TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

just a quick reminder - fmn is popular only because it is 16*, is a meme and a certain player tryharded it. Almost no one plays it unironically.

Architecture is another case where popularity got upped by broken rating and spam parts.

We want to focus on actually ambitious and well-made popular maps rather than memes, for all skill ceilings.

And well, Project Loved is supposed to fill the gap Ranked system and RC created in f.e. competitiveness or chart diversity. However, one factor isn't often enough - we don't choose great maps with 0 favs as well as mediocre maps with 100 favs. There are some standards which cannot be ignored.

howdy! lol i see about the purpose of project loved. but ambitious and well-made? lol this was the funniest comment 2018, beyond 'please don't evaluate this map with starrating, but with its quality'

So we should promote overrated maps which are a spamfest? Is that what you are saying? If not, sorry for misunderstanding.

Quality is important. What is funny in that? Do you like playing bad maps with lots of minijacks and senseless/random structure? Or maps made only for high star rating in a flawed system where you can FC 8* maps but fail 5* maps?

We are trying to find a middle grounds and reach consensus about what kind of maps should we push into Loved. Not everyone will like each map and this is perfectly fine, but bombing mapsets that aren't catering to a specific group of people seems just not fair. Please judge sv maps, ln maps, hard maps, easy maps, stamina maps separately, and not with the mindset "i hate 7k so lol downvoted" or "wtf stepmania rejected". I hope it doesn't happen but just wanted to say it anyway.

hi. first, thx for answering

what i meant is i think ghost is not quality map. also, i agree on 'quality is important' but the evaluation of quality should be various since every person has own thought and they are all different.

the comment i quoted is what you used on your volcanic. i didnt remember exact sentence. ok thx

you said like the map includes lots of minijacks with senseless/random structure is a bad map.



then i think is wouldn't be a good pattern. holding ln on line 2 and 4 3 4 mini ln jacks on line 1? isn't this 'a bad map' that you referred?

I'm pretty confident the entire map isn't mapped like that, you just took your time to find one section that includes it, from what I can see you had to go 1 minute in looking for one small example that doesn't encompass the entirety of the map.

mijkolsmith wrote:

Firstly, there are no minijacks on this screenshot.
Secondly, this is a very exact point in this chart. Without any context to preceding parts or parts that come afterwards, you can say almost nothing about whether it might be out of place or not. Especially about whether it's difficult or uncomfortable, this depends on what the rest of the chart has to offer, and around what difficulty level the total chart is. Furthermore, this is the opposite of a messily or randomly structured chart, since it has this obvious patterning.

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

just a quick reminder - fmn is popular only because it is 16*, is a meme and a certain player tryharded it. Almost no one plays it unironically.

Architecture is another case where popularity got upped by broken rating and spam parts.

We want to focus on actually ambitious and well-made popular maps rather than memes, for all skill ceilings.

And well, Project Loved is supposed to fill the gap Ranked system and RC created in f.e. competitiveness or chart diversity. However, one factor isn't often enough - we don't choose great maps with 0 favs as well as mediocre maps with 100 favs. There are some standards which cannot be ignored.

howdy! lol i see about the purpose of project loved. but ambitious and well-made? lol this was the funniest comment 2018, beyond 'please don't evaluate this map with starrating, but with its quality'

So we should promote overrated maps which are a spamfest? Is that what you are saying? If not, sorry for misunderstanding.

Quality is important. What is funny in that? Do you like playing bad maps with lots of minijacks and senseless/random structure? Or maps made only for high star rating in a flawed system where you can FC 8* maps but fail 5* maps?

