As requested,
2 bms song in a row I will mention the same thing as the one I just mod and it's that I can probably not mod Another well.
Also puush is not working so feel free to pm me if you don't understand something.
[
General]
- Perhaps lower the volume of the mp3, I can barely hear the soft hitsounds.
[
Beginner]
Hmm, strange hitsound at the begin for me, try this perhaps
00:05:909 (4) - Normal hitsound here
00:06:235 (1) - Remove the normal hitsound from the end
00:06:887 (2) - Remove clap from end
00:08:191 (4) - Remove clap from repeat
00:09:496 (2) - Remove clap from end
00:11:126 (4) - Remove clap from end
Basically change so that there's a normal hitsound every 4 white ticks and get rid of the claps, I don't understand why you decide to use normal hitsound clap here at all, I thought you change to normal hitsound so you could use the normal-hitnormal as clap without having to put a custom clap sound. Your choice through. Definitely recommend following 00:05:904 & 00:06:235 atleast.
00:36:561 (3) - Whistle at repeat sound perfect here.
00:52:213 (1,2) - Whistle at both slider begin
01:07:865 (2) - Finish with lower volume gives a nice effect.
01:13:083 (2) - ^
01:34:930 (2) - Don't think you should have clap here, think of these notes as lead up to the song or to make my point a bit more clear. Weird to have clap starting before the song begin right?
01:49:604 (4,6) - Whistle for the piano perhaps so on (4) and begin of (6).
01:54:822 (1,2) - Whistle at end of (1) and begin of (2).
Hmm can barely hear the whistle at all, if the whistle was more louder, I think some nice things could be done with the hitsound here and a nice custom hi hat sound for some parts and the hitsound will be perfect. Map look fine to me through, just think that if the whistle was louder and there was a nice custom hi hat sound, the hitsound would be a lot better.
[
Normal]
00:22:213 (5) - Why not do a short slider as well like 00:21:724 (4)?
00:26:778 (3,1) - Whistle at end of (3) and remove from (1). Following piano seems better to me.
00:43:409 (1,2) - These two sliders could look better to me.
00:46:017 (1) - I think it's better to stack this with the previous note instead of spacing it out to represent that pause feel.
00:53:517 (1,2) - Change to slider so that you emphasize (3) much more?
01:46:017 (1,2) - Same as 00:43:409.
01:56:126 (1,2,3) - Same as 00:53:517.
Looks good to me.
[
Hard]
- Consider raising hitsound volume to 90% - 100% as the mp3 is quite loud.
00:03:137 (6) - Sound better to me removing the whistle from end.
00:09:007 (4) - ^ remove whistle
00:41:778 (1,2,3) - Perhaps snap them to 1.0x snap. If this was Insane, I would suggest something along the line of anti jump, but since this is hard, I just ask to lower spacing a bit to give more accent to the note?
01:53:843 (1) - Place at x:504 y:104 for anti jump seem better then just stacking.
Nice map.
[
Hyper]
00:32:974 (1,2) - Ctrl+R then stack (2) on (6)? If this was Another, I won't complain about note stack after stream, but since this is just hyper, nicer if you don't stack a note at end of stream.
00:59:713 (5,6,7) - Place them in a similar way as 00:59:061 (2,3,4) ?
01:04:278 (1) - Same as 00:32:974, how about placing it at x:440 y:48.
01:19:767 (1) - Don't think you should have a jump here. Because of the music at 01:19:604, I was expecting a pause here and looking at the spacing, it look like there is a pause, but I was wrong and hit this note late. If you really want to keep this jump, please space out 01:19:523 (9,10) to higher distant snap.
01:24:333 (8) - Please snap this to 1.2x (place at x:88 y:320) , this part with current spacing feel really clustered (due to the stream), which doesn't give off a natural feel so making this part weird to hit. This really help. An example of why this is weird is say, if you map this and snap every single note to 0.5x distant snap, would probably be very weird to play, similar feeling here.
01:35:583 (1,2) - Same as 00:32:974.
Almost all BMS map I played have really nice Hypers :S
[
Another]
01:33:789 (4) - Ctrl+J, Ctrl+ H, Ctrl+R and put back in same spot. All sliders here points to the next slider and this is the only that doesn't.
01:38:844 (9) - I don't like this jump at all, you are using 0.8x distant snap for most of the map and then you increase the spacing by 250&, dont' think the music here really increase in intensity by 250% So perhaps make the jump 1.6x instead.
01:56:452 (1) - Stack on begin of 01:54:496 (3) instead? I prefer if you put the last circle in the center of the map, but just preference.
Hmm pretty nice map, I'll assume that the jumps are too hard for me and follow the music well.
Map looks good, I think hitsound can be nicer in Beginner and really consider lowering volume of mp3 since hitsound are barely audible.
Was quite lazy in this mod, and can't mod BMS song well so hopefully my mod wasn't useless.
Star and good luck!
lol I'm tired, wasn't suppose to star this map since you didn't follow rule 3 in my queue, oh well, be sure to read rules more carefully next time