First one is always free choice...Krisom wrote:
Y'know, you might want to reveal the first theme so at least we can start recording.
forum
osu!idol season 3
posted
Total Posts
163
If you're still waiting on a single judge, then drop that judge. His punctuality is unacceptable.
If the judges are still waiting on the host to provide the mp3s, then somebody needs to make a new competition, because that is equally unacceptable.
/sounding like a douche
If the judges are still waiting on the host to provide the mp3s, then somebody needs to make a new competition, because that is equally unacceptable.
/sounding like a douche
or maybe get a new host to take care of this competition? Because it's been only 2 rounds yet... ;u;
and I really don't want to start YET ANOTHER osu!idol when the last 2 i've entered turned out like this... . . . .
and I really don't want to start YET ANOTHER osu!idol when the last 2 i've entered turned out like this... . . . .
Having someone else take over an already-ongoing competition would be logistically ridiculously difficult to do, but given that only the preliminary is done so far, it might work.Lanttu wrote:
or maybe get a new host to take care of this competition? Because it's been only 2 rounds yet... ;u;
and I really don't want to start YET ANOTHER osu!idol when the last 2 i've entered turned out like this... . . . .
Personally, I was thinking of making a "karaoke grand prix", with 4 judges, which would work as follows:
Each judge ranks the contestants in points from x (the number of contestants) to 1, from best to worst. Each contestant's score per round would be the average of the 4 judges' ranking. Rather than eliminating people, I'd like to do a mario kart style, where points simply carry over each round. That way more people can still participate for fun, and there isn't the stress factor of "I might be knocked out this week!" Each round would be one week long, themed, with no deadline extentions, and if you miss a round you simply get a 0 that carries over into the next. Judges would have 3 days to submit their scoring, and if they aren't on time, they're disregarded for that round. Meanwhile contestants can still carry on with the next theme since there is no elimination. I was thinking 8 weeks would be a decent length, and I'll personally sponsor a 6 month supporter status for the winner if it takes off.
Given that it's been nearly two weeks since submissions were due for osu idol, and we haven't heard back yet, I'm ready to go ahead with this new format if people are interested. Let me know through either PMs or posts, and I'll check daily to decide whether we have enough interest. If it does take off, I will be personally participating, since this is for fun after all, but leaving the judging of my recordings to the other 3 judges.
I missed the start of this season? FUUU
I would love to know if this is active, and if not when the next one will be. I can't stand when a major game is started and just dropped (sorry, just being honest). If this is becoming inactive for some reason, I highly suggest someone start a new one with active people.
Also because I want to enter this so badly lol. But either way there is validity to what I'm saying (I hope).
Edit
@KoromoAmae: Genius, I gotta say. The idea of people not worrying about getting knocked sounds so much better, I support this idea 100%!
I would love to know if this is active, and if not when the next one will be. I can't stand when a major game is started and just dropped (sorry, just being honest). If this is becoming inactive for some reason, I highly suggest someone start a new one with active people.
Also because I want to enter this so badly lol. But either way there is validity to what I'm saying (I hope).
Edit
@KoromoAmae: Genius, I gotta say. The idea of people not worrying about getting knocked sounds so much better, I support this idea 100%!
@KoromoAmae
This was suggested before (if not then it was just me). A non-elimination game would be great, but the amount of recordings to judge was the main issue. Your idea is well structured, but if 12 people (or more) with 2 1/2 minute entries would take a lot of time to judge. I would suggest using something like upppy or puush so the judges don't need to download anything (I used MediaFire at first then switched lol). I'd be glad to host and gather some judges (possibly the same ones).
This was suggested before (if not then it was just me). A non-elimination game would be great, but the amount of recordings to judge was the main issue. Your idea is well structured, but if 12 people (or more) with 2 1/2 minute entries would take a lot of time to judge. I would suggest using something like upppy or puush so the judges don't need to download anything (I used MediaFire at first then switched lol). I'd be glad to host and gather some judges (possibly the same ones).
lol
THIS IS GETTING STUPID
Then I would suggest someone reputable at least make a thread and get it started. This isn't official I suppose, the judges shouldn't have to be the same or reviewed, I wouldn't mind who judged, and I prefer that all kinds of people judging, old/new people, all musical tastes, etc. I just want to start seeing what I'll have to do. At this rate not much will happen.
