PantyDev wrote:

Hello, i'm from modding queue(NM)

• [Victor's easy]

1. Nice diff (thank you)
   
   [Victor's Light Insane]
2. 00:08:775 (1,2) - fix blanket please(second slider a little bit higher) (OK)
3. 00:13:112 (1,1,2) - i think these sliders looks same-type, and some overlaped, no? (no)
   

rohasshiki wrote:

Hello from my queue! Please keep in mind that I am quite inexperienced with modding easy and normal difficulties, but I will try my best.

Victor's Easy

1. 00:07:329 (4) - This blanket is slightly off FIXED
2. 00:14:558 (3) - This blanket feels a little off as well FIXED
3. 00:20:702 (3) - I think NC here FIXED

Victor's Light Insane

1. 00:08:413 (5) - Change the angle maybe? Looks kind of ugly OK
2. 00:08:775 (1,2) - This blanket is ugly, readjust maybe OK
3. 00:19:979 (1) - Take away NC here OK
4. 00:20:702 (2) - Put it here instead OK
5. 00:38:413 (3) - Maybe adjust this spacing to make it even with the previous two notes OK

Seto Kousuke wrote:

Irc mod with shadow

2017-08-23 22:12 yShadowXOP_: ACTION is listening to [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1376113 Brad Breeck - Gravity Falls OST (16bit cover)]
2017-08-23 22:15 Seto Kousuke: quer aquele feedback?
2017-08-23 22:16 yShadowXOP_: claro
2017-08-23 22:16 Seto Kousuke: o mapa, como esperado tá muito bom, tua estrutura é bem clean
2017-08-23 22:16 Seto Kousuke: mas ainda tem aquele problema com intensidades, e algumas inconsistencias
2017-08-23 22:16 Seto Kousuke: sem contar com alguns conceitos que acho que seria importante tu lembrar na hora de fazer uma pattern
2017-08-23 22:16 Seto Kousuke: então bora lá, um passo de cada vez
2017-08-23 22:17 Seto Kousuke: o mapa é cs 4,8...cs5 praticamente
2017-08-23 22:17 Seto Kousuke: quando o mapa é de CS alto, tu tem que botar na cabeça que 100% do tempo o jogador vai ter estresse na aim
2017-08-23 22:17 Seto Kousuke: isso é importante lembrar ^
2017-08-23 22:17 Seto Kousuke: o mapa por si só ja dá um estresse grande
2017-08-23 22:17 Seto Kousuke: então tu não pode usar patterns com um estresse demasiado que joga doloroso sem razão, por exemplo:
2017-08-23 22:17 Seto Kousuke: 00:23:232 (1,1,2) - 
2017-08-23 22:18 Seto Kousuke: 2 erros grotescos aqui que apareceram , principalmente por causa do estresse do CS
2017-08-23 22:18 Seto Kousuke: 1- linha reta
2017-08-23 22:18 Seto Kousuke: logo na transição
2017-08-23 22:18 Seto Kousuke: isso joga muito dolorido...e ainda aplica um estresse muito grande no jogador
2017-08-23 22:18 Seto Kousuke: quando eu digo estresse, não é de ''URGH TO PUTO'', é estresse de desgaste
2017-08-23 22:18 Seto Kousuke: tu força o jogador a se desgastar cada vez mais sem necessidade entende?
2017-08-23 22:19 Seto Kousuke: o segundo problema é o DS delas
2017-08-23 22:19 Seto Kousuke: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8920529 observa como é ''quase o msm DS''
2017-08-23 22:19 Seto Kousuke: eu dei um NC ali só pra tu ver as setinhas
2017-08-23 22:19 Seto Kousuke: se fosse o mesmo DS, seria menos doloroso
2017-08-23 22:19 Seto Kousuke: mas como tu faz o 3 ficar menor do que 1->2  é ainda mais estresse na mira do jogador
2017-08-23 22:19 Seto Kousuke: porque além de ele ter que manter a mira numa velocidade super constante e estressada
2017-08-23 22:20 Seto Kousuke: tu ainda faz ele ter que diminuir a velocidade no meio do caminho
2017-08-23 22:20 Seto Kousuke: fazendo com que seja um movimento super merda de jogar
2017-08-23 22:20 yShadowXOP_: entao deveria diminuir os DS da slider aos circulos?
2017-08-23 22:20 Seto Kousuke: hmmm.....das 2 uma:
2017-08-23 22:20 Seto Kousuke: ou tu deixa o DS do 1->2 igual ao de 2->3 
2017-08-23 22:20 Seto Kousuke: ou tu tira essa linha reta
2017-08-23 22:20 Seto Kousuke: e bota um ângulo melhor
2017-08-23 22:21 Seto Kousuke: regra de bíblia: todos os movimentos de 90° são levemente doloridos...todos os movimentos de 80°-40° são super confortaveis
2017-08-23 22:21 Seto Kousuke: e os de 30° pra baixo são situacionais, precisam de uma pattern e motivo
2017-08-23 22:21 Seto Kousuke: todos os movimentos de 91° pra cima vão jogar esquisito, a não ser que tu faça uma pattern bacana
2017-08-23 22:21 Seto Kousuke: e um flow bacana...mas mesmo assim, não é recomendado abusar muito
2017-08-23 22:22 Seto Kousuke: linha reta = 180°, entende agora? o
2017-08-23 22:22 Seto Kousuke: o:
2017-08-23 22:22 yShadowXOP_: tendeu ;v vo replanejar esse meu kiai da vida
2017-08-23 22:22 Seto Kousuke: poise, isso acontece bastante
2017-08-23 22:22 Seto Kousuke: 00:26:124 (1,1,2) - 
2017-08-23 22:22 Seto Kousuke: não foi 180° mas muito próximo
2017-08-23 22:22 Seto Kousuke: mesmo problema
2017-08-23 22:23 Seto Kousuke: 00:29:016 (1,1,2) - aqui tambem, um pouco acima de 90°
2017-08-23 22:23 Seto Kousuke: e com um DS bem mais doloroso do 1->1
2017-08-23 22:23 Seto Kousuke: é um problema similar ao mapa do imperial circus, as transições tão com uns movimentos muito estressantes e ainda com DS inconsistente entende
2017-08-23 22:24 Seto Kousuke: agora pro segundo problema
2017-08-23 22:24 Seto Kousuke: intensidades
2017-08-23 22:24 Seto Kousuke: ao que deu de entender do teu mapping, da música e da escolha de kiai
2017-08-23 22:24 Seto Kousuke: era pra ser '' intensidade ok...KIAI WOW....intensidade ok'' fim do mapa
