forum

Celebrity PYP Mafia II - The Revenge (MAFIA WIN!!!)

posted
Total Posts
355
show more
Mara

animask wrote:

Do you think your role matches your celebrity?
I don't think so.
UnderminE
Mine doesn't match, either. But some people can say it matches in their opinions.
Swatty
I think mine doesn't match >.>
bmin11

animask wrote:

I prefer not being part of the RVS
and you vote for Swatty anyway?


mine matches.
LadySuburu

animask wrote:

Vote: Swatty the new people always end up being mafia!

I prefer not being part of the RVS, so lets make this a RQS instead.

Do you think your role matches your celebrity? Mine does not match at all.
My role doesn't match in my opinion.
Nyquill
Hey, anyone noticed that pieguy is the only one who wagoned so far.
foulcoon
my role could have been so much better. doesn't match at all.

WAY TO GO MASHLEY EVERY ROLE DOESNT MAKE SENSE WOW
Rantai
Mine sort of makes sense.
Lybydose
my role mostly makes sense
pieguyn
Mine makes a little sense if you think about it o-o//
Kanye West
Mine makes zero sense.
foulcoon

kanye west wrote:

Mine makes zero sense.
You are Kanye West, a Gay Fish (Serial Killer). Each night you may choose to strangle (or in any way other than shooting, kill) someone who won't explain why you are a gay fish.


you clearly think your role makes zero sense because you don't believe that you're a gay fish.
Papi Bear
My role matches my pick and it makes sense too.
Kanye West

foulcoon wrote:

kanye west wrote:

Mine makes zero sense.
You are Kanye West, a Gay Fish (Serial Killer). Each night you may choose to strangle (or in any way other than shooting, kill) someone who won't explain why you are a gay fish.


you clearly think your role makes zero sense because you don't believe that you're a gay fish.
But...but...I do believe I'm a gay fish! And it still makes no sense! Halp plz
NoHitter
Regarding my role, it does make sense if you think about it.

Let's compile a list:
animask - doesn't match
LunaticMara - doesn't match
UnderminE - doesn't match, but some may think it matches
bmin11 - matches
Nyquill - didn't answer the question, but posted
foulcoon - doesn't match
Rantai - matches somewhat
Lybydose - matches mostly
pieguy1372 - matches a little
kanye west - doesn't match
Papi Bear Rocks - matches
NoHitter - somewhat matches

Nyquill wrote:

Hey, anyone noticed that pieguy is the only one who wagoned so far.
I was thinking of that too, but was wondering if that was because of RVS only.
Now that the question is out in the open, might as well ask pieguy.
Swatty
I also posted i think mine doesn't match
Papi Bear
RQS:

1.)If you've been picked as Mafia, how do you convince town so you can survive?
2.)What role are you thinking that will pop out when you first pick a celebrity?

My answers:
1.)Act town. That's all
2.)Um... I don't actually know what role will pop out on my first 2 picks. The other one I think will pop out as a Third Person role.
Rantai
I can't quite grasp how these questions will help.
Mara
Vote: Papi Bear ROCKS

Keep acting as a town.
UnderminE
What are these questions for
Makar
My role doesn't match my pick
Lybydose
2.)Um... I don't actually know what role will pop out on my first 2 picks. The other one I think will pop out as a Third Person role.
dafuq does this even mean
Papi Bear
Sorry guys.. -.- nevermind the questions then.
DeathxShinigami
My role matches somewhat.

Only think it could be properly done better if Mashley actually knew more about who I chose.

Also gaaawwwddd the annoyance factor on Papi is strong.
bmin11
Asking questions are okay, but the second question is a huge role fishing if you think about it (this is PyP).

I wasn't too sure how to react to pieguy's vote as I've seen it way too often being used for past games. My only worry is that this is his first random bandwagon I've seen from him.

Unvote, but regardless of being a RV, I'm going to keep an eye on Rantai for his mafia history.
bmin11
Oh, I forgot to tell you guys that I'm in the middle of AP tests. I may not be able to post as often as you guys expect me to. Sorry.
pieguyn
Yeah, that was just an RV... I forgot someone had already voted NoHitter :?
Rantai
Forgot? You were only 1 post behind the first one and only 40 mins later O.o
UnderminE
I will be in a different city this weekend, so same as bmin, I may not be able to post for a while.
NoHitter
List so far:
animask - doesn't match
LunaticMara - doesn't match
UnderminE - doesn't match, but some may think it matches
Swatty - doesn't match
bmin11 - matches
Nyquill - didn't answer the question, but posted
foulcoon - doesn't match
Rantai - matches somewhat
Lybydose - matches mostly
pieguy1372 - matches a little
kanye west - doesn't match
Papi Bear Rocks - matches
NoHitter - somewhat matches
Makar8000 - doesn't match
DeathxShinigami - somewhat matches

Re: pieguy

Rantai wrote:

Forgot? You were only 1 post behind the first one and only 40 mins later O.o
Basically this.
I highly doubt that you would actually not notice that someone had already voted for me.

Besides, if it really was a RV, why do you even care that someone voted me already before?
RV's are random, they're supposed to not be affected by whether or not someone voted the one you RV'd before.
Vote: pieguy1372

Re: Papi
I agree that his RQS was sort of suspicious.
His first question was a bit useless, and he even answered it in a vague way himself.
The second one was somewhat a rolefish, and I doubt it'll be useful for town as most people's role "doesn't match or only somewhat matched" their picked celebrity.
I'm not sure if this is because he's newbie town or scum. Leaning on the former though.
NoHitter
EBWOP:
Noticed that I forgot to add LS.

animask - doesn't match
LunaticMara - doesn't match
UnderminE - doesn't match, but some may think it matches
Swatty - doesn't match
bmin11 - matches
LadySuburu - doesn't match
Nyquill - didn't answer the question, but posted
foulcoon - doesn't match
Rantai - matches somewhat
Lybydose - matches mostly
pieguy1372 - matches a little
kanye west - doesn't match
Papi Bear Rocks - matches
NoHitter - somewhat matches
Makar8000 - doesn't match
DeathxShinigami - somewhat matches
Sleep Powder
unvote IGMEOY Swatty

@Papi, Why'd you feel the need to ask another question after I did? Your first question makes you seem scummy and so does your 2nd (for above reason of rolefishing) tbh, I think that 2nd question isn't going to benefit the town (or anyone) at all.

Since I don't really have much else to add, I just say that Mashley sounds really scummy. He keeps giving me ideas via PM that there is a 3rd party among us (or some independents).

We could try comparing how he described our win conditions, but idk if that will help.
Topic Starter
Mashley
VOTE COUNT
NoHItter - 2 Makar8000, pieguy1372
Nyquill - 1 Papi Bear ROCKS
Makar8000 - 1 kanye west
Lybydose - 1 Nyquill
pieguy1372 - 2 UnderminE, NoHItter
foulcoon - 1 Swatty
Papi Bear ROCKS - 1 LunaticMara

DAY ENDS AROUND 8:00PM GMT ON FRIDAY 11TH MAY. WITH 16 ALIVE, IT TAKES 9 TO HAMMER.
Yeah, that's less than 24 hours.
Topic Starter
Mashley
also itt we call out the host as scummy
huh
Nyquill
Oh, I didn't answer the question because I don't know quite what to think of mine.

On one hand it doesn't match but then again I don't know what I expected from choosing this person either.

If there is an independant, we'll get a better idea of what it is after N1.
Sleep Powder
inb4 someone votes at the last minute
LadySuburu
Vote: pieguy1372

Yeah, that was just an RV... I forgot someone had already voted NoHitter
The phrasing strikes me as odd, as "I forgot" around the circumstances doesn't really make much sense. I wanted to vote bmin, as his pointing out of (a second vote on same person in RVS, which isn't really that notable expecially if someone isn't watching meticulously to make sure they don't) in a game with this many people seems more like a subtle scum tactic than town. However, something really irks me about pieguy's statement and we're less than a day from deadline. Also hitter still had 2 votes and was on the lead to be lynched (assuming there's a lynch at deadline versus no lynch, haven't checked the rules on that part at the time I'm posting this. Trying to finish posting before the storm kills my electricity.
pieguyn
That probably wasn't the best word to use, but regardless, I wasn't really paying much attention, as it was just RVS.

unvote, vote NoHitter... oh wait, I'm already voting him. Anyway he called me out for not caring about my RV and then asked why I would care in the first place. It seems like a bit of a contradiction IMO.
NoHitter

pieguy1372 wrote:

That probably wasn't the best word to use, but regardless, I wasn't really paying much attention, as it was just RVS.

unvote, vote NoHitter... oh wait, I'm already voting him. Anyway he called me out for not caring about my RV and then asked why I would care in the first place. It seems like a bit of a contradiction IMO.
EXACTLY! RV's are not supposed to be thought about in the first place. They're RANDOM - no need to reason why you did it.
If you answered something like, "Nothing really, I just voted NoHitter randomly." then that wouldn't be suspicious.

The very fact that you were concerned about voting me after someone else did, and you attempted to explain it by saying that "you forgot someone already voted for me", makes it look like your vote WASN'T A RV at all, and therefore, suspicious.
bmin11
Hmm... I can logically agree with your accusations, but it isn't heavy enough for a lynch for me. I really wish I could get something to work on.

I'm concerned with NoH'i'tter's attitude right now. I think he is pushing this lynch way harder then the actual weight of suspiciousness.
DeathxShinigami
Personally I see NoHitter's reasoning for pushing for a lynch is that we'll get an idea by seeing the Lynchee's alignment which will give all of us a general idea what this setup looks like. I mean I'd rather lynch someone than a no lynch on Day 1 for pyp's. Just my opinion.

I'll vote in a bit.
NoHitter

bmin11 wrote:

Hmm... I can logically agree with your accusations, but it isn't heavy enough for a lynch for me. I really wish I could get something to work on.

I'm concerned with NoH'i'tter's attitude right now. I think he is pushing this lynch way harder then the actual weight of suspiciousness.
Well this is the only suspicious thing that arose today apart from Papi who I think is just inexperienced.

DeathxShinigami wrote:

Personally I see NoHitter's reasoning for pushing for a lynch is that we'll get an idea by seeing the Lynchee's alignment which will give all of us a general idea what this setup looks like. I mean I'd rather lynch someone than a no lynch on Day 1 for pyp's. Just my opinion.
I'm pushing for the lynch because among everyone today, pieguy has acted most suspiciously.
bmin11
Ya, the activeness isn't really helping right now. It's hard for me to have confidence with my vote.
DeathxShinigami
Vote:pieguy1372

Deadline approaches...
pieguyn
That's what I meant, but I was in kind of in a rush when making that post. Well, since I'm screwed

roleclaim: flavor cop

go town :?
NoHitter
Who's the celebrity, pieguy?
Makar
unvote
NoHitter
So I waited, and although pieguy hasn't claimed his celebrity, I'd rather not risk the loss of a flavor cop.
(There was one present in the first Celebrity PyP IIRC.)

Barring any counterclams,
Unvote

Vote: Papi Bear Rocks
Second most suspicious today.
Mara
My brains are not working again, sorry, but dafuq is FLAVOR cop?
Topic Starter
Mashley
Gonna give you guys a 24 hour extension because you need it
DAY NOW ENDS AROUND 3:30PM GMT ON SATURDAY 12TH MAY. WITH 16 ALIVE, IT TAKES 9 TO HAMMER
Rantai
Hmmm flavour cop can still go both ways.
Nyquill
I'd rather wait to see if pieguy gets NK'd. If he's not, he'll reveal someone's role for us. We can make a better judgement on to believe him or not then.

If he does, well then there goes our Flavor Cop.

That being said,

Unvote
DeathxShinigami
Hmm...unvote

Vote: Papi Bear ROCKS

Learn to play...
Papi Bear
o_o

I just want to ask questions and trying to get this game rolling since I don't like this game to be quiet as well...

Question # 2, since you said it, is a big role fishing. And I just realise that it's more helpful for Mafia since they can pick their target. Sorry about that guys.

Deadline is near so I'll roleclaim.

Bruno Mars as Motivator

As I said before, my pick matches my pick since his songs. I don't know how his song can motivate people but he can make them feel better. (giving them motivation to have a power role)
Papi Bear

Papi Bear ROCKS wrote:

o_o

I just want to ask questions and trying to get this game rolling since I don't like this game to be quiet as well...

Question # 2, since you said it, is a big role fishing. And I just realise that it's more helpful for Mafia since they can pick their target. Sorry about that guys.

Deadline is near so I'll roleclaim.

Bruno Mars as Motivator

As I said before, my pick role matches my pick since his songs. I don't know how his song can motivate people but he can make them feel better. (giving them motivation to have a power role)
x(
pieguyn
My celebrity is Chihara Minori from Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu. My previous celebrity was Hirano Aya from the same series. (Actually I've been picking nothing but voice actors from Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu both games o.o//)

I think my role makes a little sense since she is the voice actor for Nagato Yuki, who I guess would be able to look up data and information on people.
Nyquill
well dxs effectively forced two people to claim today.
NoHitter

Rantai wrote:

Hmmm flavour cop can still go both ways.
Last game, Flavor Cop was town, so I think that this time, it'll still be the same.

As for the Bruno Mars as Motivator, I personally think it's kind of skewed.
NoHitter
EBWOP:
As opposed to what Papi claimed that they "matched".
DeathxShinigami
pieguy's role is definetly more or less hero based so to me he's town for now.

Also yes Nyquill thanks for the blow by blow happenings on why people are roleclaiming.
Rantai
Going to need a replacement

Boring stuff
Doc says I have a fever and tachycardia due to stress, I'll be off my computer for a while
Topic Starter
Mashley
VOTE COUNT
Papi Bear ROCKS - 3 LunaticMara, NoHItter, DeathxShinigami
pieguy1372 - 1 UnderminE
NoHItter - 1 pieguy1372
Nyquill - 1 Papi Bear ROCKS
Makar8000 - 1 kanye west
foulcoon - 1 Swatty

DAY ENDS AROUND 3:30PM GMT ON SATURDAY 12TH MAY. WITH 16 ALIVE, IT TAKES 9 TO HAMMER
A little over 3 hours left guys.


If anyone's lurking I need a replacement for Rantai
Topic Starter
Mashley
JInxyjem is replacing Rantai.
Topic Starter
Mashley
When the sun had gone down, the chosen lynch with only 3 votes was Bruno Mars.


Papi Bear ROCKS was Bruno Mars, the Motivator. He sided with the town.
Disappointed, the celebrities returned to their cells. Hopefully tomorrow they would hit the mafia.

IT IS NOW NIGHT ONE. THIS PHASE WILL END IN 24 HOURS OR WHEN ALL NIGHT ACTIONS HAVE BEEN RECEIVED.
Topic Starter
Mashley
Sorry for the delay guys, all actions are in but I don't have time to start the day right now so we'll get going later.
Topic Starter
Mashley
The celebrities awoke to find the mafia had taken it's first victim; Johnny Yonng Bosch (LadySuburu).



LadySuburu was Johnny Yong Bosch, the even-night commuter. On even numbered nights, he left the area completely and could not be targeted. He sided with the town.
The shocked celebrities prepared themselves for another hard day.

IT IS NOW DAY TWO. DAY ENDS AROUND 6:30PM GMT ON FRIDAY 18TH MAY. WITH 14 ALIVE, IT TAKES 8 TO HAMMER.
LadySuburu
Am I really that intimidating? I think I've died N1 quite a bit now.

