Tada Aoi - Harvest [Taiko|Osu]

posted
Total Posts
99
show more
GiNa

Scorpiour wrote:

[Lucia]
  1. 00:33:321 (2,3) - it may be too hard if it's a normal diff....i'd like to remove (2) I would like to keep this since there are 2 circles only
  2. 00:56:206 (2,3) - a reverse slider here may be better? Fixed
  3. 01:17:166 (2,3,4,1,2,3) - also difficulty issues...consider more sliders? Changed 2, 3, 4 to a slider
  4. 01:31:013 (2,3,4,1,2,3) - ^.... continuing notes is always one of the hardest part to new players imo. ^
Thank you
http://puu.sh/G4yQ
Topic Starter
S o r d a
thanks for mod!
upload diffs~
@Melo
ok removed!
alacat

Scorpiour wrote:

[Kotori]
  1. 00:16:974 (2,1) - (nazi) blanket it well? fixed
  2. 00:24:667 (1,2,1,2) - to be honest...the claps here are not very fine for me...maybe....the clap sample is not very suit for the music? not very sure but i suppose it's not as clean as it should be... fixed, change to whistle
  3. 00:45:629 (3) - heard off a bit...i may choose the beat here like that:
    no change
  4. 00:47:936 (2) - ^^
  5. 00:57:359 (2,1,2,3) - also heard off....i know it's because of vocal...but you may consider more about red lines?don't follow vocal
Thanks modding~ :oops:

http://puu.sh/G5PN
aabc271

Lizbeth wrote:

[aabc's Taiko]
I don't see the point for those slow downs. I suggest to remove it.
Those slowdowns are there because the song is softer. A softer part should fit well with a less-dense + slower part :3
aside from it, sounds good Thx :)

wmfchris wrote:

Taiko mod as requested

[Taiko]
For a short song, HP 5 is good enough. The rest is fine.
I prefer using HP 4 because this is an easier taiko diff ( ~7*). Some less-experienced players may have difficulty in passing easy taiko diffs if the HP is set to 5, which is also a setting used in some 10* or above diffs. imo HP 4 suits well for easier diffs :3
No change for the above two ~
Anyway, thx for your modding :3
Topic Starter
S o r d a
@alacat
01:27:744 (2) - spinner bug It disappeared newcombo fixed add newcombo by myself please update~

also thanks for checking aabc!
alacat
sry, thanks ><
kosiga
Sordaさん こんにちは~ :)

thank you for the request~ :D

here my mod~

[General]
  1. fine


[Kotori]
  1. 00:21:589 (1,2) - 00:21:589 (1) - これをピアノに合わているので、次もテンポ良く1/1で押せる方がリズム取りやすいかなぁと感じました。 http://puu.sh/Gyk7
  2. 00:36:589(x) - ここにものすごく置いて欲しい@x@ もしくは00:36:205 (3) - を移動してclapを置く。
  3. 00:56:206 (1,2,1) - 少し取りづらいリズムだと思います。>< シンプルリズム: http://puu.sh/Gyx2. vocalフォロー: http://puu.sh/GyD0
  4. 01:06:205 (1) - 前の2つfinish付いてたので折り返しが少し寂しい気がします。 折り返しにwhistle. 01:07:743 (2,1) - ついでにこの2つのstartにもwhistle入れたら私としては良い感じに :D
  5. 01:18:513 (1) - 01:19:474に01:19:859 (2) - のstartと同じような音あるので、endを伸ばした方が良いと思います。
  6. 01:21:590 (1) - ^同様です。01:22:359の音を取るよりもリズム的に良いかなと思ったので。 and hitsound提案: 01:21:590 (1) - endのclap削除。 01:22:936 (2) - startにfinish
  7. 01:24:282 (1) - vocal合わせなので少し音量下げて30%くらいでも合うかなと思います。 あとkiaiendがスピナーの間にあるので、スピナーstartもしくはendに置いた方が良いかな思います。


[Lucia]
  1. 00:18:513 (1,2,3,4) - 00:15:436 (1,2,3,4) - I think that the same rhythm is better here. since rhythm changes suddenly, I feel some sense of incongruity :o
  2. 00:38:513 (4) - add whistle to start of the slider ?
  3. 00:55:052 (1) - remove NC and 00:56:205 (2) - add NC. I thought look is not good... :(
  4. 01:00:821 (1) - add whistle to start of the slider ?
  5. 01:02:744 (1,2,3,4) - nazi. 01:02:936 (2) - one grid left or 01:03:706 (4) - one grid left. ( better to use same spacing )
  6. 01:05:821 (3) - add NC and 01:06:782 (1) - remove NC and 01:08:512 (2) - add NC. same reasons as 00:55:052 (1)
  7. 01:24:475 (1) - It is recommended that you put to downbeat the start of the spinner. (start move to 01:24:666) because 01:21:590 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - Here does not follow the vocal. This spinner if you want to follow the vocal, 01:24:282 (3) - remove note. and spinner start 01:24:282 is better imo.


[Chihaya]
  1. 00:18:513 (1) - 潰れてて流れが少し悪いように思います。 私の提案: http://puu.sh/GzM8
    156,332,18512,6,0,B|129:377|64:371|37:328,1,140,4|8
    156,196,19089,2,0,B|183:151|248:157|275:200,1,140,0|0
    320,252,19666,1,8
    384,280,19859,2,0,B|468:260|464:180,1,140
    320,252,20436,2,0,B|292:280|308:324,1,70,8|4
    380,208,20820,2,0,B|408:180|392:136,1,70
    388,72,21205,1,12
    256,28,21589,5,4
  2. 00:29:331 (1) - 1/8で置く必要あるのかな?なんて思っちゃいます。
  3. 00:53:321 (3,1) - 3をリピートスライダーにして、アンチジャンプ作るようにしてみては。 (1のジャンプが少しやり難いと思ったので。 :o )
  4. 01:24:715 (1) - 00:29:331 (1)に同じ


[Kagari]
  1. 00:28:320 (3) - Ctrl+Rした方が私は好きです。 :D 次のnoteとの流れも良いかなと思ったので。


[Shizuru]
  1. 00:45:820 (6) - x192,y32 くらいに移動してみては?
  2. 01:03:705 (3) - startにfinish ?
  3. 01:13:128 (1) - サビ中にここだけNC短いのでなんか気になりました :o
  4. 01:27:743 (4) - ジャンプここからなので、ここでadd NC and 01:27:935 (1) - remove NCの方が良いのでは。


good map~ Star☆~

頑張ってください~ :)
GiNa

kosiga wrote:

[Lucia]
  1. 00:18:513 (1,2,3,4) - 00:15:436 (1,2,3,4) - I think that the same rhythm is better here. since rhythm changes suddenly, I feel some sense of incongruity :o  Fixed
  2. 00:38:513 (4) - add whistle to start of the slider ? Fixed
  3. 00:55:052 (1) - remove NC and 00:56:205 (2) - add NC. I thought look is not good... :(  Well ... that's how it should be imo. Perhaps, I don't really use single combo in my diff/map, so no change
  4. 01:00:821 (1) - add whistle to start of the slider ? Fixed
  5. 01:02:744 (1,2,3,4) - nazi. 01:02:936 (2) - one grid left or 01:03:706 (4) - one grid left. ( better to use same spacing ) Fixed
  6. 01:05:821 (3) - add NC and 01:06:782 (1) - remove NC and 01:08:512 (2) - add NC. same reasons as 00:55:052 (1) same as 00:55:052
  7. 01:24:475 (1) - It is recommended that you put to downbeat the start of the spinner. (start move to 01:24:666) because 01:21:590 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - Here does not follow the vocal. This spinner if you want to follow the vocal, 01:24:282 (3) - remove note. and spinner start 01:24:282 is better imo. Fixed
Thank you
alacat

kosiga wrote:

[Kotori]
  1. 00:21:589 (1,2) - 00:21:589 (1) - これをピアノに合わているので、次もテンポ良く1/1で押せる方がリズム取りやすいかなぁと感じました。 http://puu.sh/Gyk7
  2. 00:36:589(x) - ここにものすごく置いて欲しい@x@ もしくは00:36:205 (3) - を移動してclapを置く。移動して、clapを追加しました
  3. 00:56:206 (1,2,1) - 少し取りづらいリズムだと思います。>< シンプルリズム: http://puu.sh/Gyx2. vocalフォロー: http://puu.sh/GyD0vocalフォローの方に変更しました
  4. 01:06:205 (1) - 前の2つfinish付いてたので折り返しが少し寂しい気がします。 折り返しにwhistle. 01:07:743 (2,1) - ついでにこの2つのstartにもwhistle入れたら私としては良い感じに :D
  5. 01:18:513 (1) - 01:19:474に01:19:859 (2) - のstartと同じような音あるので、endを伸ばした方が良いと思います。
  6. 01:21:590 (1) - ^同様です。01:22:359の音を取るよりもリズム的に良いかなと思ったので。 and hitsound提案: 01:21:590 (1) - endのclap削除。 01:22:936 (2) - startにfinish
  7. 01:24:282 (1) - vocal合わせなので少し音量下げて30%くらいでも合うかなと思います。 あとkiaiendがスピナーの間にあるので、スピナーstartもしくはendに置いた方が良いかな思います。
all fixed

mod ありがとうございました :oops:

http://puu.sh/GM5U
aabc271
Seems that there's a problem in the taiko bg ( Bottom part is stacked & repeated )
Please replace the current taiko bg with this
Thx :3
Topic Starter
S o r d a
k,changed taiko BG :3
Cuvelia
good map :3

Star ~
Topic Starter
S o r d a
thank you!
Miya
Hello Sorda :3

General
  1. Hmm, i think you can cut the 7 second blank spot in the start of music.


Kotori
  1. 00:40:820 (2,3) - I think this beat doesnt follow the music properly. In the music, there is no beat that start in here 00:40:820- and here 00:42:359 (3) - . Because you add a note in that time, it doesnt follow the music properly and sounds off from the music. It is best to just focus to one beat at time, like piano or something. Here, this is just a general idea how to insert a beat in this time : http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/515233 . You can extend (00:40:052 (1) -) length until reach 00:40:628- and then add a 1/1 slider at this time 00:41:012- so it will end at the cymbal sounds from the music. Since i'm focus at the cymbal sounds here, it's best to add another note to cover the cymbal sounds here 00:42:166-.
  2. 00:34:665 (2,3) - Same case as above.
  3. 00:52:166 (1) - I think you should start the spinner at 00:52:359- since you can hear a heavy beat from the song there.
  4. 00:58:128 (3,1,2,3,4) - Ugh, you just spamming 1/1 note at this time. But the music is not playing at 1/1 rythim. So it's sounds very off in my perspective. It's same case as 00:40:820 (2,3) -. So you can fix this by yourself. Well, just pm if you need a general idea how to fix this.
  5. 01:07:743 (2) - Same, i think this silder is off from the music too. Well, its simple to fix this. Just delete this slider and add a circle in this time 01:07:936-.
  6. 01:10:052 (3,4) - Same case, i think this one is not follow the music very well too. Well, just reduce this slider length 01:10:052 (3) - by 1/2 and then move 01:11:205 (4) - 1/2 backward too.
  7. 01:21:589 (1) - I think its better to change the whistle at the slider start to finish sounds. Follow the cymbal sounds from the song properly.


Lucia
  1. 00:23:128 (3) - This slider doesnt follow the music properly again >.<. Well, just move this slider 1/2 forward, and that will fix the problem.
  2. 00:41:398 (3) - I believe the vocal end at 00:42:359- so you should end this slider 1/2 backward. There is a heavy beat on that time too. So it will be really good to hear.
  3. 00:44:282 (2,3,4) - How about make you variate this rythim to be like this > http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/515245 . It follow the music properly and really good to hear than just plain 1/1 spam >.<
  4. 00:50:821 (1) - This circle sounds off, since the cymbal sounds are on this spot 00:50:628-. Well, just move this circle 1/2 backward.
  5. 01:09:090 (1) - Can you make this slider shape more interesting to see? i think it's really awkward slider shape.
  6. 01:24:282 (1) - I think you should move this spinner to 1/1 forward, since the heavy beat from the song (and the long vocal too) start there. But make it ends at the same spot. If you want to cover vocal 'ho', you can add an addiational note here 01:24:282-


Chihaya
  1. Looks good, but the big jump is a bit harsh for a hard diff. Besides that, it's looks really good.


Kagari
  1. It's good too. *_*


Shizuru
  1. 00:41:397 (2,4) - umm, there is no finish sounds at the start at both of this slider. It's inconsistent. Are you forget to add finish here? o.o
  2. 00:58:801 (10) - I don't think triplet fit here. There's no sounds from the music that support triplet. Better to remove this note.
  3. 01:07:743 (5) - Umm, overmapped part here ><. Note at this time 01:07:743- sounds really off, since there is not note in the music that support this part. Well, better to remove this slider and add a circle here 01:07:936-
  4. 01:11:109 (7) - Same, triplet doesnt suit here. Remove this circle is the best imo.


That's it. There's a lot of off note in normal and easy diff. Both hard looks great, Insane look good too. Well, the most anoying thing is 7 second blank spot at the start of the music. You should remove it >.<
hoLysoup
bubble time~
02:50 S o r d a: nene soup mp3 cut dekiru?
02:53 hoLysoup: un
02:53 hoLysoup: tabun ne
02:53 hoLysoup: :>
02:53 S o r d a: oo maji?
02:53 hoLysoup: yattemiru
02:53 *S o r d a is listening to [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/164157 Tada Aoi - Harvest]
02:53 S o r d a: kore!
02:54 S o r d a: miya said i think you can cut the 7 second blank spot in the start of music.
02:54 hoLysoup: oh
02:54 hoLysoup: naruhodo
02:54 hoLysoup: matte
02:57 hoLysoup: http://puu.sh/1xlBb
02:57 hoLysoup: dekita!
02:57 S o r d a: so fast!
02:58 hoLysoup: <--- magicaL
02:58 hoLysoup: !!
02:58 hoLysoup: ^^
02:58 S o r d a: wwww
02:58 S o r d a: kore offset need change?
03:05 hoLysoup: un
03:05 hoLysoup: ok
03:05 hoLysoup: try:
03:06 hoLysoup: bpm, 147 offset, 7876
03:06 hoLysoup: and
03:06 hoLysoup: bpm, 156 offset, 9415
03:07 hoLysoup: soshite hokano green line
03:07 hoLysoup: resnap
03:11 hoLysoup: oh and set atarashii preview point
03:11 hoLysoup: :D!
03:11 S o r d a: ehh why i cant wrong many notes T_T
03:12 hoLysoup: http://puu.sh/1xlLi
03:12 hoLysoup: konna kanji?
03:12 S o r d a: waaaa arigatoo can other diffs ?
03:13 hoLysoup: matte
03:13 hoLysoup: did it work??
03:13 S o r d a: un
03:13 hoLysoup: :D!
03:16 hoLysoup: http://puu.sh/1xlNF
03:16 hoLysoup: kagari diff
03:17 S o r d a: work~
03:18 hoLysoup: http://puu.sh/1xlOR
03:18 hoLysoup: chihaya diff
03:20 hoLysoup: http://puu.sh/1xlPJ
03:20 hoLysoup: lucia~
03:21 S o r d a: mmm chihaya diff need some resnap green line?
03:21 hoLysoup: every diff green line needs resnap...
03:21 hoLysoup: www
03:21 hoLysoup: a lot of work
03:22 hoLysoup: http://puu.sh/1xlQU
03:22 hoLysoup: kotori diff
03:22 S o r d a: okkk
03:22 hoLysoup: I just resnapped beats + red line
03:22 hoLysoup: I didn't resnap green lines
03:22 S o r d a: I see!
03:24 hoLysoup: and taiko diff
03:24 hoLysoup: http://puu.sh/1xlRO
03:24 hoLysoup: :>!
03:24 S o r d a: ty ty! how much offset - for all diff ..?
03:25 hoLysoup: for green lines?
03:25 S o r d a: un
03:25 hoLysoup: matte ne
03:25 hoLysoup: ww
03:30 hoLysoup: ok
03:30 hoLysoup: all the green lines:
03:31 hoLysoup: -6021 offset
03:35 S o r d a: waaa change to all!
03:35 S o r d a: really thank you soup >_< i want give you kds
03:35 hoLysoup: like this for shizuru diff
03:35 hoLysoup: http://puu.sh/1xlXr
03:35 hoLysoup: :D
03:36 S o r d a: where change?
03:42 hoLysoup: yay! it worked
03:42 S o r d a: un un
03:43 S o r d a: soup can post?
03:44 hoLysoup: btw set new preview point??
03:44 S o r d a: a i forgot!

^^~!
fight!

btw my花嫁: http://puu.sh/1xm4m
Topic Starter
S o r d a
really thank you soup!
your 花嫁its cute btw!
>>Miya
All fixed
and changed mp3 and offset thank you!
alacat
>Miya

Thanks modding :3

all fixed ~ :)

http://puu.sh/1xpQp

@sordaさん
offset等の変更前に修正してしまったので、お手数ですが、調整お願いします>_<
aabc271
As requested, I've fixed the taiko diff :3
Good luck on rank :)
aabc's Taiko
GiNa
Fixed everything, thank you !
I was having a hard time to find the real notes due to the timing changed, but all fine now xD
I also changed some little things.

http://puu.sh/1xE8J
Miya
Recheck time~

General
  1. Good, you have fixed the 7 second blank spot :3. But, i found inconsistencies at red timing point at Kotori diff right now @@. Please take a look at the first red timing in kotori diff. It's different from others. And yes, with the new offset, i think the new offset start too early. So it's best to add +10ms to all timing point and resnap all note in all diff.


Kotori
  1. 00:30:977 (1,2) - About the whistle pattern, according to your previous pattern, the whistle sounds should be on slider 1 repeat and circle no. 2. It's best to keep hitsounds consistent.


Lucia
  1. 00:09:439 (1) - How about a finish at this slider start? Finish will be suitable here since this is the opening part of the song.
  2. 00:23:285 (1) - Err, i don't remember this slider being here last time. It's sounds very off at the end. Better to reduce this slider length by 1/2 so it would be 1/1 slider.
  3. 00:35:400 (3) - I still think this slider ends at the wrong time. The heavy beat is at this time 00:36:169-, why you dont end this slider at that time instead? It's more good to hear and doesn't sound off too >.< . If you do this, it will be good if you add additional soft-finish sounds at the slider end.
  4. 00:44:823 (1) - Move this circle 1/2 backward. Same reason as above, sounds off and doesnt suit that time is not a good place to put a circle. If you do this, you have to remove the new combo at this one and put the new combo at the next circle.
  5. 00:50:208 (5) - I suggest you put a new combo here. The distance from previous note is too far.
  6. 01:02:515 (2) - Same case as above. You should put a new combo here since the distance from previous note is too far. But be reminded that it will cause 00:59:823 (3,1) - combo pattern become not consistant. To fix this, just remove the new combo from 01:00:785 (1) - and put a new combo at 00:59:823 (3) -
  7. 01:03:092 (1) - Why you no fix this slider to better shape? ._. It's really awkward to see.
  8. 01:13:669- To make the note more consistant, i suggest to add a circle at this time. And yes, a clap here will be good too.
  9. 01:18:669 (1) - You forget to keep this spinner to end at the same spot. So please reduce this spinner length by 1/2.


Cihaya
  1. Wow, so many unsnapped object at this diff. >.< That's why i feel weird when playing this diff now.


Kagari
  1. 00:33:295 (2) - I think you should add a new combo here, since the distant from the previous note is too long.
  2. 00:48:102 (2) - I think you need a clap sound at this slider start to cover up the drum sounds from the music.


Shizuru
  1. 00:27:910 (1) - Hmm, how about you make this slider curve like the next slider? More good to see imo than just a lone long straight slider ><
  2. 00:42:141 (5) - Can you turn down the volume of finish here by 10-20%? A bit too loud imo.
  3. 00:59:833 (1) - I think you need a finish sounds at this slider end. A cymbal sounds can be hear clearly at this spot.


That's it.
Well, easy is quite good now, but normal still need a bit work >.<
And yeah. that unsnapped thingy at hard diff @@.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply