I'm not paranoid, I'm just solving a puzzle. What you think about it is your call.
forum
Information Mafia
posted
Total Posts
888
I have no idea if it directs to Royston or maybe to Vertify. Most likely just a play from mod.
I think so, or maybe Rantai, I doubt there's a new guy, but it's also possible.
an anagram? I doubt.
Harden - bergia...
inb4 bastard game
an anagram? I doubt.
Harden - bergia...
inb4 bastard game
I seriously doubt it redirects to any of the current players. It's most likely a hint for a SerialKiller, as I mentioned before, though the mod probably lied as I mentioned I feel like there might be such possibility.
And yes, most likely a bastard game.
And yes, most likely a bastard game.
Topic Starter
I don't think I have it in me to host a game that's not at least somewhat bastard. (Excluding those newbie mafia style games I've done.)fartownik wrote:
And yes, most likely a bastard game.
However, I will not lie this game, as that's not this game's gimmick.
All hints are important.
Hardenbergia isn't even a real user, so either it's a fake name for someone or it means something special
it anagrams to "harbingered a". lol? maybe it's gonna end up screwing us over if we leave it there too long or even do something to it
it anagrams to "harbingered a". lol? maybe it's gonna end up screwing us over if we leave it there too long or even do something to it
btw sorry for inactivity, been getting a map ranked and working on other maps + trying to close out mystery mafia
once that game ends I should be a bit more active for then
once that game ends I should be a bit more active for then
Okay, so if you're not lying and all the hints are important - we should probably lynch The 15 Person, unless you just said that so we do it without hesitation.
I get the distinct feeling that there isn't a 15th person.
just my guts though
just my guts though
The only way to find out is to lynch it. If there's no 15th Person then the lynch won't happen and we lose only one day on finding it out, finally getting some info. But if the 15th Person is actually something dangerous, as the mod hints us, it might be just the right move.
Though it might also be a trap - let's say - everyone who was on the lynch wagon of "???" dies after it's dead. If we want to lynch it, let one person vote him and wait 24 hours without posting so the day ends automatically, or wait for the deadline with only one vote on him. This way the losses would be reduced to minimum.
Though it might also be a trap - let's say - everyone who was on the lynch wagon of "???" dies after it's dead. If we want to lynch it, let one person vote him and wait 24 hours without posting so the day ends automatically, or wait for the deadline with only one vote on him. This way the losses would be reduced to minimum.
if there was supposed to be a 15th person, he/she should've posted in the topic while we were signing in (providing there's no premade setup there, that's a possibility though). in any case I still think we should wait until the situation progresses.
It can seriously be anything. LS might've asked someone privately to join an experimental game; it might be Vertify; it might be the mod himself; it might be a first lynched player that gets revived in another role; it might be another player that is playing 2 roles at once; it can be NOTHING as well.rEdo wrote:
if there was supposed to be a 15th person, he/she should've posted in the topic while we were signing in (providing there's no premade setup there, that's a possibility though). in any case I still think we should wait until the situation progresses.
Also if it's someone then it most likely has some kind of post restriction.
I think this is a hoax.
also there is literally nothing that is absurdly bastard that can screw us over. I think the modtalk here is deriving our attention from the goal: finding scum.
overall the inactivity here kills us.
Mod: Prod everyone who can be prodded.
also, I am open for a policy lynch on either kook, yuno or royston. especially the first two will be more of a hindrance than actual help. they also both hinted retardidly at them knowing things.
I would mostly ignore the shenanigans set up by the mod. we should worry about actually doing something instead of speculations.
also there is literally nothing that is absurdly bastard that can screw us over. I think the modtalk here is deriving our attention from the goal: finding scum.
overall the inactivity here kills us.
Mod: Prod everyone who can be prodded.
also, I am open for a policy lynch on either kook, yuno or royston. especially the first two will be more of a hindrance than actual help. they also both hinted retardidly at them knowing things.
I would mostly ignore the shenanigans set up by the mod. we should worry about actually doing something instead of speculations.
IMO traps are complete BS, I see you're watching out for one after what happened in lucid dreamersfartownik wrote:
The only way to find out is to lynch it. If there's no 15th Person then the lynch won't happen and we lose only one day on finding it out, finally getting some info. But if the 15th Person is actually something dangerous, as the mod hints us, it might be just the right move.
Though it might also be a trap - let's say - everyone who was on the lynch wagon of "???" dies after it's dead. If we want to lynch it, let one person vote him and wait 24 hours without posting so the day ends automatically, or wait for the deadline with only one vote on him. This way the losses would be reduced to minimum.
knowing LS seems like something he'd put. I think it's worth having the 15th player out and just playing a normal game.
inb4it's some mechanic where we can't win if it's dead
guys, seriously, stop focusing on things that have no value to them.
we can't check on the 15th player without wasting precious time. so don't fucking do it.
if you continue I will give you scumcred.
we can't check on the 15th player without wasting precious time. so don't fucking do it.
if you continue I will give you scumcred.
so if all the hints are relevant
"No one saw the egg"
"No one found the hint"
"News flash"
I'm still wondering about the first one. at first guess it's related to Yoshi cause why else would there be an egg @_@
I agree with Tanz read my previous post
post with actual content coming later cause I have to leave right now 0.0
"No one saw the egg"
"No one found the hint"
"News flash"
I'm still wondering about the first one. at first guess it's related to Yoshi cause why else would there be an egg @_@
I agree with Tanz read my previous post
post with actual content coming later cause I have to leave right now 0.0
that's exactly why I'm not into lynching that guy. I know it also might work the opposite way, but I'll highly stick to my proposition to leave 15th be. time will show what we have to do.pieguy1372 wrote:
inb4it's some mechanic where we can't win if it's dead
If the mod says he doesn't lie, then I think it's true.
But - it doesn't mean he has good intentions. For example - "???" might be dangerous for us, but only when we lynch it. The mod doesn't lie, but lynching "???" is not in our favor in such scenario.
Though you're probably right. It might as well just a way to move the thread forward.
But - it doesn't mean he has good intentions. For example - "???" might be dangerous for us, but only when we lynch it. The mod doesn't lie, but lynching "???" is not in our favor in such scenario.
Though you're probably right. It might as well just a way to move the thread forward.
Also I guess it was just a light hint for another hint that I've already found, doesn't really matter.pieguy1372 wrote:
so if all the hints are relevant
"No one saw the egg"
"No one found the hint"
"News flash"
I'm still wondering about the first one. at first guess it's related to Yoshi cause why else would there be an egg @_@
By egg is most likely refering to an easter egg, a hint to be careful at night, that was what farto found. Unless they have a deeper meaning.
We shouldn't risk lynching this new(?) guy, we'll find out what he is/does, in this night, everyone that is eager for lynch him is likely scum as they've found a somehow easy lynch, let's stick to the things we already know and find scum, then we can look for the meaning of this Hardenbergia, deadline is still far away, so we can make both things.
We shouldn't risk lynching this new(?) guy, we'll find out what he is/does, in this night, everyone that is eager for lynch him is likely scum as they've found a somehow easy lynch, let's stick to the things we already know and find scum, then we can look for the meaning of this Hardenbergia, deadline is still far away, so we can make both things.
Why are you so intent on protecting this Hamburger guy? 'Anyone who is eager to lynch him is scum'. Really now!?DakeDekaane wrote:
By egg is most likely refering to an easter egg, a hint to be careful at night, that was what farto found. Unless they have a deeper meaning.
We shouldn't risk lynching this new(?) guy, we'll find out what he is/does, in this night, everyone that is eager for lynch him is likely scum as they've found a somehow easy lynch, let's stick to the things we already know and find scum, then we can look for the meaning of this Hardenbergia, deadline is still far away, so we can make both things.
the question is, why are you trying to prove that he's not something we should stay away from, even though we've stated why we should protect him? you just deny it without saying anything productive. also, you certainly got mad at that "anyone who is eager to lynch him is scum" sentence, as if trying to defend himself. clearly looks anti-town to me right now.
Unvote
Vote: Royston
Unvote
Vote: Royston
The reason I just prod dodged rather than say anything is that nothing really changed.
I still think royson should be lynched. And I thought stuff would happen after I posted. I was wrong.
Nothing really happened.
Vote royston, guys.
I still think royson should be lynched. And I thought stuff would happen after I posted. I was wrong.
Nothing really happened.
Vote royston, guys.
oh for the love of...
yes I did get mad at the "everyone who is eager to lynch him is scum" because it's basically an attempt to scum-paint anyone who would dare vote for this unknown person.
The only scenario I can see where someone town-aligned would say something like that is if they have additional knowledge of the Hamburglar in some way (i.e. to know that it would be helpful to town and thus scaring people off from voting it to keep it alive)
and I actually do agree that it's not wise to vote for Hamburger-man right now, as I've stated before it would only be preferable at this stage to vote it over randomly voting someone else.
But that's okay, because I'm not voting randomly
vote:DakeDekaane
yes I did get mad at the "everyone who is eager to lynch him is scum" because it's basically an attempt to scum-paint anyone who would dare vote for this unknown person.
The only scenario I can see where someone town-aligned would say something like that is if they have additional knowledge of the Hamburglar in some way (i.e. to know that it would be helpful to town and thus scaring people off from voting it to keep it alive)
and I actually do agree that it's not wise to vote for Hamburger-man right now, as I've stated before it would only be preferable at this stage to vote it over randomly voting someone else.
But that's okay, because I'm not voting randomly
vote:DakeDekaane
Let me reword that to: "anyone who is eager to lynch this Hardenbergia is potential scum".
Why? it's an easy scapegoat for them in D1 where there are a very few leads. And I'm not defending this Hardenbergia guy, we don't even know if it's real.
What if we lynch it and it's a bomb/vengeful thing? it's better to find it out later when we know at least what it could do if something really bad happens in N1 as LS warned us.
Why? it's an easy scapegoat for them in D1 where there are a very few leads. And I'm not defending this Hardenbergia guy, we don't even know if it's real.
What if we lynch it and it's a bomb/vengeful thing? it's better to find it out later when we know at least what it could do if something really bad happens in N1 as LS warned us.
Neither me. I'm voting the one I think is scum, not a random person. OMGUS.Royston wrote:
I've stated before it would only be preferable at this stage to vote it over randomly voting someone else.
But that's okay, because I'm not voting randomly
^ what
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
NH is already on the replacements list.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
NH is already on the replacements list.
oh, nevermind me then. I'm off to bed, you're aware how much of a slowpoke I am right now :v
k time to post actual content
first off, unvote
I'm not even going to say anything about the 15th cause that will lead nowhere for now I'm sure
*rereads thread*
vote: reDo
he's done nothing but setup speculation the whole time without even doing anything. He said something like "we should wait till it progresses" but he hasn't done anything to progress it.
Also, I don't buy the reasoning of "anyone who's eager to lynch the 15th is scum". I think it'd be a good strategy to get rid of him and just play a normal game, but knowing LS, everything will go wrong if we try that > < This makes me lean towards DakeDekaane cause that reason just seems a bit too basic. I'm also wondering about Tsukasa cause he was so against setup speculation, but he hasn't really done anything else as far as I can see (if I'm wrong correct me plz, reading the whole thread at once makes me confused a bit @_@)
I don't know what to say about YunoFanatic or kookookook, both of them seem not doing anything but they're both new so idk. BRBP is his usual self, so is Caligno but I've never played a game with Caligno as mafia so..
and before any of you get mad that I didn't even mention gut feeling, you all get mad when I do do it, so pick a side plz
srsly, I haven't got any gut feelings so far this game, cause not enough has happened. occult stuff can't be explained using logical ideas
first off, unvote
I'm not even going to say anything about the 15th cause that will lead nowhere for now I'm sure
*rereads thread*
vote: reDo
he's done nothing but setup speculation the whole time without even doing anything. He said something like "we should wait till it progresses" but he hasn't done anything to progress it.
Also, I don't buy the reasoning of "anyone who's eager to lynch the 15th is scum". I think it'd be a good strategy to get rid of him and just play a normal game, but knowing LS, everything will go wrong if we try that > < This makes me lean towards DakeDekaane cause that reason just seems a bit too basic. I'm also wondering about Tsukasa cause he was so against setup speculation, but he hasn't really done anything else as far as I can see (if I'm wrong correct me plz, reading the whole thread at once makes me confused a bit @_@)
I don't know what to say about YunoFanatic or kookookook, both of them seem not doing anything but they're both new so idk. BRBP is his usual self, so is Caligno but I've never played a game with Caligno as mafia so..
and before any of you get mad that I didn't even mention gut feeling, you all get mad when I do do it, so pick a side plz
srsly, I haven't got any gut feelings so far this game, cause not enough has happened. occult stuff can't be explained using logical ideas Also, I find those Royston votes pretty scummy. We can't ignore the fact that "???" is there, and when mod gives us hints we must consider every possibility, not reject everything as it doesn't exist. This is not a usual kind of game, everything seems possible here. Dake came in and instantly threw off his argument, not even considering the possibility of the hint being true. I understand Royston's vote on him and I'm against policy lynch/voting him.
My vote is still on kook though, still waiting for his reply to my previous post. Second choice is someone from Royston's wagon.
My vote is still on kook though, still waiting for his reply to my previous post. Second choice is someone from Royston's wagon.
ebwop: vote: rEdo
man these caps
man these caps
Nice ninja there, pieguy. You have my sword.
So uh.
Hardenbergia is a genus of vines found in Australia.
Could this person be Australian... wait, I'm surprised Lilac isn't in this game.
Hardenbergia is a genus of vines found in Australia.
Could this person be Australian... wait, I'm surprised Lilac isn't in this game.
Nope, stahp. That would be way too obvious/easy. You just take the word, wikipedia it and you get the answer. That's not very hard considering the previous hint/the promise to make them harder.Rantai wrote:
So uh.
Hardenbergia is a genus of vines found in Australia.
Could this person be Australian... wait, I'm surprised Lilac isn't in this game.
Unless it's you.
Where did LS say he was going to make them harder? He said he'll make better hints which can mean just about anything. I smell some cahoots here.fartownik wrote:
Nope, stahp. That would be way too obvious/easy. You just take the word, wikipedia it and you get the answer. That's not very hard considering the previous hint/the promise to make them harder.
My second line can be considered independent of the word because I am simply surprised Lilac isn't in an LS game. Then again, the hardenbergia is also a purple flowering plant, similar to Lilacs. Coincidence?
And no, seeing as I am already listed, I highly doubt I'm another person.
lilac also shunned BRBP and - more importantly - vertify.Rantai wrote:
Where did LS say he was going to make them harder? He said he'll make better hints which can mean just about anything. I smell some cahoots here.fartownik wrote:
Nope, stahp. That would be way too obvious/easy. You just take the word, wikipedia it and you get the answer. That's not very hard considering the previous hint/the promise to make them harder.
My second line can be considered independent of the word because I am simply surprised Lilac isn't in an LS game. Then again, the hardenbergia is also a purple flowering plant, similar to Lilacs. Coincidence?
And no, seeing as I am already listed, I highly doubt I'm another person.
especially the vertify shun now seems odd. why shun someone for something that you do yourself?
The purple vine lilac species itself is the Hardenbergia Violacea, also known as the "happy wanderer".
This must have something to do with Lilac, but it doesn't seem complex enough. "Happy wanderer" might have something to do with a role maybe?
Perhaps I'm overthinking this, but it will probably get us somewhere.
This must have something to do with Lilac, but it doesn't seem complex enough. "Happy wanderer" might have something to do with a role maybe?
Perhaps I'm overthinking this, but it will probably get us somewhere.
I said it like three times now that 15th could be either a trap or vengeful, and that's what I base on, thus I force the idea of ignoring him for this part of the game. anyway I'm voting Roy because he got stick to his wagon of lynching 15th, and that will remain anti-town for me, since some of us take the possibility from above in consideration :Ppieguy1372 wrote:
he's done nothing but setup speculation the whole time without even doing anything. He said something like "we should wait till it progresses" but he hasn't done anything to progress it.
it's just like Tanz said - ignore that unknown guy, it's going nowhere. let the game progress. I've got a feeling that something big's happening tonight. yes I do repeat myself, but that's what we should do imo
As others have said, wikipediaing leads me to believe the mystery person is Lilac though I guess it doesn't really matter who the person is, their role & purpose is more important.
I wonder if BRBP will vote me when he gets back, I'd guess so based on his posts.
mod: votecount
Anyway, I will not go gentle into that good night yada yada, I'm gonna keep throwing out my stupid ideas because at least you'll know I was being honest when I die
Yuno, what are your thoughts on what's going on?
I wonder if BRBP will vote me when he gets back, I'd guess so based on his posts.
mod: votecount
Anyway, I will not go gentle into that good night yada yada, I'm gonna keep throwing out my stupid ideas because at least you'll know I was being honest when I die
Yuno, what are your thoughts on what's going on?
God fuck the 15 person. Why can't we focus on scum hunting? Play it like a regular game.
Raging Bull wrote:
So what? If he really didn't say anything, you would have kept your vote on him? Even though you said he didn't attack back?
Come on Blue Yoshi.
Vote:Blue Yoshi
inb4Idiecauseegghint
we lynchRaging Bull wrote:
God fuck the 15 person. Why can't we focus on scum hunting? Play it like a regular game.
I guess that means LS ain't gonna mod count anymore, so I'll save him the trouble (and give us an overview of current voting), doing that on my own.LadySuburu wrote:
No.BRBP wrote:
Mod: Vote count please
Okay fine, but just this once.
______________________________________________________________________________________________
Royston (4) - CalignoBot, DakeDekaane, Tsukasa, rEdo
Blue Yoshi (1) - Raging Bull
DakeDekaane (1) - Royston
BRBP (1) - BRBP
fartownik (1) - YunoFanatic
kookookook (1) - fartownik
rEdo (1) - pieguy1372
??? (1) - kookookook
Not voting (3) - Blue Yoshi, BRBP, Rantai
@BRBP: fack you 
)))
Also my vote is still on kook, STILL didn't post anything from the point I called him out.
)))Also my vote is still on kook, STILL didn't post anything from the point I called him out.
fixing OMGISrEdo wrote:
Royston (4) - CalignoBot, DakeDekaane, Tsukasa, rEdo
Blue Yoshi (1) - Raging Bull
DakeDekaane (1) - Royston
BRBP (1) - Tanzklaue
fartownik (1) - YunoFanatic
kookookook (1) - fartownik
rEdo (1) - pieguy1372
??? (1) - kookookook
Not voting (3) - Blue Yoshi, BRBP, Rantai
I went to bed after the last post and to school this morning.
And after using up half an hour to read the posts I realized fartownik called me...
I've nothing to say, though after checking posts I have some hypothesis in my mind which cannot be fully supported in a handful of posts.
And after using up half an hour to read the posts I realized fartownik called me...
I've nothing to say, though after checking posts I have some hypothesis in my mind which cannot be fully supported in a handful of posts.
cool, kook seems to at least know what he plays and how to do it \:D/
leaves us with yuno as policy lynch.
kook, please try to explain your thoughts on everyone to the best of your abilities.
leaves us with yuno as policy lynch.
kook, please try to explain your thoughts on everyone to the best of your abilities.
Err... one of people I suspect is actually yuno. He really didn't post much and try to post something useless to attain his post count.Tanzklaue wrote:
leaves us with yuno as policy lynch.
Page 11YunoFanatic wrote:
we lynchRaging Bull wrote:
God fuck the 15 person. Why can't we focus on scum hunting? Play it like a regular game.
YunoFanatic wrote:
:D
Well, I also suspect others but the reason is too ridiculous to be told.
Yeah, he's doing it, but you're doing almost exact same thing.kookookook wrote:
Err... one of people I suspect is actually yuno. He really didn't post much and try to post something useless to attain his post count.Tanzklaue wrote:
leaves us with yuno as policy lynch.
Speak. Anything is better than nothing.kookookook wrote:
Well, I also suspect others but the reason is too ridiculous to be told.
....nngh, I forgot about this. Sorry.Raging Bull wrote:
Raging Bull wrote:
So what? If he really didn't say anything, you would have kept your vote on him? Even though you said he didn't attack back?
Come on Blue Yoshi.
If he had simply ignored it I probably would've kept my vote on.
If he made a big deal about it, I would've kept my vote on.
He didn't. He was paying attention to what was going on, and he's focused into the actual game.
k
Unvote
Vote: Tsukasa
Unvote
Vote: Tsukasa
What are you saying? He posted only 3 freaken times before he even said "anything" How could you have noticed he focused on the game with so little post? It was mainly RVS, seeing someone edit and request mod kill, and comment on one of the RVS on him.Blue Yoshi wrote:
....nngh, I forgot about this. Sorry.
If he had simply ignored it I probably would've kept my vote on.
If he made a big deal about it, I would've kept my vote on.
He didn't. He was paying attention to what was going on, and he's focused into the actual game.
RB townRaging Bull wrote:
God fuck the 15 person. Why can't we focus on scum hunting? Play it like a regular game.
So, we're just gonna wait out until the mislynch, are we.
Going to be V/LA for four days starting Friday. I will leave it up to the mod to decide whether to replace me (either temporarily or permanently) or not.
I'll get a post full of thoughts up at some point before I leave; most likely tomorrow. This game flew right by me.
I'll get a post full of thoughts up at some point before I leave; most likely tomorrow. This game flew right by me.
You just want to put the votes out from you but don't give any more hints about why should we not vote you.Royston wrote:
So, we're just gonna wait out until the mislynch, are we.
I'm also curious about your vote on Tsukasa farto, it'd be nice if you explain, though I think I can understand why.
Also Blue Yoshi, why do you think a "calm reaction" from BRBP makes him town?
And~
@Tanz, why should we policy lynch Yuno? you aren't confident on find for scum or are you not trying to find them?
Okay, fine. I'm a motivator. I can target a person at night to "increase their role's effectiveness" (I presume it would give the role an additional action as on the wiki) and if possible it will take effect on the night it's used.
omgTanzklaue wrote:
leaves us with yuno as policy lynch.
Anything to say in your defense?
this inactivity..
I assume that was directed at Yuno and not me, Dake
I assume that was directed at Yuno and not me, Dake
DakeDekaane wrote:
Anything to say in your defense?
ill be speechless if this was happend D:
inb4 Jester
As weird as Yuno is I don't believe it'd be a good idea to lynch either him or kookookook just cause. mb I'm just being too nice 0.0
RB seems town for me. he's acting legitimately pissed off at the 15th person just like he was pissed off at me in Mystery Mafia
I'm willing to bet there's a scum on the Royston wagon. CalignoBot always starts wagons even if they're wrong iirc, so not much to say there. Tsukasa is weird as ever, and I'm already voting rEdo. That leaves DakeDekaane who incidentally seems to be posting the same amount he was in Touhou PyP IV as mafia
As weird as Yuno is I don't believe it'd be a good idea to lynch either him or kookookook just cause. mb I'm just being too nice 0.0
RB seems town for me. he's acting legitimately pissed off at the 15th person just like he was pissed off at me in Mystery Mafia
I'm willing to bet there's a scum on the Royston wagon. CalignoBot always starts wagons even if they're wrong iirc, so not much to say there. Tsukasa is weird as ever, and I'm already voting rEdo. That leaves DakeDekaane who incidentally seems to be posting the same amount he was in Touhou PyP IV as mafia
except by saying it 3 times you're doing the exact opposite of ignoring him. and you're not really making much progress without discussing the 15th person to back up your wordsrEdo wrote:
I said it like three times now that 15th could be either a trap or vengeful, and that's what I base on, thus I force the idea of ignoring him for this part of the game. anyway I'm voting Roy because he got stick to his wagon of lynching 15th, and that will remain anti-town for me, since some of us take the possibility from above in consideration :P
it's just like Tanz said - ignore that unknown guy, it's going nowhere. let the game progress. I've got a feeling that something big's happening tonight. yes I do repeat myself, but that's what we should do imo
i yoloed lol xD
mb is nice and im not
hes my other and not fart
dacing because raging is nice...
Why everyone thinks im weird yolo D: im nice D: its 15th person fault D: i will puch you with my moe pucnch
mb is nice and im not
hes my other and not fart
dacing because raging is nice...
Why everyone thinks im weird yolo D: im nice D: its 15th person fault D: i will puch you with my moe pucnch
unvoteYunoFanatic wrote:
i yoloed lol xD
mb is nice and im not
hes my other and not fart
dacing because raging is nice...
