing me about these... never knew how to use them xD
About hitsounds
Find some hitsounds which fit the song better, and you'd better consider your hitsounds more. Actrully, I can't really understand why you do that in some partterns.
Finally, flow overall seems good.
Regarding hit sounds, im fairly new to t his whole thing and would love some help heh
Good luck for rank Thank you!

Lumin wrote:

Heyaa NM here from queuee

[Extra stage]

1. At first testplay I noticed that yo have nice map but flow and aesthetical issues were found
2. As I checked your map I don't recall seeing any sliders with red anchors? You should use them here and there (especially in those big unique sliders) They help a lot I promise you (straight when you learn to use them tho ) And if you for some reason don't know how to make red anchor just doubleclick while making slider or ctrl + click a white anchor
3. 00:03:666 (4) - Make this slider more appealling Yeah i know the sliders were terrible xD
4. 00:04:234 (5) - Inconsistent spacing between 4 and 6 fixed
5. 00:04:478 (8,1) - NC 8 and 00:05:774 (8) - NC Alrighty
6. 00:07:396 (1) - necessary NC? okay I won't point NCs out anymore if they aren't horrible Got it
7. 00:10:234 (2,3) - how did you think this placement is a good idea?? Make spacing consistent, this looks and plays bad and breaks flow Got it
8. 00:17:774 (6) - place to x:220 y:268 or around somwhere there and it plays much more nicely Will do
9. 00:17:936 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I don't like this flow hereMade it a bit better
10. 00:24:423 (1,3) - overlap Please be more specific but I did something lol
11. 00:42:261 (3,1) - overlap ^
12. 00:44:531 (2,3,4) - Not good flow Fixed
13. 00:51:504 (7) - shape it properly and don't make it look random (symmetrical is the key!) and NC btw Sliders were hard
14. 01:11:936 (3,4,5) - these are chronologically in same distance but then this huge jump?! (note 4) JUST LOOK AT IT lol fixed
15. 01:20:369 (1,2,3,4) - Well this is a bad flow fixed
16. 01:25:072 (4,1) - overlap Specify but I did something
17. 02:04:477 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - wow this inconsistency made me puke. Did you know that you can make stream in this way -> 1) make slider 2)ctrl + shift + f (made one next to yours in this way) Fixed and THANKS HOLY I NEVER KNEW THAT
18. 02:19:720 (6) - could be made better and cleanerOkay
19. 02:29:126 (8) - :puke: I'm sorry for being this rude but this is not a good slider! xD fixed
20. 02:45:991 (1,2,3) - CONSISTENT SPACING Will do
21. 03:00:099 (7,1,2) - 7 and 2 are not consistent chronologically, but they have same jump -> confusion and player clicks 2 earlier Fixed
22. 03:01:558 (4,7) - overlap Please specify ;w; but sure
23. 03:46:315 (1) - x:108 y:152, looks better with stream Nice!
24. 03:54:585 (2) - ummm.. eeehhh.. Remake it, make it look good and don't let it lap itself, and btw make this end at 03:55:720 - and start new slider at 03:55:964 - Felt weird at first but sure
25. 03:54:585 (2,1) - and you even managed to make these overlap :facepalm: \:D/
26. 03:57:342 (2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - you leave A LOT of sounds unmapped and they should be mapped ->undermapping Fixed
27. 04:06:747 (3,1) - here leaving guitar unmapped is ok
28. 04:36:261 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - maybe most intense stream in this map and you make this stream so boring.. ugh 0.16 Distance snapyeah... Fixed it lol
29. 05:00:909 (1,1,1) - you don't need new timing points for these notes.. Delete timing points and use 1/8 snap divisior Got it

Sorry for being rude , it's just that I've been modding a lot of maps lately and I'm tired of this and I just modded a hopeless map before this so I'm a little repressed. But don't worry it is not a hopeless map, needs just modding! Good luck!
No problem I understand it can get frustrating and I appreciate the honest feedback Thanks !\:D/

E n d wrote:

00:24:423 (1,3) - overlap Please be more specific but I did something lol
00:42:261 (3,1) - overlap ^

Lumin wrote:

E n d wrote:

00:24:423 (1,3) - overlap Please be more specific but I did something lol
00:42:261 (3,1) - overlap ^

Overlapping means when notes or sliders are on top of each other and it doesn't look good

Hello! NM from modding queue~!
2 hours of modding, yeay ._.

