forum

Jacky.H.Cheung - Ni Hao Du

posted
Total Posts
6
Topic Starter
95648
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 2015年2月11日 at 17:41:17

Artist: Jacky.H.Cheung
Title: Ni Hao Du
Tags: Ni Hao duuuuu
BPM: 121.88
Filesize: 12412kb
Play Time: 03:36
Difficulties Available:
  1. Hard (3.35 stars, 499 notes)
  2. Normal (1.9 stars, 218 notes)
Download: Jacky.H.Cheung - Ni Hao Du
Download: Jacky.H.Cheung - Ni Hao Du (no video)
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
NI HAO DUDU~o~O~O
DT WILL BETTER
MOD PLEASE OTL
pkk
[Hard]

00:31:049 - Beat spacing error. Basically if the notes are close together on the timeline, then you put them close together. However, your (3)(4)(5)(6)(7) are not the same distance from each other on the timeline, even though you put them the same distance apart on the map. Your (6) and (7) should be farther apart, like this: http://puu.sh/6iwEF.jpg

00:47:580 - http://puu.sh/6iwYR.jpg You should move your (2) circle over there and arrange the circles like that in the picture so it flows better.

00:51:051 - Again, beat spacing. Try placing the (1) farther to the left, like this: http://puu.sh/6ix7R.jpg

00:53:332 - (4) should be placed farther away due to distance in timeline

01:48:583 - Your (1)(2)(3) looks kind of crooked, I think you need to straighten out the (2) so that the (1)(2)(3) goes in a straight line like your (1)(2)(3) at 01:49:743

02:49:622 - Beat spacing, try to place the (1)(-->)( ) and (2)(-->)( ) farther away from the previous (8) circle.

03:05:085 - Over here the (1) to (7) timing seemed to be off, so I put it into 1/12 beat snap divider at the top right corner and moved (1) to (7). Here is how you should place the notes (make sure you set beat snap divider to 1/12 first, you can change it back to 1/4 after you finish placing the notes) http://puu.sh/6ixOY.jpg

03:12:607 to 03:15:287 - Beat spacing, try placing the (1) (2) (3) farther away from the previous (6). Also timing errors. Try putting it into 1/12 and place the notes so they land on the beat that you want them to. A easy way to do this is to set the timing to 25% and play through it a couple of times, then place the notes on the timeline in 1/12 beat snap divider on the place that you think fits.


----Beat Spacing----

Here's a helpful article on beat spacing and an illustration http://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Beatmapping#What ... Spacing.3F It is important that you beat space properly. Let's say you have (1) (2) (3) (4) on the map with equal distance between each other. (1), (2), and (3) are 1 second apart from each other in the song, but (4) comes 2 seconds after (3). Therefore, it is logical to place (4) farther away from (3) than you place (3) from (2). So instead of (1) (2) (3) (4), you would have something like (1) (2) (3) (4). I hope this clears things up.

------

Overall, some things you should do are review your beatmap and look for any beat spacing errors and see if the notes flow correctly. Anyways, it was a pretty good map. The music was really good, partly because I could understand the lyrics :lol: Given this information, you should fix up your beat map and your other difficulty as well. Have fun beat mapping! :)
Topic Starter
95648

pkmnyab wrote:

[Hard]

00:31:049 - Beat spacing error. Basically if the notes are close together on the timeline, then you put them close together. However, your (3)(4)(5)(6)(7) are not the same distance from each other on the timeline, even though you put them the same distance apart on the map. Your (6) and (7) should be farther apart, like this: http://puu.sh/6iwEF.jpg

00:47:580 - http://puu.sh/6iwYR.jpg You should move your (2) circle over there and arrange the circles like that in the picture so it flows better.

00:51:051 - Again, beat spacing. Try placing the (1) farther to the left, like this: http://puu.sh/6ix7R.jpg

00:53:332 - (4) should be placed farther away due to distance in timeline

01:48:583 - Your (1)(2)(3) looks kind of crooked, I think you need to straighten out the (2) so that the (1)(2)(3) goes in a straight line like your (1)(2)(3) at 01:49:743

02:49:622 - Beat spacing, try to place the (1)(-->)( ) and (2)(-->)( ) farther away from the previous (8) circle.

03:05:085 - Over here the (1) to (7) timing seemed to be off, so I put it into 1/12 beat snap divider at the top right corner and moved (1) to (7). Here is how you should place the notes (make sure you set beat snap divider to 1/12 first, you can change it back to 1/4 after you finish placing the notes) http://puu.sh/6ixOY.jpg

03:12:607 to 03:15:287 - Beat spacing, try placing the (1) (2) (3) farther away from the previous (6). Also timing errors. Try putting it into 1/12 and place the notes so they land on the beat that you want them to. A easy way to do this is to set the timing to 25% and play through it a couple of times, then place the notes on the timeline in 1/12 beat snap divider on the place that you think fits.


----Beat Spacing----

Here's a helpful article on beat spacing and an illustration http://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Beatmapping#What ... Spacing.3F It is important that you beat space properly. Let's say you have (1) (2) (3) (4) on the map with equal distance between each other. (1), (2), and (3) are 1 second apart from each other in the song, but (4) comes 2 seconds after (3). Therefore, it is logical to place (4) farther away from (3) than you place (3) from (2). So instead of (1) (2) (3) (4), you would have something like (1) (2) (3) (4). I hope this clears things up.

------

Overall, some things you should do are review your beatmap and look for any beat spacing errors and see if the notes flow correctly. Anyways, it was a pretty good map. The music was really good, partly because I could understand the lyrics :lol: Given this information, you should fix up your beat map and your other difficulty as well. Have fun beat mapping! :)
THX :) :) :) :D :D :D
Akabato
hi~random mod here cause of Chinese song. 這歌我很懷念啊,當年看MV的時候還不知道布袋戲為何物,結果現在變粉絲了……

嗯,基本都是一些大方向上的建議啦~

1. 首先,感覺你的這首MP3音質不是很好,很多地方聽起來都像單聲道似的……我另找了一個,雖然也是128kbps的,但應該比原先這個音質要好。如果換mp3的話,注意offset一般也是要變的 http://puu.sh/6QPxi.mp3
2. 背景圖片,4:3比例的話大小一般是1024x768,可以把現在這個尺寸改改。normal難度沒有插入bg,記得在design界面設置一下
3. 缺少一個rank所必需的低於3星的難度
4. 關於歌曲信息,既然是中文歌,歌手和歌名應該用中文填寫,romanised那兩行可以跟原來一樣;如果這首歌不是出自某影視劇作品的話,source那欄應該留空,在tags裡添加專輯名

下面說關於圖本身的一些問題……

1. 很明顯,現在這個offset完全是設錯了,整個錯開了1/4拍,以至於note全部壓著藍線……offset應該落在重音起始,也就是長白線上,所以以你現在的mp3文件來說,offset應該大概在00:00:349這裡;第一條綠線可以刪除,給紅線設置音量即可;注意改offset後用aimod檢查unsnap的notes。我用BPManalyzer測出的BPM是121.88,建議還是去找timing厲害的人幫忙再測下這歌的timing
2. combo color可以再多選一至二種,現在這樣有些單調
3. 關於NC的設置,一般都是按著一長白線一NC或者跟著vocal來一句詞一NC這樣,可以按著這種思路整理一下NC,現在這NC設得略亂
4. 像hard難度這種notes的密集程度,ar設成7或8還比較正常,hp和od也可以相應提高
5. 關於排列,建議開最小格(view菜單-grid level 4),並且善用distance snap,這圖的排列還可以再做的更好
00:43:667 (1) - hard難度這裡,這個滑條思路很贊!對應歌詞裡的"左右搖擺",可惜,這種滑條現在應該是unrankable的了,可以考慮用折返滑條代替
6. 關於音效,可以看出大概的思路了,但是也可以做得更好。finish用得不錯,可以在2,4白線上適當加clap音效,有些段落音效比很空
7. 關於節奏,相當贊!很有思路,把hard的ar改成7之後在test裡打起來還是很爽的

大概就這樣了
總之,這圖還是有比較大的提升空間,也能看出很大的潛力,如果排列和音效上再好好做做,相信會變成一張很好的圖。加油啊~ :)
Topic Starter
95648

Akabato wrote:

hi~random mod here cause of Chinese song. 這歌我很懷念啊,當年看MV的時候還不知道布袋戲為何物,結果現在變粉絲了……

嗯,基本都是一些大方向上的建議啦~

1. 首先,感覺你的這首MP3音質不是很好,很多地方聽起來都像單聲道似的……我另找了一個,雖然也是128kbps的,但應該比原先這個音質要好。如果換mp3的話,注意offset一般也是要變的 http://puu.sh/6QPxi.mp3
2. 背景圖片,4:3比例的話大小一般是1024x768,可以把現在這個尺寸改改。normal難度沒有插入bg,記得在design界面設置一下
3. 缺少一個rank所必需的低於3星的難度
4. 關於歌曲信息,既然是中文歌,歌手和歌名應該用中文填寫,romanised那兩行可以跟原來一樣;如果這首歌不是出自某影視劇作品的話,source那欄應該留空,在tags裡添加專輯名

下面說關於圖本身的一些問題……

1. 很明顯,現在這個offset完全是設錯了,整個錯開了1/4拍,以至於note全部壓著藍線……offset應該落在重音起始,也就是長白線上,所以以你現在的mp3文件來說,offset應該大概在00:00:349這裡;第一條綠線可以刪除,給紅線設置音量即可;注意改offset後用aimod檢查unsnap的notes。我用BPManalyzer測出的BPM是121.88,建議還是去找timing厲害的人幫忙再測下這歌的timing
2. combo color可以再多選一至二種,現在這樣有些單調 我是跟着字幕顏色做的orz 不過會盡量想的
3. 關於NC的設置,一般都是按著一長白線一NC或者跟著vocal來一句詞一NC這樣,可以按著這種思路整理一下NC,現在這NC設得略亂
4. 像hard難度這種notes的密集程度,ar設成7或8還比較正常,hp和od也可以相應提高
5. 關於排列,建議開最小格(view菜單-grid level 4),並且善用distance snap,這圖的排列還可以再做的更好
00:43:667 (1) - hard難度這裡,這個滑條思路很贊!對應歌詞裡的"左右搖擺",可惜,這種滑條現在應該是unrankable的了,可以考慮用折返滑條代替
6. 關於音效,可以看出大概的思路了,但是也可以做得更好。finish用得不錯,可以在2,4白線上適當加clap音效,有些段落音效比很空
7. 關於節奏,相當贊!很有思路,把hard的ar改成7之後在test裡打起來還是很爽的

大概就這樣了
總之,這圖還是有比較大的提升空間,也能看出很大的潛力,如果排列和音效上再好好做做,相信會變成一張很好的圖。加油啊~ :)

我已經看出來了 8-)
Bungaku Shounen
Title:Ni Hao Du
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply