Byakugan249 wrote:

sorry i wanna keep my mod organized

Byakugan249 wrote:

[SK's Normal]
the settings look a bit too hard for players, so i suggest that you decrease the OR and OD by 1. it'd look easier for players at the normal level.
00:03:034 (2) - remove this and add a 1/2 repeat slider starting at 00:02:856 to follow the piano. i felt a bit uncomfortable when i hit this note as i'm focusing the piano. Done.
00:07:677 (4) - maybe add a finish at the beginning since you have it at (2), and it follows the vocals? Finish here sound bad for me, no.
00:09:106 (2) - same as above but add the finish. same as above
00:13:034 (2) - same as 00:07:677 but at the end. ^
00:13:749 (3) - Ctrl+H. the path looks a lot smoother during gameplay. Ok
00:38:570 (2) - replace this for a circle and a 1/1 slider to follow vocals accurately? Fixed.
00:44:999 (1,2,3) - try to something easier than this. players at the normal level might not get used to this kind of pattern as you have to alternate the keys or the mouse clicks.
01:10:177 (3) - are you sure that this is stacked perfectly at the end? it looks weird during gameplay.
01:16:963 (1,2,3) - try this instead? a 1/2 repeat slider followed by a circle and a NC because of new lyrics. (7) is following the long pause.

Byakugan249 wrote:

[jieusieu's Hard]
00:16:606 (3,4) - *nazi* not stacked perfectly. go 1 grid up because it looks weird of the note isn't stacked properly.
01:15:713 (2) - replace this for a 1/2 slider to follow the long pause accurately.
if you're a new mapper, this is a pretty nice diff.

-Chata- wrote:

hello. request from jieusieu.

so light mod : l

jieusieu's Hard

• 
  00:00:356 - 휘슬
  00:03:392 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - 인세인에 나와도 어려운 패턴. 슬라이더를 혼합해서 다르게 배치하세요. 그리고 00:03:392 (1) 이건 없어도 될거같음
  00:03:749 (3) - 휘슬
  00:04:463 (7) - ^
  00:04:820 (1,1) - 둘중 한곳에 피니시. 00:04:820 (1) - 여기 추천
  00:05:892 (3) - 휘슬
  00:07:320 (3) - ^
  00:07:677 - 피니시
  00:08:035 (5) - 휘슬
  00:09:106 (5) - 피니시
  00:09:820 (1) - ^
  00:10:534 - ^
  00:15:892 (1) - 피니시
  00:16:070 (2) - 노말사운드. 커스텀1 클랩사용
  00:16:606 (3) - ^
  00:17:678 (8) - ^
  00:46:249 - 여기서부터 s:1을 사용해서 00:49:106 (1) - 00:49:820 (3) - 00:50:535 (5) - 이런식의 간격으로 00:54:106 까지 쭈욱 클랩 배치
  00:54:820 - 노말사운드 클랩
  00:55:356 - ^
  00:55:892 (5) - ^
  00:56:249 (7) - ^
  00:56:606 - 노트 추가후 노말사운드
  00:56:785 (1,2,3,4,5) - 이것도 00:03:392 여기와 같은 이유로 수정요망
  00:58:927 - 스핀의 끝지점을 이곳으로
  00:59:106 ~ 00:59:642 - 노트추가

popner wrote:

Hi ~ Some simple mod.

Just suggestions:

[Easy]
00:21:248 (2,3) - a little difficult, change to a short slider? I rejected both of these in previous mods because I thought they were easy enough.
01:26:963 (5,6) - ^ ^

[Insane]
00:16:427 (2) - there is vocal at slidertick, change a pattern to catch the vocal? Vocal on slidertick is fine imo. I don't think I need to make the pattern more difficult.
00:41:963 (4) - add note? feels empty here Done. Just filled in the rest of the gap with notes
01:08:749 (1) - why not put it like this? http://puu.sh/tpPq if you are worried abort spacing, you can change 01:08:035 (2,3) like this http://puu.sh/tpPX I didn't think of that before. Done.


That's all I can find. GL~

-Bakari- wrote:

lol
from 3modreqs :O

[General]
maybe source Saki Achiga-hen episode of Side-A not Saki: Achiga-hen - episode of side-A There is a general consensus to use the colon with the manga and other mappers, so the colon is staying.