We are trying to find a middle grounds and reach consensus about what kind of maps should we push into Loved. Not everyone will like each map and this is perfectly fine, but bombing mapsets that aren't catering to a specific group of people seems just not fair. Please judge sv maps, ln maps, hard maps, easy maps, stamina maps separately, and not with the mindset "i hate 7k so lol downvoted" or "wtf stepmania rejected". I hope it doesn't happen but just wanted to say it anyway.

hi. first, thx for answering

what i meant is i think ghost is not quality map. also, i agree on 'quality is important' but the evaluation of quality should be various since every person has own thought and they are all different.

the comment i quoted is what you used on your volcanic. i didnt remember exact sentence. ok thx

you said like the map includes lots of minijacks with senseless/random structure is a bad map.



then i think is wouldn't be a good pattern. holding ln on line 2 and 4 3 4 mini ln jacks on line 1? isn't this 'a bad map' that you referred?

I'm pretty confident the entire map isn't mapped like that, you just took your time to find one section that includes it, from what I can see you had to go 1 minute in looking for one small example that doesn't encompass the entirety of the map.

oh hi thx for your opinion osu!catch user lol


actually i didnt see the whole map and i only saw the screenshot that someone uploaded. and you made me see the whole chart. and my opinion on the map got more negatively. thx

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

just a quick reminder - fmn is popular only because it is 16*, is a meme and a certain player tryharded it. Almost no one plays it unironically.

Architecture is another case where popularity got upped by broken rating and spam parts.

We want to focus on actually ambitious and well-made popular maps rather than memes, for all skill ceilings.

And well, Project Loved is supposed to fill the gap Ranked system and RC created in f.e. competitiveness or chart diversity. However, one factor isn't often enough - we don't choose great maps with 0 favs as well as mediocre maps with 100 favs. There are some standards which cannot be ignored.

howdy! lol i see about the purpose of project loved. but ambitious and well-made? lol this was the funniest comment 2018, beyond 'please don't evaluate this map with starrating, but with its quality'

So we should promote overrated maps which are a spamfest? Is that what you are saying? If not, sorry for misunderstanding.

Quality is important. What is funny in that? Do you like playing bad maps with lots of minijacks and senseless/random structure? Or maps made only for high star rating in a flawed system where you can FC 8* maps but fail 5* maps?

We are trying to find a middle grounds and reach consensus about what kind of maps should we push into Loved. Not everyone will like each map and this is perfectly fine, but bombing mapsets that aren't catering to a specific group of people seems just not fair. Please judge sv maps, ln maps, hard maps, easy maps, stamina maps separately, and not with the mindset "i hate 7k so lol downvoted" or "wtf stepmania rejected". I hope it doesn't happen but just wanted to say it anyway.

hi. first, thx for answering

what i meant is i think ghost is not quality map. also, i agree on 'quality is important' but the evaluation of quality should be various since every person has own thought and they are all different.

the comment i quoted is what you used on your volcanic. i didnt remember exact sentence. ok thx

you said like the map includes lots of minijacks with senseless/random structure is a bad map.



then i think is wouldn't be a good pattern. holding ln on line 2 and 4 3 4 mini ln jacks on line 1? isn't this 'a bad map' that you referred?

I'm pretty confident the entire map isn't mapped like that, you just took your time to find one section that includes it, from what I can see you had to go 1 minute in looking for one small example that doesn't encompass the entirety of the map.

oh hi thx for your opinion osu!catch user lol


actually i didnt see the whole map and i only saw the screenshot that someone uploaded. and you made me see the whole chart. and my opinion on the map got more negatively. thx

You're welcome mania player, but I doubt you found it from a random screenshot, you took your time to find that. Don't try to hide your shame embrace it, once you've posted it, it's done. Anyways looking at the numbers looks like the dislike is the minority. That concludes an opinion from a minigame player. Good luck in trying to find flaws and not pointing anything out tippy tap player

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

oh thx a catch player who is rude as much as me lol

iirc, the map which going to loved has to get yes vote four times more than no vote. what would this mean? i think i dont have to explain it specifically

Kasumii-sama wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

oh thx a catch player who is rude as much as me lol

iirc, the map which going to loved has to get yes vote four times more than no vote. what would this mean? i think i dont have to explain it specifically

How is TheFlameWind rude? He's just stating facts. Hell, you and every Korean user here is rude by hating on this map, and putting a "no" vote only on it, while ignoring every single other Loved map in osu!mania, and not giving constructive feedback, just bringing more drama. (I'm aware this comment does not help, thank you.) And even saying the entire Loved section is shit.

