Blazevoir wrote:

Yay, more Pokémon maps~

[General]
Uhh... I don't think you should add Magikarp Gyarados Staryu Starmie Taillow Swellow Doduo Dodrio as tags... Aren't they just being used for storyboarding (or did I miss a new rule/guideline somewhere)?

Speaking of tags, I think you should change Heart Soul to HeartGold SoulSilver since that's their actual names in the DS versions (typing HeartGold or SoulSilver as it is now doesn't bring this map up).

[Normal]
This feels like a Normal+, but don't worry about changing the difficulty name for now.

00:46:821 (1) - This feels like it's out of place... Maybe actually map here or make this start a white tick later and place a note where this spinner originally started?
00:59:642 (4) - Add a soft finish?
01:07:847 (4) - I was expecting a hitsound for this.
01:14:001 (1) - ^
01:32:462 (2) - Add a soft finish?

[Hard]
There's no way this feels like a Hard...It feels more like an Insane.

00:38:616 (4,1) - Why isn't there anything mapped between these?
01:55:539 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - I think these should be removed. The song is pretty much over when it hits this part anyway.

[1811's Taiko Oni]
Sorry, I don't mod Taiko diffs.

Gonna wait till there's an easier diff before I give you a star

_Gezo_ wrote:

Although there is already a taiko; may I make one for your map ?

I'll mod 1811's later

_Gezo_ wrote:

very easy map, maybe a Muzukashii 1 or 2 stars.

hillaryzx wrote:

Normal

00:33:744 - add circle here +whistle.. to me, seems nice it kills the hitsound flow a little, so no
00:50:411 - ^ ^
00:54:513 - ^ ^
01:18:872 - maybe a circle fit here... k
01:22:975 - same reason as above nope
01:49:642 - ^ k

Blazevoir wrote:

[Normal]
This feels like a Normal+, but don't worry about changing the difficulty name for now.

00:46:821 (1) - This feels like it's out of place... Maybe actually map here or make this start a white tick later and place a note where this spinner originally started?
00:59:642 (4) - Add a soft finish?
01:07:847 (4) - I was expecting a hitsound for this.
01:14:001 (1) - ^
01:32:462 (2) - Add a soft finish?

Crimmi wrote:

Modding, CrimmiStyle!!

Since when does Tailow & Swellow appear in HG/SS? megusta.well I found them on bulbapedia since falkner got it in pokemon (anime)

-Sekai- wrote:

why the Normal have Insane logo~ o.o

mekadon wrote:

[attachment=0:d92dc]Junichi Masuda - Olivine CityViolet City (PokeRemixStudio Remix) (HeatKai) [Normal].osu[/attachment:d92dc]

1. 00:12:462 (2,4) - Nazi, you can make these slider more , with the third control point in the center like this http://puu.sh/jhZg, if you agree don't forget do the same with the other..
2. 00:37:077 (1) - Add finish or whistle at the start.
3. 00:38:616 (2) - Sounds a bit empty, add clap
4. 00:50:924 (2,4,6) - Clap here plase.. ugghu your pattern of clap is weird, if you agree with these claps remove the clap at the end of 00:51:436 (3).
5. 01:07:334 (2,3) - Please fix this spacing!
6. 01:20:283 (1) - Imo don't sound good with the finish and clap together, remove the finish please.
7. 01:36:565 (3) - What the.. Ctr+R please!

1. 00:47:334 (1) - Whistle at the start.
2. 01:06:308 (1) - Remove this new combo please, is needless.
3. 01:10:411 (1) - Same as above.
4. 01:12:462 (1) - Again... please fix this type of combo imo are totally needless.
5. Like this 01:26:821 (1) or 01:29:129 (1), 01:40:667 (1), 01:51:949 (1).
6. Why this diff is the only one to finish here? easy, hard and inclusively the taiko diffs finish at 02:03:231, go go map the last part for be consistent!!

