-Bakari- wrote:

hi-hi~

[General]
there's two ,osb filis in your folder, delete one of them, please. done
gray combo colour seems a bit confusing in multiplayer mode (you will see this colour if you fail song in multiplayer, lol) change it to something else maybe? Eh, I think this should be fine

[Normal]
00:14:229 (4) - try to put new combo here? it fits with music pretty good and helps you to make map more readable k
00:16:075 (1) - velocity changes are confusing for easiest diff in mapset. :< (a specially x0.5 SV changes because it's too slow, imo) ig you will put spinner here (00:16:075 - start / 00:17:921 - end) you will make this map much easier for beginners (note: Normal is easist diff in your mapset. that's why i want you to make it a bit easier) It's a slow down but not speed up change, it should be easier :/
00:31:998 - unused green line? (not a big problem but i think you should remove it) k
01:13:306 (1,2,3,4) - what if you will try to make rhythm a bit easier to follow? (example i guess it's ok to use this many 1/2 notes for this pattern because this is Normal diff after all) aye
01:27:613 - same as 00:31:998 done
01:29:921 (1) - finish + clap fits here better, imo.
01:28:998 (3) - try to add 1 more reverse here? it will follow music better, imo. Finish only sounds more clear
03:20:690 (5) - just thinking.. will new combo fit here? ..try to put new combo here. i guess it's a good idea >.< nah, I feel it's fine

[Hard]
OD and HP Drain are too low, i think. try to use 6 or 5 instead? k
03:21:498 (3) - this one is a bit confusing to me. i think you can make rhythm here a bit more interesting example sounds nice, changed

[Insane]
00:47:229 (6,1,2) - try to reduce spacing one by one? (1,4 -> 1.2 -> 1.0 example this looked weird for me so no

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

awesome map <3

thanks for you mod

1. 02:32:690 - 不做個什麼fountain嗎

1. 00:00:383 (1,2,1) - spacing能統一下嗎 略醜0.0
2. 00:08:690 (3,1) - NC switch? (3)出來的時候音樂有變動 lol
3. 00:12:383 (2) - 上面那個有fix的話這裡就nc
4. 00:29:921 (2) - (end) clap+finish好吵啊
5. 00:32:690 (6,1) - nc switch?
6. 00:58:536 (1,2) - clap 太安靜了
7. 02:36:383 (1) - 好醜lol
   
   SPOILER

   
8. 03:20:690 (5) - nc?

1. 00:42:844 (5,6) - e 大概是這樣吧
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:46:883 (8) - 第二個錨點往左偏了 往右一小格 (gird level4)
3. 01:13:306 (2,4,6,8) - 這四顆的spacing順序是1.3>1.4>1.6>1.9, 1.3>1.4>1.5>1.6比較好看吧>_>
4. 01:16:998 (4) - nc
5. 02:49:767 (3) - 這個放x:332, y:224是不是跟(4)看起來圓點

1. 01:12:844 - 不下clap麼
2. 01:42:383 (6) - ^

Flask wrote:

From #modreqs

Perfume♥

[General]

1. 02:32:690 - 不做個什麼fountain嗎 这里感觉不太需要

[Normal]

1. 00:00:383 (1,2,1) - spacing能統一下嗎 略醜0.0 k
2. 00:08:690 (3,1) - NC switch? (3)出來的時候音樂有變動 lol k
3. 00:12:383 (2) - 上面那個有fix的話這裡就nc
4. 00:29:921 (2) - (end) clap+finish好吵啊 去掉了clap
5. 00:32:690 (6,1) - nc switch? 没看懂什么意思
6. 00:58:536 (1,2) - clap 太安靜了 这里没clap :/
7. 02:36:383 (1) - 好醜lol 改了下
   
   SPOILER

   
8. 03:20:690 (5) - nc? nah

[Hard]

1. 00:42:844 (5,6) - e 大概是這樣吧 k
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:46:883 (8) - 第二個錨點往左偏了 往右一小格 (gird level4) k
3. 01:13:306 (2,4,6,8) - 這四顆的spacing順序是1.3>1.4>1.6>1.9, 1.3>1.4>1.5>1.6比較好看吧>_> 这个倒是差不了多少
4. 01:16:998 (4) - nc 我觉得没必要
5. 02:49:767 (3) - 這個放x:332, y:224是不是跟(4)看起來圓點 这里也没可以要去弄圆

