forum

Megpoid GUMI - Dark Parade

posted
Total Posts
39
show more
No_Gu
sp3你太有前途了
DarknessAngel
request from in-game
sorry來晚了
3分鐘4難度啊...orz

General

  1. 00:37:121 (1) 和 01:31:904 (1) - 這裡明顯不是副歌而且也沒有很激情(?,為啥開kai咧 ? :O
  2. (01:08:317)和(01:08:426) - 分別關掉和開啟kai嗎 ? 總覺得效果會比較好(純屬建議)

Easy

  1. 00:36:795 (2) - 這finish得刪掉,跟後面那個finish配合之後的結果,反而是第一個太過突兀,Kai的finish的強調效果被蓋過
  2. 01:08:099 (2) - 這個finish去掉比較好喔。因為finish太頻繁就做不出應有的強調效果,這時機應該要這麼做的(全難度適用)
  3. 01:17:556 (1) - 尾部finish換成whistle,這樣比較能襯托出最後一個鑼聲finish(結束)的感覺。使用whistle的目的在於你對歌曲中「啦 ~ 」的強調的讓步(好啦,其實不加whistle就有點奇怪了XD)
  4. 01:18:860 (1) - 不加clap嗎 ? 音樂中有個鼓聲,加上去聽起來不錯
  5. 02:02:882 (2) - finish砍掉。理由同[01:08:099 (2)]
  6. 02:54:404 (2) - 尾部的finish去掉。理由同[01:08:099 (2)]
  7. 03:10:056 (1) - 箭頭上的whistle移到中間。聽聽看演唱者的音調,箭頭上的比尾部的要高,所以加在箭頭上較為好
  8. 03:13:643 (1) - 要不要在尾部加個soft-clap2 ? 我覺得這樣還不錯
    順便一提,這slider拉的真厲害啊...我學不來orz

Normal

  1. 02:29:295 (1) - 頭上不來個finish嗎 ? [02:34:513 (1)]有加喔
  2. 01:36:469 (4) - 因為頭上的clap而造成尾部這個「慣例的clap」的違和感,尾部的clap刪了比較好聽
  3. 03:13:643 (1) - 我再度為這個slider表示讚嘆XD

TuHard



  • 這難度名真有特色...
  1. 01:08:099 (6) - 頭上加個clap嗎 ?
  2. 01:13:317 (9) - 總覺得尾部的clap有點多餘了呢,刪掉比較好聽
  3. 02:38:426 (6) - 頭上是不是忘了放個whistle ? 這一大段就這裡沒有呢:O
  4. 03:00:599 (1) - 要不要加個soft-clap2在這呢 ? 前兩段的這裡你都有加鑼聲音效,可是這裡沒有
    如果覺得soft-clap2不好的話,調低[02:59:947 (6)]尾部soft-finish的音量,然後在[03:00:599 (1)]放個正常音量的finish
  5. 03:14:621 (4) - 頭尾都放上clap嗎 ? 音樂中有鼓聲
  6. 這音效我喜歡,很棒 ~

Spinboxer

  1. 00:24:621 (1) - 你躲在後面害羞啥 ? 露出一點好讓人看到啊
  2. 00:26:034 (4) - 這個soft-clap2不是很好,有點突兀了,換成普通的吧 ?
  3. 00:35:817 (5,6) - 頭上都放個whistle嗎 ? 搭配[00:34:186 (1,2)]的whistle效果不錯
  4. 這難度的finish的使用比Easy收斂許多,不錯 ~
    稍微說一下,這譜面有很多是一長串長條不斷連結而成,我覺得有點沒變化了,可以放個note或停頓一下之類增加難度和變化性
    (畢竟是最難難度),啊啊,這意思不是說你的圖不好,我只是說說我個人的淺見罷了 ~


恩,這是好圖
常常受你的關照了,感謝不盡m(_ _)m
好圖射顆星,感謝的小心意再+1顆><
加油,祝好運!
LKs
mod req from in-game PM

General

Errors

  1. countdown in all diffs is useless
  2. [Events]
    //Background and Video events
    0,0,"BG.jpg"
    Video,-30,"gumi - Dark Parade.avi"
    用于修改视频的插入时间 之前的有点慢
Easy

00:24:078 (1,1,1) - 既然这里spacing没变 我觉得NC的视觉效果不如不NC
00:34:513 (1,1,1) -
00:44:947 (1,1,1) -
00:55:382 (1,1,1) -
01:05:817 (1,1,1) -
01:16:252 (1,1,1) -
01:16:252 (1,1,1) -
01:39:730 (1,1,1) -
02:11:034 (1,1,1) -
03:03:208 (1,1,1) - 还有 你这些NC的颜色顺序都不一样 如果要保留至少顺序一样
从歌曲开始一直到1分12秒 你的整个object打下来的感觉就是鼠标围着逆时针绕大圈 你可以看一遍..我觉得你可能是无意识的 但这毕竟有点
之后一直到2分钟是一直顺时钟绕大圈

Normal

normal和easy一样的问题
另外都有的问题还有finish并不太适合这首歌 尤其是连用 而你其他的音效又太少

TuHard

我马上要mod的下一张也有你的GD

00:37:773 (2) - 中间下clap
00:38:752 (3) - 别clap和whistle一起下 建议删clap
00:41:578 (5) - whistle在开头
01:00:491 (7) - 这NC位置很尴尬
迷迷糊糊听了半天突然感觉音效有点违和? 是不是这么下比较好
256,168,123534,5,8
144,84,123860,2,0,B|96:92|60:140,1,93.3333333333333,0|8
92,168,124186,2,0,B|112:220|160:232,1,93.3333333333333,0|8
204,256,124513,2,0,B|176:332|80:340,2,140,0|8|0
192,164,125382,2,0,B|220:120,1,46.6666666666667,0|8
要说理由的话我只能说尾音clap压着下一个音比较能塑造节奏感和紧迫感

Spinboxer

er没什么问题
但难度跨度和tuha相比有点小 至少AR到9吧
Cyril Scarlet






 ● vocaloid vocaloid2 : I think only vocaloid is fine because we can find all of them imo
 ● I think offset is a bit fast ? maybe only me. XD






- Fine for me


01:18:860 (1) - stop spinner at 01:21:469 ?






how about to increase volume (5%~10%)

since...

00:57:991 until 01:18:860
01:52:773 until 02:13:643
02:44:947 until 03:05:817



01:18:860 (1) - stop spinner at 01:21:469 ? I like to stop here :P
totally is fine for me , but I just think some part is hard for Normal, Probably.






Same opinion with Normal


00:27:013 (2) - stop slider at 00:27:230 and add note at 00:27:339 ?
00:29:839 - add note ?

00:59:947 - useless green line ? I saw these line are same with 00:57:991 and didn't change anything
01:00:273 - ^
01:18:208 - ^
01:18:534 - ^

01:50:165 (1) - I think change this spinner to note like these 00:55:382 (1,2,3,4,5,6)

01:21:469 - add note with finish sound ?
01:50:165 (1) - same opinion with Blue MOD

02:12:991 - useless green line ?
02:13:317 - ^

02:43:534 (5) - new combo ?
02:43:643 (1) - remove new combo

02:44:295 - useless green line ?
02:44:621 - ^
02:49:513 - ^
02:49:839 - ^
02:59:947 - ^
03:00:273 - ^
03:10:382 - ^
03:10:708 - ^






Same opinion with Normal


00:41:904 (7,8,9) - change to stream in this part is better for me
like this part ~ 00:52:013 (6,7,8,9,10,11) -
01:05:165 (7) - change to single note and try to add slider at 01:05:382 (8) ~ 01:05:599

01:21:469 - add note with finish sound ?

01:47:013 - add note ? stream at this part is better, I think.
Topic Starter
spboxer3

S i R i R u wrote:

STATUS : NOW MODDING







 ● vocaloid vocaloid2 : I think only vocaloid is fine because we can find all of them imo
 ● I think offset is a bit fast ? maybe only me. XD






- Fine for me


01:18:860 (1) - stop spinner at 01:21:469 ?






how about to increase volume (5%~10%)

since...

00:57:991 until 01:18:860
01:52:773 until 02:13:643
02:44:947 until 03:05:817



01:18:860 (1) - stop spinner at 01:21:469 ? I like to stop here :P
totally is fine for me , but I just think some part is hard for Normal, Probably.






Same opinion with Normal


00:27:013 (2) - stop slider at 00:27:230 and add note at 00:27:339 ?
00:29:839 - add note ?

