十分感谢~
forum
kemu - Ikasama Life Game
posted
Total Posts
222
a32又rank 哭哭哦
EDIT: 星爷难度简直..
EDIT: 星爷难度简直..
好
edit 777 post
edit 777 post
nice 
又rank
April fool's day is passed ppl jesus christ >.>
Joker - everything that is wrong with 2013 maps.
Unranking due to readability issues and some internal discussion. Please read below. (Other staff members should be adding their opinions as well on this map.)
This mod is WIP. Expect edits.
Joker
This mod is WIP. Expect edits.
Joker
- Tick 2 is a must on this difficulty.
- 00:19:896 (5) - How does a player know how slow this is? Note: 00:15:696 (5) -
- 01:35:946 (1,1) - This overlap needs to go.
- 01:45:996 (2,1) - This is blatantly unreadable without tick rate 2.
- 01:55:296 (1) - Is this really a slowdown? It should speed up, if you want to be consistent with 00:57:696 (1) -
- 02:15:096 (5,6,7,8,1) - The stream needs to go outwards, not inwards.
- Tick 2 as well.
- 00:19:896 (4,1) - 0.5 -> 1.5x? Just no. Also the path of the second slider makes this literally almost unreadable, if not unreadable.
Just a couple observations on the Joker diff since this was brought up in #lounge.
First, tick rate 2 of course. These slider speed changes are unreadable otherwise.
All the soft hitsounds with 1/4 spam everywhere doesn't fit this very loud song at all.
03:36:096 (1,1,1,1,1) - Please don't new combo spam.
03:58:296 (1,1,1,1) - ^
02:33:996 (1,1,1,1) - This sudden slowdown doesn't really fit well with the song at this point - especially with that acceleration right afterward.
The bad sliders were already pointed out be dkun.
First, tick rate 2 of course. These slider speed changes are unreadable otherwise.
All the soft hitsounds with 1/4 spam everywhere doesn't fit this very loud song at all.
03:36:096 (1,1,1,1,1) - Please don't new combo spam.
03:58:296 (1,1,1,1) - ^
02:33:996 (1,1,1,1) - This sudden slowdown doesn't really fit well with the song at this point - especially with that acceleration right afterward.
The bad sliders were already pointed out be dkun.
Posting my opinion on something for more clarification.
00:19:896 (5) - This note is a readability trap. Looking at 00:16:296 (7) - , they are a compareable length, so it can be safe to assume that 00:19:896 (5) - is the start of a 1/4 triplet, 00:20:196 (1) - being the last note. But its not.
00:38:346 (5) - You do the concept I explained above, so you are just conflicting your use of short sliders, that is very bad for readability because it leads the player to guessing the nature of these short sliders every time they appear.
00:41:046 (7,8,9,10,11,12,13,1,2) - Then this and everything similar to it is just blatantly overmapped, not acceptable at all.
Other staff had some issues too, they will most likely post too.
00:19:896 (5) - This note is a readability trap. Looking at 00:16:296 (7) - , they are a compareable length, so it can be safe to assume that 00:19:896 (5) - is the start of a 1/4 triplet, 00:20:196 (1) - being the last note. But its not.
00:38:346 (5) - You do the concept I explained above, so you are just conflicting your use of short sliders, that is very bad for readability because it leads the player to guessing the nature of these short sliders every time they appear.
00:41:046 (7,8,9,10,11,12,13,1,2) - Then this and everything similar to it is just blatantly overmapped, not acceptable at all.
Other staff had some issues too, they will most likely post too.
LOL
3BAT MOD.
00:58:821 (5,1) - The devil jump lol
03:27:696 (1,2) - I thought this to be near timing.
03:55:896 (3,4) - I don't know this just stack hidden sliders.ask BAT.
go rerank!
3BAT MOD.
00:58:821 (5,1) - The devil jump lol
03:27:696 (1,2) - I thought this to be near timing.
03:55:896 (3,4) - I don't know this just stack hidden sliders.ask BAT.
go rerank!
00:16:896 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - for starters, they aren't all the same spacing, but they should honestly just keep the same form but be connected.
what
If you need evidence that this map is readable, I was able to sightread Skystar, Regou and Joker and then achieved an FC on all three difficulties (with HD on Regou). I understand that some users find the map less readable, for which the lower difficulties are available. However, there is an audience for this kind of map that finds it playable and the unrank is subjective rather than objective.dkun wrote:
(Other staff members should be adding their opinions as well on this map.)
I strongly disagree with the unranking of this map and I'm disappointed to see it done so quickly without any discussion in the Moderator's Lounge. If the map was literally impossible to sightread, then I would not have been able to sightread it.
Can't tell if he's actually srs lol
The same opinionSapphireGhost wrote:
However, there is an audience for this kind of map that finds it playable and the unrank is subjective rather than objective.
The same opinion384059043 wrote:
The same opinionSapphireGhost wrote:
However, there is an audience for this kind of map that finds it playable and the unrank is subjective rather than objective.
You all have bad opinions.
(lol'd at subjective opinions I kill myself XD)
(lol'd at subjective opinions I kill myself XD)
says one of the best pattern readers in the game.SapphireGhost wrote:
If you need evidence that this map is readable, I was able to sightread Skystar, Regou and Joker and then achieved an FC on all three difficulties (with HD on Regou). I understand that some users find the map less readable, for which the lower difficulties are available. However, there is an audience for this kind of map that finds it playable and the unrank is subjective rather than objective.dkun wrote:
(Other staff members should be adding their opinions as well on this map.)
I strongly disagree with the unranking of this map and I'm disappointed to see it done so quickly without any discussion in the Moderator's Lounge. If the map was literally impossible to sightread, then I would not have been able to sightread it.
I certainly hope you don't think your reading capabilities should set the standard for everyone else in this game.
all the difficulties are readable imo but im not staff member so
hehe
hehe
384059043 wrote:
The same opinionSapphireGhost wrote:
However, there is an audience for this kind of map that finds it playable and the unrank is subjective rather than objective.
Thanks.kriers wrote:
says one of the best pattern readers in the game.SapphireGhost wrote:
If you need evidence that this map is readable, I was able to sightread Skystar, Regou and Joker and then achieved an FC on all three difficulties (with HD on Regou). I understand that some users find the map less readable, for which the lower difficulties are available. However, there is an audience for this kind of map that finds it playable and the unrank is subjective rather than objective.
I strongly disagree with the unranking of this map and I'm disappointed to see it done so quickly without any discussion in the Moderator's Lounge. If the map was literally impossible to sightread, then I would not have been able to sightread it.
I certainly hope you don't think your reading capabilities should set the standard for everyone else in this game.
I think this is the most perfect statement ever.kriers wrote:
says one of the best pattern readers in the game.SapphireGhost wrote:
If you need evidence that this map is readable, I was able to sightread Skystar, Regou and Joker and then achieved an FC on all three difficulties (with HD on Regou). I understand that some users find the map less readable, for which the lower difficulties are available. However, there is an audience for this kind of map that finds it playable and the unrank is subjective rather than objective.
I strongly disagree with the unranking of this map and I'm disappointed to see it done so quickly without any discussion in the Moderator's Lounge. If the map was literally impossible to sightread, then I would not have been able to sightread it.
I certainly hope you don't think your reading capabilities should set the standard for everyone else in this game.
Good thing there are five other difficultieskriers wrote:
says one of the best pattern readers in the game.
I certainly hope you don't think your reading capabilities should set the standard for everyone else in this game.
No, they do not. However, maps cannot appeal to everybody. Some maps are difficult to play for reasons like a fast stream speed or large jumps and not all players can play these patterns. I cannot request that these maps be unranked because not everyone can play them. Part of the difficulty of this map is the fact that the patterns are difficult to read, which some people can and cannot do. This does not make the map unrankable, because the patterns are not impossible to read.kriers wrote:
I certainly hope you don't think your reading capabilities should set the standard for everyone else in this game.
I am certainly not the only player in the game that can read this map, but I realize there are not many and I realize I have the unpopular opinion amongst the BAT. I am still going to support it, because an unpopular opinion is not an incorrect one. I respectfully disagree and I hope you can return that respect.
Well, some of the players even can't play Normal diff. Should we unrank ALL mapsets?kriers wrote:
says one of the best pattern readers in the game.SapphireGhost wrote:
If you need evidence that this map is readable, I was able to sightread Skystar, Regou and Joker and then achieved an FC on all three difficulties (with HD on Regou). I understand that some users find the map less readable, for which the lower difficulties are available. However, there is an audience for this kind of map that finds it playable and the unrank is subjective rather than objective.
I strongly disagree with the unranking of this map and I'm disappointed to see it done so quickly without any discussion in the Moderator's Lounge. If the map was literally impossible to sightread, then I would not have been able to sightread it.
I certainly hope you don't think your reading capabilities should set the standard for everyone else in this game.
还是那句老话。贵圈真乱。
呵呵。
And yes pro maps designed for prosJarby wrote:
Good thing there are five other difficultieskriers wrote:
says one of the best pattern readers in the game.
I certainly hope you don't think your reading capabilities should set the standard for everyone else in this game.
To other posters: better to use English instead of Chinese. Using Chinese worth nothing and would make the argument more serious.
You kill me man. Best jokes of all time <3 you to death.384059043 wrote:
Well, some of the players even can't play Normal diff. Should we unrank ALL mapsets?
还是那句老话。贵圈真乱。
呵呵。
same to you.kriers wrote:
I certainly hope you don't think your reading capabilities should set the standard for everyone else in this game.
I believe I am serious enough. Understand or not, it's your choice.YodaSnipe wrote:
You kill me man. Best jokes of all time <3 you to death.384059043 wrote:
Well, some of the players even can't play Normal diff. Should we unrank ALL mapsets?
还是那句老话。贵圈真乱。
呵呵。
EDIT: 为什么总是给我自动加e2 @ar3
EDIT2: 不服不要玩，再见。
+1qq944364487 wrote:
人家作图就是为了玩 如果因为读图不是很好就un掉 我只能说麻痹不服别玩啊
bybf bfbyw
If you can't play Joker why not try my easy ;_;
384059043 wrote:
Well, some of the players even can't play Normal diff. Should we unrank ALL mapsets?
还是那句老话。贵圈真乱。
呵呵。
Bro let's get it on- All mapsets are now being unranked.384059043 wrote:
I believe I am serious enough. Understand or not, it's your choice.
EDIT: 为什么总是给我自动加e2 @ar3
EDIT2: 不服不要玩，再见。
This is definitely the most beautiful BAT post I have ever read.SapphireGhost wrote:
No, they do not. However, maps cannot appeal to everybody. Some maps are difficult to play for reasons like a fast stream speed or large jumps and not all players can play these patterns. I cannot request that these maps be unranked because not everyone can play them. Part of the difficulty of this map is the fact that the patterns are difficult to read, which some people can and cannot do. This does not make the map unrankable, because the patterns are not impossible to read.kriers wrote:
I certainly hope you don't think your reading capabilities should set the standard for everyone else in this game.
I am certainly not the only player in the game that can read this map, but I realize there are not many and I realize I have the unpopular opinion amongst the BAT. I am still going to support it, because an unpopular opinion is not an incorrect one. I respectfully disagree and I hope you can return that respect.
maybe Regou's Normal is more challenging to them wwFlask wrote:
If you can't play Joker why not try my easy ;_;
why are you so serious about this?YodaSnipe wrote:
384059043 wrote:
Well, some of the players even can't play Normal diff. Should we unrank ALL mapsets?
还是那句老话。贵圈真乱。
呵呵。Bro let's get it on- All mapsets are now being unranked.384059043 wrote:
I believe I am serious enough. Understand or not, it's your choice.
EDIT: 为什么总是给我自动加e2 @ar3
EDIT2: 不服不要玩，再见。