[Insane]

1. 01:12:844 - 不下clap麼
2. 01:42:383 (6) - ^ 都加了

大概就這樣了 微風加油~

Jarby wrote:

The title is Fushizen na Girl as Melophobia said, so please change it to that. Negative offsets are generally unnecessary; changing it to 1306 would be better for the title pulse and shouldn't affect gameplay. Well, change title to English name "Unnatural Girl" then, offset I think it should be fine

Insane:

00:00:729 (2) - Very awkward for me as it doesn't match the vocals which are the only instrument playing at the time. Hmm, lyric seems like this
02:36:613 (2,3,4,5) - Rhythm is a little odd, I'd consider changing it. yeah, agree, changed

Lovely map and storyboard overall. Unfortunately, I only got through part of Normal because my display driver crashed, but I'll get to it later and post again if I find anything. Good luck!

KingsAL2 wrote:

By AL2 modding queue
==General==
Perfume Again >W< LOVE <3
中文吧~ 要改的不多 :3 你都大了 T_T 有什麼好MOD的 ~~~

==Hard==
-- Combo Problem --
00:03:152 (5) - 第二句了NC黑色嗎? @_@ 这里刚好是唱到"不自然（ぜん）なガル"的ん和な的地方, 应该不用这里nc
-- Sound --
01:31:306 (4) - 把CLAP換WHISTLE吧~ 正好是一個沒聲的位置~然後突出那個5的FINISH 换normal hitsound了
01:45:844 (7) - FINISH會好一點嗎? 还不错, 改了
02:16:536 (1-2nd) - 加一個whistle?
02:31:767 (3-2nd) - ^ -w-
02:45:613 (1,2,3) - 要把他們都換做finish嗎? 我聽那個背景都是finish的 -w- k
-- Spacing --
00:44:690 (1,2,3,4,5) - 感覺4到5的SPACING有點怪 @_@ 这里是逐渐加spacing的
-- Other(S) --

==OVERALL==
LIKE : 喵~ 都是這樣 >w<
UNLIKE : 伙為什麼沒有insane呀 T_T? 咦是你没下载到么

Steph De Chine wrote:

General
你的Kiai time怎么都只有1/4拍啊？不应该是一段时间的吗？
难道你的Kiai time只是为了闪光才加上去的？ 对, 个人习惯而已

StoryBoard的话可以参考一下这个：Perfume - Baby Cruising Love
Peppy做的，超帅SB，而且“About ten new storyboard script features were added to make this possible……”果然这个游戏的开发者就是不一般啊……
主要参考下他做的那个边缘闪光特效和全屏闪光特效，用多点颜色会好看好多的，不要老是白色了吧…… 爱情不是你想买, 想买就能买...

Normal
01:13:306 (1,2,3,4,5) - 这里的时间安排不太好，不均匀，考虑把2换成note，3移到01:14:229，在01:14:690那里加一个note 现在这样应该也不难吧
01:18:844 (3) - 这个可以把它缩短到01:19:306，再在01:19:536那里加个note或者slider 感觉这样改会复杂很多
01:20:690 (1,2) - 这两个中间的空位那里有个很重的“ま”,所以建议把1缩短半拍，2往前移半拍，然后往后再拉出一个折返来 长音用间隔note应该也没大碍吧
01:27:844 (1,2,3) - 这三个还是有些不对，考虑把1,2,3改成:

SPOILER

01:27:844 (1) - 半拍的slider
01:28:306 (2) - 半拍的slider
01:28:767 (3) - 长度只有半拍，但是有3个折返箭头的slider 我的想法是normal尽量不出现一折返以上的slider, 那样可能会对新手来说稍微难判断了点

01:53:690 (5) - 这个把折返箭头前面那一半换成note,后面那一半换成半拍slider加折返 改了点
01:55:075 (1) - 往前移半拍，然后在后面再加个一样的slider 我觉得这样节奏太复杂了点
02:06:844 (1) - 这个似乎毫无意义啊……换成note怎么样? 有何不同?
02:11:690 (3) - 有必要加这个吗？删掉？ 节奏的连贯性
02:28:767 (1,2,3) - 这种东西确实Confusing啊…… 咦会么
02:52:998 (1,2) - 1缩短半拍，然后把2提前半拍? 为什么?
03:31:767 (1,2,3) - 继续confusing :S ??