00:59:947 - useless green line ? I saw these line are same with 00:57:991 and didn't change anything
01:00:273 - ^
01:18:208 - ^
01:18:534 - ^

01:50:165 (1) - I think change this spinner to note like these 00:55:382 (1,2,3,4,5,6)

01:21:469 - add note with finish sound ?
01:50:165 (1) - same opinion with Blue MOD

02:12:991 - useless green line ?
02:13:317 - ^

02:43:534 (5) - new combo ?
02:43:643 (1) - remove new combo

02:44:295 - useless green line ?
02:44:621 - ^
02:49:513 - ^
02:49:839 - ^
02:59:947 - ^
03:00:273 - ^
03:10:382 - ^
03:10:708 - ^






Same opinion with Normal


00:41:904 (7,8,9) - change to stream in this part is better for me
like this part ~ 00:52:013 (6,7,8,9,10,11) -
01:05:165 (7) - change to single note and try to add slider at 01:05:382 (8) ~ 01:05:599

01:21:469 - add note with finish sound ?

01:47:013 - add note ? stream at this part is better, I think.
thanks!! It's really helpful mod for me!
Kiddo-Kun
Hello.

General:

• Inconsistent audio leadin on tutuhaha's diff.

Easy:

• 01:03:208 (1) - Finish on the sliders start, please. You can hear a fairly clear cymbal crash in the music.
• 01:08:426 (1) - Crazy jump in an easy diff. Please use correct spacing.
• 01:13:643 (1) - Again, I was expecting a finish on this note...
• 01:18:860 (1) - Add a finish instead of a clap. It matches the music better, and a clap would only work if you end the spinner 1/1 note earlier.
• 01:50:165 (1,1,1) - These combos are inconsistent to the previous, identical pattern (00:55:382 (1,2,3) - )
• 02:43:643 - A note would fit here well in my opinion. It's a tad empty without one.
• 03:13:643 (1) - Change this slider. First off it looks hideous, and secondly, it overlaps itself.

Normal:

• 00:52:773 (1,3) - Remove the finish on (3) and put it on (1)'s start. It matches the music better that way.
• 01:14:295 (2,3) - There is an awkward flow between these two sliders. This pattern would play much better if you did this.
• 01:18:860 (1) - Add a finish instead of a clap. It matches the music better, and a clap would only work if you end the spinner 1/1 note earlier.
• 01:50:165 (1,1,1) - Just like the Easy difficulty, this is inconsistent with the previous pattern like this (00:55:382 (1,2,3) - ). Try to keep your comboing nice and consistent.
• 02:09:078 (2,3) - Just like before, it would flow better and play better if it was turned.
• 02:43:643 - Also just like the easy difficulty, a note will fit rather well here.
• 02:47:556 (1,1,1) - Finishes on all these slider starts to stay consistent with the previous kiais.

TuHard:

• 00:34:621 (1) - Yeah, this spinner seems very unfitting, and rather odd. I would just simply map through it.
• 01:39:730 (1) - ^ Only this one isn't as bad.

Spinboxer:

• 00:24:621 (1) - Slider track is not visible, which is a unrankable.
• 00:56:578 (1) - ^
• 02:49:947 (2,3) - 1/3rd notes after a slowdown slider does not play very well. Delete (2) to fix that.
• 02:59:947 (1,2,3) - ^

Overall:

I'm rather disappointed in the easier difficulties, they seem rather repetitive and seeing the same patterns over really gets boring. Other than that, this is a fairly well balanced mapset. I see space for improvement , but it's almost there.

Star.
Topic Starter
spboxer3

Kiddo-Kun wrote:

Hello.

General:

• Inconsistent audio leadin on tutuhaha's diff. Done

Easy:

• 01:03:208 (1) - Finish on the sliders start, please. You can hear a fairly clear cymbal crash in the music. ok
• 01:08:426 (1) - Crazy jump in an easy diff. Please use correct spacing. ok
• 01:13:643 (1) - Again, I was expecting a finish on this note... ok
• 01:18:860 (1) - Add a finish instead of a clap. It matches the music better, and a clap would only work if you end the spinner 1/1 note earlier. ok
• 01:50:165 (1,1,1) - These combos are inconsistent to the previous, identical pattern (00:55:382 (1,2,3) - ) ok
• 02:43:643 - A note would fit here well in my opinion. It's a tad empty without one. ok
• 03:13:643 (1) - Change this slider. First off it looks hideous, and secondly, it overlaps itself. ok

Normal:

• 00:52:773 (1,3) - Remove the finish on (3) and put it on (1)'s start. It matches the music better that way. ok
• 01:14:295 (2,3) - There is an awkward flow between these two sliders. This pattern would play much better if you did this. ok
• 01:18:860 (1) - Add a finish instead of a clap. It matches the music better, and a clap would only work if you end the spinner 1/1 note earlier. ok
• 01:50:165 (1,1,1) - Just like the Easy difficulty, this is inconsistent with the previous pattern like this (00:55:382 (1,2,3) - ). Try to keep your comboing nice and consistent. ok
• 02:09:078 (2,3) - Just like before, it would flow better and play better if it was turned. ok
• 02:43:643 - Also just like the easy difficulty, a note will fit rather well here. ok
• 02:47:556 (1,1,1) - Finishes on all these slider starts to stay consistent with the previous kiais. ok

TuHard:

• 00:34:621 (1) - Yeah, this spinner seems very unfitting, and rather odd. I would just simply map through it.
• 01:39:730 (1) - ^ Only this one isn't as bad.

Spinboxer:

• 00:24:621 (1) - Slider track is not visible, which is a unrankable. :o It's rankable ex: Bomfunk MC's - Freestyler
• 00:56:578 (1) - ^ ^
• 02:49:947 (2,3) - 1/3rd notes after a slowdown slider does not play very well. Delete (2) to fix that. It's too easy for kiai time ~ lol
• 02:59:947 (1,2,3) - ^ ^

Overall:

I'm rather disappointed in the easier difficulties, they seem rather repetitive and seeing the same patterns over really gets boring. Other than that, this is a fairly well balanced mapset. I see space for improvement , but it's almost there.

Star.
Thanks for mod and star >w<~
DarknessAngel
忍不住想說...
我每次看到這個心裡都很不舒服因為
你只回復特定幾個人
有點諂媚的感覺
Kiddo-Kun
As far as I'm concerned, this is not visible at all:


Thus rendering this un-rankable. And don't use Freestyler as an example, the covered up sliders are terrible in gameplay.


800th post~
Topic Starter
spboxer3

DarknessAngel wrote:

忍不住想說...
我每次看到這個心裡都很不舒服因為
你只回復特定幾個人
有點諂媚的感覺
並不是 只是因為我不想最近這兩張的post數太高... ((不然我以前都會回的~不信你可以去看我以前Rank的
我會回濕路路是因為人家在考試中還因為我之前的要求(還被我催好幾次) 特地跑來幫我mod 所以我有回
額...下次我會注意的...

Kiddo-Kun wrote:

As far as I'm concerned, this is not visible at all:


Thus rendering this un-rankable. And don't use Freestyler as an example, the covered up sliders are terrible in gameplay.


OK~fixed



800th post~
1400th post ~yeah I win \:D/
DJPop
- Delete tag "vocaloid2", only vocaloid should be enough
- Uncheck "Enable countdown" in storyboarding tab

~Easy~
02:01:252 (1,1) - remove new combo
02:41:034 (1,1) - ^ (optional)

~Normal~
01:16:904 (1,1) - remove new combo
02:01:252 (1,1) - ^
02:53:426 (1,1) - ^

~TuHard~
01:18:860 (1) - end on 01:21:469

~Spinboxer~
02:07:773 (1) - add new combo (optional)
Topic Starter
spboxer3

DJPop wrote:

- Delete tag "vocaloid2", only vocaloid should be enough
- Uncheck "Enable countdown" in storyboarding tab

~Easy~
02:01:252 (1,1) - remove new combo
02:41:034 (1,1) - ^ (optional)

~Normal~
01:16:904 (1,1) - remove new combo
02:01:252 (1,1) - ^
02:53:426 (1,1) - ^

~TuHard~
01:18:860 (1) - end on 01:21:469

~Spinboxer~
02:07:773 (1) - add new combo (optional)

all fixed Thanks you ~<3
DJPop
Bubble
Topic Starter
spboxer3

DJPop wrote:

Bubble
Thanks your bubble ^^
Sakura
Pretty good, i like it
Ranked!
Nitojgrem
Hmm wow, two Gumi songs in a row :)
Gratz ^.^
tutuhaha
\o/
GD也算的话首页我rank了3张么O口O?!
~\(≧▽≦)/~啦啦啦
Topic Starter
spboxer3
>"<!!!
Thanks you Hana!!
DarknessAngel
水唷又一張 ~
YTYuyu
ooh 2 straight gumi songs ranked. congratz Sp-sama :P
emonite
Congratulations!
Loneight
恭喜 阿三醬!! :)
Scorpiour
咱是果断来围观的!
ertyukjh010
恭喜喔~sp3
phonic
Congratz!!
Dino99
恭喜啦~
L_P
恭喜一声
AIR315
恭喜盒子 :)
Topic Starter
spboxer3
Thanks everyone~:D
Please sign in to reply.

New reply