trot was here
forum
Ryu* vs. kors k - Force of Wind
posted
Total Posts
160
Michi wrote:
rank pls
Topic Starter
post 88 was a german
>signs
>signs
Extra would be great if it didn't have circle stream jumps
It's barely playable with them in it. It creates a jerky movement that doesn't fit the rest of the difficulty.
Wait, I think I said that already
It's barely playable with them in it. It creates a jerky movement that doesn't fit the rest of the difficulty.
Wait, I think I said that already
Circle stream jumps are unplayable.
Hate to say it I usually enjoy your maps, but those circle stream jumps just totally ruin the flow and make the map unplayable.
Hate to say it I usually enjoy your maps, but those circle stream jumps just totally ruin the flow and make the map unplayable.
Auto doesn't 100% the Extra.
Not to mention the 1/4 jumps are impossible to hit.
Not to mention the 1/4 jumps are impossible to hit.
Very true.Love wrote:
Auto doesn't 100% the Extra.
Not to mention the 1/4 jumps are impossible to hit.
01:03:785 (1) - Auto 100's at the end because of the distance. You should stack it on top of 01:05:141 (1) - or a little more to the left if you want, as long as auto doesn't 100. Also you need extend it one more tick on 1/8th so it's accurate to the music.
Topic Starter
Fixed the slider, though I liked how a player could possibly gain more accuracy than auto on a map.
quoting Michi is funMichi wrote:
pussies
Topic Starter
Zarerion, Michi, you're not helping.
If it was for stream-stream-stream jumps, I can see that, those mostly suck but as this is slider-stream-slider, it is possible due to the slider leniency system; I've had various testers (e.g. Rucker, rrtyui, Michi, tsuka, myself if you want to count that) and none of those/"us" had problems catching them, though, there's one or two things I consider changing when I'm back at my host's house.
If it was for stream-stream-stream jumps, I can see that, those mostly suck but as this is slider-stream-slider, it is possible due to the slider leniency system; I've had various testers (e.g. Rucker, rrtyui, Michi, tsuka, myself if you want to count that) and none of those/"us" had problems catching them, though, there's one or two things I consider changing when I'm back at my host's house.
I don't think the stream jumps are as bad as they're made out to be. I don't know about mouse users but they're pretty intuitive and easy to catch with the tablet.
Anyway, the bubble was popped for that slider, why isn't it rebubbled yet?
Topic Starter
galv, they're fine on my end and I did put thought into them being doable while mapping - you know, I'm not the healthiest (-> fastest, in this case) on this game and I'm fine with anything like what I mapped here so yeah, my 2ct as the mapper
@Zarerion: MMzz wanted to fullmod it but did not get to it yet, it appears
@Zarerion: MMzz wanted to fullmod it but did not get to it yet, it appears
Let me just point this out:
That map is now approved, no one cared about Auto not SS'ing. So why would you, MMzz, pop the bubble here? And more importantly, not rebubble it immediately after it's "fixed"?
If a BAT can't "get to" recheck a map, he shouldn't pop a bubble (for no reason) in the first place.
This is a quote from Charles about RLC's new map "The Pretender" (which got approved in 6 days, but that's another story)Charles445 wrote:
Auto doesn't know how to handle extremely short repeat sliders very well. It appears to let go of the slider too soon.
This isn't a problem with the map, this is just how auto plays.
That map is now approved, no one cared about Auto not SS'ing. So why would you, MMzz, pop the bubble here? And more importantly, not rebubble it immediately after it's "fixed"?
If a BAT can't "get to" recheck a map, he shouldn't pop a bubble (for no reason) in the first place.
Seems like he isn't coming back..
Topic Starter
your turn then, gabe :v
okay~~with MMzz's agree~~lemmi take a look what can i help :>
red - must be fixed
blue - highly recommend to consider
black - only suggestions
[General]
i'm sorry but i can't bubble the map until you solve that.
red - must be fixed
blue - highly recommend to consider
black - only suggestions
[General]
- The star rating of the lowest diff is over 3.24 :<
- Disable count down since you didn't leave enough space to it
- ArtistUnicode : Ryu☆
- Some of your diffs are still v11, just simply open them and save directly~
- 00:20:395 (1) - split to two sliders?
- 01:47:514 (2,3) - actually i expect a 4-ticks reverse slider here~ combine them together?
- 00:07:684 (12,13) - ctrl+g for better flow?