1. 00:00:585 (1,2,3,4) - What is this shape ^^" Either make it a perfect rhombus or a better trapezium
2. 00:03:180 (1,2,3,4) - this pattern looks so random Make it a rhombus?
3. 00:04:234 (5,6,7,1) - I'd really rather have a normal curve here, because the flow feels a bit awkward
4. 00:04:964 (4,1) - I think this is too close
5. What about making 00:13:396 (4,5) - and 00:12:747 (1,2) - the same distance and angle. If not, at least move 00:13:558 (5) - a bit to the left, as I really do think that the flow to the next slider will be nicer.
6. 01:18:423 (1,2) - move the greenline
7. 00:19:234 (7) - add more curve
8. 00:23:126 (1) - ^
9. move 00:28:964 (2,3,4) - to make 00:28:801 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - a rhombus
10. 00:38:045 (2,3) - this confuses me. try to separate (3) from 00:38:045 (2) -
11. 00:56:693 (3,4,5) - just... why is it not like this ;w;
12. The close spacing of 00:57:342 (1,2,3,4,5) - and this triplet 00:57:504 (2,3,4) - makes it tricky to do this triangle jump 00:57:828 (5,6,7) - ._.
    If not, at least the tapping pattern does feel weird.
13. 01:02:693 (2,4) - overlap. Try a blanket instead
14. 01:03:991 (3,5) - ^
15. 01:04:801 (1,2,3,4,5) - it's hard to tap that pattern
16. 01:12:180 (4,5) - what about making this a curve instead of putting them on top of each other
17. 01:28:477 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - it's hard to tap that pattern
18. 01:33:342 (1) - why NC here
19. 01:37:234 (1) - ^
20. 01:42:342 (5) - why no NC here
21. 02:21:342 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - this could be neater
22. 02:32:369 (3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - "eh" tapping. I don't know what beat you are trying to follow.
23. 02:40:396 (4,5,1,2,3) - ^
24. 02:39:991 (3,5) - stack
25. 02:52:315 (1,2,3) - this starts too soon. I would suggest you to remove 02:52:315 (1,2) - as the next few sliders are pretty *relaxing* as well.
26. 02:53:450 (5) - eeeh greenline.
27. 02:57:666 (1) - ^
28. 03:00:261 (1,2) - I suggest you should add more spacing for this, just a little bit. Probably right above 03:00:909 (1) -
29. 03:06:991 (2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3) - nazi, tapping .-.
30. 03:13:072 (1) - greenline fix
31. 03:14:369 (1,2,3) - is this spacing even possible? ._. move 03:14:774 (2) - up
32. 03:15:180 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - nazi, tapping
33. 03:19:720 (1,2,3,4) - ^
34. 03:37:234 (3,4,5) - what about a curve
35. 03:46:964 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6) - nazi, tapping
36. 03:45:504 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3) - o u c h s t r e a m
37. 03:55:964 (3) - why does this slider end there? Sounds off-beat to me :/
38. 04:06:423 (1,2,3) - w h o a
39. 04:16:153 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I'm ded here. Probably make the stream pattern better? :/
40. 04:17:450 (1) - why NC
41. 04:22:477 (3,4,5,6,7) - out of all my "nazi, tapping" comments, you should pay more attention to this one. Move it to be something like this or idk ==
42. 04:32:612 (2) - remove
43. 04:37:558 (1) - fix greenline
44. 04:38:207 (1) - ^
45. 05:00:261 (1,1,1,1,1) - the beat is getting slower, but why are the notes getting closer? This might result in confusion =="

