forum

Shirahamazaka Koukou Gasshou-Bu - Shiokaze no Harmony (TV Si

posted
Total Posts
79
show more
Topic Starter
Andrea
Fixed, thanks again =w=
Chewin
Okay, bubbled ><
Dark_Ai
Oh dear God, I can't post my opinion in your map thread?!
HakuNoKaemi
[General]
  1. Il BG è di scarsa qualità e si vede la scritta pulita male, usa http://puu.sh/13hLu o http://puu.sh/13hLO(senza filtri).
  2. Video Offset: 11226 (+26ms)
[Rika's Easy]
  1. [Gameplay]
    1. 00:22:786 (1) - Make it 1/2 longer and add a slidertick hitsound. It'll be a bit funnier
    2. 00:34:786 (4) - One Less repeat? and add circle in the free white tick
    3. 00:56:510 (x) - Since you're changing from drums to vocals, it'll be better to add a note here
    4. 00:58:579 (3) - Use NC here as the males start singing here. Move 00:56:923 (1) NC to 00:54:234 (3). It seems more logical like this.
    5. 01:02:510 (3) - They start singing togheter, add an NC here instead of 01:00:855 (1) -
    6. 01:04:165 (1) - Move NC to 01:05:613 (2) - or just Delete NC
    7. 01:19:061 (1) - Make it start in 01:18:855, so it'll start by following the -ri completely
    8. 01:21:130 (x) - Add note, I know it's after the spinner, but newbie will probably click here as it'll be intuitive to add a note here
    9. 01:28:165 (4) - Add NC, yeah, a sigle hit combo. But it'll enhance the tornado (01:25:682 (1,2,3)) effectivity with users. Other than following new lines in lyrics rightly.
  2. 00:37:061 (2,3) - It's maybe really little, though you can curve those a little bit
    SPOILER
    [spoilerbox]
    [/spoilerbox]
[xxheroxx's Normal]
  1. è parecchio faciluccia per essere una normal... se la differenza tra questa e la Hard è quasi colossale, con la Easy... è piccola.
  2. [Gameplay]
    1. 00:45:958 (1) - Se lo muovi qualche pixel sotto, otterrai una semi-simmetria più il fatto che non sarà coperto tanto facilmente dal punteggio o dalla barra dell'HP
    2. 01:19:061 (2,3,4,5,1) - Potrebbe sembrare strano da giocare poiche (2) non tocca niente di ciò che seguivi. Quindi segui meglio la batteria, ricordati dei Finish su (2),(4) e fine(1) e dei clap (3) e inizio(1).
    3. 01:32:303 (1) - Segui le liriche? ka-na(1) (clap)(2) - de-yowo(3)
[Hard]
  1. [Gameplay]
    1. 00:43:268 (2) - Fallo finire direttamente dove c'è il Clap( 00:43:889 )
    2. 00:51:855 (x) - Perchè no? La nota c'è, lo stream non è finito, la voce non si è fermata, non ci sono Finish a finire lo stream ne genericamente beat pesanti... completa lo stream
  2. [Graphic]
    1. Con una canzone del genere, stanno meglio curvati che a punta i pattern. Il Flow è migliore con le curve che con quegli odiosissimi angoli appuntiti come un diamante.
    2. 00:12:855 (1) - Alza il punto di mezzo di un grid, preferisco che preservi un perfetto blanket e una buona simmetria, anziche uno scarso blanket e una perfetta simmetria.
    3. 00:14:717 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Diminuisci le punte
    4. 00:16:165 (1,2) - e curva lo slider qui
    5. 00:21:751 (3) -
    6. 00:22:372 (4) - Non è nè simmetrico nè un buon blanket
    7. 00:26:096 (1) - Curving
    8. 00:26:717 (2,3,4) - Il flow è migliore così
    9. 01:00:648 (3) - Visto che sono tutte "Curvalo", penso che non serva che te loo dica
    10. 01:02:510 (1) - ^
    11. Adesso ti sarai rotto le palle, ma di base " dovresti usare più curve " per questo genere di canzoni. E non dirmi che è il tuo stile dopo che hai 100 e rotte ranked.(effettivamente non ti ho moddato altre mappe, non so come mi risponderesti >.<)
Cygnus
It feels weird that [Easy] has more notes than [Normal].

is that okay?
Diasios
Haku: Grazie per il mod però preferisco non modificare niente di ciò che mi hai suggerito, scusami.





Philippines wrote:

It feels weird that [Easy] has more notes than [Normal].

is that okay?
This beatmap was supposed to have only 2 difficulties but after me and Andrea finished our difficulties Rika wanted to join in and she made... that. :?
If I were Andrea I'd remove that Easy because it's not necessary in this mapset since my difficulty is a Easy/Normal, but whatever.
Cygnus

xxheroxx wrote:

Haku: Grazie per il mod però preferisco non modificare niente di ciò che mi hai suggerito, scusami.





Philippines wrote:

It feels weird that [Easy] has more notes than [Normal].

is that okay?
This beatmap was supposed to have only 2 difficulties but after me and Andrea finished our difficulties Rika wanted to join in and she made... that. :?
If I were Andrea I'd remove that Easy because it's not necessary in this mapset since my difficulty is a Easy/Normal, but whatever.
It would be better if you add more notes in your diff though. Hard has more than 200 notes. Try making the number of notes like 120-150.

This statement may or may not make issues, but I think this map is not ready yet. But that's just me.
Topic Starter
Andrea
Changed some stuff, thank you for checking!

EDIT: After some discussion with Rika, we decided to remove the difficulty from the mapset and to add it in the beatmap's comments instead.
Chewin
Added a new combo in the hard diff.
I don't like mapsets with just 2 diffs but everything is fine anyways.
So, rebubbled ~
Aurele
Andrea... your map is a TV Size and have only two difficulty... that's not alot.
To make it more fair... maybe Rika can work out her's Normal to make it more easier...?
Topic Starter
Andrea
She didn't wanted to do that, already talked with her ;w;
Aurele
Aweh..
Dark_Ai
Why you dont map yourself an easy diff? ;> Cuz you made one diff only in YOUR map
Tanzklaue

Dark_Ai wrote:

Why you dont map yourself an easy diff? ;> Cuz you made one diff only in YOUR map
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/29906
you shouldn't throw with rocks while sitting in a glasshouse.
Dark_Ai
Look how often that happening with Andrea's maps and how often with Mine then we will talk again ;>
And this is also only a TV Size too so think about what you saying, Thanks ;)
BrokenArrow

Tanzklaue wrote:

Dark_Ai wrote:

Why you dont map yourself an easy diff? ;> Cuz you made one diff only in YOUR map
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/29906
you shouldn't throw with rocks while sitting in a glasshouse.
You do have a point there. But it's still a different situation in my opinion since Andrea is one of the most experienced mappers here in osu (just by looking at his number of ranked maps, guest diffs, mod posts, time spent in editor, etc.) so we can at least expect from him to put more of his own work into his mapsets. However, it's his own choice, so I'm not going to argue about this anymore.

Andrea is going to kill us for discussing this here. :D
/me runs
Tanzklaue

Dark_Ai wrote:

Look how often that happening with Andrea's maps and how often with Mine then we will talk again ;>
And this is also only a TV Size too so think about what you saying, Thanks ;)
you mapped less than 50% of the diffs on all your mapsets, taiko included. the only mapset where this is not the case is also a TV Size map. please, stop posting, you hypocrite.

@Broken:
andrea can put as much work in his mapsets as he wants. I don't say that I like his mappingstyle, or the way he deals with mapping in general, but I don't go and follow him everywhere to shit on him. I only do that to Broetchen <3
BrokenArrow

Tanzklaue wrote:

Dark_Ai wrote:

Look how often that happening with Andrea's maps and how often with Mine then we will talk again ;>
And this is also only a TV Size too so think about what you saying, Thanks ;)
you mapped less than 50% of the diffs on all your mapsets, taiko included. the only mapset where this is not the case is also a TV Size map. please, stop posting, you hypocrite.