1. The settings don't should be are like this? http://puu.sh/jqiu all the settings at the center....

1. 01:31:693 (1) - Remove this new combo
2. Nice nice :3

Kenezz wrote:

Heat :'(
Kenezz's Bakamod~
Taiko Diffs

1. The settings don't should be are like this? http://puu.sh/jqiu all the settings at the center....

it should be fine

Hard

1. 01:31:693 (1) - Remove this new combo
2. Nice nice :3

hehe <3

Sorry Heat, call me when you fix it u__ú
Good Luck <3~

Kenezz wrote:

Taiko Diffs

1. The settings don't should be are like this? http://puu.sh/jqiu all the settings at the center....

Kenezz wrote:

Normal

1. 00:47:334 (1) - Whistle at the start. k
2. 01:06:308 (1) - Remove this new combo please, is needless. k
3. 01:10:411 (1) - Same as above. k
4. 01:12:462 (1) - Again... please fix this type of combo imo are totally needless. k
5. Like this 01:26:821 (1) or 01:29:129 (1), 01:40:667 (1), 01:51:949 (1). k
6. Why this diff is the only one to finish here? easy, hard and inclusively the taiko diffs finish at 02:03:231, go go map the last part for be consistent!! I didn't map because that part's too annoying to map, besides the song's is very silent that time, so I thought it deserves to not be mapped. I don't know why heatkai mapped this but oh well

TheVileOne wrote:

Okay, time to brush up on my modding abilities.
Hard

00:32:718 (2,3,4,5,6) - Strange looking transition ._. strange but fine right :3

01:22:975 (4,5,1) - Spacing is uneven. I think it shouldn't be such a large jump. 1.5 spacing fits the song perfectly here. hait, fixed!

01:38:103 (3) - Remove end clap. hait, fixed!

02:00:411 (9) - Move this forward to the blue tick and respace. fine for me


Maps are in good shape. Star

TheNutritiousGuy wrote:

Support.

1. Nothing wrong here

• - 00:21:180 (5) - You should probably to add a new combo to follow the music in my opinion
  - 00:28:872 (5) - ^
  - 01:16:052 (1,3) - I don't really like this overlap. Really, if you can to move this slider in other place
  - 01:37:847 (x) - Perhaps you should move this break here 01:38:616,looks nice in my opinion
  - 01:48:872 (1) - Remove new combo to follow your pattern?

• - 00:13:231 (3) - For being consistent,add a whistle here please

• - 01:52:975 (5) - New combo here to follow the music?

MoodyRPG wrote:

Normal

• - 00:13:231 (3) - For being consistent,add a whistle here please

fixed

Hard

• - 01:52:975 (5) - New combo here to follow the music?

fixed

I'm a little tired right now but for now. Good Work

MoodyRPG wrote:

Peaceful

General

1. Nothing wrong here

Bobo

• - 00:21:180 (5) - You should probably to add a new combo to follow the music in my opinion Done
  - 00:28:872 (5) - ^^
  - 01:16:052 (1,3) - I don't really like this overlap. Really, if you can to move this slider in other place Ehh, done?
  - 01:37:847 (x) - Perhaps you should move this break here 01:38:616,looks nice in my opinion Did it like this to be consistent with hard :L
  - 01:48:872 (1) - Remove new combo to follow your pattern? Alright

I'm a little tired right now but for now. Good Work

1. Storyboard : In taiko difficulties, The black image with the title should be moved some pixels down not to have that :
   
   SPOILER

   

1. OD4 is quite a lot for an easy, besides you only use HPdrain 1. It's better when those settings are balanced. Consider using Hpdrain 2 and OD 3 please.
2. 00:49:385 (1) - This note is only 1/1 after the spinner, that doesn't let enough time to the player to hit the slider correctly in my opinion. Try this instead ?
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:54:001 (4) - The clap should be on this circle according to the music, not at the beginning of (5). Change it, doesn't it sounds better ?
4. 01:20:283 (1) - Same as 00:49:385 (1).
5. 01:38:616 - Select the edge of the break and move it here ?
   
   SPOILER

   
6. 01:58:616 (4,5) - Stack them correctly with (2) please. (1 grid down).

