1. osu! forums
  2. Other
  3. Off-Topic
  4. Forum Games
  5. Mafia
show more
posted
Stream of consciousness post ahead:

Actually DxS is a town read for me. His slight "hinting" that his role can be motivated seems townie in a sense. I don't think mafia would do something like that. Also meta says that DxS is acting the usual way.

Sync is also a town read for me due to the his giving information that would benefit town - roles and information about the IRC game we played before.

That leaves, Rantai, Swift, Nyquill and Makar.

Right now, Rantai is pretty much a null read. Meta so far is consistent with his town and scum meta.

Swift is also a null read. Though he did try to spark discussion with the "methods", it doesn't necessarily mean he's town or scum.

So with both Nyquill and Makar, I notice that they have an interest with the inducer and it's effects.
Nyquill asking if inducing was forced, and Makar verifying that they weren't forced on IRC.
Why do they display an interest? Well I'd rather not say the reason I think so.

Among Nyquill and Makar, gut tells me that Nyquill is more suspicious.
The "Are you scum?" question was also pointless, didn't contribute at all, and is WIFOM.
Ergo, Vote: Nyquill
posted
Im just curious about it because we could try to use that information to trace who the inducers are (positive to verify that person is town, and negative to verify that the person is mafia). So... If we knew who was negatively induced we could try to trace back on who did it, sorta like rantai is asking in the previous post.

Also, I have a feeling nyquill is just asking out of curiosity or thinking the same thing as me on this; I don't think its a good reason to accuse him though we have nothing to go on at the moment. We don't have much time left in the day so its probably best to go with him on this
posted
Here's some food for thought; Hitter became happier last night.
posted
Though going by what Mashley's pm says, I'm not sure he is even aware of it.
posted

Makar8000 wrote:

Im just curious about it because we could try to use that information to trace who the inducers are (positive to verify that person is town, and negative to verify that the person is mafia). So... If we knew who was negatively induced we could try to trace back on who did it, sorta like rantai is asking in the previous post.
Yeah, but that's the thing. You can't really tell if you've been induced or not.
posted

Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:

Makar8000 wrote:

Im just curious about it because we could try to use that information to trace who the inducers are (positive to verify that person is town, and negative to verify that the person is mafia). So... If we knew who was negatively induced we could try to trace back on who did it, sorta like rantai is asking in the previous post.
Yeah, but that's the thing. You can't really tell if you've been induced or not.
I guess we would have to wait then... if somebody was induced then that person who was induced should notice their ability changing right?

In that case maybe we should just no lynch this round
posted
Actually, they can't tell if their ability changed unless they were an informative role like the cop.
posted

Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:

Actually, they can't tell if their ability changed unless they were an informative role like the cop.
If lets say you had a docter role, and the person you tried to protect ended up being shot, then that should spark up a clue that your role has changed lol.

Of course we don't exactly know how roles change even based on the IRC log Sync gave (they could be different?), and it may just be pointless to try to find scum through this method.

I think we should nolynch this round, or vote Nyquill due to reasons NoHitter gave though I think its insufficient info.
posted

Makar8000 wrote:

Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:

Actually, they can't tell if their ability changed unless they were an informative role like the cop.
If lets say you had a docter role, and the person you tried to protect ended up being shot, then that should spark up a clue that your role has changed lol.
It's possible that if there's two mafia, they could have a strongman in that situation.
posted
Going a no lynch here serves no purpose here. We've already had one night and we'll be throwing away what could be our only lynch, if not, half of our possible lynches. Well unless we have a doc that successfully blocks (or similar role).

Just to emphasise, in a set up this small we need every lynch we can get.
posted
Like I said earlier about the two mafia possibility, if we have another shooter, it's already game over if we make our vote today.

With 7 alive, one mislynch could cause an instant game over if the other shooter makes their shot that night along with the mafia kill.
However, if the shooter and the mafia shoot the same person, or the shooter hits mafia, then we still have another day.
If we get a successful lynch, however, then we can last another day.
If there's only one mafia and one other shooter, we'll still be able to last another day.
If there's NO shooter, then we still have another day regardless of how many mafia we have.



Yes, I'm still assuming we have a second mafia. There's a slight chance that we have another one, but like I said before, I'm a bit iffy on that if we have a shooter roaming around.
posted
2 mafia AND an SK?

I highly, highly doubt that. 1 mafia/1 SK or 2 mafia makes much for sense.

Though even if there is 2 mafia it'd be a 2:5 meaning that today is the only safe lynch.
posted
Unless a doctor successfully protected somebody... since Mashley was killed and Rantai was shot, 2 mafia and a shooter seems unlikely
posted

NoHitter wrote:

Why do they display an interest? Well I'd rather not say the reason I think so.
Keep thinking, you're getting it wrong.

NoHitter wrote:

Among Nyquill and Makar, gut tells me that Nyquill is more suspicious.
The "Are you scum?" question was also pointless, didn't contribute at all, and is WIFOM.
The WIFOM question was because of something sync pulled on me the other day on IRC. If anything this was a half hearted joke and perhaps gain a bit more of a town favor from sync since he was town that game when he asked it.

Also, you're risking a mislynch on the basis of a half hearted WIFOM. You are also one to talk when it comes to contributing to town discussion, coming in after 41 hours to throw an accusing analysis post from lurking for the greater portion of the day.

Vote: NoHitter
posted
It's true, Hitter's vote on Nyquill is completely unjustified. "Are you scum?" is a commonly asked question amongst those who play IRC mafia in our channel (and the official one). In fact, Hitter has more than likely been exposed to it seeing as he participates in IRC mafia too.

The matter of the fact is, I'm not completely sure.

When it comes down to it, Hitter's vote (either way) was unjustified and reaction-hunting is a little strong for a first-post.
posted

Nyquill wrote:

Also, you're risking a mislynch on the basis of a half hearted WIFOM. You are also one to talk when it comes to contributing to town discussion, coming in after 41 hours to throw an accusing analysis post from lurking for the greater portion of the day.

Sync wrote:

When it comes down to it, Hitter's vote (either way) was unjustified and reaction-hunting is a little strong for a first-post.
I agree, as I have said before it wasn't a good reason imo, and now that you mention it, yes it was strange for a first post.

Vote: NoHitter
posted
Mod: Requesting day be extended by 24 hours

Like sync said, not sure at all if NoHitter's post was just an reactionary guage. I would like to see what he has to say first.
posted

Rantai wrote:

2 mafia AND an SK?

I highly, highly doubt that. 1 mafia/1 SK or 2 mafia makes much for sense.

Though even if there is 2 mafia it'd be a 2:5 meaning that today is the only safe lynch.

Makar8000 wrote:

Unless a doctor successfully protected somebody... since Mashley was killed and Rantai was shot, 2 mafia and a shooter seems unlikely
Since when did I say SK? It could be a vig for all we know, which is probably more likely than a SK.
posted
Eh I used shooter as a general term :/
posted

Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:

Rantai wrote:

2 mafia AND an SK?

I highly, highly doubt that. 1 mafia/1 SK or 2 mafia makes much for sense.

Though even if there is 2 mafia it'd be a 2:5 meaning that today is the only safe lynch.

Makar8000 wrote:

Unless a doctor successfully protected somebody... since Mashley was killed and Rantai was shot, 2 mafia and a shooter seems unlikely
Since when did I say SK? It could be a vig for all we know, which is probably more likely than a SK.
Going with that then, we know our vig is dead. So that throws out the 2 shooter in that regard.
show more
Please sign in to reply.