forum

Mayday is the best map ever

posted
Total Posts
43
Topic Starter
[MTF] Wolfette
Mayday takes everything that is great about rustbell maps, the structure of rrtyui maps, and the SV control of handsome maps, creating something truly amazing. All the patterns look good and make sense, the storyboard is amazing, the skin is nice, and the 2b gimmick is very well executed.

It's also amazing how the map doesn't autofail. Who knows how that works?

2017 was graces of heaven, 2018 is mayday.

Come to me when you see a map of a very niche genre and mapping style that pulls it off as perfectly as mayday. Do it.
worst fl player
add this to the beasttrollmc tribute section
Kaine
i disagree
Jatie
how is graces of heaven best of 2017 it was mapped in 2014
Topic Starter
[MTF] Wolfette

Jatie wrote:

how is graces of heaven best of 2017 it was mapped in 2014


It was loved in 2017
Momoi Airi
Mayday map can be challenging for me to get better combo on that cuz I can't 2B for balls.
I can agree about that. Definitely A E S T H E T I C
Topic Starter
[MTF] Wolfette

Kaine wrote:

i disagree


Then what’s the best map ever?
D_Loomz

AsrielDr33murr wrote:

Kaine wrote:

i disagree
Then what’s the best map ever?
Why even bother what's the best map? There are good ones, bad ones and mediocre, best is too relative. Also not only aesthetics can make a map good coz that map is made purely for only that one purpose.

This topic is also harshly GnR material, rather OT.
Akanagi
Ya I love 1/2 spam maps.
Maps are meant to be played, not to be some kind of canvas. If you look at the map from a gameplay perspective, it sucks.
I'm pretty sure that quite a few people who like that map are Beast fans who just adapt his opinions.

The song is nice, though.
Topic Starter
[MTF] Wolfette

Rayne wrote:

Ya I love 1/2 spam maps.
Maps are meant to be played, not to be some kind of canvas. If you look at the map from a gameplay perspective, it sucks.
I'm pretty sure that quite a few people who like that map are Beast fans who just adapt his opinions.

The song is nice, though.


I’m not a beast fan tho. I just like how it pulls off the 2b gimmick so well
ManuelOsuPlayer
That map isn't nearly to be the best to my preferences.
As an art piece 8/10
As a map to have fun and enjoy while playing 1/10.

I don't know exactly what map i would say is the best ever. But prob would be something like:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/534280
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/411435
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/210731
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/323329
https://osu.ppy.sh/b/722934?m=0
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/468418
https://osu.ppy.sh/b/826968&m=0

There is hundreds of good maps.
-Makishima S-

AsrielDr33murr wrote:

Kaine wrote:

i disagree
Then what’s the best map ever?
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/107565

- Considered as best map ever made by top players
- Most upvotes in reddit poll about best map
I could find more achievements what this one map made in term of quality and playability.
mulraf
you mean this one? https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1605148 or did i get the wrong map? if yes then wow, well, to each his own i guess. i mean it's definitely not bad but if you bring up rrtyui i e.g. i wouldn't consider the map being close in an artsy battle. if i may take my favorite example, reality distortion, i find the patterns and product way more interesting both to look at and to play. and while mapping is always very subjective, as a video editor, i'll definitely have to say that even comparing the storyboards would be an insult to reality distortion, the technique behind the sb of it is just miles apart (while i have to say mayday has a nice storyboard, i really don't want to make it sound bad it's just that rrtyui's sb is too great and imho the best storyboard i've ever seen.)

while talking about all this fancyness i have to say that usually i'm a pretty vanilla guy and i preffer to play stuff like neonat's MariannE, MashaSG's Ashes of the Dawn, Brocolly's Towa yori Towa ni or at the most technical it gets MaridiuS' Lost Emotions or ProffessionalBox's d: for the delta.

how not to autofail a 2b map? just keep the sliders short and try around with spinners. i've made a topic on this too and on reddit you can find some stuff. eg. if you look at Probox's aspire or monstrata's aspire or the map by me in my signature you'll see that there are many 2b maps that don't auto-fail.
Buster
C A L L I N G O U T M A Y D AY
Topic Starter
[MTF] Wolfette

TheQuacking666 wrote:

C A L L I N G O U T M A Y D AY

Heheh
Deva
How is spamming circle shaped sliders that are too big to fit on screen aesthetically pleasing? I'd say it takes everything that's good about rustbell maps and fucks them up beyond repair.

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/83560 has much better SB imo and I'd bet there are tons of others (I don't play with SB so I don't know many examples)

I agree that the song is awesome though
Topic Starter
[MTF] Wolfette

Deva wrote:

How is spamming circle shaped sliders that are too big to fit on screen aesthetically pleasing? I'd say it takes everything that's good about rustbell maps and fucks them up beyond repair.