This is a PSA directed to you and every person who hates on this map, or the entire Loved section: Learn how to do constructive feedback, help the Loved section. Don't do this kind of circlejerk where you just hate on one map without any constructivve argument.

Also a map needs 80% of yes votes to get loved. Don't know where in the name of fuck you saw the "get yes vote four times more than no vote".

Cheong wrote:

Kasumii-sama wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

oh thx a catch player who is rude as much as me lol

iirc, the map which going to loved has to get yes vote four times more than no vote. what would this mean? i think i dont have to explain it specifically

How is TheFlameWind rude? He's just stating facts. Hell, you and every Korean user here is rude by hating on this map, and putting a "no" vote only on it, while ignoring every single other Loved map in osu!mania, and not giving constructive feedback, just bringing more drama. (I'm aware this comment does not help, thank you.) And even saying the entire Loved section is shit.

This is a PSA directed to you and every person who hates on this map, or the entire Loved section: Learn how to do constructive feedback, help the Loved section. Don't do this kind of circlejerk where you just hate on one map without any constructivve argument.

Also a map needs 80% of yes votes to get loved. Don't know where in the name of fuck you saw the "get yes vote four times more than no vote".

yes i'm rude i agree on it. but korean users are rude by voting no and hating this map? why is it rude? though they really dont like map and dont agree to be a loved map, they have to press agree and pretend to like the map since hating it and pressing no vote is rude? lol how about saying just playing mania is rude lmao

Cheong wrote:

Kasumii-sama wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

oh thx a catch player who is rude as much as me lol

iirc, the map which going to loved has to get yes vote four times more than no vote. what would this mean? i think i dont have to explain it specifically

How is TheFlameWind rude? He's just stating facts. Hell, you and every Korean user here is rude by hating on this map, and putting a "no" vote only on it, while ignoring every single other Loved map in osu!mania, and not giving constructive feedback, just bringing more drama. (I'm aware this comment does not help, thank you.) And even saying the entire Loved section is shit.

This is a PSA directed to you and every person who hates on this map, or the entire Loved section: Learn how to do constructive feedback, help the Loved section. Don't do this kind of circlejerk where you just hate on one map without any constructivve argument.

Also a map needs 80% of yes votes to get loved. Don't know where in the name of fuck you saw the "get yes vote four times more than no vote".

yes i'm rude i agree on it. but korean users are rude by voting no and hating this map? why is it rude? though they really dont like map and dont agree to be a loved map, they have to press agree and pretend to like the map since hating it and pressing no vote is rude? lol how about saying just playing mania is rude lmao

Cheong wrote:

Kasumii-sama wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

oh thx a catch player who is rude as much as me lol

iirc, the map which going to loved has to get yes vote four times more than no vote. what would this mean? i think i dont have to explain it specifically

How is TheFlameWind rude? He's just stating facts. Hell, you and every Korean user here is rude by hating on this map, and putting a "no" vote only on it, while ignoring every single other Loved map in osu!mania, and not giving constructive feedback, just bringing more drama. (I'm aware this comment does not help, thank you.) And even saying the entire Loved section is shit.

This is a PSA directed to you and every person who hates on this map, or the entire Loved section: Learn how to do constructive feedback, help the Loved section. Don't do this kind of circlejerk where you just hate on one map without any constructivve argument.