就是这样了……Hard似乎没找到啥问题

ztrot wrote:

Hello saw this in mod request and figured i would take a look.
Remember anything I point out is suggestions so it really is up to you if you want to use them.
Feel free to give me feed back in my gaps between my posts.

[Normal]
00:36:383 (1) - I don't really care for the shape of this but I can't deny it is made well, so I guess it could stay but maybe try something else? Eh, like what?

00:38:229 (2) - I think this would look much better if it was angled and arc'ed around the slider before it sorta like this fixed


This isn't a mod but I have to say I love the drum sample you used >.<b

01:10:767 (2) - center this with the slider before it?

01:11:460 (3) - ^ k

01:50:229 (1) - smooth this guy out like so

02:12:152 (1) - that was fucking cool just saying

02:47:921 (1) - this slider has one to many grid points thus it makes the arc look a bit lopsided. maybe tighten that up? k

03:28:536 (2,3,4,5,6) - this patten is far to clustered maybe spread it out a bit? I think this should be fine, they are all distance snapped

[Hard]
20 secs in and the map already looks great! i think you spent a bit more time on this one

01:29:921 (5) - can you make this not over lap as much as it is now? personaly i would do something like this

02:32:690 (6) - ^ changed

Yeah hard is way more structured than normal decent map no real problems here great job.

[Insane]

00:52:536 (1) - I don't think the new combo here for the jump is needed personally.

01:51:613 (1) - again ^

02:06:383 (1) - ^ more easy to notice and read, isn't it

02:43:536 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - no need for the new combo spam you didn't use it on similar patterns so why now? those notes are gradual increasing spacing so new combo

03:27:613 (1,2,3,1,2,1,2,1,2) - NC over used but the same type of pattern/music at 03:31:536 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - doesn't use it so i would just kill the NC spam. 03:31:536 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) they are distance snaped so no nc

[Overall]
pretty darn solid map plays nice and has some interesting patterns, fun too!
Major fan of the hit sounds as well!

Leorda wrote:

Hi Big Breeze


[General]
* I have 2 OSBs, remove the wrong one done


[Storyboarding]
02:27:152 - Dunno why the cube-big1.png are not appear here...
02:38:229 - ^


[Normal]
00:36:383 (1) - Would be better if 2nd slidertick overlapped by 4th slidertick. Like http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/440178 k


[Hard]
00:31:075 (4) - New combo for your combo pattern
01:52:998 (7) - Remove 1 repeating slider, so players are able to click the next note with perfect timed nah, here fit music
02:07:767 (7) - ^ ^


That's all I got, hope it's help!

1. 突然有个想法，能不能把sliderpoint10.png做成和tickpoint一样的小方块，这样似乎会更有趣一点～
2. 02:32:690 - 我觉得这里可以加个kiai喷泉？

1. 00:15:613 (4) - 这里的音量感觉太轻了，软绵绵的和鼓点没有搭上的样子……
2. 00:32:690 (6) - 考虑把后面的NC挪到这里？
3. 01:00:383 (3) - 感觉上可以把这里的音效换成clap，然后在01:00:844 - 也是用clap的音效，听起来更带感一点～
4. 01:04:536 - 唔…………这里好重的鼓点……跳过去会不会有一点点可惜？
5. 01:24:383 (1) - 头上加个finish?
6. 01:53:460 (3,4) - 这里的节奏有点没听明白……因为在01:53:921 - 上前面的stream音也结束了，鼓点重音在这里，而vocal重音是在01:54:152 - ……
7. 02:25:306 (1) - 头finish?
8. 02:39:613 (1) - 尾finish?
9. 02:42:613 (2) - 建议从前面的白线02:42:383 - 开始
10. 03:24:383 (3) - 感觉这里可以起个NC?