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/83560 has much better SB imo and I'd bet there are tons of others (I don't play with SB so I don't know many examples)

I agree that the song is awesome though


Lol are you drunk?
Deva
Playing that map was extremely unenjoyable experience for me

Also considering that I've played probably 100x more maps than you did I'm not sure how our opinions can even be compared ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
And that map is usually praised by people who have played like 10 maps out of which 9 are jump only farm maps (except for a few retarded individuals and even fewer ones who say it's good just to fit in)

Also v3.0 this is just my opinion so go fuck yourself
Nao Tomori
bro its a meme
Tae
p/6529855
g i m m i c k s
Caput Mortuum
is this ot
Topic Starter
[MTF] Wolfette

Tae wrote:

https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/6529855
g i m m i c k s


That comment was a joke
ManuelOsuPlayer

Deva wrote:

Playing that map was extremely unenjoyable experience for me

Also considering that I've played probably 100x more maps than you did I'm not sure how our opinions can even be compared ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
And that map is usually praised by people who have played like 10 maps out of which 9 are jump only farm maps (except for a few retarded individuals and even fewer ones who say it's good just to fit in)

Also v3.0 this is just my opinion so go fuck yourself
I also have played thousands of different maps and think mayday is boring thrash.
Kondou-Shinichi
Aesthetically pleasing? Try ikenai borderline

Mayday offers one of the most boring gameplay that pp maps can't even begin to compete
Some of the sliders are ok, but kiai is a giant mess
With that said, I don't think the map is bad, it's just far (very) from the best map

Remember that ikenai borderline? the one in the loved section that you guys complained about that it's a unplayable art?
I would say that map is even more interesting, more aesthetically looking (the sliders are beautiful man)

Thanks to BeastTrollMC, mayfay was overrated as fucking hell
again, the map isnt bad, but it's far from the best.
Topic Starter
[MTF] Wolfette

Kondou-Shinichi wrote:

Aesthetically pleasing? Try ikenai borderline

Mayday offers one of the most boring gameplay that pp maps can't even begin to compete
Some of the sliders are ok, but kiai is a giant mess
With that said, I don't think the map is bad, it's just far (very) from the best map

Remember that ikenai borderline? the one in the loved section that you guys complained about that it's a unplayable art?
I would say that map is even more interesting, more aesthetically looking (the sliders are beautiful man)

Thanks to BeastTrollMC, mayfay was overrated as fucking hell
again, the map isnt bad, but it's far from the best.


Umm… I’ve played ikenai borderline. Wasn’t really a fan since it’s pretty much unplayable at no mod speed. It’s only possible to actually hit the sliders properly at HT speed.
Kondou-Shinichi

AsrielDr33murr wrote:

Umm… I’ve played ikenai borderline. Wasn’t really a fan since it’s pretty much unplayable at no mod speed. It’s only possible to actually hit the sliders properly at HT speed.
you don't say. but you see, even following sliderticks only is more interesting than 1/2 singletaps for like the whole fucking map

also, the mapper actually poured tons of efforts onto the sliders, whereas mayday? most are just copy pastes/random circle sliders (notably kiai)
Topic Starter
[MTF] Wolfette

Kondou-Shinichi wrote:

AsrielDr33murr wrote:

Umm… I’ve played ikenai borderline. Wasn’t really a fan since it’s pretty much unplayable at no mod speed. It’s only possible to actually hit the sliders properly at HT speed.

you don't say. but you see, even following sliderticks only is more interesting than 1/2 singletaps for like the whole fucking map


The former is obviously worse. It feels unfair to be expected to hit so many weirdly placed ticks with dodgy hitboxes.
Kondou-Shinichi

AsrielDr33murr wrote:

The former is obviously worse. It feels unfair to be expected to hit so many weirdly placed ticks with dodgy hitboxes.
yes yes yes, I think you missed the point.

all I wanted to say is that mayday is fucking boring, and even a unplayable map ppays more interesting than it.
Topic Starter
[MTF] Wolfette

Kondou-Shinichi wrote:

AsrielDr33murr wrote:

The former is obviously worse. It feels unfair to be expected to hit so many weirdly placed ticks with dodgy hitboxes.

yes yes yes, I think you missed the point.

all I wanted to say is that mayday is fucking boring, and even a unplayable map ppays more interesting than it.


Pretty much any of hollow wings’ low bpm marathon shit maps is the worst. I don’t think you entirely know what boring is.
Kondou-Shinichi

AsrielDr33murr wrote:

Pretty much any of hollow wings’ low bpm marathon shit maps is the worst. I don’t think you entirely know what boring is.
what did you expect from low bpm low sr maps? intense gameplay?
Topic Starter
[MTF] Wolfette

Kondou-Shinichi wrote:

AsrielDr33murr wrote:

Pretty much any of hollow wings’ low bpm marathon shit maps is the worst. I don’t think you entirely know what boring is.

what did you expect from low bpm low sr maps? intense gameplay?


No, but I at least expect an interesting gimmick to keep me from falling asleep and keep the map from being shite.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply