forum

Papaya- Hero (Happy Grandale Mix)

posted
Total Posts
19
Topic Starter
Maximum
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
mtmcl
This is looking good. It's so refreshing to see timing that actually works. And the spacing seems good. In a brief look, I'm slightly concerned with the placement of some markers on the timeline. This concern is based entirely on the series of four combos after the first spinner in insane (starting at 12:19) If you slow it down and listen to each combo's 6 and 7, I think you'll find that they're a little late.

Take a look at those. They're easily fixed by pulling them back a little on the timeline. I'll add more examples if I find anything that stands out like those.

Oh, but you're definitely starred.
Topic Starter
Maximum
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
mtmcl
Fun! I wish I could pass insane without half time or some other difficulty reducing mod, but that's just my problem.
Topic Starter
Maximum
It seems a little easy for me. But sadly, I had to get a wired mouse. >:(
Echo
I noticed a lot of misleading spacing going on:
  1. In normal around 47.50, the 5-6 spacing is extremely misleading. It makes the interval between the 5 and 6 look like it's half the time of the 4 and 5 when it's actually double it.
  2. In insane at 15.50, the interval between 3 and 4 seems to be the same as the one between 4 and 5. If you set the grid to level 3 (most precise), shift the 4 and 5 three "grids" to the left so the edge of the 4 is touching the edge of the 3. Similarly, the blue 7 at 16.00 should be equidistant from the 6 and 8.
  3. Also in insane, you tend to halve the distance between beats if they're on a diagonal. This is completely misleading. All instances of this (such as green combo at 24.00, red 2/3 at 1:11.70, and more) will need to be fixed by either doubling the distance of beats on the diagonal or by halving the distance of horizontal/vertical beats.
I'm dropping you back to a star, but fix these and the map should turn out great :)
Topic Starter
Maximum
Made the beats horizontal/vertical, and such.
AuRevoir_old
i like this song... this beatmap is pretty good in my opinion.

btw, could you guys review my beatmap as well? nobody has posted a reply yet :(
mtmcl
I'm not very good with small spacing discrepancies. I'd bubble this again right now, but I'm still questioning the 3/4/5 at 15:50. Hopefully Echo can clear that up.
James
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Topic Starter
Maximum
I added a new difficulty and did WHAT James said.
James
Normal sounds better now. Hope you're not mad at me. *hides*
Topic Starter
Maximum
Ok...I fixed some beats in difficult.
James
Why this isnit bubbled?
I don't care about the Difficult version :P
Topic Starter
Maximum
Finally. I made easy more easier and moved some beats in normal.
mtmcl
WTF DID YOU DO TO "DIFFICULT"?

It's all bungled up, fo sho.
Topic Starter
Maximum
:? What the heck? Aw, it got mixed up with the OTHER unfinished beatmap. :( More editing again...

EDIT: YAY! Difficult is now done! :)
mtmcl
The series of circles about 10 seconds into Difficult is really really hard to figure out. I've watched it in edit mode and tried to play it several times and I still keep missing part of it.
Saturos
Easy is fine.

Normal:

  1. 00:38:49 (1) - Slider seems a bit short. Sounds better ending at 0:39:02.
  2. 00:54:28 (5) - Slider seems a bit too long? Sounds better ending at 0:55:61.
  3. 01:16:18 (4) - Quarter beat too early.
Difficult:

  1. See attached.
  2. Various slider length and beat placement changes.
  3. Removed the 4th spinner in the in the beginning section of the map because it was literally impossible to get anything but a 50 on since it was instant.
Insane:

  1. See attached.
  2. Various beat placement changes.
Demoting this back to a star for now, but I'll rebubble it if you approve of these changes. ;x

Download: PAPAYA - HERO (HAPPY GRANDALE MIX) (Maximum) [Difficult].osu

Download: PAPAYA - HERO (HAPPY GRANDALE MIX) (Maximum) [Insane].osu
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply