Rad- wrote:
- Qualified section at the moment is mostly just a placeholder for maps during a week for QATs or other people to find unrankable issues, or other really strong issues with the map, but most go by as any map can be ranked regardless of ''quality'';
- Maps can be ''speedranked'' if knowing the right people and have help prior to submitting the map, while alot of unknown mappers are left behind.
- The only way for players to vote maps they like are with hype to help nominate a map (even though mappers can easily obtain 5 hype just from modders alone), or voting for loved section maps.
1. This is very false, there could be more than just "serious issue", changing just one circle even it is not too harmful can cause disqualification as it is needed to be fixed.
2. I can say Nao makes a very good reply on this about "unknown mappers" I can say myself I'm not really known and I don't think there is much any difficulties to find them, even when I first time ranking a set, I called a lot of BNs (like 5 or 6 if I remember correctly) and most of them came to check my set, even it is just a mod, not a nomination.
3. Pretty sure a big part of players don't really care much about hyping even tho they really like the set, this was discussed in the #osu-web-modding if i remember correctly
Rad- wrote:
3. At least 10-15 people need to give at least 3 different suggestions to your map;
4. Each difficulty needs at least 3 different modders with 1 suggestion each;
5. A mapper would now have to wait 2 weeks after submitting the map (maybe 3 weeks is more appropriate).
These are very unnecessary, as some mappers (new or known) can map pretty much very well made map and might just need 1-2 or even no mods, there's no need to put much unnecessary mods like "fix blanket" or the like just to fulfill this requirement. (also im very sure most mapset dont need 30 ~ 45 suggestion just to rank it, even with the current system they are already good)
Rad- wrote:
After all 3 requirements are verified, the mapper will be able to unlock the ''Push to Qualify'' button on their mapset thread if they see their mapset fit ready for qualifying, as this could be an autonomous method for checking if maps do have the requirements already before giving the mapper the choice to push forward to the next step.
this could cause some overhyped
bad maps being pushed anyway, as there are a lot of players like it aside the fact that its bad in front of mapper and modders eye, and therefore it would most likely get pass through 80-85% threshold.
Rad- wrote:
*About the Aimod, sending a mapset with issues from Aimod, gives a trigger to the submitted mapset thread saying that it could not get ranked and thus not being allowed to push to qualify yet.
does this counts as they're not in 5min+ set and AIMod still triggers a warn to it lol, and sometimes it bugged on NHI sets
Rad- wrote:
''Would you like this mapset to be ranked?'' voting below after submitting a play on it (or 1 in 2 different difficulties if it has more than 1 difficulty, this can be another solution to troll voters).
well, guess I can spam NFDT and post "No" to the map I dislike! regardless on how can I play it or not~
Rad- wrote:
About the new mapset getting qualified, other players, and modders alike, can still submit suggestions or report any issues they find with the map, if a certain number of issues has been reported and the mapper chooses to fix said issues because, it may impact on the map vote % if these issues are too bad, then it will continue in pending for at least another week, giving time to fix said issues and for the mapper to improve now that they got more publicity to their mapset thanks to the qualified section and it's leaderboards.
1. What will happen if there's serious issue and the percentage is still up to 85%? This sounds really unclear.
2. What will happen if the mapper hasn't fix/update it yet before one week?
3. Will these got automatically qualified after one week?
4. Will the counter of two weeks happen again?
pls answer thanks, its very unclear on how should it be requalified.
Rad- wrote:
QAT things
holy this just makes things for QAT way too heavy, although its their job, they still have life and other things to do, especially everyday that could be more than 10 maps to qualify, that could mean they need to check every each of them, and they will hurry more when some days those qualified rounds going to get ranked, even though with the 2 weeks span, im very sure with a big load of maps they might not be able to handle all of them (no bad feelings for QATs, i just think it would be overwhelming, you guys do pretty cool job!)
also think about other gamemodes who have less QAT members, that could be way much worse for them to handle :c
Guess that's all that I can say, hopefully its clear enough!
edit: lol nao mostly covers everything i would also want to say