Also a map needs 80% of yes votes to get loved. Don't know where in the name of fuck you saw the "get yes vote four times more than no vote".

yes i'm rude i agree on it. but korean users are rude by voting no and hating this map? why is it rude? though they really dont like map and dont agree to be a loved map, they have to press agree and pretend to like the map since hating it and pressing no vote is rude? lol how about saying just playing mania is rude lmao

Cheong wrote:

Raveille wrote:

Cheong wrote:

Kasumii-sama wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

oh thx a catch player who is rude as much as me lol

iirc, the map which going to loved has to get yes vote four times more than no vote. what would this mean? i think i dont have to explain it specifically

How is TheFlameWind rude? He's just stating facts. Hell, you and every Korean user here is rude by hating on this map, and putting a "no" vote only on it, while ignoring every single other Loved map in osu!mania, and not giving constructive feedback, just bringing more drama. (I'm aware this comment does not help, thank you.) And even saying the entire Loved section is shit.

This is a PSA directed to you and every person who hates on this map, or the entire Loved section: Learn how to do constructive feedback, help the Loved section. Don't do this kind of circlejerk where you just hate on one map without any constructivve argument.

Also a map needs 80% of yes votes to get loved. Don't know where in the name of fuck you saw the "get yes vote four times more than no vote".

yes i'm rude i agree on it. but korean users are rude by voting no and hating this map? why is it rude? though they really dont like map and dont agree to be a loved map, they have to press agree and pretend to like the map since hating it and pressing no vote is rude? lol how about saying just playing mania is rude lmao

Let’s see... someone called the map “dog shit”. Someone commented that “Toaphster is captain? Dismissed”.

On your first comment on this forum, you call us “lots of retards”.

Korean users aren’t rude because they bombard this voting with “no”s, you need to read the comments and realize that many of you give no constructive feedback and just useless comments like that.

Also, surprise, you don’t have to be rude to give constructive criticism. It isn’t difficult.

sry it is difficult since the map sucks as shit kthx

Kasumii-sama wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

[quote="_underjoy"]too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

oh thx a catch player who is rude as much as me lol

iirc, the map which going to loved has to get yes vote four times more than no vote. what would this mean? i think i dont have to explain it specifically

Cheong wrote:

Raveille wrote:

Cheong wrote:

Kasumii-sama wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

oh thx a catch player who is rude as much as me lol

iirc, the map which going to loved has to get yes vote four times more than no vote. what would this mean? i think i dont have to explain it specifically

How is TheFlameWind rude? He's just stating facts. Hell, you and every Korean user here is rude by hating on this map, and putting a "no" vote only on it, while ignoring every single other Loved map in osu!mania, and not giving constructive feedback, just bringing more drama. (I'm aware this comment does not help, thank you.) And even saying the entire Loved section is shit.

This is a PSA directed to you and every person who hates on this map, or the entire Loved section: Learn how to do constructive feedback, help the Loved section. Don't do this kind of circlejerk where you just hate on one map without any constructivve argument.

Also a map needs 80% of yes votes to get loved. Don't know where in the name of fuck you saw the "get yes vote four times more than no vote".

yes i'm rude i agree on it. but korean users are rude by voting no and hating this map? why is it rude? though they really dont like map and dont agree to be a loved map, they have to press agree and pretend to like the map since hating it and pressing no vote is rude? lol how about saying just playing mania is rude lmao

Let’s see... someone called the map “dog shit”. Someone commented that “Toaphster is captain? Dismissed”.

On your first comment on this forum, you call us “lots of retards”.

Korean users aren’t rude because they bombard this voting with “no”s, you need to read the comments and realize that many of you give no constructive feedback and just useless comments like that.

Also, surprise, you don’t have to be rude to give constructive criticism. It isn’t difficult.

sry it is difficult since the map sucks as shit kthx

Cheong wrote:

Kasumii-sama wrote:

Cheong wrote:

Kasumii-sama wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

oh thx a catch player who is rude as much as me lol

iirc, the map which going to loved has to get yes vote four times more than no vote. what would this mean? i think i dont have to explain it specifically

How is TheFlameWind rude? He's just stating facts. Hell, you and every Korean user here is rude by hating on this map, and putting a "no" vote only on it, while ignoring every single other Loved map in osu!mania, and not giving constructive feedback, just bringing more drama. (I'm aware this comment does not help, thank you.) And even saying the entire Loved section is shit.

