forum

Why does combo even matter?

posted
Total Posts
5
Topic Starter
gremlin998
Let me introduce myself; I've been an offline player for most of the time I've played. I haven't cared about rank or PP because I play for my personal growth and achievement. I don't interact with the osu! community, I don't fully understand the ranking system, and I don't follow top ranked nor pro players. After having the video linked at the end of this post on my YouTube recommended, it has helped me codify the exact reason I feel so apathetic to the ranking system:

Combo feels completely arbitrary and unnecessary in a game about how accurate you are at clicking circles.

Shouldn't the most valuable metric be the total number of mistakes made on a map? From my understanding of the current system, missing once in the middle of the map is far more detrimental than hard choking at the very start or end due to the total combo of the map and the significance that combo plays.

If you wanted to nitpick, the difficulty of the section you miss in would be valuable to know, but that is also a blindspot of the current ranking system. What do you all think?


The video I mentioned:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ML1e_cIRLRo
Wimpy Cursed
I honestly think combo is just there for consistency. There's a goal, a motivation to get a good score with good combo. I don't think many actually care for it, but making it so that pp is rewarded for doing so, people will try to get fcs.

With this new system.. It's a bit odd to see. How will players approach their plays now?
I didn't watch the video linked in this thread because I don't have time to right now. I may edit this to expand or change my opinion afterwards.
_mp1506
IDK... But I think it should exist to the point that it really affects your pp not to the point that it's detrimental, but I also agree that accuracy and misses is more important. Why would I think so? I think pp is a competition, and what is competition if you don't get better from competing? Nothing right?

So combo should matter, because if not people just don't care about choking and they would just be.. Oh hey I got 99% acc but like 20 misses out of chokes? Choke is a disease, and pp farming is also a disease. They will choke out of OWC out of inconsistency.
Sublime
In the video Willy makes a solid argument but how will this affect scores on maps? I'm willing to bet it would shuffle many leaderboards significantly.
Jellinad
it's probably from other rhythm games and the culture from before. I haven't played other ones much but from what I've seen, back in the day full comboing through the fire and flames on guitar hero was a big deal. Then somewhere along the line combo was dropped, as I now hear mania players commenting on how, in mania they don't have to worry about combo as much. And also this is likely a remnant from the old days of score being the primary ranking method, so with this change pp and score will be entirely disconnected from one another.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply