-1 town vote whyy
forum
You are Mafia. (Mafia win!)
posted
Total Posts
1,898
Oh, I'm sure you'll do fine without me. You've got this game won!
Just force everyone to reveal their roles. Maybe you can find another priest and lynch him!
ok now im really confus
Ok.
I'll tell you what happened.
Nothing.
like I said, my stuff is random.
I'll tell you what happened.
Nothing.
like I said, my stuff is random.
Ival did anything happen to you? I really can't tell.
nobody asked you
more interested in ival
more interested in ival
Stop feigning idiocy.
ok sorry
Rule out the feigning.
One more time please.
One more time please.
obviously what happened was we used our day chat to coordinate "confirming him as town"
Vote: Rantai
I actually think lynching rantai is a good idea to mostly confirm KRZY
unvote, vote rantai
unvote, vote rantai
so two is a cult leader or what? can we get the mafia and independent count again please?
wouldnt lynching krzy confirm rantai? dont see how lynching rantai wold confirm krzy unless rantai was mafia. just saying because krzy would be more likely mafia because he didnt die hiding behind rantai. if he had, i would understand lynching rantai.
KRZY is mafia so it doesn't matter
Rather, they both are, and you as well
Of course if anyone buys that backwards logic I'll be amazed.Two wrote:
I actually think lynching rantai is a good idea to mostly confirm KRZY
unvote, vote rantai
Mainly because lynching the hidee doesn't confirm anything about the hider.
So who's up for a lynch on a player who kills off town players to save himself? Not exactly pro-town play ^.^
Vote: Two
i actually dont think two is mafia, but he could possibly be independent. i think krzy is likely mafia, but if i cant convince you guys im fine with lynching rantai i guess?
rantai's logic is right here, imo were better off lynching krzy.
rantai's logic is right here, imo were better off lynching krzy.
Just get lunaticmara to stab krzy in broad daylight or whatever.
krzy should hide behind someone else if lunaticmara agrees to that, and do it tomorrow
let krzy hide behind me, if hes alive tomorrow we lynch or vig kill him.
right?
right?
whatever you say guys, I'm in the middle of a LoL game right now and can't read that well
fair enough. ival just seemed to have thought i was mafia.
Alright guys
not so fast
some text coming, wait a bit please
not so fast
some text coming, wait a bit please
I'm not a hider. Reason I fakeclaimed was because I wanted to be seen as a somewhat useful town role, because I have a completely useless role.
I am a one-shot lynchproof townie. When I get the most votes for a lynch, the person with the second most votes gets lynched instead. From what I read, I can choose to use this power or not when I am about to be lynched.
So I did not hide behind Rantai N1, nor can I hide at all. Sorry guys, I was about to make this claim at the end of D1 but failed to find the timing.
I am a one-shot lynchproof townie. When I get the most votes for a lynch, the person with the second most votes gets lynched instead. From what I read, I can choose to use this power or not when I am about to be lynched.
So I did not hide behind Rantai N1, nor can I hide at all. Sorry guys, I was about to make this claim at the end of D1 but failed to find the timing.
so youre saying
"i lied, tried to confirm someone who may be mafia as town, but you cant lynch me ok?"
wow
"i lied, tried to confirm someone who may be mafia as town, but you cant lynch me ok?"
wow
I've hopefully stopped us from making a wasted lynch. I understand if you guys want to test my ability; it'd be a more useful lynch than lynching Rantai, and Two can confirm my role too.
Yeah that's why I am roleclaiming now, so I can cancel the claim I made earlier. I was willing to go with this a bit further before claiming my actual role but decided not to after there were movements to lynch Rantai.foulcoon wrote:
so youre saying
"i lied, tried to confirm someone who may be mafia as town, but you cant lynch me ok?"
wow
Uhhhh...well why wouldnt a one-shot be useful to us? ;-;
Thats a little silly KRZY.
Thats a little silly KRZY.
Yeah.
Roleclaim: Seraph Knight again.
It has a bit of a change though. Instead of dying on mafia I role block them.
Roleclaim: Seraph Knight again.
It has a bit of a change though. Instead of dying on mafia I role block them.
how about we put rantai at 2nd most votes then. why would you be defending someone you cant confirm even AFTER you lied about it.
unvote, Vote: KRZY
Its usefulness is minimal, and I felt I was a good candidate to lynch D1 because I've found in recent games that the way I play tend to get me lynched D1 often.Backfire wrote:
Uhhhh...well why wouldnt a one-shot be useful to us? ;-;
Thats a little silly KRZY.
one shot lynchproof is a good power to have as mafia
please explain why you would say
"yes
I am alive = Rantai is town"
please explain why you would say
"yes
I am alive = Rantai is town"
also back to LoL
Wow.
No, I have used mine already.
I am sitting on bmin because I didn't believe his story (ie I still think he may be mafia).
I am sitting on bmin because I didn't believe his story (ie I still think he may be mafia).
Uh, bmin.
so you chose to be a roleblocker instead of a doctor, when doctors are gamebreaking
We have a doctor, a non 1 shot doctor.
For me, I wanted to block a mafia and in the worst case scenario give a townie night kill immunity. Of course the chances of me getting mislynched is astronomically high (you really love misleading people into me for some reason) so I used it first night to get something done.
For me, I wanted to block a mafia and in the worst case scenario give a townie night kill immunity. Of course the chances of me getting mislynched is astronomically high (you really love misleading people into me for some reason) so I used it first night to get something done.
that is news to meRantai wrote:
We have a doctor, a non 1 shot doctor.
who
Rephrasing that; we have a claimed doctor. Unless I misunderstood his role.
1 shot tri-protect and then normal afterwards is what I thought.
1 shot tri-protect and then normal afterwards is what I thought.
well I thought it was just the 3
anyway, lets lynch rust today
unvote, vote rust45
anyway, lets lynch rust today
unvote, vote rust45
wait a second, if you thought animask was a formal doctor, why would you not have seraphed him?
I can make another assumption on theseKRZY wrote:
I'm not a hider. Reason I fakeclaimed was because I wanted to be seen as a somewhat useful town role, because I have a completely useless role.
I am a one-shot lynchproof townie. When I get the most votes for a lynch, the person with the second most votes gets lynched instead. From what I read, I can choose to use this power or not when I am about to be lynched.
So I did not hide behind Rantai N1, nor can I hide at all. Sorry guys, I was about to make this claim at the end of D1 but failed to find the timing.
KRZY might be fakeroleclaming again, he roleclaimed as a Hider to make the real Hider debunk him and letting his mafia friends know the real hider to avoid hitting the hider at night.
KRZY is really smells scummy to me so
Vote KRZY
but nobody counter-claimed...
NOBODY IS LISTENING TO ME? THIS MUST BE SOME SORT OF CURSE!
THE FIRST 5 PEOPLE WHO WILL COPYPASTE THIS PRAY IN THEIR MESSAGE WILL BE BLESSED WITH A MORE POWERFUL BLESSING OF LADY MARA
DEAR LADY MARA, PLEASE DO NOT GIVE ANY HARM TO GOOD PEOPLE, AND PLEASE GUIDE US TO THE VICTORY.
THE FIRST 5 PEOPLE WHO WILL COPYPASTE THIS PRAY IN THEIR MESSAGE WILL BE BLESSED WITH A MORE POWERFUL BLESSING OF LADY MARA
DEAR LADY MARA, PLEASE DO NOT GIVE ANY HARM TO GOOD PEOPLE, AND PLEASE GUIDE US TO THE VICTORY.
because the true hider may know that scenario first-handedly
DEAR LADY MARA, PLEASE DO NOT GIVE ANY HARM TO GOOD PEOPLE, AND PLEASE GUIDE US TO THE VICTORY.
DEAR LADY MARA, PLEASE DO NOT GIVE ANY HARM TO GOOD PEOPLE, AND PLEASE GUIDE US TO THE VICTORY.
Because if there was a watcher then no mafia in their right mind would have targeted him so there was no need. Not one of us would have been worth a 1:1 on N1.Two wrote:
wait a second, if you thought animask was a formal doctor, why would you not have seraphed him?
And I was right, no one was willing to take the risk.
DEAR LADY MARA, PLEASE DO NOT GIVE ANY HARM TO GOOD PEOPLE, AND PLEASE GUIDE US TO VICTORY.
Apparently not. Especially when they know who the doctor targets are, the doctor is practically useless anyway.Two wrote:
it's not about night 1 it's about long term
Which is a result of this subtle mass claim that's happening.
rantai if adam roleclaimed what do you think would have happened? well, I'll tell you: we'd have lynched someone who didn't roleclaim yesterday, someone we inevitably have to lynch today
in other words, we'd have saved a day and saved a power role, so please tell me how not claiming is pro-town
in other words, we'd have saved a day and saved a power role, so please tell me how not claiming is pro-town
Don't come off too defensive, I am just pointing out a negative of it.
We save a town, we cripple an aux or more depending.
Besides we know the reason you wanted to lynch adam was not because he didn't roleclaim but because you wanted to evade a death (which is why you hoped he was town, right?). Him not roleclaiming is just an excuse for you and ultimately stifled any potentially better lynches by forcing the people to vote without a single reason of their own.
Even if you want to ignore/deny the excuse part the rest of it is true and you know it (partially from voting patterns of some of the voters and your outright statement from earlier).
We save a town, we cripple an aux or more depending.
Besides we know the reason you wanted to lynch adam was not because he didn't roleclaim but because you wanted to evade a death (which is why you hoped he was town, right?). Him not roleclaiming is just an excuse for you and ultimately stifled any potentially better lynches by forcing the people to vote without a single reason of their own.
Even if you want to ignore/deny the excuse part the rest of it is true and you know it (partially from voting patterns of some of the voters and your outright statement from earlier).
I did want to lynch adam yesterday, town or not. The thing is, if he claimed a role like priest, there'd be no reason to lynch him since he has a demonstrable power. The idea behind massclaiming is that the town gains massive cop-like properties. For example, if someone claims a cop and isn't a cop, the real cop knows they are mafia. This usually means that mafia will claim roles that can't be proven, or take what powers they do have and try to pass them off as town. Through a process of elimination, the town can determine which active roles are fake, and which people are probable mafia.
The biggest problem is that I can't ignore 2 for 1. There is every possibility that LS has incorporated fake roles that can be publicly announced so the benefit of mass claiming reduces significantly. No one can counterclaim them and people would be far less likely to question a mod/publicly confirmed role.Two wrote:
I did want to lynch adam yesterday, town or not. The thing is, if he claimed a role like priest, there'd be no reason to lynch him since he has a demonstrable power. The idea behind massclaiming is that the town gains massive cop-like properties. For example, if someone claims a cop and isn't a cop, the real cop knows they are mafia. This usually means that mafia will claim roles that can't be proven, or take what powers they do have and try to pass them off as town. Through a process of elimination, the town can determine which active roles are fake, and which people are probable mafia.
I do agree if he had claimed he would have saved himself. On the other hand he could be easily killed off before he could use it and it drains the fun out of the role (that part is something else entirely but still there).
he got killed off by town, and in the process wasted one of our limited kills
Actually your advocating for a lynch got him killed, the sheep followed per say. There was almost nothing pointing to scum.
As I said before, him acting as he always does indicated nothing for scum, if anything it was more town if meta was to be used. Also him not wanting to claim also indicated nothing scummy as I highly doubt a mafia would ever stand up like that if they had a mind to win.
I shouldn't have trusted that 'plan'. Too bad I'm as gullible as a 4 year old.
As I said before, him acting as he always does indicated nothing for scum, if anything it was more town if meta was to be used. Also him not wanting to claim also indicated nothing scummy as I highly doubt a mafia would ever stand up like that if they had a mind to win.
I shouldn't have trusted that 'plan'. Too bad I'm as gullible as a 4 year old.
trying to argue that adam did the right thing is like trying to argue that (almost used hitler here but then realized hitler had reasons) x person who killed their family did the right thing
it just makes no sense at all and is selfish
that aside, what do you think about rust and why aren't you posting bmin
it just makes no sense at all and is selfish
that aside, what do you think about rust and why aren't you posting bmin
MDuh wrote:
I can make another assumption on these
KRZY might be fakeroleclaming again, he roleclaimed as a Hider to make the real Hider debunk him and letting his mafia friends know the real hider to avoid hitting the hider at night.
I'm sorry, but what are you saying.MDuh wrote:
because the true hider may know that scenario first-handedly
@Two's question: I posted that I was about to go a bit further with this Hider thing until you guys decided to lynch Rantai, when we can assess what possible information we got from N1 and come up with a much better lynchee candidate. Don't take me wrong, for I am not protecting Rantai; I just want the best possible lynch.
Sweet, sweet irony.Two wrote:
it just makes no sense at all and is selfish
Also I'm not saying he did the right thing, I'm saying we did the wrong thing. Small difference there.
About rust; I actually think he is town because he saw the fundamental problems with the adam lynch (somewhat). Other than that he hasn't posted for this day yet so I have no read on him.
Vote: KRZY for obvious confirmation
Even if mafia has a fake role, I think we can at least cut down the list. Mafia would claim a role that can't be confirmed with it's action, since it's a "fake" role that doesn't really has an ability to use. It would be a mess if we have tons of aux roles that can't be confirmed with their actions, but I'm saying mass claim wouldn't be entirely useless even mafia has a fake role to claim.
Even if mafia has a fake role, I think we can at least cut down the list. Mafia would claim a role that can't be confirmed with it's action, since it's a "fake" role that doesn't really has an ability to use. It would be a mess if we have tons of aux roles that can't be confirmed with their actions, but I'm saying mass claim wouldn't be entirely useless even mafia has a fake role to claim.
Two can you still confirm roles
Never said it was useless, just beginning to bring equal or more harm than good (ie reduced benefit)
Actually nevermind, even if you could confirm additional roles today it would be a waste to use it on me.
I would rather if we do not lynch me today, but I understand how Town has more to gain if I am lynched and turn up Mafia than what they lose if I turn up town and the second-most-voted person is lynched.
I would rather if we do not lynch me today, but I understand how Town has more to gain if I am lynched and turn up Mafia than what they lose if I turn up town and the second-most-voted person is lynched.
That actually sounds like a good idea. A great idea, actually. By lynching me and putting someone else at second-most-voted, you can confirm one as town AND get another lynch.
You may think I could be faking this whole thing, but you gotta trust me on this one.
You may think I could be faking this whole thing, but you gotta trust me on this one.
ninja'd
I thought that was the plan all along?KRZY wrote:
That actually sounds like a good idea. A great idea, actually. By lynching me and putting someone else at second-most-voted, you can confirm one as town AND get another lynch.
You may think I could be faking this whole thing, but you gotta trust me on this one.
was it ._.
._. it was
Topic Starter
MDuh wrote:
DEAR LADY MARA, PLEASE DO NOT GIVE ANY HARM TO GOOD PEOPLE, AND PLEASE GUIDE US TO THE VICTORY.
2/5 Blessings of Mara spread.foulcoon wrote:
DEAR LADY MARA, PLEASE DO NOT GIVE ANY HARM TO GOOD PEOPLE, AND PLEASE GUIDE US TO VICTORY.
by saying we did the wrong thing you are saying he did the right thingRantai wrote:
Also I'm not saying he did the right thing, I'm saying we did the wrong thing. Small difference there.
rust's posts: search.php?author_id=117369&t=67143
he's made 9 posts since this game started
players he's attacked: 0_o, swiftwolf, animask
players he's defended: adam, nohitter
supported the idea of wojjan, backfire, and lunaticmara being confirmed town
that said, he posts more than mduh and kokizi and at least mduh is posting a little more (the fact that I can even list what I listed makes him more valuable to keep around)
I don't see how confirming KRZY as lynchproof is going to do anything for us except give us an excuse to waste a potential mafia power, but lets put kokizi as the second highest number of votes
Is this blessing still on
DEAR LADY MARA, PLEASE DO NOT GIVE ANY HARM TO GOOD PEOPLE, AND PLEASE GUIDE US TO VICTORY.
DEAR LADY MARA, PLEASE DO NOT GIVE ANY HARM TO GOOD PEOPLE, AND PLEASE GUIDE US TO VICTORY.
DEAR LADY MARA, PLEASE DO NOT GIVE ANY HARM TO GOOD PEOPLE, AND PLEASE GUIDE US TO VICTORY.
Curiosity gets the better of me again.
Curiosity gets the better of me again.
Topic Starter
Blessings of Mara 5/5 Recieved.
and you guys are all falling for this?
can I show you another game I played where a cunductor's baton was voted amongst the living every night
which was essentially a scum roleblock/rolecop to whoever it went to.
can I show you another game I played where a cunductor's baton was voted amongst the living every night
which was essentially a scum roleblock/rolecop to whoever it went to.
Rust has been reluctant to join the game from the beginning, which leads me to think that his lack of contribution at least has a fair excuse compared to that of Kokizi.
aka yeah let's lynch Kokizi unless something else comes up.
aka yeah let's lynch Kokizi unless something else comes up.
School does a lot to one doesn't it? Such as making them not being able to be on the internet as often. This day started while I was in school and I got back from school just a little ago. I know you're trying to find someone to lynch and I can see your logic, but in my defense, I would like to say that I have tried to look at people's roles and try to analyze people in how their roles work.
With that said:
Vote: KRZY
I'm calling bull on KRYZ's claim. First of all, the host did say that everyone would get an awesome role, being unlynchable isn't really that awesome for a townie. Secondly, you did fakeclaim in D1 and it did cause some confusion today, neither of those are good things to do as town, pretty good to do as mafia though. And thirdly, most lies have a grain of truth in them, so I believe that you are an unlycnhable player, but you are for the mafia.
Of course, since I do actually believe you're unlynchable, I suggest we find someone else to put in second and then lynch KRZY to burn the one shot.
With that said:
Vote: KRZY
I'm calling bull on KRYZ's claim. First of all, the host did say that everyone would get an awesome role, being unlynchable isn't really that awesome for a townie. Secondly, you did fakeclaim in D1 and it did cause some confusion today, neither of those are good things to do as town, pretty good to do as mafia though. And thirdly, most lies have a grain of truth in them, so I believe that you are an unlycnhable player, but you are for the mafia.
Of course, since I do actually believe you're unlynchable, I suggest we find someone else to put in second and then lynch KRZY to burn the one shot.
Also, NoHitter: You never answered my question to you on D1:
...question for NoHitter: When did you use your demotivater ability on Mara?
Worst reasonrust45 wrote:
I'm calling bull on KRYZ's claim. First of all, the host did say that everyone would get an awesome role, being unlynchable isn't really that awesome for a townie.
I explained why I fakeclaimed and what I hoped to achieve in my previous posts.rust45 wrote:
Secondly, you did fakeclaim in D1 and it did cause some confusion today, neither of those are good things to do as town, pretty good to do as mafia though.
Just as bad as the first reason.rust45 wrote:
And thirdly, most lies have a grain of truth in them, so I believe that you are an unlycnhable player, but you are for the mafia.
But I understand.
And I'm calling bull on that.KRZY wrote:
I explained why I fakeclaimed and what I hoped to achieve in my previous posts.
That's not a good reason to fakeclaim and you only did to make yourself look good to the rest of the town.KRZY wrote:
I'm not a hider. Reason I fakeclaimed was because I wanted to be seen as a somewhat useful town role, because I have a completely useless role.
vote: Kokizi
I don't get why rust is even discussing about this
Lynch KRZY, put second lynchee, if KRZY survives, it's all good
Unless he's a lynchproof mafia which would fucking suck
Lynch KRZY, put second lynchee, if KRZY survives, it's all good
Unless he's a lynchproof mafia which would fucking suck
I'm trying my best to keep it up with the thread and do my homework at the same time. Maybe I should only do once I guess ._.;;Two wrote:
bmin how many times are you going to lurk and not post
I have nothing to say, but that I'm failing on understanding Wojjan's post. I'm not sure what cunductor means and stuff.
wojjan isn't even in this game
Who should we backup lynch? 
I still think it's bmin11, though it's still mostly a gut feeling
I still think it's bmin11, though it's still mostly a gut feeling
my gut feeling is you
now should we go with gut feelings pieguy or should we get rid of someone who has posted nothing (kokizi)
now should we go with gut feelings pieguy or should we get rid of someone who has posted nothing (kokizi)
If your really a seraph knight, Rantai, you really should have protected me so we could stay somewhat NK-proof. With KRZY, I don't think we can confirm him being town-aligned. Also, do we even have a watcher?
@KRZY, Wojjan probably has that role where she isn't even part of the game until Day 3 or something... she isn't on the list.
@KRZY, Wojjan probably has that role where she isn't even part of the game until Day 3 or something... she isn't on the list.