realy0_ wrote:
I dunno how this proposal works on the vs. songs, they are basically song complilations because you merge multiples originals songs into one
Yes, vs type maps would be included in this and would require some kind of logical relation between them to be fine, so stuff like
this and
this wouldn't be allowed under this rule.
@Monstrata, thanks for the replies to Krfawy, I pretty much agree with it completely, now as for this
Monstrata wrote:
As for the original proposal though, "More vague relations like simply the same artist,"
> What? Songs from the same artist should not be a "vague relation". They are a direct relation. Songs shouldn't just have to sound the same to be part of the same compilation. You can have songs from wildly different genre's mixed into the same song (ALIEN), you can have the same singer (same voice) singing to widely different music genres. This part of the proposal absolutely needs to change.
Okay, first of all I'll say I'm willing to change this if it's absolutely necessary for the rest of the proposal to pass, but for now I'll just give my full thoughts as to why I put having the artist as the only relation between songs in the 10 min category.
OKAAY SO, let me just address the ALIEN part first. The difference between that and slamming 2 songs from the same artist together, is that ALIEN is one song, the huge contrast between the parts of ALIEN are the intended effect of the musicians who made the song. Which is why I think it's irrelevant to bring it up when talking about putting two wildly different songs from the same artist together, one is the intended experience, the other is not.
Now why put it in the 10 min category? Because I believe that putting 2 songs of the same artist together, when they have nothing in common, isn't fitting. Like you said artists create wildly different songs, so putting them together under the basis that the person who made them is the same just isn't good enough in my eyes to justify the songs being associated with one another and to make them part of the same experience.
Here's where the 10 min part fixes this, larger compilations, those that feature a much larger part of the work of an artist work, instead of associating two songs together, serve to give a variety and showcase of what a specific artist can do. Good example of this are
Demetori - Songs Compilation and
sana - Songs Compilation The intended experience here completely changes, and the large amount of songs shown in these helps alleviate the issue of the songs not necessarily fitting with one another.
Hopefully this helps clear up some confusion as to why artist was put where it is in the rule