Why everyone thinks im weird yolo D: im nice D: its 15th person fault D: i will puch you with my moe pucnch
vote: YunoFanatic
Topic Starter
NoHItter replaces CalignoBot
I... don't understand? Care to make that coherent?YunoFanatic wrote:
i yoloed lol xD
mb is nice and im not
hes my other and not fart
dacing because raging is nice...
Why everyone thinks im weird yolo D: im nice D: its 15th person fault D: i will puch you with my moe pucnch
And wow quick trigger there Royston, feeling a bit fidgety?
--
(Hi NH too)
I don't think I could live with myself for not voting after a post like that
hi NH \:D/
So apart from being incoherent, did you actually read something in there that would give you the idea he should be voted?Royston wrote:
I don't think I could live with myself for not voting after a post like that
Or was it just an excuse to jump onto the wagon simply because it made no sense.
I don't see how his play benefits town in any way.Rantai wrote:
So apart from being incoherent, did you actually read something in there that would give you the idea he should be voted?
Look at this 1 vote wagon go, it's outta control!Rantai wrote:
Or was it just an excuse to jump onto the wagon simply because it made no sense.
What the hell is that post Yuno?
And seriously, why not get Blue Yoshi? If you guys don't want Royston or Kook, get him. Why would he vote for someone and plant his vote. Then decide to remove it the moment BRBP literally says "anything" as a trolling remark to him. And not only that, apparently BRBP looked town to Blue Yoshi just after 3 post with no damn content at all.
And seriously, why not get Blue Yoshi? If you guys don't want Royston or Kook, get him. Why would he vote for someone and plant his vote. Then decide to remove it the moment BRBP literally says "anything" as a trolling remark to him. And not only that, apparently BRBP looked town to Blue Yoshi just after 3 post with no damn content at all.
The problem being is that someone has already initiated the sentiment. Your quick trigger reeks of someone looking to capitalise it for any reason.
Where did that happen again? I am the lazy to dig it up (busy and such).Raging Bull wrote:
And seriously, why not get Blue Yoshi? If you guys don't want Royston or Kook, get him. Why would he vote for someone and plant his vote. Then decide to remove it the moment BRBP literally says "anything" as a trolling remark to him. And not only that, apparently BRBP looked town to Blue Yoshi just after 3 post with no damn content at all.
Initial vote
Questioned him and got reaction test reply. Keeping vote regardless until BRBP says anything. (BRBP says literally anything in next post) Apparently warrants an unvote for him
Seemed townie because lack of reaction to vote
Apparently to Blue yoshi, BRBP is paying attention and focusing on the game But BRBP's post only has him posting 3 times between /in and the "anything" part. How can that even be enough to show that he was focusing in the game?
Questioned him and got reaction test reply. Keeping vote regardless until BRBP says anything. (BRBP says literally anything in next post) Apparently warrants an unvote for him
Seemed townie because lack of reaction to vote
Apparently to Blue yoshi, BRBP is paying attention and focusing on the game But BRBP's post only has him posting 3 times between /in and the "anything" part. How can that even be enough to show that he was focusing in the game?
Huh I see.
So it started with you questioning an RV, getting some generic excuse and BRBP specifically posting to get it off him? (not to repeat everything, I need it in my own words).
I have to agree that I'm not sure how he got a townread from what essentially was a vote dodge (for lack of better words). I'm going to hazard a guess and say because he responded in that specific way, that BRBP at least read his post and that to him shows he's paying attention...?
.. I'm not even going to try and rationalise that, that actually doesn't make sense to me at all.
So it started with you questioning an RV, getting some generic excuse and BRBP specifically posting to get it off him? (not to repeat everything, I need it in my own words).
I have to agree that I'm not sure how he got a townread from what essentially was a vote dodge (for lack of better words). I'm going to hazard a guess and say because he responded in that specific way, that BRBP at least read his post and that to him shows he's paying attention...?
.. I'm not even going to try and rationalise that, that actually doesn't make sense to me at all.
Vote himmm do ittttt. /me poke Rantai
No.
I want to see what he has to say about this first (ie defend himself). I'm not sure if it's just dumb play or something more insidious.
I want to see what he has to say about this first (ie defend himself). I'm not sure if it's just dumb play or something more insidious.
@mod: requesting a replacement for YunoFanatic
Look at your ISO and ask yourself the same question.Tsukasa wrote:
Reasons being?fartownik wrote:
k
Unvote
Vote: Tsukasa
not sure whether we should get rid of that VI or wait for a replacement... besides from Royston (and, potentially - (FOS: Tsukasa and Tanzklaue due to inactivity) I have no idea who should we aim for. pretty much everyone else seem either town or null to me for now.
EBWOP: it's his first Mafia game, and he apparently didn't even read the FAQ and stuff. doesn't look like a jester to me, it's just a bad play from his side.
YunoFanatic doesn't know what's going on in this game, he's nowhere to be considered scummy in my eyes, just stupid.
Royston has a lot of silly votes on himself of people I consider scummy, I'm highly against lynching him.
kookookook still didn't post anything relevant/useful, even after my encouraging to do it. Might be newbie scum, but I would resist from lynching him today yet.
I don't see anything exceptionally scummy in Blue Yoshi, but nothing exceptionally Towny as well.
Tsukasa plays like scum/Jester. Posts nothing but votes without proper reasoning, townreads without proper reasoning and is ASKING ME FOR REASONS why I'm voting him, then not even commenting on them. He does NOTHING, it's really off his meta by the way.
Royston has a lot of silly votes on himself of people I consider scummy, I'm highly against lynching him.
kookookook still didn't post anything relevant/useful, even after my encouraging to do it. Might be newbie scum, but I would resist from lynching him today yet.
I don't see anything exceptionally scummy in Blue Yoshi, but nothing exceptionally Towny as well.
Tsukasa plays like scum/Jester. Posts nothing but votes without proper reasoning, townreads without proper reasoning and is ASKING ME FOR REASONS why I'm voting him, then not even commenting on them. He does NOTHING, it's really off his meta by the way.
Holy crap.
Unvote
Tsukasa may also be a lyncher.
I missed Royston post when claimed? motivator, got distracted by Yuno's post, though I'm still a bit afraid of him being scum, but well, his claim hasn't been countered yet, so I'll give him a chance.
I'll wait for replies from Tanz, Tsukasa and Yoshi to decide my vote this time. We still have like 3 days guys, we can do it.
Unvote
Tsukasa may also be a lyncher.
I missed Royston post when claimed? motivator, got distracted by Yuno's post, though I'm still a bit afraid of him being scum, but well, his claim hasn't been countered yet, so I'll give him a chance.
I'll wait for replies from Tanz, Tsukasa and Yoshi to decide my vote this time. We still have like 3 days guys, we can do it.
I highly doubt it would be a good tactic for Lyncher to scream "HEY LYNCH THAT GUY, I HAVE NO REASONS FOR IT". It's more like a Jester tactic, because it's more likely you're going to be suspected for saying that, and I don't think Tsukasa is this stupid.
Topic Starter
Yuno doesn't qualify for a prod/replacement, nor has he requested one himself.fartownik wrote:
@mod: requesting a replacement for YunoFanatic
@dake:
the lynch priority goes scum-scumsuspect-antitown-lurker, the newbies act antitown and lurkery, I have no scumsuspects at this point, so I offer my acceptance of an policy lynch at the end of the day.
the lynch priority goes scum-scumsuspect-antitown-lurker, the newbies act antitown and lurkery, I have no scumsuspects at this point, so I offer my acceptance of an policy lynch at the end of the day.
But he clearly has no clue about this game's rules and how it should be played.LadySuburu wrote:
Yuno doesn't qualify for a prod/replacement, nor has he requested one himself.fartownik wrote:
@mod: requesting a replacement for YunoFanatic
Tanzklaue wrote:
@dake:
the lynch priority goes scum-scumsuspect-antitown-lurker, the newbies act antitown and lurkery, I have no scumsuspects at this point, so I offer my acceptance of an policy lynch at the end of the day.
So, Tsukasa doesn't seem scummy to you? So he seems Town to you, right? But why would he seem to Town to you if he had only posted shit quality stuff?