YAY ! Bring it on season 4 ! xD
Aww.... just realize this... xDanimask wrote:
I dedicate my audition to alvisto and uh...other people who uh.....like hearing me sing or something.
Just so you know dkun just told me he's going to send the entries today.
If not, well... I guess this can end like the second one <w<;
If not, well... I guess this can end like the second one <w<;
Topic Starter
I will, my apologies. I just have bad time management.Beuchi-chan wrote:
Just so you know dkun just told me he's going to send the entries today.
If not, well... I guess this can end like the second one <w<;
(27 hours ago)dkun wrote:
I will, my apologies. I just have bad time management.
... I don't really understand what's the problem with the entries, really. It should only take 5-10 minutes to send them
Unstickied
I would probably be out anyway.
Urk.
Urk.
Topic Starter
I just sent the entries out.
Please excuse my leave of absence. I'll talk it over with the judges for a possible replacement for myself if need be.
Please excuse my leave of absence. I'll talk it over with the judges for a possible replacement for myself if need be.
So how much longer till they're done judging?
Topic Starter
So far, Wiinter and I are finished.rust45 wrote:
So how much longer till they're done judging?
I'm done!
Alright, has someone not judged yet, or is dkun out again?
Topic Starter
I'm still here.
Still waiting for Beuchi and KRZY.
Still waiting for Beuchi and KRZY.
It's been 7 days since you sent the submissions out. A week is plenty of time to judge, imo. I say give it one more day and if you don't get results back, proceed without. Keeping people waiting is not a good thing.
It took nearly three weeks after the submission deadline for the entries to be sent to the judges.
It's been a week since the judge received the entries, and we've yet to hear back.
We've been waiting for nearly a month for this to move forward. Neither the host nor the judges should need this much time to provide results. I'd say that results should be posted within 3 days of the deadline. It's been 24 days. This competition needs a new host, new judges, or to be scrapped in favor of something new.
Given the logistic difficulty of finding a new host and judges, I'd just declare this thread dead. If there's someone who actually has the time and will to host one of these competitions, then step up, because everything since the original osu idol has been a complete failure.
It's been a week since the judge received the entries, and we've yet to hear back.
We've been waiting for nearly a month for this to move forward. Neither the host nor the judges should need this much time to provide results. I'd say that results should be posted within 3 days of the deadline. It's been 24 days. This competition needs a new host, new judges, or to be scrapped in favor of something new.
Given the logistic difficulty of finding a new host and judges, I'd just declare this thread dead. If there's someone who actually has the time and will to host one of these competitions, then step up, because everything since the original osu idol has been a complete failure.
I'm going to be out of the country for two weeks, so if this gets rolling soon, I'll drop out. If not, I think everyone is going to drop out anyway. >_>
Well, I want other people to hear my horrible singing and I'm not gonna wait for dkun to post results if they ever arrive.
http://www.mediafire.com/?mn5u5fw5c92megx
http://www.mediafire.com/?mn5u5fw5c92megx
I am pretty sure Azure_Kyte sang this before in osu!idol season 1... xDrust45 wrote:
Well, I want other people to hear my horrible singing and I'm not gonna wait for dkun to post results if they ever arrive.
http://www.mediafire.com/?mn5u5fw5c92megx
He did, and he did a much better job, but I really like the song.
http://puu.sh/2hXN
I didn't expect that I would pass that round so I just sung something that nobody has sung in osu!idol so far and should be done. Marisa
I didn't expect that I would pass that round so I just sung something that nobody has sung in osu!idol so far and should be done. Marisa
ILU <3 - would have been even better if it was done in takes (yeah, against the rules ;_;) - I can imagine how out of breath you were after recording XDXgor wrote:
http://puu.sh/2hXN
I didn't expect that I would pass that round so I just sung something that nobody has sung in osu!idol so far and should be done. Marisa
Animask's spica - Kawaii >w<. A little too soft though, don't you think? You should try singing this song more loud and forceful. Nevertheless, this recording was sweet
rust's diary of jane - Strong deep voice <3. Changes in key could have been better, but overall I liked it >w<
More voice clips please!
Hi every1 I haven't been on osu in a long time I remember the first 2 osu idols ...
What ever happened to this? Did this round never even get started?
What ever happened to this? Did this round never even get started?