1. 00:16:052 (9) - Because there is a clap in the music's background, you should use a katsu here. Otherwise it feels awkard.
2. 00:17:077 (1,2,3,1) - This pattern sounds weird according to me. Try k-d---d-k.
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:19:129 (1,1,2,3) - Sounds awkward to me too. Try : k-d---d-k.
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 00:21:693 (2) - This note sounds out of place. Better to remove it o.o
5. 00:22:206 (3) - Because there is a clap in the music's background, you should use a katsu here. Otherwise it feels awkard.
6. 00:24:257 (2) - ^
7. 00:25:795 (1) - Again this note sounds out of place and better to remove it.
8. 00:26:821 (2,1,2,1,2,3,1,2) - Again this pattern is very weird o.o
   Better to do that :
   
   SPOILER

   
9. 00:29:642 - I would add a katsu here and remove 00:29:898 (3). That'd sound better.
10. 01:22:206 (1) - A don fits better here. (This way, this don would follow the drum and the nexts katsus the piano).
11. 01:39:129 (1,1,2,3,1) - Again this pattern sounds awkward. Better to do that :
    
    SPOILER

    
12. 01:41:180 (2,1,2,3,1) - Again, this pattern sounds awkward.
    
    SPOILER

    
13. 01:43:231 (1,1,2,3,1,1,1,2,3,1) - ^
14. 01:49:385 (2,1) - In my opinion, k d sounds better than d k.
15. 01:51:436 (2,1) - ^
16. 01:55:026 (2,1,2,1,2,1,1,2,3,4,5) - I don't think this is a good idea to map this in a Taiko since there is no drums here... (and it's awkward to play). I'd remove it.

1. Eh, this is a normal, don't use such high difficulty settings o.o
   Use OD5, HPdrain 5 and AR6 please o.o
2. 00:09:898 (3) - Looks like a whistle is missing here
3. 00:36:308 (2,3) - Don't stick them with the slider's track, they are partially hidden by the slider track and its hitburst.
4. 01:03:744 - Add a finish ?
5. 01:12:462 - Forgotten to add clap here ?
6. 01:19:642 - ^
7. 01:44:513 (3) - According to your previous hitsounds, the whistle should be on (2)'s end and not on this circle.
8. 01:55:026 (1) - There is nothing at this spot in the music, so you should have a circle here. However there is drum 1/4 earlier, but if you put something on it that'd play awkward. The best solution is to remove this circle.
9. 01:55:539 - The hitsound volume is just too loud here, that's very noisy. Decrease it please.

1. 00:32:718 (2,3,4) - This triple looks awkward eh. It overlaps the slider too much.
   I would do the pattern like this :
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:43:360 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - This stream isn't justified by the music like the others. That's why it sounds out of place. Change it please. (overmapping is bad >:D)
3. 00:53:488 (4) - You shouldn't do an anti-jump here. The player make think it is 1/4 or think that 00:53:744 (1,2,3) are 1/2 which is confusing. And it actually looks better like this :
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 01:04:642 (2,3) - It is hard to notice those circles because they are hidden by the stream's hitbursts. Make them visible please.
5. 01:13:744 (1,2,3,4) - These notes are only 1/2 after the spinner which make them hard to hit. Besides they are at the center of the screen thus they are hidden by the spinner hitburst which make them even harder to hit. (and this pattern is quite complex so ... @.@). Rearrange the pattern please xD
6. 01:57:077 (4) - New combo
7. 01:59:642 (8) - ^

1. 01:55:026 (2,3,1,1,2,1,1,2,3,1,1,2,1,2,1,1,1,2,1,2,1,1,1) - I don't think this is a good idea to map this in a Taiko since there is no drums here... (and it's awkward to play). I'd remove it.

Kurai wrote:

General

1. Storyboard : In taiko difficulties, The black image with the title should be moved some pixels down not to have that :
   
   SPOILER

   

Bobo's Easy

1. OD4 is quite a lot for an easy, besides you only use HPdrain 1. It's better when those settings are balanced. Consider using Hpdrain 2 and OD 3 please. OKaaaay
2. 00:49:385 (1) - This note is only 1/1 after the spinner, that doesn't let enough time to the player to hit the slider correctly in my opinion. Try this instead ? Fixed a couple things
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:54:001 (4) - The clap should be on this circle according to the music, not at the beginning of (5). Change it, doesn't it sounds better ? OKaaay
4. 01:20:283 (1) - Same as 00:49:385 (1). Yup
5. 01:38:616 - Select the edge of the break and move it here ? OKaaay
   
