As requested by KDS, I'm coming for a Taiko mod ~
Let's go :3
Blue~ Critical issues. You must fix thisPurple~ It's better to fix thisPink~ Suggestions / thoughts only. Change only if you want toGrey~ Suggestions that have no effects on gameplay-----------------------
[General]
• Just saying that mint's Oni seem to have a longer kiai period. You might want to unify all kiai times ( Better ask him beforehand )
-----------------------
[Taiko Easy]
All fine
Suggested patternsSuggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~
00:21:111 ( x ) - Add a red note here ? ( To add a bit variety to the pattern )
01:00:690 ( 8 ) - Blue note ? ( ddd ddd could be a bit monotonic as this is a kiai section ? )
Nice map with good use of patterns :3 ~
-----------------------
[Taiko Normal]
Also all fine
Suggested patternsSuggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~
00:31:168 ( x ) - Add a blue note ? ( To add variety by using ddkkd instead of repeating ddk d ? )
Hitsounds are nice :3 ~
-----------------------
[Taiko Hard]
• 00:24:842 ( 1 ) - Maybe it's me, but I expect this note to be on 00:25:004 ( white line ) instead because of the simpler patterns before. I'd map this part like
this, but it's your choice to decide whether to change or not ~
Suggested patternsSuggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~
00:41:063 ( 1 ) - Red note ? ( imo k sounds unnatural because of the lower pitch of vocal )
-----------------------
[Taiko Oni]
Well, still all fine www
Suggested patternsSuggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~
01:24:047 ( 1, 1 ~ 8 ) - ooooooooo ? ( kdddddddd sounds a bit odd for me as the drum sound isn't that significant )
I'll say your style is already stabilized and good enough for most maps
-----------------------
[mint's Taiko]
• Try to adjust combo color in editor next time so that modders can check easier ? :3
• 00:15:110 ( 3 ~ 12 ) - This stream seems to widening the diff spread. Although the music also sounds like stream, but you should care about the players at muzu level who will probably miss this. You can notice that other parts of the diff is easier ( eg kiai ). I suggest using simpler patterns here ( eg 1/2, 3-plets, 5-plets )
• 00:43:171 ( 1~8, 1~8, 1 ) - ^, other parts of the song don't have long streams. Try to break this down into smaller sections
• 00:16:570 ~ 00:23:707 - The note arrangements seem to be quite random ( esp 00:16:570 (1) ), but maybe it's only me who think so ? You might want to remap this part ?
Suggested patternsSuggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~
00:36:196 ( x ) - Add a blue note ? ( To avoid same pattern of d k and create variation )
Overall ok except some random notes & streams. I guess you're not really experienced in taiko mapping ? Well, at least this is a good try :3
-----------------------
I'll say after fixing some issues in mint's taiko, this mapset is ready to go :3
Star and good luck ~