[Easy]
1/2 (168 BPM) for easy. kinda hard for beginners, lol
00:11:248 (4) - stack with 00:08:391 (1) I dislike stacking and the psacing will be more confusing this way imo.
00:18:391 (1) - distance? and it's so close to overlap (2 grids up or more) They are not touching, they are properly spaced, and I don't want it touching the hp bar, so I don't think I will change it.
00:21:248 (2,3) - it's easy! Yay! xD
00:26:963 (1) - don't like new combo here I know everything is normally spaced, but I did want to accent that 1 particular line of lyrics.
00:29:463 (1) - ^ ^
00:31:963 (1,2) - crossing can confuse beginners! Looks nice and is easy enough to read imo.
00:38:034 (1) - don't like new combo here same as 00:26:963 (1)
00:56:963 (4) - new combo What happened there....Fixed.
01:06:248 (1,3) - confusing for beginners If beginners really have problems with this, I'll be a little sad.
01:15:534 (3,4) - ^ ^
01:26:963 (5,6) - kinda confusing for beginners Confusing, how so?
01:27:498 (1) - too short for beginners? I was worried about this, but since it fits, I will keep it for now.

[Rush!]
is it insane? Yep insane, bur rush sounds cooler and fits the song title.
00:03:213 (6) - maybe try this? Hmmm, I think it more readily apparent to follow 4 than arc around 2.... Still, an interesting thought.
00:04:820 (8) - looong boooring slider Yeah... Not much I can do about it with the music the way it is.
00:16:427 (2) - too close to (1)? Fixed.
00:25:356 (3) - ugly shape I like the shape, so it is staying.
00:29:284 (1) - disagree with NC here Emphasizing the line of lyrics before this combo, so it is fine.
01:00:535 (3) - a bit not symmetrical o.o Fixed a bit, not perfect but whatever.
01:01:963 (3) - ^ ^
01:24:106 (1) - looks a bit wrong ^
01:26:249 (1) - new combo not here but here 01:25:892 (7) Since the new combos follow the music, the current combo formation is right.

-Bakari- wrote:

[jieusieu's Hard]
AR +1
00:04:642 (4,4) - overlap
00:54:285 (2,4) - ^

Kenezz wrote:

Aloha!
Kenezz's Bakamod~

[Easy]
00:11:962 (1) - Maybe put finish instead whistle like the others diffs. Done.
00:21:249 (2,3) - Hmm this stack could be are confusing to the rookie players, I prefer a 1/2 slider here like this http://puu.sh/uwvW and if you agree with this point then change this 01:26:963 (5,6). Remember that is just a suggestion...imo not is a problem but many people say that this is hard to the new players. Is this really that difficult? Whatever since people keep on complaining, I'll change it.
00:28:748 (1) - Omg this space not is intentional really? Okay, fix this and here my suggestion: Select 00:28:748 (1) and 00:29:820 (2), now ctrl + R and fix a bit the spacing and the hitsound. Woops, was testing something and forgot to change it back. Thanks for the catch.
00:34:820 (1) - Same as 00:11:962 (1) here at the start. Done.
01:21:248 (3) - Imo not is neccesary the slider because sounds bad, only with a circle in the white tick is okay for me. Needed a bridge from the white to red tick to keep my 1 beat intervals.

[Rush]
-The flow is a bit weird o3o
00:16:427 (2) - Maybe finish at the start... hmm imo the slider don't fits good here. Added the finish , but I like to follow the lyrics here.
01:00:535 (3) - The new combo should be start here? if you agree remove the new combo in 00:59:820 (1) The current combo follow the lyrics better imo.
01:06:249 (1) - Finish instead whistle. Done.
01:11:963 (5) - Same as 01:00:535 (3) here not is neccesary remove the new combo of 01:11:249 (1) As with 01:00:535 (3), the current combo follows the lyrical phrases better, so I'm keeping it this way.
01:27:499 (1) - imo the new combo is needless. It puts emphasis on this last note. I like it xD

That's All!
Good Luck :3~~

Kenezz wrote:

[jieusieu's Hard]
-Maybe AR-1
00:15:892 (1) - Put clap here instead finish, now put the finish at the start of the next slider and remove the clap.
00:46:249 (4) - The new combo should be start here and not here 00:46:963 (1).
00:54:820 (3) - Remove the clap at the start.
00:51:249 (1) - Remove the new combo, now add new combo here 00:51:963 (10).
00:54:106 (1) - If you agree with the previous point then remove the new combo, and now add new combo here 00:54:820 (8).
00:59:820 (1) - Another combo suggestion, remove the new combo and put nc here 01:00:534 (5) and remove new combo 01:01:249 (1).
01:13:392 (4) - Missing finish at the start.
01:21:785 (1) - Add finish at the end and start, now remove the clap here 01:22:320 (2) and add finish.
01:26:249 (4) - Finish at the start.
01:26:963 (6,7) - Add finish instead clap.

Garven wrote:

[jieusieu's Hard]
00:59:106 (1) - mm I'd reserve 1/2 after a spinner for Insane difficulties.
00:59:106 (1,2) - Disappointed at the lack of hitsounding during such a powerful part. :<
01:27:588 (1) - End this at 01:28:570 - like in bliss' difficulties.
Good use of patterns here - good job!

Garven wrote:

[SK's Normal]
00:02:856 (2) - Maybe add a repeat? Feels empty otherwise Repeat here will be weird, so i moved the spinner to red tick.
00:12:677 (1) - Should move this closer to the center to aid in recovery. It's borderline soon afterward as is. I Really have to change this? will keep this for now and will and I will ask my sister a opinion (she's a a beginner here).
00:22:677 (2,1) - Feels a tad close. Don't see any problem with this...
00:40:534 (5,1) - That jump intended? Doesn't fit with the rest of your mapping. Oh i forgot! Fixed!
00:53:749 (3) - Add clap
01:06:606 (1) - Way too soon after a spinner for a Normal Intended to make this here.
01:10:356 - Add a note or make the spinner start here Started spinner here
01:27:677 (1) - End this at the red tick like Bliss' diffs. Ok

Garven wrote:

[Vicho]
01:14:284 (2) - Still fairly covered by the hitburst

NoHitter wrote:

Random check.

[Easy]
00:03:749 (3) - I think it would be better if you move this 1/2 back then extend by 1/2. It fits more as the music starts at 00:03:570. Done, sort of a quick fix, but I think it works.
00:09:106 (2,3) - Perhaps center this like so? It looks better aesthetically. I think it is better aesthetically if 2 follows the previous slider since there is still a shadow of it on screen when it first starts. Also, you don't have an axis while playing, so it is hard to judge where is the center, losing some of the aesthetic effect.
00:15:534 (3) - I find it odd this slider ends at an "empty" part of the song when most of the hitobjects so far have been on lyrics/strong parts of the song. The "ooooh" sound is still being held and I rather have the red tick to red tick transition I have right now than a more difficult white tick to red tick one.
00:18:391 (1) - Spacing is inconsistent with next notes, but I don't know how exactly to fix. Done.... That took a while to fix.
00:40:177 (1) - [nazi] Move one grid right. It's too close to 00:39:106 (2). Done.
00:42:320 (1) - It would fit the current rhythm pattern more if you move this back 1/1 to 00:41:963. ] I know this is a bit weird, but I like to keep the lyrical snap
01:21:248 (3) - Same as 00:15:534 (3). Same response as 00:15:534 (3).

[Rush!]
00:59:106 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - Tricky... It is not that bad imo.....(I am probably going to refuse most changes to this pattern just because it is the most iconic part of the map right now..... xD(horrible reasoning))
Fine otherwise xD

Not going to pop, but please consider fixing.

NoHitter wrote:

[jieusieu's Hard]
00:20:881 () - Map this part? A break here is unneeded.

NoHitter wrote:

[SK's Normal]
00:02:142 (1,2) - A pattern involving two one-repeat sliders will flow better IMO. Like this. Okay, fixed but made this: http://puu.sh/CAxX
00:37:320 (5,6) - [nazi] One grid right. To align with 00:36:249 (3). Okay
00:53:034 (2) - I have a suggestion for your hitsounding scheme. Add a clap at the end. (Similar mods in spoilerbox.) Fixed

SPOILER

00:54:106 (4) - Add clap Fixed
00:54:463 (5) - Add clap at 00:54:820 Fixed
00:55:892 (2) - Add clap at beginning. Add finish at the end. Fixed
00:57:320 (4) - Add clap Fixed

01:06:249 (5) - Add finish for consistency with your current hitsounding scheme. Fixed
01:09:463 (2) - Add clap at the start. ^ OKAY

1. Everything appears to check out.

1. Add +1 HP drain. In my opinion, 1 for any stat is much too low and easy.
2. 00:03:034 (2) - Short sliders like these with such an intense curve don't look very visually appealing.
3. 00:03:570 (3) - This slider is asymmetrical at the bottom part of it. I fixed it up a bit for you -
   

   342,351,3570,2,0,B|404:327|408:280|398:236|372:214|372:214|351:191|320:168|312:120|

4. 00:11:962 (1) - You should add a whistle to this circle along with the finish to follow your hitsound pattern. You also did this at 00:05:534 (1).
5. 00:16:963 (5) - The curving point of this slider is hidden. Not that this is unrankable, but it doesn't necessarily look good.
6. 00:21:249 (2) - See my first suggestion.
7. 00:43:391 (1) - Since this slider starts following the vocals, it should also end that way in order to avoid odd sounding sliders. Shorten it by one tick.
8. 01:04:105 (3) - What happened to the claps on this slider?

1. 00:02:856 (2) - Add a whistle to the beginning of this slider. It follows the music.
2. 00:44:106 (4) - Straighten out this slider. It looks neater.

1. 00:33:749 (6) - To feel less awkward to play, this slider should end one 1/4th tick shorter. Start the repeat slider directly after it.
2. 01:16:784 (8) - ^ (But this one will be a short 1/4th slider.)

1. 00:08:392 (1,2,3,4,5) - Perhaps you could space these out farther as jumps so that they don't become cluttered with hitbursts.
2. 00:17:767 (1) - The break after this spinner shouldn't be there. It's not even in the easy difficulty.

1. Nice work.

Jacob wrote:

Hello!

General

1. Everything appears to check out.

Easy

1. Add +1 HP drain. In my opinion, 1 for any stat is much too low and easy. Done.
2. 00:03:034 (2) - Short sliders like these with such an intense curve don't look very visually appealing. Sort of fixed.
3. 00:03:570 (3) - This slider is asymmetrical at the bottom part of it. I fixed it up a bit for you -
   

   342,351,3570,2,0,B|404:327|408:280|398:236|372:214|372:214|351:191|320:168|312:120|

   Since I had to fix some of teh top part of the slider, I fixed it up myself, but thanks.
4. 00:11:962 (1) - You should add a whistle to this circle along with the finish to follow your hitsound pattern. You also did this at 00:05:534 (1). Done.
5. 00:16:963 (5) - The curving point of this slider is hidden. Not that this is unrankable, but it doesn't necessarily look good. I actually like how all sharp corners are hidden and a pinwheel shape is formed, so minimal changes to clean up a small visible part during gameplay.
6. 00:21:249 (2) - See my first suggestion. This one is staying for symmetry purposes.
7. 00:43:391 (1) - Since this slider starts following the vocals, it should also end that way in order to avoid odd sounding sliders. Shorten it by one tick. Having a 1.5 white tick difference between notes is harder for an easy than an extended slider, so I am not changing this.
8. 01:04:105 (3) - What happened to the claps on this slider? Fixed.

SK's Normal

1. 00:02:856 (2) - Add a whistle to the beginning of this slider. It follows the music.
2. 00:44:106 (4) - Straighten out this slider. It looks neater.

Vicho's Hard Edit: Vicho said he prefers no changes.

1. 00:33:749 (6) - To feel less awkward to play, this slider should end one 1/4th tick shorter. Start the repeat slider directly after it.
2. 01:16:784 (8) - ^ (But this one will be a short 1/4th slider.)

jieusieu's Hard Edit: jieusieu fixed the break (forgot to upload the updated copy) and did not want to fix the first item.

1. 00:08:392 (1,2,3,4,5) - Perhaps you could space these out farther as jumps so that they don't become cluttered with hitbursts.
2. 00:17:767 (1) - The break after this spinner shouldn't be there. It's not even in the easy difficulty.

Rush!

1. Nice work.

Sorry, but this mod was rushed due to real life circumstances. If you want, throw me a PM or chat me via IRC and I will do a full recheck without the need of kudosu. Good luck! Your mod was fine, don't worry.