   SPOILER

   
6. 01:58:616 (4,5) - Stack them correctly with (2) please. (1 grid down). Gotcha

Kurai wrote:

General

1. Storyboard : In taiko difficulties, The black image with the title should be moved some pixels down not to have that :
   
   SPOILER

   

later I'll talk to you in the game :>

Hard

1. 00:32:718 (2,3,4) - This triple looks awkward eh. It overlaps the slider too much.
   I would do the pattern like this :
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:43:360 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - This stream isn't justified by the music like the others. That's why it sounds out of place. Change it please. (overmapping is bad >:D)
3. 00:53:488 (4) - You shouldn't do an anti-jump here. The player make think it is 1/4 or think that 00:53:744 (1,2,3) are 1/2 which is confusing. And it actually looks better like this :
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 01:04:642 (2,3) - It is hard to notice those circles because they are hidden by the stream's hitbursts. Make them visible please.
5. 01:13:744 (1,2,3,4) - These notes are only 1/2 after the spinner which make them hard to hit. Besides they are at the center of the screen thus they are hidden by the spinner hitburst which make them even harder to hit. (and this pattern is quite complex so ... @.@). Rearrange the pattern please xD
6. 01:57:077 (4) - New combo
7. 01:59:642 (8) - ^

Kurai wrote:

1811's Taiko Oni

1. 01:55:026 (2,3,1,1,2,1,1,2,3,1,1,2,1,2,1,1,1,2,1,2,1,1,1) - I don't think this is a good idea to map this in a Taiko since there is no drums here... (and it's awkward to play). I'd remove it.

HeatKai wrote:

Alright!

Kurai wrote:

HeatKai wrote:

Alright!

SapphireGhost wrote:

The Source and Tags section took up most of this mod, actually. I'll trust you know more about Pokemon than I do.

[Source and Tags]
- On your previous map, the source was listed as "Pokemon: Gold/Silver/Crystal". Change the source of this map to match the other one?
- "Bobo" is a missing tag on [1811's Taiko Oni].
- I don't think anyone will search for this map by pokemon names, so personally I'd remove those from tags.
- If you're going to have "Heart" and "Soul", you might consider changing those to "Heart Gold" and "Soul Silver".
- Who is the "19" of [19's Taiko Muzukashii], by the way? Their username should be in tags if it's not already.

[Hard]
01:34:513 (1,2,3,4) - Most of the map is pretty calm, and these are fairly large jumps. Not sure if it's worth changing but I might as well point this out.
01:38:616 - Break should start at this point!

[mekadon's Normal]
- For future maps, you could have probably avoided a lot of overlapping by using a slightly higher slider velocity. Keeps things looking neat and all that.
01:50:154 (4,5) - You could change this just a little so it doesn't touch the HP bar.

[Bobo's Easy]
00:46:821 (1) - I'd probably suggest mapping through this spinner, it's a bit out of place in the map and for an [Easy], it keeps things simpler not to have spinners in the middle of other patterns.
01:19:642 (1) - Same here!

That's all! Should be able to rank after fixes.

SapphireGhost wrote:

- Who is the "19" of [19's Taiko Muzukashii], by the way? Their username should be in tags if it's not already.

_Gezo_ wrote:

SapphireGhost wrote:

- Who is the "19" of [19's Taiko Muzukashii], by the way? Their username should be in tags if it's not already.

19 is the number related to me since ages (Maybe April '10...)

HeatKai : Put Gezoda and _Gezo_ in the tags : (Gezoda is my old username sooo... we don't know !)

SapphireGhost wrote:

Source and Tags are still inconsistent since Bobo's difficulty was updated, sorry. Just need to fix those, I think.

SapphireGhost wrote:

It seems I should increase my knowledge of Pokemon a bit more. yes

Aoriki wrote:

Woo, pokemon map!
Gratz on getting ranked!

Philippines wrote:

I'm having errors with the skip button. You have to skip fast right after the song start, if you miss a second, you will have to wait til start.

Bobo wrote:

Congratz Kai o/
Thanks Sapphy