2017-08-23 22:24 Seto Kousuke: no entanto, tu fez ''intensidade ok com inconsistencia....KIAI WOW....KIAI WOW'' fim do mapa
2017-08-23 22:24 Seto Kousuke: isso é claramente observado aqui olha só
2017-08-23 22:25 Seto Kousuke: 00:32:269 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - 
2017-08-23 22:25 Seto Kousuke: isso é muito igual se não tão forte quanto as que tem no kiai
2017-08-23 22:25 Seto Kousuke: quando tá super diferente do começo do mapa
2017-08-23 22:25 Seto Kousuke: por mais que tu quisesse fazer ele ser mais forte que o inicio do mapa, ainda tá forte demais
2017-08-23 22:25 Seto Kousuke: tá muito igual o kiai, tornando assim inconsistente a construção das sessões
2017-08-23 22:26 yShadowXOP_: hm entao seria aconcelhavem dimunir um pouco mais o DS dele?
2017-08-23 22:26 Seto Kousuke: sim
2017-08-23 22:26 Seto Kousuke: ou isso, ou mudar algumas singles pra sliders
2017-08-23 22:26 Seto Kousuke: igual tu fez no inicio do mapa
2017-08-23 22:26 Seto Kousuke: usar menos DS e mais sliders
2017-08-23 22:26 Seto Kousuke: ja acabou o kiai, ja acabou a energia, não precisa meter pattern de 13 single notes com jumps
2017-08-23 22:27 Seto Kousuke: alguma dúvida sobre esse ponto?
2017-08-23 22:27 Seto Kousuke: ou posso ir pro próximo
2017-08-23 22:27 yShadowXOP_: pode ir
2017-08-23 22:27 Seto Kousuke: baleza
2017-08-23 22:28 Seto Kousuke: agora é sobre a inconsistencia da intro
2017-08-23 22:28 Seto Kousuke: como eu havia falado, a intro era pra ser ''ok'' na intensidade correto? 
2017-08-23 22:28 Seto Kousuke: mais fraco que o kiai
2017-08-23 22:28 Seto Kousuke: e mais fraco ou igual ao fim do mapa
2017-08-23 22:28 Seto Kousuke: então fica muito bagunçado e inconsistente você começar com isso aqui:
2017-08-23 22:28 Seto Kousuke: 00:08:775 (1,2,3,4,5) - 
2017-08-23 22:28 Seto Kousuke: compara esse DS absurdo
2017-08-23 22:28 Seto Kousuke: com isso aqui 00:09:859 (5,1,2,3) - 
2017-08-23 22:29 Seto Kousuke: olha a diferença brutal
2017-08-23 22:29 Seto Kousuke: e a música tá simplesmente igual, super de boa
2017-08-23 22:29 Seto Kousuke: 00:13:112 (1,2,3,4) - e aqui tu continua fraco
2017-08-23 22:29 Seto Kousuke: ou seja, dá de entender que era pra intro ser fraca
2017-08-23 22:29 Seto Kousuke: mas ali no começo tem uma explosão absurda
2017-08-23 22:29 Seto Kousuke: 00:10:943 (3,4,5) - mesma coisa aqui
2017-08-23 22:30 Seto Kousuke: toda hora tu fica trocando a lógica de intensidade
2017-08-23 22:30 Seto Kousuke: uma hora tu explode do nada, outra hora tu faz jump em uma sessão onde logo depois tu fez super perto e era o mesmo som
2017-08-23 22:30 Seto Kousuke: tu precisa manter uma ideia na cabeça e falar ''ok, vai funcionar assim:''
2017-08-23 22:30 Seto Kousuke: o teu estilo é super clean e bem estruturado no visual, então tu acaba ficando preso às lógicas de estrutura
2017-08-23 22:31 Seto Kousuke: ai tu meio que é obrigado a seguir elas...então tu precisa ficar consistente
2017-08-23 22:31 Seto Kousuke: 00:13:112 (1,2,3,4) - por exemplo aqui era a transição, e tu fez super apertado com pouco DS
2017-08-23 22:32 Seto Kousuke: 00:10:943 (3,4,5,1) - mas aqui tu fez jump
2017-08-23 22:32 Seto Kousuke: e a primeira transição que eu linkei é muito mais importante que essa
2017-08-23 22:32 Seto Kousuke: e só pra finalizar, lembra o que eu falei dos angulos?  00:14:558 (1,2,3) - 
2017-08-23 22:32 yShadowXOP_: yup
2017-08-23 22:33 Seto Kousuke: além de isso ser muito agudo pra esse momento, olha o que tu faz logo em seguida:
2017-08-23 22:33 Seto Kousuke: 00:15:100 (2,3,4) - viu a linha reta?
2017-08-23 22:33 Seto Kousuke: por mais que seja 2 sliders 1/2 espelhados
2017-08-23 22:33 Seto Kousuke: eles jogam parado por causa do tamanho deles
2017-08-23 22:33 Seto Kousuke: então fica 2 issues combadas...o angulo bem agudo com a linha reta
2017-08-23 22:33 Seto Kousuke: essa pattern em sí joga muito wanky
2017-08-23 22:34 Seto Kousuke: 00:16:004 (1,2,3) - ó a linha reta enfraquecendo o flow de novo
2017-08-23 22:34 Seto Kousuke: e bom, é isso
2017-08-23 22:34 Seto Kousuke: o mapa tá bem estruturadinho, tá bonito....mas tem problemas similares ao do circus lá, inconsistencia nos DS e problema de ênfase nos momentos adequados
2017-08-23 22:35 Seto Kousuke: te aconselho padronizar as coisas ''pra 1/2 comuns eu vou usar X de DS''
2017-08-23 22:35 Seto Kousuke: ''pra 1/2 jump em transição e afins eu uso Y''
2017-08-23 22:35 Seto Kousuke: ''pra momentos MUITO fortes eu uso Z''
2017-08-23 22:35 Seto Kousuke: ''pra momentos onde não é intensidade mas preciso de um pequeno jump pra pattern eu uso X + B''
2017-08-23 22:35 Seto Kousuke: etc
2017-08-23 22:38 Seto Kousuke: agora o que não é um erro, mas uma observação mesmo
2017-08-23 22:38 Seto Kousuke: não é melhor deletar isso? 00:04:076 (4) - 
2017-08-23 22:38 Seto Kousuke: 00:03:714 (3) - faz uma reverse
2017-08-23 22:38 Seto Kousuke: 00:04:257 - bota single note aqui
2017-08-23 22:38 Seto Kousuke: ritmo vai fazer muito mais sentido com a música, porque se tu bota 2 cliques de slider 1/2 ali
2017-08-23 22:38 Seto Kousuke: tu tá dizendo que os 2 cliques são importantes no ritmo
2017-08-23 22:39 Seto Kousuke: quando o que tu apresentou foi 00:02:992 (1) - 
2017-08-23 22:39 Seto Kousuke: o que de fato joga melhor do que 2 cliques
2017-08-23 22:40 yShadowXOP_: hm ate q fico melhor msm

fiz um irc mod com o shadow na ultima diff, percebi agora que o mapset é de BRs, se vocês quiserem um irc mod também, é só me procurar in-game quando eu não estiver jogando que eu dou uma olhada

rockstarrzz wrote:

Hi, from modreqs

Normal

Reduce OD to 3? i think its fine
00:02:992 (1,3) - could make same shape? done
00:08:594 (5,6) - i think make these parallel to 4? its alright rn imo
00:19:618 (4,1) - spacing seems a bit big reduced just a bit
00:26:124 (5) - nc my bad, fixed
00:26:485 (1) - remove nc previous sound is rly distinct imo so another NC here is fine
00:35:160 (1) - same slider as 5 sound are pretty different so i dont see why
there are nc issues but it's really weird as alot are on slidertails

Advanced

AR5.5/6 OD4.5/5 ? increased AR to 6, OD is already at 5 .-.
00:04:437 (1) - same angle as 00:02:992 (1) just variating a bit, i dont see that as a problem
00:05:883 (1,3) - keep angles consistent, decide on a couple to use throughout the map and stick to it otherwise it seems too random ^
00:12:208 (2,3,4) - overlaps look a bit crap moved objects a bit
00:24:678 (1,2,3,4) - looks ugly, take the first one and rotate the other 3 by the same angle, 90, 180, 270 ect looks fine to me rn, i'll consider changing if someone point that out again
00:35:160 (1) - remove nc explanation for that in Normal
hm..there are some slider shape/angle issues here

Insane

jump spam is a little ott imo
00:29:377 (1) - remove nc explanation for that in Normal
00:29:377 (1,2,3) - keep slider shape consistent that's to make contrast with the next 3 sliders since they have a cleaner sound imo
00:30:823 (1) - remove nc explanation for that in Normal
00:32:269 (1) - ^ ^
00:32:269 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - too random wow i didn't notice that, fixed
00:35:160 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ew god no, don't do that why not?
00:36:787 (2,3) - blanket sure
00:41:305 (1) - put in center doesn't change much but i prefer it where it is rn

rockstarrzz wrote:

Hi, from modreqs

ShadowX's Hard

AR8 OD6 is far too high for a <3*, consider AR7 OD6, even then that seems a bit high
00:03:714 (3,4) - add note inbetween on red? Nop,because in this part I'm following the "clap"
00:05:160 (3,4) - same ^
00:06:606 (3,4) - ^ ^
00:13:654 (2,4) - stack properly Ok
00:14:558 (1,2) - blanket? Nop
rest is very good
maybe you could scale it up a little bit to make it 3.15* or so? i'll think about it later

ShadowX's Summer Adventure

wow this jump spam
change to od9 and u got a 'good' farm map here
00:17:449 (1,2,3) - maybe some spacing here? Nop
00:18:895 (1,2,3,4) - and here ^
00:31:726 (2,1) - too close Ok

Thanks For Modding

• ShadowX's Summer Adventures

1. 00:20:160 (5,6) - to what are they mapped? it seems overmapped to me at least lol
2. 00:24:678 (1,1,2) - looks a bit unorganized u could try structuring the jumps a bit more
3. 00:28:293 (1,2,1,2) - i think they are a bit too spaced like most jumps here are 2 - 2.5 and 00:28:654 (1,2) - they increase up to 3.0 for no reason it should rather be lower spaced cuz pitch is lower too
4. 00:30:823 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - uh... contrast isnt there it feels almost as spaced as the jumps before making the jumps before that less spaced fixxes that and makes the difference of it more noticable (cuz u apparently tried to make the higher pitch there stand out with moar spacing)
5. 00:30:100 (1,1) - unintended overlap i guess... looks kinda bad try to structure it a bit more
6. 00:32:991 (1,2) - same

Moge-ko wrote:

Smol mod lul

• ShadowX's Summer Adventures

1. 00:20:160 (5,6) - to what are they mapped? it seems overmapped to me at least lol maybe it's a little bit for consistency?
2. 00:24:678 (1,1,2) - looks a bit unorganized u could try structuring the jumps a bit more Ok
3. 00:28:293 (1,2,1,2) - i think they are a bit too spaced like most jumps here are 2 - 2.5 and 00:28:654 (1,2) - they increase up to 3.0 for no reason it should rather be lower spaced cuz pitch is lower too Fixed
4. 00:30:823 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - uh... contrast isnt there it feels almost as spaced as the jumps before making the jumps before that less spaced fixxes that and makes the difference of it more noticable (cuz u apparently tried to make the higher pitch there stand out with moar spacing) i tried to highlight the finishing of the kiai with an extra spacing
5. 00:30:100 (1,1) - unintended overlap i guess... looks kinda bad try to structure it a bit more i think this overlap is great
6. 00:32:991 (1,2) - same ^

Thanks For Modding

UniqueBlock11 wrote:

Hello from my queue.

general
Add ShadowX and Victor to tags done
Kiai inconsistencies: GDs dont need to have same kiai times

Not extremely important, but combo color inconsistencies: fixed


Your map has +12 SP, you can get Beatmap Nominators to check your map. i'll do that

normal
00:18:895 (3) - This slider overlaps the error bar at the bottom of the screen, you don't have to move it but I'd recommend you do. i'll keep that for now, i'll change only if necessary
00:19:618 (4,1) - Distance snap problem in Normal diff, (1) to far from (4). i dont see that as a huge deal, i'm just emphasizing the kiai start
00:20:341 - Kiai should start here. This is where the more intense part of the song occurs, don't start Kiai on the first object in the Kiai unless if it really is needed. actually youre timestamp is where the song ''transition'' to kiai is, then 00:20:702 (1) - is where the intense and characteristic parts kick in so i dont see any problem here
00:26:124 (1) - Remove NC, this is only a transition from the previous combo to the next and shouldn't be NCed. This also keeps combos consistent in your map. this is a very distinct from the others so i dont see any problem NCing that also
00:31:907 - Kiai starts here ^, and have it end at 00:38:413 (6). Otherwise, you'd have a 3 second Kiai period... explanation above, and the map has 38sec drain, 3sec kiai isnt out of place imo

advanced
00:08:775 (5) - Add NC, and remove NC on 00:09:136 (2), this looks and flows better with the music. done
00:11:666 (1,2,3,4) - This distance snapping looks a bit misleading, you should space (3) and (4) the same way you did (1) and (2) to prevent confusion. my bad, fixed
00:20:341 - Kiai should start here. This is where the more intense part of the song occurs, don't start Kiai on the first object in the Kiai unless if it really is needed. explanation for that in normal
00:31:907 - Kiai starts here ^, and have it end at 00:38:413 (6). ^

insane
You jumped an entire star from the previous difficulty to this one... that's not a good thing. You might want to lower the difficulty of this map by a bit. yeah, i'll probably need to nerf this down a bit, but i'll keep that as it is rn

00:08:775 (1) - Improve this sliderwave for visual appeal: done

00:23:232 (1) - ^ as said in normal, i find this sound pretty distinct from the others so a different slider shape is suitable
00:26:124 (1) - ^ ^
00:36:245 (1,2,3) - Improve the double blankets here. done

Thx for the mod

UniqueBlock11 wrote:

Hello from my queue.

shadowx's hard
00:13:112 (1,3) - You can improve this blanket. Fixed
00:37:690 (1,3) - ^ ^

shadowx's summer adventures
00:08:413 (5) - If you're evil like me, convert this to a stream and challenge the insanely pro players without regrets (optional). i think not XD
00:20:341 - Use softer hitsounds here, using this loud normal sampleset is really startling. Ok

Thanks For Modding

rockstarrzz wrote:

Hi, from modreqs

Victor's Easy

00:22:871 (6,1) - This gap seems..awkward, maybe change 6 into a slider?
00:30:823 (1) - remove nc
yeah, solid map, not much to say

Victor's Light Insane

00:09:859 (1) - rotate and copy paste for 2
00:19:979 (1) - remove nc
00:21:064 (1,2) - rotate by same angle
00:29:377 (1,2) - parallel
00:38:413 (3) - extend to red?
good map

fixed all

UniqueBlock11 wrote:

victor's easy
00:11:666 (4) - NC, this slider occurs on the start of a measure, and remove NC on 00:12:751 (1).
00:14:558 (3) - NC for same reason ^, remove NC on 00:15:642 (1).
00:17:449 (4) - NC ^, remove NC on 00:18:895 (1).
00:20:702 (3) - NC ^
00:20:341 - Kiai should start here. This is where the more intense part of the song occurs, don't start Kiai on the first object in the Kiai unless if it really is needed.

victor's light insane
Redundant inherited timing points:
00:10:582
00:31:726
00:38:775

okay fixed all

Stormiverse wrote:

NM from my Q~
Just a small mod if you don't mind

[ShadowX's Hard]

1. 00:05:883 (1,3) - I think it would look nicer if these two are aligned, like at 00:02:992 (1,3) - . It just seems off to me.

SPOILER

All Fixed
Thanks For Modding

Naotoshi wrote:

[insane]
this diff has same issue as the top one, except even more so.
00:09:317 (2,3,4,5,6) - stuff like this, while it looks pretty, doesn't follow the same thing as 00:11:666 (1,2,3) - this kinda thing. so you end up with this weird contrast between parts where the melody is off having 1/2 spam and tons of jumps and then the parts with the melody on are really calm tapping wise. i don't rly get your point here, i just choose to map what had the most emphasis in the song itself

then the kiai comes and its just polygon generated jump patterns with little relevance to the song. like 00:21:787 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - 1234 have a held melody note, then 56 have one and 78 have one but its not differentiated at all. 00:27:570 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - same here.
the 1/2 spam also has the same issue, it seems like its just there to inflate difficulty and stuff instead of really following the important part of the song. the background track shouldn't be supporting fullscreen jumps everywhere, that just feels very overdone to me.

and then, to top things off, after making the entire thing 1/2 jumps based on the pitch, you put the highest pitch things on small spacing sliders at 00:29:377 (1,2,3,1,1,2,3) - ... >.> i prefer giving SV emphasis rather than spacing

anyway yeah, the top diffs need a lot of work. good luck!

Thx for the mod . I see there's a lot of wrong stuff here so i'll basically remap my diff keeping your points in mind.

Neoskylove wrote:

Q

[Insane]
00:10:763 (2,3,4,5,6) - you don't need to add many beats in here. so you're suggesting what exactly? .-.
00:15:642 (5,1) - why you reduced DS suddenly? It has emphasis, so you should jump here. my bad, i'll do that in the remap
00:34:799 (1,1) - only this part doesn't have jump? kiai has ended so idk why this should be a jump, its fine rn imo
00:38:413 (3) - NC? yea fixed

GL

Thx for the mod

Naotoshi wrote:

[summer adventures]
this diff feels really overdone to me. it's true there's a background 1/2 track, but this (to me) should not mean that you just go ham and map giant jumps and 1/2 spam everywhere. you lose a lot of ability to represent the song by doing this.

some examples of what i mean:
00:21:787 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - in the middle of this pattern, the melody type thing changes notes. but that's not represented at all since it's a 1-2 jump pattern.