:D

Good luck, town and scum. Play well and make the game interesting!
Nyquill
Well then pieguy, I see you're still alive. Care to claim your action?
Nyquill
Also, judging from the single NK, we can assume the independant is not an SK. Two factions targeting the same person for NK is just balls out impossible with this many people.

So we have a jester, lyncher, or perhaps a survivor?
bmin11
I won't be surprised to see a jester tbh
pieguyn
I checked NoHitter and got nothing, so I guess I was roleblocked >_<
Kanye West

pieguy1372 wrote:

I checked NoHitter and got nothing, so I guess I was roleblocked >_<
If you were blocked, you would get a block message. And why NoHitter?

vote: pieguy1372
bmin11
I would not jump on so fast like that.

Pieguy, can you clarify it? Like the context and such idk.
pieguyn
Mashley just said that I was unable to find any information on NoHitter.

kanye, if you read the thread, you'd know I was suspicious of him. FoS: kanye west since that whole post just seems weird...just a gut feeling I guess ><
Nyquill

pieguy1372 wrote:

Mashley just said that I was unable to find any information on NoHitter.

kanye, if you read the thread, you'd know I was suspicious of him. FoS: kanye west since that whole post just seems weird...just a gut feeling I guess ><
Remember what happened last time when you did "Gut feeling"? xD.

On a more serious note, I agree that jump was way too fast.

Regardless of whether or not pieguy is bullshitting, we have the following new information today: There may or may not be a roleblocker.
NoHitter may or may not be immune to night actions.

Hitter, I'm not forcing you to claim today, but if you are a role with some form of night action immunity you can (or not?) step forward to clear pieguy for now. Same can be said to the roleblocker (only if you blocked pieguy).
NoHitter
Rantai replaced out... Well anyway:

If pieguy were to investigate me, it should have been successful if there wasn't any interference.
I guess we do have a roleblocker.

Nyquill, I'm surprised that you brought up the possibility of someone being action immune.
Most people would just correlate that with the presence of a roleblocker.

NOw, I don't think lynching pieguy is a good idea. I still sort of believe his claim.
Nyquill
@hitter, just a lot of IRC mafia games have given me the habit of considering all possibilities.
Jinxy
Just posting to say I'm here, but I have something I need clarified by Mash so I'm currently waiting for his reply first.
Topic Starter
Mashley
Need a replacement for Swatty.
Sleep Powder
I knew it! Swatty can't handle the pressure, so he must be mafia!

@kanye west, I thought people aren't normally informed if they're roleblocked or not? My first guess is that you're the roleblocker acting as if you don't know anything about them to forge innocence. That's just my initial impression anyways.

pieguy previously claimed, but wasn't killed last night and then there's the fact that his action "failed". I assume a doctor (or similar protecting role) would protect him which could've been what the mafia were thinking (so they went after LS instead). Afterwards, NoHitter assumes that there is a roleblocker. If you add the two, it seems likely that the mafia roleblocked pieguy and killed LS.
UnderminE

animask wrote:

I knew it! Swatty can't handle the pressure, so he must be mafia!
So Rantai must be mafia as well!
pieguyn
Yeah animask has a point, when you're roleblocked it's supposed to say something generic. People don't find out they got roleblocked...

vote: kanye west Seems to me like he's mafia trying to get rid of the flavor cop, since his post seems so unusual. o.o//
UnderminE

pieguy1372 wrote:

vote: kanye west Seems to me like he's mafia trying to get rid of the flavor cop
This.

vote: kanye west
Let's see.
DeathxShinigami
Woah, animask making sense?

This is good news to me.

Vote: kanye west
Topic Starter
Mashley
Guys, there are 14 of you. There's no reason for this ridiculous sort of inactivity. If this continues I'll have to start sending regular prods.
Sleep Powder
I get the feeling one of you guys (who voted so far) are mafia, but not a lot of people are discussing things. The probability that someone who posted recently is mafia should be low.

@kanye west, I suggest you explain yourself before I vote you for your lack of response. Saying nothing will only make it worse for you at this point.

Also, vote count please.
Topic Starter
Mashley
A game that runs this slow is not a mafia game at all. Start posting or I'll call off the game and the mafia forum will be pronounced dead. That's really how it goes.
Topic Starter
Mashley
o and vote count

VOTE COUNT
kanye west - 3 pieguy1372, UnderminE, DeathxShinigami
pieguy1372 - 1 kanye west
Kanye West

animask wrote:

I knew it! Swatty can't handle the pressure, so he must be mafia!

@kanye west, I thought people aren't normally informed if they're roleblocked or not? My first guess is that you're the roleblocker acting as if you don't know anything about them to forge innocence. That's just my initial impression anyways.

pieguy previously claimed, but wasn't killed last night and then there's the fact that his action "failed". I assume a doctor (or similar protecting role) would protect him which could've been what the mafia were thinking (so they went after LS instead). Afterwards, NoHitter assumes that there is a roleblocker. If you add the two, it seems likely that the mafia roleblocked pieguy and killed LS.
In IRC, you get a message if you were roleblocked so I assumed it was the same here. If that is really not the case, then unvote

I guess what you're saying makes sense but don't discount the possibility of pieguy making a convenient flavor cop claim (which can still be mafia) and claiming getting roleblocked on top of that.

RC:KW:T
TDLN,TRW:HDNLHC.
Jinxy
Well, I do believe in pieguy's claim right now. I don't play irc mafia much, so can someone confirm what kanye said?

Also:

kanye west wrote:

RC:KW:T
TDLN,TRW:HDNLHC.
?
UnderminE
I think he's just RC'd.

Oh and looks like, he is Kanye West and T means Town. But couldn't get the rest of it.
Kanye West

I wrote:

RC:KW:T
TDLN,TRW:HDNLHC.
That's my RC. I don't know if I really need to RC yet so I'm just going to leave it like that for the time being.
Nyquill
Kanye west: Townie...?
Jinxy
T for town-aligned I assume

I don't think anyone here is vanilla townie
Mara

JInxyjem wrote:

I don't think anyone here is vanilla townie
I also think this way - celeb as a peasant sounds silly.
Sleep Powder

kanye west wrote:

RC:KW:T
TDLN,TRW:HDNLHC.
Roleclaim, Kanye West, Town(??)

I agree and think that it just means he is town-aligned. Why give use the bottom half to decipher? You know how much some of us love trying to solve these kinds of things.

Nobody has anything else to add? For now I'm going to believe kanye west and pieguy.
UnderminE
unvote then.

Well, dunno why but, somehow I can't trust pieguy. Looks like it's just me.
Jinxy

UnderminE wrote:

unvote then.

Well, dunno why but, somehow I can't trust pieguy. Looks like it's just me.

UnderminE wrote:

pieguy1372 wrote:

vote: kanye west Seems to me like he's mafia trying to get rid of the flavor cop
This.
And yet you wagoned on kanye after pieguy's single post. If you didn't trust pieguy, why would you believe in that post?
Seems like you're just trying to join any wagon and contradicted yourself as you did so.

Vote: UnderminE
UnderminE
Obviously I don't think he is mafia. According to his celebrity, he can't be mafia. I only said I just can't trust him somehow. It could be something else than mafia.

And kanye west part. I don't see any wrong thing about there. If someone else had told the same thing, I would have quote and say "this." because Kanye jumped on pieguy so quickly.

Well, I have to say I'm kinda newbie at these mafia games (I remember I said it on the first page though), so I change my mind easily according to other players' thoughts.
Kanye West
Hey Mashley, can you mass prod the inactives? Probably around half the players in this game aren't posting at all

Looking back through the thread, DxS has wagoned twice now, and the first time was onto a townie

vote: DxS

It's really hard to find scum now though; lots of null reads due to inactivity
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply