Sieg wrote:

popner wrote:

[Timing]
BPM: 180
offset: 607

Thanks for a timing check, I'll left timing as it is for now. But maybe change this in future after some more checks and kd you.

popner wrote:

Why not change it, your current timing is clearly unrankable since the red line at 00:33:925 is a meaningless half BPM.

popner wrote:

Why not change it, your current timing is clearly unrankable since the red line at 00:33:925 is a meaningless half BPM.

NatsumeRin wrote:

[General]
The second red line is not needed... (00:33:925 - ) just make it/the following sections 0.5x

Ok I wrote about this http://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/1619122, and I still don't feel this is needed to be changed.

[Normal]
00:35:091 (1) - feel your placement for this part is a bit too...clustered? would a general spacing like this be better..? http://puu.sh/DXzI
That's a good point, I dont feel that is so wrong or horrible, but I think about this.
00:55:258 (1,2,1) - not a good choice for Normal imo. keep the spacing consistent? (problem is you set the 90BPM in the previous part and 180 here again, so the spacing changes with distance snap)
not much to say.
Yep that bpm jump is so painful.

[Hard]
00:29:091 - add a note? No need imo.
00:31:591 (2) - ctrl+J? 00:29:258 (1) is going up but i think this one is more like "going down" Yep, mb. +
01:15:674 (1) - a bit too tight after a spinner.. maybe end it at 01:17:257 - and start you pattern from 01:17:924 - ? That's sliders not a big deal for hard.

[Insane]
00:29:591 (5,11,15,17,19,20,21) - add whistle? Yep, great!
00:31:591 (1,2,3,5,7,11,17) - ^if you accepte this, add whistle here too. ^
00:55:925 (1,2,3,4) - maybe a small jump here? So painful part.... yeah i guess i need some sort of jump here
01:15:174 (8) - nazi but 1 grid down. still a difference here.

Such a nice mapset with +0, wow. Call me back when you make it +12. Thanks!
Some stars.

NatsumeRin wrote:

About the red line... it's probably something you have to change. Red line is not used to change slider speed (green lines are). In this song, the BPM doesn't really change at that point, only the thythms become "slow", so if you want a slowdown section there, you have to use green line not red line... It's one of those rules orz.

http://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Ranking_Criteria#Timing

Spectator wrote:

[ General ]

add same kiai time on Taiko Difficulties too...?
there is no need in this

[ Insane ]

a lot of unsnapped notes... you can find it on AiMod
that a strange bug there was no unsnapped notes on last submit

SPOILER

00:35:258 (3) - add finish, remove whistle

00:36:591 (2) - ^

00:37:925 (2) - ^

00:39:258 (3) - ^

00:40:591 (2) - ^

00:41:925 (3) - ^

00:43:258 (3) - ^

00:45:925 (2) - ^

00:47:258 (2) - ^

00:48:592 (2) - ^

00:49:925 (3) - ^

00:51:258 (2) - ^

00:52:592 (3) - ^

00:53:925 (3) - ^

I don't feel these finishes suits better than my whistles.

01:07:590 (1) - remove NC why? NC follows pattern, music, placing etc here

01:23:423 (1,2) - remove these and put longer spinner? like http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/371948 why? they suits fine

Frizz925 wrote:

Hi there, from modding queue.

[Normal]
00:42:925 (1,2,3) - Spacing? That's a interesting spot, repeating slides or notes with spacing will be more difficult to play because of overlap imo
00:53:591 (1,2,3) - ^
01:10:924 (5) - Feels kinda empty, make it like this instead? http://puu.sh/IK4a Yep, I'll think about this.

[Hard]
00:18:591 (1,2,1) - These sliders have their points outside the grid, idk if it's okay it's ok
00:29:258 (1,2) - idk if this is unrankable or not but these sliders confuse me at the first time ok, as planned
Other than that all good

[Insane]
00:11:925 (4) - Remove clap on slider end and put it on 00:12:258 (5) slider end instead, sounds better for me. If there's another similar hitsound pattern to this, I suggest you to do the same.
00:17:591 (8) - Whistle on slider start, sounds better for me
00:23:758 (2) - Whistle on slider end?
00:26:841 (4) - Whistle on slider start?
00:27:091 (5) - ^
no changes in hs here
00:55:925 - You may want to change the SV of this inherited point to x1.00 because from this point it'll cause sudden speedup in Taiko.
Alright that's all, good luck.

• Offset +8 or so
  I think there are so good maps, but I feel that the different of difficulty between Normal and Hard is too large.
  how about make normal a little more harder(for example, increase the SV) and add Easy?
  then more players will be able to enjoy this map.

