1. Broken Key (2.46 stars, 140 notes)
2. Keyhole (4.67 stars, 284 notes)
3. saymun's Lock (3.24 stars, 190 notes)
4. simplistiC's ChainLock (4.94 stars, 315 notes)
5. thekillerhjkhjk's MasterKey (4.98 stars, 398 notes)

Dusty wrote:

Make a Normal blah blah.

EDIT: Source would be "Tales of Destiny 2", right?

[KeyHole]
00:01:030 (1,2,3) - confusing spacing =o well it makes sense to me XD
00:05:058 (10) - ^ Done
00:23:917 (1,2) - terrible antijump looks fine and flows well =o
00:47:169 (8) - spacing? well its readable and just kinda happened lol XD
00:55:959 (11,1,2) - confusing stack. First a 1/2 beat and then 1 beat in between them? Also it's on the end of a slider which can make stuff worse.

02:08:097 (6) - lol around here I actually got used to your stacks... and then the map ended. lol gotcha

[simplistiC]
00:05:058 (1) - Mean, hidden jump

[Thekillerhjkhjk]
00:39:114 (7) - Possibly unrankable slider

Dusty wrote:

Make a Normal blah blah.

EDIT: Source would be "Tales of Destiny 2", right?

[KeyHole]
00:01:030 (1,2,3) - confusing spacing
00:05:058 (10) - ^
00:23:917 (1,2) - terrible antijump
00:47:169 (8) - spacing?
00:55:959 (11,1,2) - confusing stack. First a 1/2 beat and then 1 beat in between them? Also it's on the end of a slider which can make stuff worse.

02:08:097 (6) - lol around here I actually got used to your stacks... and then the map ended.

[simplistiC]
00:05:058 (1) - Mean, hidden jump

[Thekillerhjkhjk]
00:39:114 (7) - Possibly unrankable slider

Glasslake wrote:

[General]
-3 Insanes? Need better difficulty spread. My difficulty is hardly even insane hard at best maybe but i doubt its even that hard it has to do with the bpm for sure Dx

[KeyHole]
-Increase the overall difficulty by 2 ticks.[?] done
-Disable countdown.[?] done
-Disable letterbox during breaks.[?] done
00:02:495 (4,5) - Fix spacing or make it a new combo.[!] mmk~
00:05:059 (10) - Fix spacing or make it a new combo.[!] mmk
00:12:749 (7) - New combo.[?] mmk
00:23:917 (1) - Is this anti-jump intended? If not, move it.[?] its intended =O
00:55:959 (11,1,2) - Confusing. Change this.[!] Fixed
01:31:661 (6) - New combo.[?] kay
02:05:900 (12) - Fix spacing or make it a new combo.[!] Done
02:08:097 (6) - Hardly readable, move this.[!] Done

[simplistiC's ChainLock]
-Some of the repeat sliders have way too many repeats, I mean come on you can do better than just sticking a slider with like 30 1/4 repeats ~_~.
00:18:607 (7) - New combo[?]
01:27:450 (6) - New combo[?]
01:30:380 (6) - New combo[?]

[TheKillerhjkhjk's MasterKey]
Unfinished?

Glad you're not mapping vocaloid this time, too bad you're not mapping the whole set by yourself...

Glasslake wrote:

[simplistiC's ChainLock]
-Some of the repeat sliders have way too many repeats, I mean come on you can do better than just sticking a slider with like 30 1/4 repeats ~_~.
00:18:607 (7) - New combo[?]
01:27:450 (6) - New combo[?]
01:30:380 (6) - New combo[?]

saymun wrote:

Hey~ add my difficulty XD

man! you should get the full version~~~ really! i wanted to keep mapping to the end, but i guess i can't

EDIT: Can you add an audio lead of 1sec in my diff? i forgot X_X

thekillerhjkhjk wrote:

saymun wrote:

Hey~ add my difficulty XD

man! you should get the full version~~~ really! i wanted to keep mapping to the end, but i guess i can't

EDIT: Can you add an audio lead of 1sec in my diff? i forgot X_X

its funny cause i gave ateh-chan the actual full mp3 file to cut down to his size XD

Sakura301 wrote:

Diff checking, plus some IRC modding for a MAJOR unrankable error =P but yeah you can keep them, just dont hide one under the other, here's a suggestion, in case you wanna follow it:

Beuchi-chan wrote:

Hi hi!!

Here are some suggestions for your map~ You don't have to change them if you don't agree with me
Let's go!!

~All Diffs~
- Delete the unused .osb file. Check
- Source and Tags should be the same on all diffs. Check
- Use the same combocolours on all diffs. Check

~Broken Key~
- Check the whole map with Distance Snap on, there are some points where there's a slightly inconsistence of spacing =x

00:44:606 (5) - New Combo. Check
00:50:831 (5) - ^ Done
00:57:056 (5) - ^ Done
01:02:549 (5) - ^ Check for all~!
01:10:972 (1,1,1) - 3 spinners on a row... that's kinda lazy of you xP why don't you map something? the spinners follow that little wierd symphony beat thingy lol
01:30:380 (1) - Fix spacing, it looks like there isn't any "silence" between (6,1). im following the lyrics
01:34:408 (6) - New Combo.
01:47:224 (5) - ^
01:54:914 (9) - Align vertically with (7).
01:58:942 (5) - New Combo.
02:04:801 (6) - ^

~saymun's Lock~
00:43:141 (3,5) - Space them a bit more to make (5)'s reverse arrow visible.
00:44:972 (1,2,3,4) - First of all, this diff is a "Normal", right? Well, personally I don't think Normals should have this kind of speed-ups, but if you're really going to leave it like that, please add a SB warning.
01:52:717 (5) - New Combo.

~KeyHole~
- Change name to "Keyhole", the H shouldn't be capitalized o.O

00:01:030 (1,2,3) - Fix spacing. would rather not they are fine not to far apart not to close together and if i move those ill have to move all of the following
00:05:059 (7) - ^ o-o whats wrong with it
00:08:354 (7) - New Combo. Done
00:14:946 (1) - Fix Spacing. ish fine it flows well
00:17:875 (9) - New Combo. Done
00:23:917 (1) - Fix Spacing. reason why i placed those 2 so far is because i placed the 3 further away and it slows down i dont want to have the 1, and 2 fast and then you have to stop and hit 3 thats not a nice flow Dx
00:33:255 (1) - Shorten to 00:35:451. done
00:36:001 (1) - Delete this note, it sounds weird o.o Done
00:47:170 (8) - Fix spacing. was purposely done looks fine and flows well
00:56:691 (2) - ^ ^
01:04:014 (10) - New Combo. Done
01:04:929 (1) - Delete New Combo. Done
01:07:676 (5) - Fix Spacing. flows well and trying to keep a nice pattern
01:49:055 (6) - This slider can be kinda hard to see, change it? oxo =o looks fine to me and easy to spot
02:08:280 (7) - Fix Spacing. Done

~simplistiC's ChainLock~
- Maybe decrease Overall Difficulty 1 tick?

01:37:978 (1) - Resnap this slider to 1/3 Beat Divisor.
01:41:365 (1) - ^
01:43:837 (1) - ^
02:07:365 (4) - ^

~TheKillerhjkhjk's MasterKey~
- Increase Overall Difficulty for the sake of readability of this map @___@...
- Decrease hitsounds volume.
- Uhh... I think the spacing here is kind of ridiculous :/ but meh... if BATs are okay with this I don't have to complain about it :3

00:13:481 (4) - The reverse arrow it's hidden, move the slider away.

*star* Good luck~

Beuchi-chan wrote:

~saymun's Lock~
00:43:141 (3,5) - Space them a bit more to make (5)'s reverse arrow visible. Done
00:44:972 (1,2,3,4) - First of all, this diff is a "Normal", right? Well, personally I don't think Normals should have this kind of speed-ups, but if you're really going to leave it like that, please add a SB warning. Okay
01:52:717 (5) - New Combo. X

~TheKillerhjkhjk's MasterKey~
- Increase Overall Difficulty for the sake of readability of this map @___@... erm... ok?
- Decrease hitsounds volume.done
- Uhh... I think the spacing here is kind of ridiculous :/ but meh... if BATs are okay with this I don't have to complain about it :3lets hope so then...

00:13:481 (4) - The reverse arrow it's hidden, move the slider away.fixed

*star* Good luck~

Shulin wrote:

TheKillerhjkhjk's MasterKey:

-- Hmm... -1 HP drain.done
-- Raise stacking leniency 0.2 is unrankable.check
-- Add a spinner.fine...
-- Cut the inheriting sections that aren't in use at the end of the song.used for spinner =.=

00:47:902 -- Hitsound are a bit too loud from here. Normal whistles definitely don't fit.unloudened if thats a word
00:51:472 (3,4) - Spacing I read that as a 1/2 because of the previous sliders.distance snap says otherwise... but changed anyway
01:11:338 (1,2,3,4) - Number of returns are confusing.not really, its an insane map, you people need to pay attention to the coming notes
01:27:267 (8,1,2) - The constant back and forth beats becomes a pain about here.come to think of it, i agree. changed
01:43:562 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - This should really be snapped to 1/3, like 01:40:633 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - it is already XD
01:49:787 (2,3) - Spacing looks like a 1/2.changed like the other time
01:52:717 (3) - Completely hidden. But I guess the back and forth beats have become the norm by now.added another new combo earlier on. the yellow colour made it hard to see. its blue now.

Idk the map doesn't really suit the song... slider velocity feels too high... spacing is huge... hmm... >:(

Matma Rex wrote:

[saymun's Lock]
00:36:184 (3,4,5,1,2,3) - I'm not sure if these jumps are suitable for Normal diff. I think its fine. I think players will still be able to see the jumps coming if they listen to the song
00:44:972 (1,2,3,4) - same as above (although I like it, myself). Also it causes sweet exception (and sometimes crashes osu!) when opening timing panel (not that you can do anything about it) .....lol
00:49:366 (1,2,3,4) - again, unsuitable? X
02:03:336 (1,3) - IMO it doesn't fit here, use longer sliders with less repeats? X
02:06:632 (1,2,3) - and these jumps are not cool at all. Cmon.....i made it slightly smaller

YGOkid8 wrote:

TheKillerhjkhjk's Master Key
- tbh, it really should be "thekillerhjkhjk", since that's how his name is spelt
------------------------------------
hm... fix these stuff, and I'll pubble it

YGOkid8 wrote:

saymun's Lock:

- As was announced last night in #mod (GMT +10), having Slider Speeds other than 0.5x and 2.0x (and of course 1.0x) is unrankable. This was stated by peppy himself so saymun, good idea, but you'll have to change it Gahhhh, changed it to easy jumps because it has a similar effect, please don't complain its too hard D:

Combo Mod~
02:09:928 (1) - No New Combo. I was hoping that we'd be doing the full song version, but i guess not

xierbaliti wrote:

-thekillerhjkhjk's MasterKey-
How about Volume -10%~15% in Kiai part? A bit loud now.Lowered, but not that low.
00:43:325 (3) - New comboX
01:55:280 (8) - ^ X

yaya wrote:

[simplistiC's ChainLock]
01:28:823 (7,1) - this jump is not so good IMO..
others nice.

[saymun's Lock]
00:36:184 (3) - this finish tooooo loud. turn down.
01:40:633 (1) - ^
00:49:366 (1,2,3,4,5) - do not use jump on "Hard"


do not ask me recheck this before you make others diff better.