Andrea wrote:

Don't let this die again :<

SPOILER

SPOILER

SPOILER

1. add tag "Feel" since this studio created the anime o3o
2. AudioLeadIn: 1500 would be enough. 2000 is too much

1. 00:00:538 (1,2) - personally, i think that those notes are too loud! (-10%-20% to follow music)
2. 00:34:500 (4) - this shape and rhythm is confusing for bginners. sounds unfitting, too. like this?
3. 00:46:953 (4,5) - erm.. i think you forgot to put new combo here at (4) or (5)! It fits with your pattern and also feels empty without this new combo.
4. 00:49:405 (6,1) - I don't think that putting spinner this way is acceptable for beginners. It appears TOO FAST and beginners aren't hve enough time to read it :/

1. 00:15:632 (3) - not sure sure if NC here will follow your pattern or will ruin it. But try to add it and see what happen. I think it fits here quite good.
2. 00:22:802 (5) - sounds quite different from previous notes from the same combo chain. try to add new combo? o3o
3. 00:25:066 (3,4,5) - (nazi) i'm not sure that this triangle is readable. AR5 and 1/2 notes are already hard for Normal diff but if you'll put them this way it is confusing. I want you to ruin this triangle because it's hard to read (for [Normal] players) :<
4. 00:27:707 (4) - :V don't you want to put new combo here? It fits with vocals
5. 00:41:292 (1) - i think that you should use circle instead of second reverse. second reverse here totally BREAKS your patterns and also quite confusing for normal players. orz
6. 00:45:632 (5,6) - new combo nazi. feel free to ignore but i think that you really should put NC here >.<

1. 01:23:556 (1) - sounds a bit wrong to me. >.</ try ddk instead? http://puu.sh/1g5aR o3o

1. Should be Hentai Taiko Oni or something like this

1. HP Drain 5? Really? Your patterns are quite hard. Let's use 6
2. 00:46:387 (6,7,8,9) - personally, I don't think that this clapstorm fits here.
3. 01:24:877 - and same for [Hentai] diff. - i still think that you can mao this beat and following big white line. They're feels empty, imo :<

1. 00:49:217 (4,7) - nazi - unstack them all like you did it with (7) or stack properly o3o
2. 00:50:160 (7) - you should point out start of kiai time with CIRCLE or at least new combo. Slider here feels a bit wrong, imo.

Frostmourne wrote:

Mickey's Hard
00:52:613 (3) - whistle หางดู เสียง(เหมือนจะ)ดีขึ้น มันว่างๆไปหน่อย แก้ใหม่ใช้สไลเดอร์ 0.5 ละ
01:15:821 (6) - finish ต้นสไลด์ no, ใช้ drum-hitnormal แทน
เนี๊ยบเหมือนเคย -_-a"

-Bakari- wrote:

[Mickey's Hard]

1. HP Drain 5? Really? Your patterns are quite hard. Let's use 6 6 is too much because it's quite hard
2. 00:46:387 (6,7,8,9) - personally, I don't think that this clapstorm fits here. fixed
3. 01:24:877 - and same for [Hentai] diff. - i still think that you can mao this beat and following big white line. They're feels empty, imo :< what's mao?

1. the image for BG is not acceptable for osu!
2. this Offset bothers my ears when i'm modding.. maybe try 526

1. 00:34:877 (5) - NC
2. 01:23:368 (1) - make perfect symmetry slider

1. Good

1. 00:21:481 (4) - overlap its body perfectly on 00:20:915 (3) - 's tail

1. 00:27:519 (4) - suddenly incresed distance, NC here would make them easier to read imo
2. 00:55:632 (10) - NC for accent and jump?
3. 01:17:330 (4) - new melody, NC plz

Star Stream wrote:

[Hard]

1. 00:21:481 (4) - overlap its body perfectly on 00:20:915 (3) - 's tail

no, but fixed to something else :3

- t e n n y a - wrote:

[Mickey's Hard]

