LKs wrote:

[General]

fine

[Insane]

384,176,18114,1,0
332,105,18502,1,0
259,57,18891,1,0

a small adjustment on their looking

00:27:440 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - how about NC? just suggestion cause I think it could be more clear to see
00:30:549 (3) - ^
00:33:658 (3) - ^
No, new combos aren't needed in these, because it would break the comboing consistency, and because they are a whole pattern (that make butterflies).
00:36:766 (3) - move to x85y34 for better spacing what o.o 85:34 is at the top left corner D:
01:22:621 (1) - http://puu.sh/VREh this way? okay

[Loctav's Taiko Oni]

00:05:673 (1) - k instead of d? it sounds disorder when there is a d but the song has a hit-hat(?) sound
00:04:118 (1) - if you change the one above, make this a d would be better imo
00:10:728 (4) - at any rate I think this should be k and 00:11:117 (2) - this should be d
00:18:114 (1) - d?
00:20:057 (1,2,3) - add a note bewteen your 1 and 2? I heard something in the music
01:08:437 (2) - this should be k imo

[Hard]

nothing

[Taiko Muzukashii]

no need to mod diffs at this level..nothing to point out and it's not easy to be a bad map

[Normal]

about sliderslide I think soft-sliderslide.wav(you use for normal) is still nosiy in this diff. forgive my "bad" custom but to me any slliderslide like this is not really accpetable. Thus there is a sliderslide.wav with lower volume http://puu.sh/VRZh I actually left it that "noisy", because with a silent sound, the whole beginning feels weirdly blank

00:23:554 (1,2) - some parts like this sounds a bit too loud to me. try to use 90% or lower okay
00:35:989 (1,2,3) - personally don't like this angel. move to somewhere adjacent x136y240? okay
01:41:274 (4) - looks weird, why is it at the center of the screen, just stack to 01:40:497 (3) - 's end works better? nooo stacks under sliderends aaaaaaaaaaaaaa they play awful, look ugly, and are confusing most of the time D:

LKs wrote:

00:05:673 (1) - k instead of d? it sounds disorder when there is a d but the song has a hit-hat(?) sound uhm, k.
00:04:118 (1) - if you change the one above, make this a d would be better imo true.
00:10:728 (4) - at any rate I think this should be k and 00:11:117 (2) - this should be d first one okay, but the 2nd clearly should be a kat (especially because the vocal movement gets better represented)
00:18:114 (1) - d? no.
00:20:057 (1,2,3) - add a note bewteen your 1 and 2? I heard something in the music I can hear it, too!
01:08:437 (2) - this should be k imo imo, it should stay as a don, sorry.

aabc271 wrote:

Suggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~

00:08:006 ( 3 ) - Red note ? ( To fit 00:01:785 (1) where d is used. Both parts have similar music, so imo using d for both is better for consistency ) yup!

01:30:393 ( 2 ) - Add finish ? ( Start of a new section after a silenced part, so maybe use finish to differentiate that part ? ) seems good.

aabc271 wrote:

As requested by Shiro, I'm coming for a Taiko mod ~
Let's go :3

Blue~ Critical issues. You must fix this
Purple~ It's better to fix this
Pink~ Suggestions / thoughts only. Change only if you want to

-----------------------

[Taiko Muzukashii]

Also seems fine :3

Suggested patterns

Suggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~

00:33:269 ( 2 ) - Blue note ? ( It has same music as 00:30:160, in which you used k. I think using k for both is better because k fits the music better ~ ) Makes sense. Okay.

00:46:870 ( 2,1,1,1,2 ) - I somehow think dkddk doesn't really fit here. I'll prefer ooooo / ooooo ( 00:45:316 ~ 00:51:145 - I guess you're trying to make some differences with 00:39:098 ~ 00:45:121, so I kind of understand why you used dkddk here and kkd later ) kddkd sounds fine

00:50:756 ( 3 ) - Blue note ? ( 3 has a higher pitch of vocal than 4. Rather than D -> D, K -> D fits the music better imo ) I was focusing on the drums for that part, so the finishes are for the drums, not the vocals

Also nicely-mapped

Good hitsounds, the difficulty is appropriate too ~

-----------------------

Both diffs are nice overall ~

Star and good luck ~

1. 00:14:810 (T) - Unused timing section?
2. 00:20:008, 00:20:105 (T) - ^, there are many unused timing sections I can see, well, it's not a big deal though
3. 01:27:284 (1) - I feel this spinner ends at 01:28:450 would be better, ends at red tick sounds a bit strange. Even in hard diff. you are end notes at 01:28:450 right?

1. 00:53:282 (2,3) - I had to say these two slider totally stack under 00:51:727 (2,3) made them a little hard to read while playing, maybe you can just move them 1 or 2 tick left or right to make them easier to read?

Breeze wrote:

[Normal]

1. 00:14:810 (T) - Unused timing section?
2. 00:20:008, 00:20:105 (T) - ^, there are many unused timing sections I can see, well, it's not a big deal though I use the same timing sections as Insane to make sure my comboing and hitsounding is consistent through the diffs. ><
3. 01:27:284 (1) - I feel this spinner ends at 01:28:450 would be better, ends at red tick sounds a bit strange. Even in hard diff. you are end notes at 01:28:450 right? yes. I'm not sure why this one ended on the red tick. o.o

[Insane]

1. 00:53:282 (2,3) - I had to say these two slider totally stack under 00:51:727 (2,3) made them a little hard to read while playing, maybe you can just move them 1 or 2 tick left or right to make them easier to read? I'd rather not. This would kill the symmetry of the two patterns. I've never seen anyone trip on these sliders, and the new colour helps read them. =x

that's all

Andrea wrote:

More Italian music for osu!

Grats Shiro :3

Andrea wrote:

More Italian music for osu!

Grats Shiro :3

Garven wrote:

I cant mod your maps when you rank so damned fast. :p Gratz yo