This is a PSA directed to you and every person who hates on this map, or the entire Loved section: Learn how to do constructive feedback, help the Loved section. Don't do this kind of circlejerk where you just hate on one map without any constructivve argument.

Also a map needs 80% of yes votes to get loved. Don't know where in the name of fuck you saw the "get yes vote four times more than no vote".

yes i'm rude i agree on it. but korean users are rude by voting no and hating this map? why is it rude? though they really dont like map and dont agree to be a loved map, they have to press agree and pretend to like the map since hating it and pressing no vote is rude? lol how about saying just playing mania is rude lmao

it's rude imo because you guys haven't done shit or cared about the loved section ever since it's been a thing and now that GHOST gets loved "let's not ruin the loved section plz..."
yo that's hypocritical as shit
if you're gonna give "feedback" on one map, do it on all maps for this week kthx

lol okay we were rude sry thx for understanding captain kasumii chan

[Crz]SuJaK wrote:

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 짅짲갲쌎움잊넺 뼝씬뜰
옛쓰 찭성하는 놈들 잦살좀

^^..

Yuuna Yuuki- wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Sinaeb wrote:

Cheong wrote:

Raveille wrote:

Cheong wrote:

Kasumii-sama wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

TheFlameWind wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

Cheong wrote:

_underjoy wrote:

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

too damn long

oh thx a catch player who is rude as much as me lol

iirc, the map which going to loved has to get yes vote four times more than no vote. what would this mean? i think i dont have to explain it specifically

How is TheFlameWind rude? He's just stating facts. Hell, you and every Korean user here is rude by hating on this map, and putting a "no" vote only on it, while ignoring every single other Loved map in osu!mania, and not giving constructive feedback, just bringing more drama. (I'm aware this comment does not help, thank you.) And even saying the entire Loved section is shit.

This is a PSA directed to you and every person who hates on this map, or the entire Loved section: Learn how to do constructive feedback, help the Loved section. Don't do this kind of circlejerk where you just hate on one map without any constructivve argument.

Also a map needs 80% of yes votes to get loved. Don't know where in the name of fuck you saw the "get yes vote four times more than no vote".

yes i'm rude i agree on it. but korean users are rude by voting no and hating this map? why is it rude? though they really dont like map and dont agree to be a loved map, they have to press agree and pretend to like the map since hating it and pressing no vote is rude? lol how about saying just playing mania is rude lmao

Let’s see... someone called the map “dog shit”. Someone commented that “Toaphster is captain? Dismissed”.

On your first comment on this forum, you call us “lots of retards”.

Korean users aren’t rude because they bombard this voting with “no”s, you need to read the comments and realize that many of you give no constructive feedback and just useless comments like that.

Also, surprise, you don’t have to be rude to give constructive criticism. It isn’t difficult.

sry it is difficult since the map sucks as shit kthx

"the map sucks as shit" Is there any reason that you find this map to "sucks as shit"? Did you even play it? Just looking at the editor isn't enough, yes you can get a general grasp of how the map can play, but you cannot pinpoint any part to be bad because you don't know the context of why it's mapped like that

It's probably too hard for him, we have a no fail mod for these circumstances though.

Edit 1: Ahhh we also have a half-time mod as well it can work wonders for him

I can pass that map. but I think ghost is very sucks as shit
fucking slow sv + Full LN
mapper brain seems to have only poop

Celcious wrote:

Break it up all lol
If you like this map, press the "Yes" button.
If you don't like this map, simply press the "No" button.
That's all! Can't be better than this! Isn't it?