- 00:12:599 (1,2) - i suppose slider first and then note is better~~
- 01:24:124 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13) - this kinda stream maybe too hard for this diff..
- 02:28:870 (5) - move to 256:142? also difficulty issue
- AR+1
- 00:43:785 (1,1,1) - if this is a Normal diff these spinners are too long. if this is a Hard, your difficulty setting is too low.
- 01:15:989 (1,2,3) - ^, similar case, also 01:17:345 (1,2,3) - . These note are hard to click for new players.
i'm sorry but i can't bubble the map until you solve that.
Topic Starter
what's your suggestion to solve the spread issue? remove one or more diffs or redesign (which?) parts of diffs?
(as i don't have internet at home right now i will try to figure out things and talk to you asap)
(as i don't have internet at home right now i will try to figure out things and talk to you asap)
Topic Starter
Rebuilt parts of Ultimate's diff - star rating is now correct; KiyoshiX101 is on an SB.
(Also applied the other suggestions)
SB is done!!
(Also applied the other suggestions)
SB is done!!
Also~
There's Inconsistency in Kiai Times~
Snap all Kiai times in all difficulties to the same Beginning and Ending time. :3
There's Inconsistency in Kiai Times~
Snap all Kiai times in all difficulties to the same Beginning and Ending time. :3
Topic Starter
The maps are meant to have the kiaitimes of their respective mapper's preference so that's a wanted 'issue' - can change that in case a BAT sees it as a bad thing but in general, I like this diversity to distinguish mappers.
Renamed galv's diff (to make it more apparent what level it is) and the Starter with Ultimate's agreement (as it apparently is more of a Collab-Redesign thing now?).
Renamed galv's diff (to make it more apparent what level it is) and the Starter with Ultimate's agreement (as it apparently is more of a Collab-Redesign thing now?).
Topic Starter
Scorp, you coming back? >:
[Extra]
- 01:21:284 (3) - Unsnapped (1ms off)
Topic Starter
Fixed~ (update took me like 15 minutes because of crapnet <_<)
rebubbled~~
Well, selecting which diff will be in or out is mapset owner's decision, but making a diff isn't that easy job, even it's a Taiko diff. At least you should notify me about excluding my Taiko diff from it. Nothing will prevent this to be ranked, but don't forget that I felt bad after I know that you excluded my diff from your mapset.
Did I give my guest Taiko diff too easily? Hmm.
Did I give my guest Taiko diff too easily? Hmm.
Topic Starter
I tried contacting you but you kinda were gone for ages and for the last two months, I did not have internet available at home/workplace - I saved the diff as stated IRC and as said, I'm planning to re-upload it in a Taiko- and Full Version set, to not have it cut and make your effort wasted.
I also removed my own (and winber's) diffs, so please don't say it like I did just kick you out for the lulz.
I'm sorry if I made it sound wrong but I took long enough to take that into consideration and I will not just dumb any diffs mapped for or by me.
I also removed my own (and winber's) diffs, so please don't say it like I did just kick you out for the lulz.
I'm sorry if I made it sound wrong but I took long enough to take that into consideration and I will not just dumb any diffs mapped for or by me.
- The current Artist and Title aren't exactly correct (Reference)SPOILER
Track: 18
Title: Force of wind
Desciption: New song for album / A collaboration song with kors k - As there's none of specific Artist name for this track was provided on the webpage , I would suggest to use this form:
Artist: Ryu☆ & kors k
Romanised Artist: Ryu* & kors k
Title: Force of wind
Romanised Title: Force of wind
And a little question here...I'm curious about the reason of adding the "beatmap" tag xD
Anyways, I'll give a full check asap, popped for now
Topic Starter
removed beatmap tag and changed the artist name to be more precise
the reasoning for using "feat." is, that all of Ryu*'s songs in this album add up to one big .mp3, also called Starmine Compilation/Marathon
kors k is some kind of "guest" for this part, so I think "feat." is better than "&", because it sounds more like Ryu* is the real "host" of the song this way, which he is, as the whole Starmine Marathon is "his project" - I hope this makes sense to you o3o
the reasoning for using "feat." is, that all of Ryu*'s songs in this album add up to one big .mp3, also called Starmine Compilation/Marathon
kors k is some kind of "guest" for this part, so I think "feat." is better than "&", because it sounds more like Ryu* is the real "host" of the song this way, which he is, as the whole Starmine Marathon is "his project" - I hope this makes sense to you o3o
metadata help, here is the booklet scan:
that is, title as 'Force of wind' and artist as 'the 4th (Ryu☆ vs. kors k)'
that is, title as 'Force of wind' and artist as 'the 4th (Ryu☆ vs. kors k)'
I've already got one from here. So please don't give kds to this post!
And.... seems I'm not able to rank this due to some big changes, please call me back for a bubble repair
Red: Unrankable issues or Highly recommended
Black: Opinions
General
- As informed through irc chats, I tired to gather a few opinions from other staffs (5 of total amount), 4 of them agreed for the revision of fixing uppercase W to a lowercase one. Indeed I'm a bit stubborn on this case, hehe xD
- And about the epilepsy warning, hmm... As if enabled from song's setting, it would provide a permission to disable storyboard from the 1st play until you leave a score on the mapset. Plus, the lead-in stuff would be skipped after a retry (Which storyboard warning couldn't). Hence, I'd recommend to remove the customized warning and check the option from song's setting.
Extra
01:17:175 (8) - , 01:18:531 (8) - Slider's arrow is totally invisable, there's no way to indentify these objects as a reverse slider. I would highly recommend to fix this stuff before getting it to be ranked status. And I've found those slow down of slider's speed on these two 1/8s, is there any specific reasons? As this problem could be solved by increasing the slider's speed, I would suggest to remove two slow downs.
gAlv's 'nother
- 00:32:938 - The drain width is kinda dangerous on this section (dropped under 75%), I would suggest to cut combos on 00:35:650 (4) - and 00:49:209 (5) -
01:08:870 (1) - Is it intentional for a single new combo here? It isn't a must to rearrange the combo pattern or not, but it does look weird when comparing to other combos.
01:31:667 (1) - ^
02:01:921 (9) - May need to cut off the new combo here as well
02:39:887 (6) - This clap was misplaced, it should be on the slider tail of 02:39:548 (5) -
02:50:734 (1) - And again a removable new combo
Hyper
- 01:42:345 (6) - This was stacked to a position which is kinda unreadable, I would suggest to stack this manually like this:
02:52:938 (1,1) - Jenny so tricky, please extend the spacing to -at least- 1.20x to avoid a mislead on rhythm. For example:
Intermediate
- 00:43:785 (1) - There's only 1 beat to next spinner which has a difference with following spinners, please crop it at 00:48:192 -
And.... seems I'm not able to rank this due to some big changes, please call me back for a bubble repair
Topic Starter
Fixed the diff specific changes (and added a few NCs on galv's diff); as for the General things... you're not the only stubborn person, orz
I and the people and I asked think that the capital W does look better and in this case, does "outweigh" the 'correct form' because a lower case W does kinda look like an accident in the song title (not to say bad).
About the epilepsy warning, I think it's better like this because it is not bound to have a player retry the map in order to skip the leadIn/warning - I find it kinda compatible and suiting as-is; urging the player to retry the map in order to play the start properly is some thing I don't see a point in, neither in adding an unwantedly long leadIn to "counter" the long display time of the default warning because that'd kinda be in the way when retrying.
What I am trying to say on this point is, at the current state I find it to be the allround-best solution to keep the custom warning and current leadIn time, may be personal opinion though.
I and the people and I asked think that the capital W does look better and in this case, does "outweigh" the 'correct form' because a lower case W does kinda look like an accident in the song title (not to say bad).
About the epilepsy warning, I think it's better like this because it is not bound to have a player retry the map in order to skip the leadIn/warning - I find it kinda compatible and suiting as-is; urging the player to retry the map in order to play the start properly is some thing I don't see a point in, neither in adding an unwantedly long leadIn to "counter" the long display time of the default warning because that'd kinda be in the way when retrying.
What I am trying to say on this point is, at the current state I find it to be the allround-best solution to keep the custom warning and current leadIn time, may be personal opinion though.
Alright then, rechecked. I'll give a pass to those two general issues.
And in additional, please log your changes next time (especially those weren't included in previous modding's content)
To next BAT: Feel free to have another pop if any objection according to the title and epilepsy warning.
And in additional, please log your changes next time (especially those weren't included in previous modding's content)
To next BAT: Feel free to have another pop if any objection according to the title and epilepsy warning.
If you have evidence showing that the artist intended it to be in that form, you should set it that way. I came across this same issue with another song recently that has nonstandard and redundant nomenclature, but nevertheless, that is how the artist wants it, so thats how we set it.
I don't see it, seriously.