1. 00:11:450 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - inconsistent hitsound. In fact, there are a lot of seemingly random hitsounds, I think. Please take a second look
2. e.g. you put a clap here 00:42:423 (4) - . What about also putting a clap on the end of 00:42:747 (1) - and 00:44:045 (1) - and remove the one on 00:45:991 (2) -
3. And, well, many more ^^" or is it on purpose of improvisation? But at least, make it consistent. Don't make it abstract then suddenly neat and repetitive.
4. 01:18:423 (1,2,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,1,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6) - fix the claps here
5. 02:07:234 (1) - remove clap
6. hmm the next few bit is pretty consistent
7. 03:29:774 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14) - claps~
8. Actually please look at other streams' clap sound. eg. 03:45:504 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3) -

Annadine wrote:

Hello! NM from modding queue~!
2 hours of modding, yeay ._.

Extra Stage[]
First, have you checked AiMod? ^^" ctrl+shift+A nope lol

1. 00:00:585 (1,2,3,4) - What is this shape ^^" Either make it a perfect rhombus or a better trapezium I think its fine
2. 00:03:180 (1,2,3,4) - this pattern looks so random Make it a rhombus? Possibly?
3. 00:04:234 (5,6,7,1) - I'd really rather have a normal curve here, because the flow feels a bit awkward Maybe
4. 00:04:964 (4,1) - I think this is too close got it
5. What about making 00:13:396 (4,5) - and 00:12:747 (1,2) - the same distance and angle. If not, at least move 00:13:558 (5) - a bit to the left, as I really do think that the flow to the next slider will be nicer. Will do
6. 01:18:423 (1,2) - move the greenline got it xd
7. 00:19:234 (7) - add more curve alrighty
8. 00:23:126 (1) - ^ ^
9. move 00:28:964 (2,3,4) - to make 00:28:801 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - a rhombus Will attempt lol
10. 00:38:045 (2,3) - this confuses me. try to separate (3) from 00:38:045 (2) - fixed
11. 00:56:693 (3,4,5) - just... why is it not like this ;w; fixed
12. The close spacing of 00:57:342 (1,2,3,4,5) - and this triplet 00:57:504 (2,3,4) - makes it tricky to do this triangle jump 00:57:828 (5,6,7) - ._.
    If not, at least the tapping pattern does feel weird. made an attempt lol
13. 01:02:693 (2,4) - overlap. Try a blanket instead ^
14. 01:03:991 (3,5) - ^ ^
15. 01:04:801 (1,2,3,4,5) - it's hard to tap that pattern I think its fine
16. 01:12:180 (4,5) - what about making this a curve instead of putting them on top of each other Will do
17. 01:28:477 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - it's hard to tap that pattern It's fine lol
18. 01:33:342 (1) - why NC here oops
19. 01:37:234 (1) - ^ ^
20. 01:42:342 (5) - why no NC here ^
21. 02:21:342 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - this could be neaterChanged
22. 02:32:369 (3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - "eh" tapping. I don't know what beat you are trying to follow. Its fine imo
23. 02:40:396 (4,5,1,2,3) - ^ ^
24. 02:39:991 (3,5) - stack got it
25. 02:52:315 (1,2,3) - this starts too soon. I would suggest you to remove 02:52:315 (1,2) - as the next few sliders are pretty *relaxing* as well. fixed
26. 02:53:450 (5) - eeeh greenline. lol got it
27. 02:57:666 (1) - ^ ^
28. 03:00:261 (1,2) - I suggest you should add more spacing for this, just a little bit. Probably right above 03:00:909 (1) - Sure
29. 03:06:991 (2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3) - nazi, tapping .-. Personally I dont see whats wrong with this tapping
30. 03:13:072 (1) - greenline fix fixed
31. 03:14:369 (1,2,3) - is this spacing even possible? ._. move 03:14:774 (2) - up It's definitely possible, but yes its weird
32. 03:15:180 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - nazi, tapping I agree with this one
33. 03:19:720 (1,2,3,4) - ^ doubles are fun ;^)
34. 03:37:234 (3,4,5) - what about a curve Will do
35. 03:46:964 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6) - nazi, tapping (^:
36. 03:45:504 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3) - o u c h s t r e a m Not changing unless more people seem to absolutely hate it lol
37. 03:55:964 (3) - why does this slider end there? Sounds off-beat to me :/ fixed
38. 04:06:423 (1,2,3) - w h o a F i x e d
39. 04:16:153 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I'm ded here. Probably make the stream pattern better? :/ Yeah changed
40. 04:17:450 (1) - why NC oops
41. 04:22:477 (3,4,5,6,7) - out of all my "nazi, tapping" comments, you should pay more attention to this one. Move it to be something like this or idk == I agree!
42. 04:32:612 (2) - remove ok ;w;
43. 04:37:558 (1) - fix greenline got it
44. 04:38:207 (1) - ^ ^
45. 05:00:261 (1,1,1,1,1) - the beat is getting slower, but why are the notes getting closer? This might result in confusion =="will do

Hitsounds[]
Because mod above would be too long lelelel

1. 00:11:450 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - inconsistent hitsound. In fact, there are a lot of seemingly random hitsounds, I think. Please take a second lookim bad at hitsounding lol
2. e.g. you put a clap here 00:42:423 (4) - . What about also putting a clap on the end of 00:42:747 (1) - and 00:44:045 (1) - and remove the one on 00:45:991 (2) -
3. And, well, many more ^^" or is it on purpose of improvisation? But at least, make it consistent. Don't make it abstract then suddenly neat and repetitive.
4. 01:18:423 (1,2,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,1,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6) - fix the claps here
5. 02:07:234 (1) - remove clap
6. hmm the next few bit is pretty consistent
7. 03:29:774 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14) - claps~
8. Actually please look at other streams' clap sound. eg. 03:45:504 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3) -

Aah I don't know I want to eat now >< I changed everything you suggested ty!
[]

Overall is very nice. Good luck~

Thanks for the mod you really did a good job

Intelli wrote:

Hey, since you're a new mapper and because i have like 6 god damned mods to do ;-; I'm going to shoot for more general comments rather than crazy ass specific blankets and stuff.

Things you should know to improve your map:

Blankets

Blankets could be improved drastically, and are probably the biggest issue with the map. That and slider shapes, but you can just look at some Ranked maps of similar Genre for that.

For example, at 00:24:261 (6), you are trying to have a circle placed, and then surround it with a slider. Awesome, that's a good mapping decision. The execution, however, needs work. There are some helpful techniques that I'll try to give you here, and you could start fixing them throughout the map.
Yours:


Mine:


How have I done this? Well, I use a technique where I move the slider on top of the circle on the timeline (temporarily, of course). Then, I can see how the Approach Circle Lines up with the slider. Yours looked like this when I started:


See how the blue and red line I drew in MS paint contrast? Now I fiddled with the Midpoint and got my end result. You generally don't want to mess with the start point and end point too much because it will mess with your distance snap, but if you need to, do it (I actually did mess with the endpoint here, that's why you would normally do this along the way when you're first mapping it.