• nothing to say

• AR -1
  00:33:925 ~ almost same as Insane. I want something change.
  01:07:090 (6) - the time of reversing is different from other reverse slider, so it may be confusing.
  01:15:674 (1,1) - it seems too short from the end of the spinner to the start of the slider.
  I want more interval, but if you don't put note at 01:17:925, it feels strange too. so how about move 01:18:090 (1) to more center?
  01:23:924 (1) - something strange. how about remove 01:23:425 (5) and start spinner at 01:23:425 ?

• 00:29:258 (1) ~ it is hard because I can't hear the hitsounds well.
  how about turn up the volume about 10%? or reject the 50% line.
  00:56:591 (1) - very nazi. I want this circle to be the left side of 00:56:425 (4).
  if you accept this, do Ctrl+H to all notes from here to the nest spinner. but meh, if you don't, it is no problem.

h-728 wrote:

Thank you for request

[General]

• Offset +8 or so
  I think there are so good maps, but I feel that the different of difficulty between Normal and Hard is too large.
  how about make normal a little more harder(for example, increase the SV) and add Easy?
  then more players will be able to enjoy this map.

That's a good point but i fell i'm not so pro in mapping to make a fine 180bpm easy, that's sad.

[Normal]

• nothing to say

[Hard]

• AR -1 make sense for hard, but 4~5 notes on screen in same time scares me
  00:33:925 ~ almost same as Insane. I want something change. Yep, I'll think about this, but part is hard to make variations.
  01:07:090 (6) - the time of reversing is different from other reverse slider, so it may be confusing. Following music so not a big deal i think.
  01:15:674 (1,1) - it seems too short from the end of the spinner to the start of the slider. ok for hard, spinner is long enough
  I want more interval, but if you don't put note at 01:17:925, it feels strange too. so how about move 01:18:090 (1) to more center?
  01:23:924 (1) - something strange. how about remove 01:23:425 (5) and start spinner at 01:23:425 ? +

[Insane]

• 00:29:258 (1) ~ it is hard because I can't hear the hitsounds well.
  how about turn up the volume about 10%? or reject the 50% line. seems fine to me, but i'll take a remark to this spot
  00:56:591 (1) - very nazi. I want this circle to be the left side of 00:56:425 (4).
  if you accept this, do Ctrl+H to all notes from here to the nest spinner. but meh, if you don't, it is no problem.

that's all.
cool maps so star
good luck

Sandpig wrote:

Insane

00:18:591 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - imo long stream should be ended on white tick so that it plays better. without help of new combo it's hard to count how many they are in playing for most players... I don't see this a big issue for insane players and that not really true since very next combo starts at the white tick.
00:19:925 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - ^
00:30:925 ~ 00:31:591 - this part is too empty, some notes will make it better.
00:33:258 ~ 00:33:925 - ^ empty as well. 0.5 sec of empty space, but again I following music here not creating any new rhythm.
01:13:257 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - same as the first


Hard

well, the major issue here is that you "copy" insane into hard, reduce SV, change triplet into slider, remove streams and use long sliders instead to make it easier to be a Hard. But the rhythm stay the same, except those streams. In fact those long sliders like 00:18:591 (1,2,1) have really a bad effect on your rhythm, because quite lots of notes are skipped, and in this case there is no rhythm at all.

in my point of view, Hard should not be another "version" of Insane, and as well, this principle can be applied to Normal and Easy. My suggestion here is just remap this diff, rethink the rhythm and make it a unique diff of this mapset like what you did for Normal. Some rhythm should be same as that in Insane to keep an overall style, but some part in Insane cannot be copied into Hard, such as those streams.

That an interesting idea... I'll think about sliders part. As for your point of view about difficulties and rhythm - I just want to keep this aswesome rythm of rungran for players who cant play insane. That for what map stands and I don't intend to change this ever.

Normal

00:41:925 (4,1) - the distance looks the same as 00:40:592 (2,3), but it's not a big problem.
00:52:591 (4,1) - ^ same stuff


I noticed that other modders also pointed out the issue of diff spread, plz keep this in mind. Diff spread issue - yes there is no easy diff, but look at normal it's easy enough to be 1st map diff, there is no huge gap between normal and hard because hard diff idea is a lot of sliders that don't require a super accuracy and there is "ok" gap between hard and insane because people who want challenge got it.

OnosakiHito wrote:

@Sieg: I hope you didn't used wmfchris mod by your own? Because I need to do so.

juncer wrote:

i just want to find one map about DMC rannked,even i haven't passed insane TOT
please rank it !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

NatsumeRin wrote:

[Normal]
00:56:591 - you have an extra green line here and it made the kiai time goes wrong.

[Ono's Taiko Muzukashii]
01:22:423 (1) - Unsnapped
01:22:923 (1) - Unsnapped

no kud.

spboxer3 wrote:

ok~ just point out the issue:
the ArtistUnicode and TitleUnicode should be consistent.

no kd~ just point out this problem w

NatsumeRin wrote:

Good luck.