1. 00:04:767 - 感觉这里可以下个note叠在00:04:998 (1) - 头上
2. 01:09:613 (3) - 头finish并且把NC放到这里？
3. 01:16:998 (4) - NC？
4. 02:25:306 (2) - finish & NC?
5. 02:32:690 (6) - NC？
6. 02:40:075 (3) - finish & NC?
7. 03:24:383 (2) - ^

1. 01:24:383 (3) - finish?
2. 02:18:267 (2) - 突然觉得，这里前面的1/4位上可以放个note来和这里做2连，02:18:613 (3) - 也是，节奏是这样：
   
3. 02:25:306 (6) - finish & NC?

Scorpiour wrote:

Hi there~~mod for request~~
微风娘娘贵安~~

[General]

1. 突然有个想法，能不能把sliderpoint10.png做成和tickpoint一样的小方块，这样似乎会更有趣一点～ 貌似没必要吧
2. 02:32:690 - 我觉得这里可以加个kiai喷泉？ 我倒是觉得这里感觉还不够强到要加喷泉

[Normal]

1. 00:15:613 (4) - 这里的音量感觉太轻了，软绵绵的和鼓点没有搭上的样子…… 这里确实鼓声没出来, 弄大声会很奇怪
2. 00:32:690 (6) - 考虑把后面的NC挪到这里？ k
3. 01:00:383 (3) - 感觉上可以把这里的音效换成clap，然后在01:00:844 - 也是用clap的音效，听起来更带感一点～ 01:00:844加个clap不错
4. 01:04:536 - 唔…………这里好重的鼓点……跳过去会不会有一点点可惜？ 不可惜, 大丈夫哒!
5. 01:24:383 (1) - 头上加个finish?
6. 01:53:460 (3,4) - 这里的节奏有点没听明白……因为在01:53:921 - 上前面的stream音也结束了，鼓点重音在这里，而vocal重音是在01:54:152 - …… 对应上个音节的最后三个音, 而01:53:690 (4)开始是对应最后的长音, 折返点开始是下个音节
7. 02:25:306 (1) - 头finish? why?
8. 02:39:613 (1) - 尾finish? ^
9. 02:42:613 (2) - 建议从前面的白线02:42:383 - 开始 这里是故意来放红线的那个whistle音的, 间距应该不难判断出来
10. 03:24:383 (3) - 感觉这里可以起个NC? 改了点

[Hard]

1. 00:04:767 - 感觉这里可以下个note叠在00:04:998 (1) - 头上 这里是对应背景的那个长音
2. 01:09:613 (3) - 头finish并且把NC放到这里？ why?
3. 01:16:998 (4) - NC？ 前面不久才有个nc
4. 02:25:306 (2) - finish & NC? :/ 不知道为什么你觉得这里适合finish, 我是完全不觉得这里有finish的感觉
5. 02:32:690 (6) - NC？
6. 02:40:075 (3) - finish & NC?
7. 03:24:383 (2) - ^

[Insane]

1. 01:24:383 (3) - finish?
2. 02:18:267 (2) - 突然觉得，这里前面的1/4位上可以放个note来和这里做2连，02:18:613 (3) - 也是，节奏是这样： 听起来倒也不错, 不过我其他地方都是用得3/4, 这里突然这么改有点突兀
   
3. 02:25:306 (6) - finish & NC?

大概就这些了？star~~~加油&GL~~~

NoHitter wrote:

[Normal]
- 01:53:690 (4) - Why don't you follow the vocals here? Remove the repeat then add notes at 01:54:383 and 01:54:844 instead? I think this would make here a bit hard as a Normal diff. so sorry...

[Hard]
- 00:08:921 (2,3,4,5) - I find following the offbeat here not quite fitting. Maybe just make them like this OR this? Hmm, all diff.s are follow this, seems fine
- 00:31:998 (7) - [nazi] One grid right to make into a perfect triangle. You may have to adjust the notes afterward. fixed
- 01:30:613 (1,2,3,4,5) - Maybe make them symmetrical like this? Looks better IMO. k

[Insane]
- 01:30:613 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Make this into a perfect pentagon? You can use (Ctrl+Shift+D). done
- 02:15:152 (4) - I would suggest you reverse this (Ctrl+G) for better flow. You'd have to arrange your patterns afterwards though. done

I liked the storyboard a lot! Reminded me of Baby Cruising Love ppy is god like, I can't do that effect
Nice map overall. Contact me for a recheck afterwards!

1. okay.

1. 00:16:075 (1) - I don't recommend to use x0.5 in the easiest diff because some of the newbie may get a miss from speed change, also they cannot recognise the speed change, so probably change it to x0.75 or even remove the speed change?
2. 00:57:383 (7) - Probably add a whistle at the beginning of the slider and the end of the slider to fit the instruments.
3. 01:01:306 (5) - How about adding a whistle at the beginning of the slider because of high pitch?
4. 01:12:613 (4) - ^
5. 01:14:921 (4) - ^

1. 00:17:575 - , 00:17:690 - Probably add a note here and there so that it will become a triplet which can follow the drum sound, but it will form a jump between the triplet and (1)- so you can reduce the spacing if you change it. However I think the jump is acceptable in hard.
2. 01:23:921 (1) - I don't think triplet fits the music here, I would say something like simple 1/2 is enough.
3. 01:44:460 (3) - A new combo here?
4. 03:27:844 ~ 03:33:383 - I would like to place the new combo on accents like 03:28:075 - ,03:28:998 - if I was you.

1. 00:06:844 (3) - I highly recommend to remove the 3/4 here because there is nothing to support the 3/4, so could you reduce the length of 00:06:844 (3) - to 00:07:190 - ?
2. 00:07:536 (4) - ^
3. 01:08:229 (6) - Were you doing this on purpose? Please reduce the spacing here if not.
4. 01:22:075 (8) - Consider a new combo here because this chain of combo is longer than others, so a new combo there can maintain the consistency.
5. 01:25:767 (6) - ^
6. 01:30:613 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Imperfect star-shape. Could you do some adjustment on this?

kanpakyin wrote:

Hi.

[General]

1. okay.

[Normal]

1. 00:16:075 (1) - I don't recommend to use x0.5 in the easiest diff because some of the newbie may get a miss from speed change, also they cannot recognise the speed change, so probably change it to x0.75 or even remove the speed change? k, changed
2. 00:57:383 (7) - Probably add a whistle at the beginning of the slider and the end of the slider to fit the instruments. k
3. 01:01:306 (5) - How about adding a whistle at the beginning of the slider because of high pitch? k
4. 01:12:613 (4) - ^ no for this, it sounds odd for me
5. 01:14:921 (4) - ^ k

[Hard]

1. 00:17:575 - , 00:17:690 - Probably add a note here and there so that it will become a triplet which can follow the drum sound, but it will form a jump between the triplet and (1)- so you can reduce the spacing if you change it. However I think the jump is acceptable in hard. I think double 1/4 beat notes after a slider end is a little hard to beat, so keep it
2. 01:23:921 (1) - I don't think triplet fits the music here, I would say something like simple 1/2 is enough. change to 1/2
3. 01:44:460 (3) - A new combo here? It should be fine as it is now
4. 03:27:844 ~ 03:33:383 - I would like to place the new combo on accents like 03:28:075 - ,03:28:998 - if I was you. Pity you are not me

[Insane]

1. 00:06:844 (3) - I highly recommend to remove the 3/4 here because there is nothing to support the 3/4, so could you reduce the length of 00:06:844 (3) - to 00:07:190 - ? k
2. 00:07:536 (4) - ^ This one is fit the "stop" in the lyric
3. 01:08:229 (6) - Were you doing this on purpose? Please reduce the spacing here if not. yes it's on purpose, since the whole combo is 1.6xDS
4. 01:22:075 (8) - Consider a new combo here because this chain of combo is longer than others, so a new combo there can maintain the consistency.
5. 01:25:767 (6) - ^ I think they are fine, turn NC would made last combo too short imo
6. 01:30:613 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Imperfect star-shape. Could you do some adjustment on this? lol I'm too stupid to make it perfect, I tried...at least they are distance spaced /o/