00:24:678 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - same deal here, the melody has a scale going downwards but its just the same 1-2 jumps that you used earlier. i tried to do what you have said.

i noticed that you changed the jump spacing based on the pitch. that's fine, but to me it is not representative enough of the song, especially at this level of difficulty where you have tons of freedom as to what you can do.


the other issue is the intro, the filler rhythm like 00:09:317 (2,3,4) - kinda screws up your rhythm imo. it makes it unclear what you follow. if you used a rhythm like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9009797 then it would be much more clear, since all the clicks now land on kicks in the drum line. switching between the main melody and the background 1/2 track just creates muddled rhythm that is subpar. Okay, the slider was put in place of the jump.

you could also use this technique in the kiai to try and break up the 1-2 jump sections into a more recognizable rhythm.

Naotoshi wrote:

[light insane]
there is some weird spacing stuff I saw here, and again some of the same issues as the top diffs.

00:03:353 (2,3) - for example, giant jump here? but there's nothing on 3 to support this. so ctrl g on 3 works better (fixed ?)
00:04:799 (2,3) - similarly now its a tiny jump, you could ctrl g 3+4 so it looks like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9009992 or something (changed X: and Y:)

00:05:883 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - this pattern doesn't really make sense with the song. first off its suddenly pretty big jumps considering that everything before it is 1/2 sliders. additionally, the song creates 2 pairs of 4 notes (00:05:883 (1,2,3,4) - 00:06:606 (5,6,1) -) but you divide it 3-3-2 instead of 4-4 which then puts 2 notes that were previously both clickable on the same slider. 00:07:329 (2) - the change in the song appears here, so this is where the next NC and pattern should start, not 00:06:967 (1) - (well , the circles gave more difficult star's to the music, without him it's practically a ''slider map'', but if you tell it's better I gonna see what the other's tell about but thanks <3)

00:11:124 (1,2,3) - stuff like this dilutes what you're focusing on in the melody(.i tried to follow the intense part of the music and the not intensive)like 00:11:666 (4,5,6,7) - very obviously follows the main synth but then you have more intense jumps on stuff that isn't in the melody at all. these jumps are not so extreme it's DS 1.3 00:13:654 (1,2,3,4) - same here, the biggest jumps are in a part that's completely separate from a melody.

00:28:654 (3,1) - im not really sure why you decided to put all the finishes on slider ends and then have giant jumps to fairly unimportant notes to make the next pattern. wouldn't 1/1 gaps work better..? (i remove all finish sounds)

anyway yeah, the top diffs need a lot of work. good luck!
thank you <3

ChaoticRed wrote:

I'm not that specific at modding so I prolly won't help you in any way, but I can try

I can't find anything in Summer Adventures and Insane.

Advanced

00:08:052 (3,4) - I'd make the slider one reverse arrow longer and erased the circle, arranged in any way you want. i'll consider that, but i think its fine as it is rn

Normal

00:18:895 (1) - really offscreen its ok when playing, i'll keep that for now
00:26:124 (5) - I'd remove the NC here i'm NCing that sound in my diffs since its a very distinct sound imo

Thx for the mod

Simuzax wrote:

ChaoticRed wrote:

I'm not that specific at modding so I prolly won't help you in any way, but I can try

I can't find anything in Summer Adventures and Insane.

Advanced

00:08:052 (3,4) - I'd make the slider one reverse arrow longer and erased the circle, arranged in any way you want. i'll consider that, but i think its fine as it is rn

Normal

00:18:895 (1) - really offscreen its ok when playing, i'll keep that for now
00:26:124 (5) - I'd remove the NC here i'm NCing that sound in my diffs since its a very distinct sound imo

Thx for the mod

ChaoticRed wrote:

ShadowX's Hard

00:31:546 (4) - this could not be offscreen, even one space up Fixed

I might have just been looking for sth wrong in this map when there's obviously nothing wrong with it. Great mapset! Sorry for short mod, but I pointed out in my queue that I'm a beginner at this. Thanks For Modding

Mistaken wrote:

Heyo. Sorry for the long wait. Been super busy. From Mistaken/Scarlet Modding Queue

ShadowX's Summer Adventures
00:02:992 (1,2,3,4) - Same as the insane. Maybe change one of the threes pattern. nop, that's good
00:09:498 (3,1) - Overlap Intentional
00:22:690 (2,1,1,2) - ^ Not really a fun of how this overlaps but playability is fine ^
00:25:763 (1,1) - ^ Overlap^
00:28:654 (1,1) - ^^

Thanks For Modding

Mistaken wrote:

Heyo. Sorry for the long wait. Been super busy. From Mistaken/Scarlet Modding Queue

Not really much to say. Just a few things to point out that I nitpick a lot about.

Insane
00:02:992 (1,2,3) - This repeats 6 times. Sure it help a player recognize the pattern and rhythm but I got bored of it after about 2 or 3. Maybe play with a bit of patterning. its fine imo, ill keep that for now
00:21:064 (3,5) - Overlap fixed
00:21:606 (6,3) - ^ fixed
00:28:654 (7,1) - ^ fixed

Good luck on the map though. Its pretty good. Definitelya good DT farm

Thx for the mod

C-Yuyuko wrote:

From my mod queue

ShadowX's Summer Adventures

00:35:883 (1,2) - breaks flow Fixed

Thanks For Modding

C-Yuyuko wrote:

From my mod queue

Insane

00:32:269 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - consider making it neater with Ctrl+Shift+D i'm doing it like that so overlaps dont fuck up, next object also follows the (2,4,6) curve so i think its ok
00:14:558 (1,2,3,4) - make it like this i rly dont see why, this would just turn DS here inconsistent
Generally, I'd suggest the jumps to be aligned in an isometric grid

Other diffs look okay to me, good luck

Thx for the mod

Ali- wrote:

hi, from my modding q (bit late hehe)

[Summer Adventures]
00:08:413 (5) - i think maybe this needs to have a hitsound, or just a lowered volume. the soft hitnormal in pretty much all skins are way too high pitched to represent the drum, and it sounds really out of place
00:11:666 (1) - i understand the change in flow here, and i really like it, but the flow changes again on the proceeding slider as if nothing happened. it looks and feels awk
00:13:112 (1,2) - follow points arent good here triggered (move 00:13:112 (1) - to 32,294?)
00:14:558 (1,2) - follow point issue again. imo it looks a lot worse and sacrifices little to no playability to fix these issues. the follow point should come off the end of the slider in a smooth way, this just looks too janky (ill try my best to stop pointing these out, you get the jist and will deny them all if you've denied these two)
00:19:979 (4) - i feel like this holds no emphasis and is only placed where it is to support structure. you could make it feel better by doing something like this
the next section is very structurally sound, everything works how its supposed to, but im not a fan of the heavy copy-paste at all
00:32:630 (1,2) - this weird looking overlap is the only real problem which isnt based solely on preference with the ending
00:31:907 - whats up with the random hitsound changes?

good, safe map for ranking standards, although a bit boring. thank you for the pp!lol
ill do another since its so short and ill feel scummy otherwise hehe

good luck, either way!All Fixed Thanks For Modding

Behonkiss wrote:

From my mod queue. Sorry for the delayed response.

Normal:

00:11:666 (1) Feel like you should lower the repeat end a bit so it stays within the grid. the repeat itself is already within the grid .-.

Advanced:

00:13:112 (1) Doesn't feel like this needs to be a new combo. the pitch change(i guess thats what its called) here is pretty significant imo so i dont see any problem

Thx for the mod

Dashyy- wrote:

mod 4 mod

hard:

00:09:317 (2,3) - should ds these if you're trying to keep with the consistent spacing
00:18:714 (4,1,2,3,4) - why exactly did you change rhythm here? i don't think the buildup sound in the background calls for a change this drastic

All Fixed

Dashyy- wrote:

mod 4 mod

shouldn't the title be Gravity Falls Theme Song as many of the ranked sets have that?

normal:

00:05:883 (1,2) - pattern here is not very presentable compared to the rest of the map imo. use this instead fixed in another way
00:13:112 (1) - i would suggest moving this slider up so it flows into 00:14:196 (2) - nicely fixed
00:20:702 (1,2,3,4,5) - rhythm here is counter-intuitive, use this to prioritize downbeat on 5
(kinda like what you did at 00:23:594 (1,2,3,4,1) - ) that would need a full remap imo, i guess i'll try to work on that but not sure
00:26:485 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - same rhythm issue ^
00:29:377 (1,2,3,4) - missing claps? using softer ones
00:35:160 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - clap ^
00:39:226 (1) - might wanna move this slider over to 00:39:498 (1) - , as where it is right now is too fast for a beginner to react to idk how lowering the spinner duration would be better in any way here lol, i'd just give them less time to start spinning

adv:

00:18:534 (3) - assuming that you're following the held out synths in the background, this slider isn't really following that intuitively. i would use this, as it follows those sounds a lot more smoothly yea fixed

for the chorus, i would suggest that you use 1/2 repeats to break monotony, as it's pretty boring rn. remember to be consistent with them and to not use major rhythm changes when not appropriate

00:29:377 (1,2,3,1,1,2,3,1) - clap, also assuming that this section is supposed to be different from the lack of claps, you chould change up rhythm they're already using a softer clap
00:37:690 (1,2) - you should make this a slider for consistency fixed

insane:

gap between insane and light insane is kinda huge compared to the rest of the set. might want to get another diff or buff light insane i'll probably do that

other than that everything else is fine.

o ya here's my map: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/626065

Thx for the mod , i'll get to yours probably tomorrow since i'm pretty sleepy rn.

ChaoticRed wrote:

Victor's Light Insane

00:03:714 (3,4) - wouldn't making those to go in the opposite like the previous one be better?
00:10:582 (6,1) - https://puu.sh/xB8ic/18b5a7c1ad.png you can make the angle of this slider a bit sharper to fit the blanket better and put it at x:288 y:328

Easy

00:07:329 (4) - https://puu.sh/xB8KN/92016e9053.png I'd do this one like that.

fixed all

neonat wrote:

General

The Easy has a SV that is faster than the Normal, I feel that itself is already odd. The SV in Easy could be slower. (remake with 0.70 slider speed)

Victor's Easy

00:31:907 (3) - following what was the pattern before, this would have been a NC (fixed)

Victor's Light Insane

00:06:967 (1) - this beat goes along with the phrase before this part 00:05:883 (1,2,3) - but it's now place in a different combo, a different pattern, a different position, it breaks it all apart. The start of the next phrase should have been 00:07:329 (2) - even the snare begins here, it should not have been placed together with 00:06:967 (1) - in terms of phrasing
Could do with some finish hitsounds, where the cymbals are like at 00:20:341 and 00:31:907 for example
00:21:787 (5,6) vs 00:21:064 (3,4) - the pitch at 00:21:787 (5,6,1) is higher, but the spacing between them is much lower and less significant than that of 00:21:064 (3,4) - also note that 00:21:787 (5,6,1) encompasses the 2 higher pitched beats, so it's at 00:22:510 (2) that it goes down again, but then you can see that at the moment, 00:22:148 (1,2) are matched patterns though it is between 2 different parts of the song. It's things like this that I feel can be improved upon, having things mash better with the phrasing of each part of the song. Take for example 00:24:678 (3) - the change in the tone here, 00:24:678 (3,4,5,6) differs from 00:24:317 (1,2) - but it is most likely being cloaked by the current pattern because they are merged into one repeating pattern.
Likewise 00:26:485 (4,5,6) vs 00:27:570 (7,1,2) - also note the NCing is getting irregular in this difficulty
00:29:196 (1,2) - could space them apart, like 00:30:642 (1,2)
00:36:967 (1,1) - the bigger spacing could be between 00:36:787 (2,1) - rather than 00:37:510 (2,1) - the highest tone is at 00:36:967 (1) fixed almost everything
i change some stuff you can check if more cool , but i remove some overmapped things , thank's for the big help <3



Good Luck

Dashyy- wrote:

mod 4 mod

shouldn't the title be Gravity Falls Theme Song as many of the ranked sets have that?

easy:

00:12:751 (2,3) - rhythm seems kinda out of place here, i would suggest using this to prioritize the downbeat (no)
00:14:558 (1,2) - not a huge deal, but i would make this a 3/2 reverse for consistency (ok)
00:18:895 (2,3) - odd rhythm again. use this instead so 4 gets full emphasis
00:31:907 (3) - think ur missing a nc yep

light insane:

00:06:967 (1) - nc should start on 00:07:329 (2) - instead
00:05:883 (1,2,3) - spacing wise these aren't consistent with the previous patterns, you should atleast space these out more if you want to keep this movement, and also make 00:06:967 (1) - part of the pattern aswell
(changed some things)

Xoul wrote:

Heyo. Sorry for the long wait. Been super busy. From Mistaken/Scarlet Modding Queue

Not really much to say. Just a few things to point out that I nitpick a lot about.

Victor's Light Insane
00:08:052 (5,6,1) - This could technically flow into the 1 due to the fact the drumroll goes longer (no)
00:08:775 (1,2) - Overlap (fixed)
00:11:305 (2,4) - Either stack or space out 2 (ok)
00:32:991 (3,6) - ^ (ok)


Good luck on the map though. Its pretty good. Definitelya good DT farm

C-Yuyuko wrote:

Victor's Light Insane

00:15:100 (2,3) - Ctrl+G ok
00:33:353 (5,1) - switch NC (ok)
00:17:449 (1,2,1,2,1,2,3,4) - consider making this section to this, this, and this, because flow no

Other diffs look okay to me, good luck

[Miko] wrote:

ShadowX's Hard
00:02:992 (1,2) - Might want to switch the direction both of these sliders curve to let them flow into each other better (See Here)
00:09:498 (3) - Curve the other way?
00:11:666 (1,2) - Try something neater with these sliders, flow is good, but aesthetics aren't.
00:21:967 (2,3) - You could probably blanket this a little better
00:24:678 (1,2,3) - Could make this a perfect triangle
00:27:570 (1,2,3) - ^^
00:33:353 (1,2,3) - ^^
Rest of it seems good to me, not too much to mod in a 41 second map

All Fixed,Thanks For Modding

realy0_ wrote:

hello from my queue

a

ShadowX's Hard
almost no complain, just this
00:26:485 (2) - could be more curved to diffenciate it from 00:26:847 (3,4) - I will think
00:30:823 (2) - ^ ^ Same

ShadowX's Summer Adventures
00:27:931 (1,2) - i would ctrl+g it, i know it would break the clock flow but it's seems more natural like that for me. Nop
00:31:184 (1,2) - ^ ^ Same :v

if the star rating is too low, raise a bit the difficulty of the jumps
[/url]

nice difficulty, couldn't find a lot of suggestion here. gl ! Thanks For Modding