1. 00:55:632 (9)- just suggestion, how about ctrl g this? to make a little jump no~
2. 00:58:651 (9)- ^ ^

terametis wrote:

[Mickey's Hard]
00:11:848 (1,2,3,4) - change position (2),(4).　00:10:150 (3,4,5,6) - , of flow not relevant state. k

SPOILER

00:52:037 (1) - hmm, I feel a little strange. I think if you want change the speed of the slider here, you should not use a jump here. I recommend, stack or it's close something. k
01:19:207 (6) - Add NC? You use it similar design on 00:03:358 (5,1,2,3,4) - k
01:21:282 (3) - NC here probably if you use above. k

1. Inconsistent timing offset in Nich's Easy, please fix it to 528 and don't forget to resnap all notes
2. Remove short kiai fountains in both Taiko diffs.

1. Since the offset of this diff should be fixed first, all timing point i show in mod are based on 528 but not 538.
2. 00:07:131 (3) - i'd like to start the slider from prev white tick:
   
3. 00:10:905 (1) - ^, heard much better imo~
4. 00:20:149 (5) - how about move next NC to here?

1. 00:10:528 (1) - i'd like to remove this note because the stress of music is not here but 00:10:716 (2) - , a 3/2 blank could make better sense imo.
   
2. 00:23:546 (6) - how about to move it to prev redtick and add a repeat for vocal? and also move 00:24:301 (1) - to prev red tick and change into a 1/2 slider:
   
3. 00:31:094 (2) - ^, also suggest a 1/2 repeat slider from redtick
4. 00:36:377 (2) - ^

1. 00:19:018 - d here?
2. 00:31:094 - ^

1. i suppose the naming this confusing... Taiko Oni H or Taiko Oni Collab may be better?

1. 00:12:414 (4) - place it at 120:176 for both flow and music?

1. 00:31:660 (1,2,3,4) - make the square here better? it's not neat now
2. 00:52:603 (1,2) - i'd like to choose a 1/2 slider first and then note with finish for vocal
   

Scorpiour wrote:

Hi there~~ mod from #modreqs

red - must be fixed
blue - highly recommend to consider
black - only suggestions

[General]

1. Remove short kiai fountains in both Taiko diffs. OK, fixed !

[Boss Taiko Muzukashii]

1. 00:19:018 - d here? ok
2. 00:31:094 - ^ ok

[Taiko H]

1. i suppose the naming this confusing... Taiko Oni H or Taiko Oni Collab may be better? -> Taiko (H)entai

[Hentai]

1. 00:31:660 (1,2,3,4) - make the square here better? it's not neat now fixed !
2. 00:52:603 (1,2) - i'd like to choose a 1/2 slider first and then note with finish for vocal nope, weird when play for me. x_x
   

that's all~~nice map~~try to find at least one more taiko mod and then call me back to recheck :>

Scorpiour wrote:

[Nich's Easy]

1. Since the offset of this diff should be fixed first, all timing point i show in mod are based on 528 but not 538. Fixed and resnapped.
2. 00:07:131 (3) - i'd like to start the slider from prev white tick: Nope, rhythm is strange for me.
   
3. 00:10:905 (1) - ^, heard much better imo~ ^
4. 00:20:149 (5) - how about move next NC to here? Okay, fixed

1. 00:10:905 (1) - how about putting finish here?
2. 00:12:792 (1,1) - remove this note? Though it is an interesting pattern, in my opinion they are excessive since the sound back which follows it is just the guitar.
3. 00:40:527 (1,1,2) - kkd sounds better for me with the drum back sound.
4. 00:51:094 (1,1,2,3) - k ddd is better for both sound and difficulty for me.

1. 00:37:697 (201) - remove finish to emphasize the next note?
2. 00:40:528 (216,217,218,219) - kkddk? .w.
3. 00:50:905 (36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43,44) - I like it but I prefer ddkkddddk because of the drum sound on 00:51:282 (40,41,42,43) -