@Broken:
andrea can put as much work in his mapsets as he wants. I don't say that I like his mappingstyle, or the way he deals with mapping in general, but I don't go and follow him everywhere to shit on him. I only do that to Broetchen <3
As I said, it's his own choice.
And I'm just posting here to support Ai, or at least try to do :p
Garven
Instead of focusing efforts on detracting a map, aim to make it (or others) better by contributing constructive criticism. Otherwise please direct your thoughts to a more appropriate forum.

Edit:

Haku, that is fine. I'm more talking about the tit for tat that is going on over who mapped what when and where with how much. I may moderate it later if things escalate, but I'd prefer not to. I hope that everyone will be civil with presenting their words.
HakuNoKaemi

Garven wrote:

Instead of focusing efforts on detracting a map, aim to make it (or others) better by contributing constructive criticism. Otherwise please direct your thoughts to a more appropriate forum.

All criticism said one thing:
mapping one tv size diff in your mappack is ZETTA wrong, especially making a mapset with 2 diffs. I can say at least he can "try" making some Taikos, and asking one. or just making an Insane, by removing the few Insane thing on the easier.
And with so many ranked maps HE CAN MAKE THEM.
And it's constructive, since this would make the map set richer and the spread better.
Topic Starter
Andrea
Thank you guys for ruining every beatmap thread of mine, really.

This community sucks.
ririco
@Ai Andrea can Make as Much diffs as he wants, it's his mappset not yours ok? if you have problem with it just don't bring it here ._. it's just pointless really orz.


and I'm supporting Andrea here, it's up to the mapper if he wants to make 1 diff or more so yeah ......
BrokenArrow
-Sekai-: everything you said has already been mentioned multiple times by tanzklaue and me, this discussion was already over.

Last post of me in any of your threads, do what you can not leave.
Dangaard

Andrea wrote:

Thank you guys for ruining every beatmap thread of mine, really.

This community sucks.
Ironically, this community also is helping in getting your maps ranked more than other maps, so I would be rather thankful in your place.
Breeze
All fine, but I'm afraid of the offset, it sounds late for me, I've got a offset 12840 (-15)
Topic Starter
Andrea
After some discussion, -5 to the offset.

Thank you for checking Breeze (:
Chewin

Andrea wrote:

After some discussion, -5 to the offset.
^ This.

Rebubbled, again.
Topic Starter
Andrea
Thank you once again Chewin :)
Breeze
OK, then
Melophobia
congratz :3
Chewin
Nice, baka :3
Topic Starter
Andrea
Thanks a lot guys <3

Love you all :3
Strawberry
lol gratz Andrea~!
Mythol
gratz~
Kite
congrats
Ruslya_old
congratz :3 good
ririco
Gratz moe Andrea :3
Sure
<3
Quilt
congratz xD
Topic Starter
Andrea
Thanks everyone once again :)
deadbeat
oh hey. a rank. weeee \:D/
cRyo[iceeicee]
grats your 1st, 11th, 111th, 162nd ranked map ヽ(*・ω・)ノ
IceBeam
wow already ranked
gz Andrea-nyan ;)
Cygnus
Congrats Andrea ^^

On the other hand, I miss you and your many diff maps. Please avoid this kind of things. Bring back the old and fun GD mapset. </3
spboxer3
Congratz Andrea~~~
Mercurial
/o/
No_Gu
Nice
Dark_Ai
omg...

gz
Buccakazu
:)
Shiro

BrokenArrow wrote:

Why don't you map something unique..
Doing that results in bad ratings.

Also it felt weird to me that Breeze proposed -15, and that your consensus was -5, so I checked the timing but the offset sounds fine as it is. So... grats on another rank I guess. Beats me how you can map 162 maps when I completely ran out of ideas and motivation after 21.
Cyclohexane
KEEP ROLLIN ROLLIN ROLLIN ROLLIN
KEEP ROLLIN ROLLIN ROLLIN ROLLIN
KEEP ROLLIN ROLLIN ROLLIN ROLLIN
KEEP ROLLIN ROLLIN ROLLIN ROLLIN
Please sign in to reply.

New reply