Leorda's mod
Leorda wrote:
Oh hi there
[General]
* For all diff, your current stack leniency is unrankable. Please raise it at least 2 ticks
* Inconsistent kiai times in all diff. You might want to make it consistent
[Easy]
* AR +1? Done in the last mod
00:38:372 (5) - I don't like if this overlapped by previous slider.... Move further away please Fixed
00:58:622 (3) - Add 1 repeating slider for better flow? Fixed
00:59:747 (4) - Move 1 grid up for stacking with 00:58:247 (2)? Thanks, didn't notice that I could do that until I switched my grid level.
01:27:122 (1) - While the default skin of spinner is red-orange-yellow, this might be blend while gameplay. Do the colorhax by this http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/356664 I get what you mean, and I didn't notice that because I was using the Lucky Star skin >_> Anyways, this was fixed in the last mod and now it's pink.
[Normal]
* AR +1 or +2? Your current approach rate is slow Done in the last mod as well.
00:02:372 (4) - 0,5x slider is not allowed for normal diff. Beginners will having difficult to see the slider Already removed
00:44:372 (5) - Remove 1 repeating slider? Fixed in the last mod
01:27:122 (1) - While the default skin of spinner is red-orange-yellow, this might be blend while gameplay. Do the colorhax by this http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/356664 That's the same picture as the easy one...nonetheless I think this is already fixed
[Hard]
00:08:372 (11) - Too much repeating slider can be boring for pro players. Split this slider into two slider? Fixed
00:54:496 (3) - I don't like if this overlapped by previous object.... Move further away please Fixed
01:07:996 (8) - This slider is touch the HP Bar Fixed
01:21:497 (12) - New combo please Added NC
[Kogure's Insane]
* AR +1 or +2?
01:25:997 (1) - New combo for preventing of new combo bug. Otherwise, spinner will show "300" instead of "Geki" Kogure fixed this I believe
Good luck Thanks!
Hinsvar's mod
Hinsvar wrote:
Yo.
Let's mod this.
*Note: Bolded gold ones are things you must do (or strongly recommended; usually about unrankable stuff or extreme/fatal errors). Everything in red are things that look awkward/wrong to me or something that can be improved (subjective suggestions; you can follow my lead here or not); everything else are rants and minor suggestions to make things look cooler and a bit better.
>General>Easy
- Looks fine. To the diffs.
>Normal
- Uh... 1/8 beat snap divisor? You should really switch this to 1/2 so modders won't be confused. Oh, I didn't take that into consideration, thanks. Fixed
>Hard
- The placement of the notes look... pretty random. There were some patterns, yeah, but overall it looks... scattered. This diff plays fine overall, but the design... Well, no need to remap, I guess. I wasn't really going for a symmetrical or patterned look, had more to do with flow and feeling.
- 01:20:372 (9) - Three repeats? I suggest to repeat it twice less, so that it will end at 01:20:747, and you can stack a circle below the slider, at 01:21:122. Should do well. In the current state, it's pretty hard to know when will the slider end. Fixed, hope this is what you meant http://puu.sh/HsAo
>Kogure's Insane
- Overall... I'm not really sure about this diff. Not sure about its playability, I mean. Might be because there are 1/6s and 1/4s at once though. I don't see how I could map the beginning and the ending portions otherwise
- 00:27:684 (1,2,3) - Uh... Maybe at least make sure so that these notes won't overlap each other? Dunno, looks weird right now. sloppy placement on my part :/ Fixed
- 00:40:434 (6) - NC? No thanks, I have NC's in consistent placement from each other right now and I'd like to keep it that way.
- 00:43:434 (6) - ^ Same as above.
- 00:54:121 (1,2,3,4) - Eh, I think this overlap can be avoided. Try to make these notes to NOT overlap each other. Pointed out in Leorda's mod and already fixed
- 01:20:747 (7) - NC? It's ridiculous to have over 20 objects in a combo when there's some places where you can place an NC. Fixed in last mod
- 01:22:622 (17) - ^ Consistent NC spacing, leaving it as is
I guess that's it.
- Actually it's pretty good, but I don't really like the double-circles (do they have a name?) like 00:28:434 (1,2). They're fine too, to be honest, but you somewhat overused them, and sometimes broke the flow, like 00:40:997 (2,3). Maybe you can change some of them to a simple slider, you know.
Good luck on the way