And sure enough, mine line up correctly:

ok maybe its not 100% perfect but I rushed

For reference, my sliderpoints were:
Start: 80,144
Mid: 199,179
End: 245,267

Case where you did this correctly, 01:00:909:

Overlaps

I see throughout the map that flow was a top priority in your mapping. This is very good and adds visual aesthetics to the map. However, in some cases it gets weird, especially near overlaps. For example, at 00:57:991:


While moving through the map in editor, I see a bunch of cases like this where notes look like they should be overlapped, but they aren't. Just simply move it around and adjust the surrounding mapped parts for the DS

Distance Snap

The DS, or Distance Snap, in this map is kinda all over the place. For example, there are cases where you start to make a pattern, but then out of the blue the DS changes drastically. Sometimes this is the right thing to do, but in others, it just plays poorly and it hard to read. For example, at 00:38:531:


Why doesn't that slider complete the square pattern? It's just randomly placed way off there when it would look so much nicer inside the box (literally and metaphorically).

Another case is at 01:24:099:


Why isn't 2 equal spaced between these?

Also, trying playing with the Rotate, Flip, and Scale tools in the Edit section. You can find some neat tricks out for yourself there

On a positive note, your streams were VERY well made, but it's mostly just your sliders and jumps that need work. Also, some sections, like 00:58:315 to the first kiai, looked awesome and played phenomenally. Just follow the advice I've given you here and you can fix alot of errors in your map. To conclude, I would say that this map is a good start, but messy. Just play around some and you're maps will improve drastically

also check aimod

HighTec wrote:

hOI!
from da qUEUE!

i've modded so many demetori maps now and again, sorry if not really useful because me + mapping streams = succcccccc

I'll just give some overall info over the whole map as I see mistakes being done all over

Open at own risk

00:07:396 (2,3) - this should be a blanket for instance. i see the other guy who did the mod before me explained it really nicely how they work, so try to find these and fix them! got it

00:09:991 (1) - things like these are flow-breaking. why? because making an opposite curve all of the sudden is not nice for anyone. instead, try to curve them so that a linear feeling or circular feeling will occur. Also remove the NC (new combo), there is no real reason to put it here fixed

00:10:964 (2) - now here you need a NC because of the weird rythm will do

00:20:369 (4,1) - just wanted to point out that this is the same situation as before, be aware! oke

00:24:423 (1,2) - spacing on this is too low. the sliders go wayyyyyy too fast for the sliders to be that close to each other. a fast solution would be to select 2 and then crtl+g, makes it connect to 3 better too fixed c:

00:26:207 (1) - again a NC that isn't needed as no real change happens, remove it! oopx

00:33:342 (4,5) - again a spacing problem! the notes are too close to each other, there was no reason to make the spacing smaller here than between 00:33:018 (3,4) - . pay attention to it! Fixed

00:51:504 (1) - a long slider fits the guitar, I agree, but why leave out the drums for it? mapping drums can be nice too! Not quite sure

01:16:964 (1,1) - same NC problems as before! oopx

01:27:099 (1) - is there a way to make this feel less awkward than it is right now? I know it fits the song but it just doesn't feel nice No clue ):

02:25:234 (3,1) - jumps between these may be a lot more difficult to keep up with the rest of the map keeping them ;p

02:41:450 (5,6,7,8,9) - nopenopenopenope not a stream jump like this, not nice. fix this please fixed

03:00:261 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - just follow the drums instead of the guitar so that it plays nicer. going to blue ticks all of the sudden makes the player often confused and overall not nice to play got it

the streams were very well made, so got no note on that
just the same mistakes are repeated, so look through the map yourself and fix the problems that you can also see here above

gl with the map and have a lot of fun mapping in the future!

Thanks for the suggestions

Lumin wrote:

1. 05:00:909 (1,1,1) - you don't need new timing points for these notes.. Delete timing points and use 1/8 snap divisior

Annadine wrote:

1. 05:00:261 (1,1,1,1,1) - the beat is getting slower, but why are the notes getting closer? This might result in confusion =="

1. 05:00:909 - (Offset: 300,309) | BPM: 164.000
2. 05:01:274 - (Offset: 301,274) | BPM: 143.000
3. 05:01:693 - (Offset: 301,693) | BPM: 129.000

Warfu wrote:

Hi! From my Timing Queue -w-

Lumin wrote:

1. 05:00:909 (1,1,1) - you don't need new timing points for these notes.. Delete timing points and use 1/8 snap divisior

Annadine wrote:

1. 05:00:261 (1,1,1,1,1) - the beat is getting slower, but why are the notes getting closer? This might result in confusion =="

After all, the timing is completely OK, the circles are in rhythm and the Timing Beats are in rhythm.
You know what? I was doubting if these circles at 05:00:000 needed Timing Points and THOSE^ points really got my attention.
I really think that those circles need Timing Points. In other beatmaps, most of the mappers use Timing Points for situations like this, and it's very clear that they need Timing Points because they can be more precise than the 1/8, 1/12 and 1/16 Snap Divisors.

Timing Points:

1. 05:00:909 - (Offset: 300,309) | BPM: 164.000
2. 05:01:274 - (Offset: 301,274) | BPM: 143.000
3. 05:01:693 - (Offset: 301,693) | BPM: 129.000

Warfu wrote:

Heheh thank you :3
Eeeeeh you should update again... 2nd Timing Point at 05:00:309 - messed up these circles -> 05:00:261 (1,1,1) -
It should have Offset 300,909
kekekekekek~
also don't give me kudosu for this post skdjfskjdf
also I love Touhou 10 Mountain of Faith c:

Mercusheigan wrote:

Hi, from my modding queue


Mapset

SPOILER

Same hitsound volume in all sections?

add some sweet combo colours too, for more customizationnot my forte

Extra Stage

SPOILER

00:11:936 (2) - fix blanket with 1 fixed

00:12:423 (4) - if you make 1 more curvy you can blanket this note within slider 1. You can also move it to make a triangle with the head of 1 and 2, like this: fixed

^ (if you do make a triangle, select 00:12:261 (3,4,5) - and move together)

00:15:342 (1) - blanket could be a bit better will do

00:16:153 (5) - blanket with 1 will do

00:17:126 (2,3,4,5,6) - this could look better with the ctrl+shift+D function i think i did it

00:19:720 (1) - maybe move it more to the centre of the curve of 00:19:234 (7) - will do

00:20:531 (1) - RNC from this one or 00:20:855 (1) - (not sure which one would be better, tho) got it?

00:20:855 (1) - blanket with 00:20:207 (3) - Ok

00:26:855 (1) - RNC got it

00:27:018 (2) - This should be a slider, lasting half a beat Gonna try it

00:31:234 (3) - stack with 00:30:099 (1) - got it

00:31:396 (4) - I think the guittar sound is way too loud here to no be mapped. Maybe a slider lasting 3/4th of a beat would be more fitting? Guess so

00:38:531 (3,4,5,6) - would look better with Ctrl+shift+D function. Also, 00:39:018 (5) - should be shapped like this IMO made an attempt

^blanket end with 00:38:045 (2) - (will flow better considering the patterns used in this combo) fixed

00:40:639 (4,5,6,1) - perhaphs something like this will flow better fixed

00:42:423 (4) - restack if ^ is changed ok

00:42:747 (1) - fix blanket got it

00:44:531 (2) - ^ ^

00:48:423 (3) - ^ ^

00:50:531 (2) - this blanket could be improved a bit got it

00:52:639 (2) - this reverse feels odd for me.. maybe a triangle like this can help the flow better? (also, the jump from 4 and the next slider feels good with the music.. the triangle position may not be the best and you could try other different setups with this, but this jump from 4 to 5 should be a thing, IMO) tried it



00:56:693 (3,4,5) - not really a mod but, what if you stack 4 with 5? < actually yeah thats a mod because there are several others that are made like this as we go more deep into the map Sure why not

00:58:315 (1) - fix blanket fixed

01:01:396 (3) - ^ ^

01:03:180 (4) - this curve should be more open IMO.. if changed, blanket with 01:03:828 (2) - will do

01:04:396 (4,5) - select both, move to 352, 88 got it

01:10:153 (2) - stack with 01:09:180 (3) - (the blanket of this one could be slightly better too..) Alrighty

01:09:991 (1,2,3) - should have consistent DS, IMO ;w;

01:11:612 (2) - copy and paste previous slider and place it where this one currently is Okay

01:15:180 (1,2,3) - you can make a triangle with 01:14:855 (6,4) - heads Nice Idea!

01:18:585 (2) - maybe lowering the SV even more will build better for the kiai why didn't I think of this

01:20:369 (1) - maybe blanket with 01:20:045 (5) - got it

01:25:558 (1) - stack with 01:24:585 (2) - Okay

01:26:207 (3) - blanket with 1 end if ^is changed (also stack the circle again) !!!!!!!!

01:27:099 (1) - ? should it really start here? made an improvement?

01:38:855 (2) - could make a blanket for 01:37:882 (1) - but 2 things: 1 while playing, this blanket wont show much anyway and 2 is too much workaround to fix that got it

01:40:153 (2) - should stack with 01:39:423 (4) - and 01:40:477 (3) - stack with 01:39:180 (3) - -- if changed, fix the DS to make them consistent again, as they are related Got it

01:41:126 (1) - could blanket 01:40:477 (3) - okay

01:44:693 (1,2,3,4,5) - select all, stack with 01:43:720 (1) - got it

01:44:855 (2) - blanket could be better Fixed

01:46:153 (1) - ^ ^

01:48:261 (3) - copy and paste previous slider, flip horizontally & vertically, stack with 01:47:288 (5) - Fixed

01:51:828 (1,2,3,4,5) - use the ctrl+shift+d for a better triangle shape and blanket 01:51:828 (1,4) - I tried lol

01:57:504 (4) - stack with 01:56:531 (5) - end got it

02:01:720 (1) - blanket could be improved a bit fixed

02:02:531 (4) - stack end with ^end ^

02:05:450 (1) - spacing with stream inconsistent, moving to 122, 50 fixes the DS Thanks!

02:17:936 (2) - fix blanket Fixed

02:21:342 (1) - blanket the next circle ^

02:22:639 (1) - blanket could be better ^

02:31:072 (2,3,4,5) - select all and move so that 4 stacks with 02:32:369 (3) - (also move 02:31:720 (1) - up a bit and make a triangle with 5, 1 and 2 fixed

02:34:801 (2,3,4) - maybe its better shaped like this (4 stacks with the :

fixed

02:37:396 (1,2,3) - maybe something like this flows better?



^2 end is stacked with the first note of the stream fixed

02:40:477 (5) - blanket with 02:39:991 (3) - ^

02:40:801 (1) - blanket with the new position of ^ ^

02:49:558 (5,6,7) - I'd rotate these by like 10º or 15º to flow better to the next note Good Idea

02:58:964 (1) - copy and paste 02:34:315 (1) - (this one is way better balanced) Will do

03:00:504 (2) - ? not sure if this should start here, too Eh, I think it's fine

03:26:207 (1,2) - either unstack these or stack 03:27:504 (1,2) - , for consistency sake Got it

03:31:882 (3) - stack on 1 end Got it

03:39:018 (6) - this one could follow 03:38:531 (4) - around better got it

03:44:207 (7) - maybe here a slider would fit the finish sound better Noice

03:58:639 (1) - make the DS even fixed

04:00:909 (1) - RNC got it

04:01:882 (4) - NC fixed

04:02:855 (1,1,1,1,2) - spacing could be made a bit more consistent

04:07:720 (1) - stacking with 04:06:747 (3) - looks better than with 04:05:612 (1) -

04:11:207 (2) - this is so weird lol.. it's not wrong as far as I can tell but kinda breaks the rhythm of the whole song so far... not really sure if I can express exactly what I mean... no clue, but I think it's fine

04:18:099 (1) - inconsistent spacing with stream fixed

04:33:666 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - copy 1 and paste over 2, flip horizontally. you can see in this image that some aren't really flipped like they should be

:o ty

04:37:558 (1) - inconsistent spacing with stream (move the inherit one tick to the right so the stream and the slider are by the same DS.. after fixed, move back the inherit point Fixed

04:44:693 (3,4,5) - select all, stack with 04:43:882 (1) - fixed

04:47:450 (5,6) - select both and stack 5 with 04:46:477 (1) - fixed

04:58:315 (1) - blanket could be better Alrighty

05:02:274 (1) - maybe make it start at 05:02:623 so it follow the timing spacing you used with previous hitcircles... about the end of the spinner I'm not really sure, but somewhere like 05:10:995 sounds ok. Fixed

^Also add some inherit points to reduce the volume of the slider as the sound vanishes (actually the hitsound volume should start slightly reducing since 04:57:666 (1) - , TBH) fixed

Sorry if I sounded a bit rude in some parts but I'm not on my best mood today

Hope it helped!

Warfu wrote:

Timing Points:

1. 05:00:909 - (Offset: 300,309) | BPM: 164.000

E n d wrote:

It does have an Offset 300,909 I dont really see/hear it

Warfu wrote:

Warfu wrote:

Timing Points:

1. 05:00:909 - (Offset: 300,309) | BPM: 164.000

E n d wrote:

It does have an Offset 300,909 I dont really see/hear it

omg now I see what I did there :'v ... maybe that caused the problem
It should say 05:00:909 - (Offset 300,909)

Move the Timing Point at 05:00:309 - to 05:00:909
aw man xD
Still not necessary to give me kudosu for this post

20Below wrote:

Hey! I'm kind of new to this but I like the song and the map so I thought I would give this a shot, sorry if you don't like any of my suggestions.

01:21:666 (1,2) - The sliders here work fine, I just think maybe some structured jumps could work nicely; maybe some triangles like the map Killer Song Think it's fine imo
01:26:693 - Feel like there should be a hitcircle somewhere here, sounds odd How has no one noticed this o.O Fixed
02:13:558 (1,2,3,4) - This stream feels out of place, but there seems to be a guitar riff that warrants it. Maybe remove 2 and 3 and see how that sounds to you Ehhh sounds alright, but I would rather keep the stream
02:42:585 (2,3,4) - 4 is farther away from 3 whereas 2 and 3 are closer to each other. I'd say either bring them together or separate them in full aren't they all together lol?
02:53:450 - Kiai should keep going Woops
03:00:099 (1,2,3,4,5) - This entire section feels strange to play and strange to hear. HOW DID NO ONE NOTICE FIXED
03:07:720 - Kiai should end here and not at 02:53:450 - Fixed
03:29:774 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2) - I'd make this stream just 2 separate combos, the first starting where the stream starts and the second starting around 03:30:504 - or something just to make it even. Feel free to move that around to wherever, it just feels like there are too many combos for a single stream Nice idea
03:32:531 (1) - Remove NC or bring closer Sure!
03:59:936 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - 1/6 streams maybe? 1/6 streams? uh no I think you mean 1/3, but I would rather keep the sliders imo
04:18:747 (3) - To me the slider doesn't seem to fit but musically it does... Maybe make the slider only go to the red tick and add a hitcircle where the original slider ended. Seems Good
04:56:855 (2) - I feel like if you were able to get the right person, to extend this slider and remove 04:57:666 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - in place for a slow slider. you would need to get someone to be able to do slider art though. Too much work, and I would rather just keep it like it is!

Well this was my first ever mod so I am sorry if anything I said doesn't really help you at all. GL ranking this map and I wish you the best of luck!

E n d wrote:

aren't they all together lol?

20Below wrote:

E n d wrote:

aren't they all together lol?

Oh lol I should have said the DS