[General]
Let me post my mod on general things and an Easy difficulty first since it will probably take you time to fix. Apparently this mapset needs more work in my eyes, but have enough potential. Call me back when you are ready. I will mod other difficulties as well.
- I'm not a fan of usage of drum claps in Easy / Hard / Insane which doesn't fit with the song at all. I'm sure it'd be nicer if you re-add hitsounds like what Kin did on his own guest difficulty.
- Inconsistent kiai time on Kin's Normal. You can fix this if it's not intentional. (I'd personally recommend unifying the length of the kiai time though.)
- You have to add at least 2000ms as an audio lead in on all difficulties by editing osu files automatically.
- Missing the video file on Kin's Normal. Don't forget to set the its offset as well.
- 00:01:570 (3) - The rhythm would be more natural if you add a reverse to this slider.
- 00:04:055 (2) - It sounds like there is no sound to place an object at 00:04:410 - . You can fix this by rearranging the current rhythm a bit like this.
- 00:09:735 (2) - This is just my personal taste, but I think 1/2 sliders should be avoided as much as possible in order to make patterns friendly in Easy difficulties. Therefore I'd recommend you simplifying this rhythm like this.
100% same rhythm as above though lol - 00:11:865 (1) - I'm sure it'd be better to give players recovery by removing this note.
- 00:17:191 (1,2) - I think you could have made this rhythm more friendly by avoiding a 3/4 gap like this.
- 00:22:871 (1,2) - Same as above.
- 00:32:102 (2,3) - It'd be better to avoid stack patterns in order to prevent misleading. Same goes for 01:18:966 (3,4) - , 01:22:871 (2,3) - .
- 00:37:073 (3) - This slider can be extended to 00:37:783 - . This way the rhythm would sound easier for beginners to play. Same goes for 00:39:913 (3) - .
- 00:42:398 - It'd be better fill in this gap by adding an extra note since there is a strong vocal/drum sound here.
- 00:42:753 (2,3) - A 3/4 repeat slider would make the rhythm more easier to play. I'd recommend you placing it instead of these objects.
- 00:44:351 (1) - You wanted to follow the vocal line right? If so, you should have followed a vocal stress at 00:44:528 - with a slider head or note. Therefore I'd rearrange this rhythm like this if I were you. Also this can make a 1/1 gap~.
- 00:47:368 (2) - This also can be extended to 00:48:256 (3) - for the same reason as above.
- 00:51:274 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - The completely same rhythm is repeated 4 times. I'm sure it'd be more fun to play if you make difference a bit by rearranging some a bit.
- 01:06:895 (3) - Add a finish to the end. + 01:07:960 (4) - add a clap instead of a finish. ++ 01:08:315 (1) - add a finish instead of a clap. This should be more fitting than the current hitsounding.
- 01:08:315 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - I think you can add more claps like what you did at 01:02:635 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - . Indeed the melody kinda gets calmed, but the volume change at 01:08:315 - should be enough to respect that in my opinion.
- 01:14:706 (2,3) - 1/2 sliders should be avoided as much as possible in my opinion as I mentioned on this mod. So I''d recommend you turning into a 3/4 repeat slider. This can make consistent with 01:20:386 (2) - .
- 01:25:534 (1) - There doesn't need to silence this whole spinner. That doesn't make sense at all in my opinion.
Let me post my mod on general things and an Easy difficulty first since it will probably take you time to fix. Apparently this mapset needs more work in my eyes, but have enough potential. Call me back when you are ready. I will mod other difficulties as well.